Museums: what their provenances say
We read the provenance the major museums publish for every work in their collection and cross it with the looted-art databases. We started with those that publish open data.
How we did it
Many museums publish the provenance of their works as open data: the list of owners, with dates and notes. We review each painting with the same rules we use to watch the market: whether the provenance cites a Nazi-looting inventory number (ERR, Linz, the Munich Collecting Point, Göring, the Dutch or French lists); whether the work matches a wanted or claimed work in our database by artist, title and size, including Lost Art search requests; and what the text says (looting dealers and agencies, dispossessed owners, confiscations, gaps between 1933 and 1945).
A lead does not mean a work was looted: most went through a dealer or a dispossessed collector, often with the history already researched and told by the museum itself. So we read every strong and medium lead by hand. A case is «open» only if the museum's provenance omits or contradicts another public record (a Lost Art search request, an ERR card, a published claim). The rest we classify as settled by the museum, false alarm or pending documents.
Drawings and prints were not in the scan, which for now reads paintings. The three Washington drawings we publish came from Lost Art search requests.
Buenos Aires's Museo Nacional de Bellas Artes does not publish the chain of owners of its works, only how each one entered. There the review was by hand: 641 European works, with the 1999 CEANA report, which used the museum's files.
Russia: trophy art
In 1945 and 1946 Soviet trophy brigades removed hundreds of thousands of works from Germany: from public museums (Gotha, the Prussian palaces, Berlin's Nationalgalerie, Bremen) and also collections the Nazis had stolen from Jewish families. Many are still in Russian museums. German museums list them on Lost Art as «war losses». Here we cross those records with the Pushkin's catalogue and the Russian state catalogue. An «open case» in this table is almost always a loss of a German public museum, not property taken from a family: each work says which.
| Museum | Records read | With leads | Open cases | False alarms | Pending |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pushkin State Museum of Fine ArtsMoscow | 4,347 | 230 | 177 | 31 | 22 |
| State Hermitage MuseumSaint Petersburg | 46,036 | 32 | 19 | 6 | 7 |
| State Catalogue of the Museum Fund of Russia (Goskatalog)Russia | 225,110 | 43 | 0 | 29 | 14 |
Spot checks
Museums that do not publish their collection's provenance, or that block automated reading. There, gaps in the chain of owners cannot be searched. We did two things: cross the museum's list of works (taken from Wikidata) with our database by artist, title and size, and search Lost Art and the ERR database for works those records place in the museum today. We checked each match by hand. A work not appearing does not mean its provenance is clean.
| Museum | Works crossed | Open cases | Settled | False alarms | Pending |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| High Museum of ArtAtlanta | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Norton Simon MuseumPasadena | 2 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| Saint Louis Art MuseumSt. Louis | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Virginia Museum of Fine ArtsRichmond | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Nelson-Atkins Museum of ArtKansas City | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Tel Aviv Museum of ArtTel Aviv | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
| Israel MuseumJerusalem | 31 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 29 |
| National Gallery of VictoriaMelbourne | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Detroit Institute of ArtsDetroit | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Indianapolis Museum of Art (Newfields)Indianapolis | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Toledo Museum of ArtToledo, Ohio | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Staatliche Kunstsammlungen DresdenDresden | 5,644 | 1 | 0 | 23 | 9 |
| Hamburