Ashmolean Museum
Oxford · museum data: www.ashmolean.org/collections-online (Fichas públicas del museo (sin licencia abierta declarada para los textos); se guardan sólo para revisar la procedencia) · reviewed on 2026-11-15
How to read this page
The automated analysis read the provenance Ashmolean Museum publishes for each painting and flagged 38 with some lead: a Nazi-era looting dealer or agency, a dispossessed owner, a confiscation, a gap between 1933 and 1945, a looting inventory number or a match with a wanted work in our database.
A lead does not mean the work was looted. We read the strong and medium ones by hand, one by one, and sorted them into four groups. Each work says why, with the provenance sentence that matters and its sources. Weak leads (almost always just a gap in the chain) are listed at the end, not yet reviewed.
The provenance a museum publishes is a claim to be checked, not a source in itself. Some museums have left out persecuted Jewish owners or put names in the chain that did not belong there: Laurel Zuckerman, heir of Paul and Alice Leffmann, documented it with the case of Picasso's «The Actor» at the Met («Detecting Deception in the Art Trade», Springer, 2025; the family's claim). So we separate two things: a «false alarm» is ruled out by a record independent of the museum (Lost Art, the ERR, the Collecting Point, or a match that turned out to be another work), while «cleared only by the museum's own account» means the only basis is what the museum itself says, not checked against original documents.
Open cases · 2
The museum's provenance omits or contradicts another public record: a Lost Art search request, an ERR card, a published claim.
Nicolas Poussin, The Exposition of Moses, 1654
Inventory WA1950.169 · 149.5 × 204.5 cm · Purchased with the assistance of the daughters of the Rt Hon. Sir Edward Fry, G.C.B. and the Art Fund, 1950. · Museum record
Open case. Poussin's «Exposition of Moses» (1654), bought by the Ashmolean in 1950. Lost Art lists a search request for it as property seized through Nazi persecution: it says it belonged to Hugo Simon, the Berlin banker who fled in 1933, from at least 1925 to 1936, and that in November 1936 the dealer Max Kaganovitch held it on consignment in Paris; it ends «since 1950 Ashmolean Museum». The museum's record only gives the 1950 credit line.
«Purchased with the assistance of the daughters of the Rt Hon. Sir Edward Fry, G.C.B. and the Art Fund, 1950.» — provenance published by the museum
Ashmolean: «The Exposition of Moses» (WA1950.169); Lost Art: «Findung Moses» (392611) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots; Kunstrückgabebeirat (Austria): decisión sobre otras dos obras de Hugo Simon, con su biografía (21-11-2008)
What the automated analysis flagged (level alta)
- Matches a work in our database: Findung Moses (missing) — Lost Art nombra al Ashmolean como dueño actual (desde 1950) · score 100
Full provenance published by the museum
[Crédito: Purchased with the assistance of the daughters of the Rt Hon. Sir Edward Fry, G.C.B. and the Art Fund, 1950.] Lost Art (392611): «spätestens 1925-mindestens 1936 Hugo Simon (1880-1950); 06.11.1936 Max Kaganovitch, wohl in Kommission erhalten von Hugo Simon; seit 1950 Ashmolean Museum»
Ivory panel, a man and a woman playing chess, circa 1325 - 1375
Added by hand: it did not come from the automated scan of the collection
Inventory WA2013.1.3 · 9.1 × 5.4 cm · Bequeathed by Michael Wellby, 2012. · Main source
Open case. Gothic ivory panel with a couple playing chess, bequeathed by Michael Wellby (2012). Lost Art seeks a Gothic ivory panel «with knights playing chess and three ladies», 9 × 5 cm, that belonged to Max Silberberg, the Jewish collector from Breslau whose collection was auctioned by Paul Graupe in 1935, and places it «since 2012» at the Ashmolean through the Wellby bequest. The only chess panel in that bequest is this one (9.1 × 5.4 cm); the museum publishes no provenance.
«Bequeathed by Michael Wellby, 2012.» — from the main source
Ashmolean: «Ivory panel, a man and a woman playing chess» (WA2013.1.3); Lost Art: «Gotisches Elfenbeintäfelchen» (414764) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots
What the automated analysis flagged (level alta)
- Matches a work in our database: Gotisches Elfenbeintäfelchen (missing) — Lost Art nombra al Ashmolean (legado Wellby, 2012); medidas parecidas (9 × 5 cm) · score 90
Provenance according to the sources
[Crédito: Bequeathed by Michael Wellby, 2012.] Lost Art (414764): «Sammlung Max Silberberg, Breslau; 12.10.1935 Auktion Paul Graupe, Berlin, Lot 228 […]; Michael Wellby (1928-2012 […]); seit 2012 The Ashmolean Museum […] (Michael Wellby bequest)»
Pending documents · 1
There is a persecuted owner or a looting dealer in the Nazi years and what is published is not enough to know what happened. Each says which document is missing.
Giovanni di Paolo, The Virgin and Child
Inventory WA1962.17.14 · 35 × 25.5 cm · Bequeathed by Francis Falconer Madan, 1962. · Museum record
Pending documents. A small «Virgin and Child» by Giovanni di Paolo, bequeathed by Francis Falconer Madan (1962). The detector matched it with a «Madonna and Child» by the same painter that Göring bought in January 1941 from the Rome dealer Alessandro Morandotti through Hofer, missing since 1945. The Göring record gives no dimensions and the Ashmolean does not say when or where Madan bought it, so it can be neither ruled out nor confirmed.
«Bequeathed by Francis Falconer Madan, 1962.» — provenance published by the museum
Ashmolean: «The Virgin and Child» (WA1962.17.14); DHM, Die Kunstsammlung Hermann Göring: RMG00696
What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
- Matches a work in our database: Madonna (mit Kind) (missing) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; mismo título · score 45
Full provenance published by the museum
[Crédito: Bequeathed by Francis Falconer Madan, 1962.] [Catálogo: Giovanni worked mainly in Siena, developing a sophisticated, expressive manner that deliberately recalls the art of the great Sienese masters of the previous century. Although rather worn, this small devotional work is of fine quality. A relatively late work, it perhaps dates from the early 1460s. In: Whiteley, Jon, Catherine Casley, Colin Harrison, Marlia Mundell Mango, Timothy Newberry, Christian Rumelin, Catherine Whistler, and Timothy Wilson, The Ashmolean Museum: Complete Illustrated Catalogue of Paintings, (Oxford: Ashmolean Museum 2004)]
Settled by the museum · 0
The work had a looting or forced-sale past, and the museum researched it and tells it: restitution, settlement with the heirs or purchase from them.
False alarms · 0
The lead does not hold, and something independent of the museum shows it: the automatic match is another work (another subject, other measurements) or an independent record (Lost Art, the ERR, the Munich Collecting Point) settles it.
Cleared only by the museum's own account · 1
The lead came from the museum's provenance text, and so does what rules it out: a purchase before 1933, a sale out of Nazi reach, a name said to belong to someone else. We did not check it against original documents. It is not a clearance: it is what the museum asserts. If you have documents that contradict it, write to us.
Édouard Manet, Landscape with a Church Tower
Inventory WA1940.1.6 · 30 × 44 cm · Bequeathed by Frank Hindley Smith, 1939. · Museum record
Cleared only by the museum's own account. A Manet landscape the Ashmolean received in Frank Hindley Smith's bequest (1939). The flag is Wildenstein, which showed it twice in London. According to the museum's catalogue it appeared in Paris in May 1936 at the posthumous sale of a «Mme B. L.» (probably the Benoist-Lévy family), and went from there to Hindley Smith: there is no dispossession in the chain.
«Although this painting caused some interest in the press when it appeared at auction in 1936, and although it has been twice exhibited at Wildenstein’s in London» — provenance published by the museum
What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
- Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Wildenstein & Co.: …he press when it appeared at auction in 1936, and although it has been twice exhibited at Wildenstein’s in London and is unquestionably by the hand of Manet, it has been omitted from all cata…
Full provenance published by the museum
[Crédito: Bequeathed by Frank Hindley Smith, 1939.] [Catálogo: Although this painting caused some interest in the press when it appeared at auction in 1936, and although it has been twice exhibited at Wildenstein’s in London and is unquestionably by the hand of Manet, it has been omitted from all catalogues of Manet’s work apart from Tabarant’s Manet et ses oeuvres.¹ The work was unknown before it appeared in the posthumous sale of a ‘Mme B. L.’ in May 1936, alongside a collection of jewellery and two other paintings: a view of Oloron-Sainte-Marie by Manet² and a painting of Zaandam by Monet.³ Percy Moore Turner identified the first owner of the landscape as ‘Benoit-Lévy, of Bordeaux, who had it from Manet himself in payment of wines which Manet had from him. Benoit-Lévy was a very important wine merchant of the period. At the death of Madame Benoit-Lévy it was sold at the Hôtel Drouot by Monsieur Brame’.⁴ This is supported by a report of the sale in L’Intransigeant, where it is said that all three paintings had been ‘échangés contre vin’.⁵ The story is plausible, but difficult to confirm.⁶ There do not appear to be any Benoit-Lévys in this period who are known to have traded in wine either in Paris or in Bordeaux.⁷ It is also difficult to identify a Mme Benoit-Lévy who had died in the months before the date of the sale, apart from a Mme Paul Benoist-Lévy, née Sara Cahen, who died on 30 January 1936.⁸ She outlived her husband, Paul Benoist-Lévy – or Paul Lévy as he was known – by eighteen years. Paul Lévy (1855–1918) was a brother of the banker Émile Benoist-Lévy.⁹ His name appears in several contemporary lists of addresses, but his occupation, if he had one, is unrecorded.¹⁰ The delicate, feathered touch and subdued colour of the painting link it with the group of sketches made by Manet in the period between February 1871, when he left for Oloron-Sainte-Marie, and his return to Paris in the following May. The small sketch paired with the Ashmolean painting in Mme B. L.’s sale was one of three similar works painted in Oloron. The view in the Ashmolean painting has not been identified, but the suggestion, reported by Tabarant, that it represents a site in or near Arcachon may be correct.¹¹ The expanse of sand with nearby trees and houses resembles several sites along the coast round the bay of Arcachon. The sail of a boat, half-hidden by the sand, marks an inlet with two men working on the right. The spire with its corner pinnacles is of a type not uncommon in the region and the details are vague. There is, however, a reasonable match with the church of Saint-Ferdinand, built in a neo-Romanesque style in 1855 behind the trees that once lined the broad sands of the Plage d’Eyrac. The dunes were crossed at this point by a deep channel that gave access to the sea before the present port was constructed.¹² As so much of the area has been altered, it is difficult to be certain. The church was demolished in 1898, but is illustrated in the first edition of Adolphe Joanne’s guide to Arcachon.¹³ 1. A. Tabarant, Manet ]
Weak leads, not yet read by hand · 34
These are the other 34 of the 38 works with leads. Almost all have only a gap between 1933 and 1945 with the work in Europe before the jump. We list them so anyone can check them.
Aristide Joseph Bonaventure Maillol, In the Eastern Pyrenees, 1886
Inventory WA1972.161 · 46 × 55 cm · Bequeathed by Lt-Col G. E. Bouskell-Wade, 1972. · Museum record
Arthur Lemon, Landscape with Silver Birch and distant Mountains
Inventory WA1969.19 · 24.2 × 34.3 cm · Presented by the Lady Berwick, 1969. · Museum record
Augustus Edwin John, T.E. Lawrence, 1929
Inventory WA1946.266 · 66 × 50 cm · Presented by Professor A.W. Lawrence, the sitter's brother, 1946. · Museum record
Camille Pissarro, Jeanne Pissarro (Minette) Holding a Fan, 1873 - 1874
Inventory WA1952.6.2 · 56 × 46 cm · Bequeathed by Esther Pissarro, 1952. · Museum record
Camille Pissarro, Julie Pissarro sewing, 1860
Inventory WA1952.6.1 · 16 × 11 cm · Bequeathed by Esther Pissarro, 1952. · Museum record
Camille Pissarro, The Approach to the Village of Éragny, 1885
Inventory WA1952.6.3 · 55 × 63.5 cm · Presented by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Charles Conder, Venetian Night, 1890 - 1895
Inventory WA1958.57.5 · 68 × 80 cm · Bequeathed by Archibald G. B. Russell, C.V.O., 1958. · Museum record
Domenico Morelli, Self-portrait
Inventory WA1973.5 · 43 × 33.5 cm · Bequeathed by the Lady Berwick, 1973. · Museum record
Domingos António de Sequeira, Adriao Ribeiro Neves, 1825
Inventory WA1947.270 · 40 × 32 cm · Purchased, 1947. · Museum record
Edith Corbet, Asolo, 1899
Inventory WA1969.20 · 23.6 × 32.6 cm · Presented by the Lady Berwick, 1969. · Museum record
Edward William Cooke, Shipping on the Ij, 1848
Inventory WA1967.52.5 · 10.9 × 24.8 cm · Bequeathed by Miss S. A. P. Boyle, 1967. · Museum record
François-Joseph Dupressoir, View over an Extensive Vale, 1828
Inventory WA1948.101 · 46 × 56 cm · Presented by Mrs Edith Annie Berthon, née Booker, 1948. · Museum record
Félix Pissarro, Dunes at Knokke, 1894
Inventory WA1951.225.6 · 46 × 54 cm · Presented by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Félix Pissarro, Landscape with Trees, 1893 - 1894
Inventory WA1951.225.8 · 45.5 × 38 cm · Presented by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Félix Pissarro, Landscape with Trees, 1893 - 1894
Inventory WA1951.225.8 · 45.5 × 38 cm · Presented by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Félix Pissarro, View at Hemiksem, 1894
Inventory WA1951.225.9 · 31.5 × 40.5 cm · Presented by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Félix Pissarro, Wooded landscape: a Woman walking with a Dog, 1893 - 1894
Inventory WA1951.225.10 · 27 × 35.5 cm · Presented by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Gioacchino Serangeli, Portrait of a young Woman, 1807 - 1810
Inventory WA1971.387 · 91.7 × 73.6 cm · Purchased, 1971. · Museum record
Harold John Wilde Gilman, Dieppe from the West, 1910 - 1911
Inventory WA1961.46 · 45 × 60 cm · Purchased (Bevan Fund), 1961. · Museum record
Jean-François Millet, Shepherd Recalling the Flock, 1857 - 1860
Inventory WA1956.44 · 11.5 × 15.5 cm · Purchased, 1956. · Museum record
Jean-Paul Laurens, The Judgement of Chilperic, 1881 - 1882
Inventory WA1965.30.1 · 45.5 × 36.9 cm · Purchased, 1965. · Museum record
John Crome, Bruges River, with Ostend in the distance: Moonlight, 1815 - 1820
Inventory WA1957.59 · 19 × 25 cm · Bequeathed by Percy Moore Turner, 1951. · Museum record
Konstantin Alekseevich Korovin, View of Paris by Night, 1923
Inventory WA1960.36.9 · 33 × 41 cm · Bequeathed by Dr Tatiana Gourlande, 1960. · Museum record
Lawrence Alma-Tadema, A Corner of the Gardens of the Villa Borghese, 1876
Inventory WA1966.13.1 · 34.9 × 22 cm · Presented by Miss Sylvia Gosse, 1966. · Museum record
Louis Valtat, Le Quai du Louvre, 1892 - 1893
Inventory WA1972.162 · 38 × 61 cm · Bequeathed by Lt-Col G. E. Bouskell-Wade, 1972. · Museum record
Lucien Pissarro, La Pointe de Cougoussa, Sunset, 1925
Inventory WA1951.225.18 · 38 × 46 cm · Presented by the Pissarro Family, 1951. · Museum record
Ludovic-Rodolphe Pissarro, Still Life with a Green Jar, 1897 - 1898
Inventory WA1952.6.16 · 46 × 50.5 cm · Bequeathed by Esther Pissarro, 1951. · Museum record
Mark Fisher, A Normandy Lock, 1871 - 1923
Inventory WA1961.31.1 · 52 × 69 cm · Bequeathed by J. E. Bullard, 1961. · Museum record
Sir Alfred James Munnings, Two Calves grazing by a Hedge, 1904
Inventory WA1963.150.8 · 52 × 78 cm · Bequeathed by Major Thomas Bouch, 1963. · Museum record
Sir Charles Holroyd, The Rialto, Venice, 1888 - 1898
Inventory WA1954.80.8 · 41 × 33 cm · Presented by Mrs Michael Holroyd, 1954. · Museum record
Sir Egerton Bushe Coghill, Field of Rye, Barbizon, 1874
Inventory WA1962.15 · 32 × 41 cm · Presented by the artist's sons, Sir Patrick Coghill, Bt. and Prof Nevill Coghill, 1962. · Museum record
Sir George Hayter, Thomas Babington Macaulay, 1838
Inventory WA1962.18.1 · 35.2 × 29.6 cm · Presented by Mrs Nichol Smith, in memory of her husband, Professor David Nichol Smith, 1962. · Museum record
Vincent van Gogh, Restaurant de la Sirène, Asnières, 1887
Inventory WA1972.18 · 52 × 64.4 cm · Bequeathed by Dr Erich Alport, 1972. · Museum record
William James Müller, Keynsham, near Bristol
Inventory WA1969.8 · 54 × 80 cm · Bequeathed by Mrs C. W. Dyson Perrins, 1969. · Museum record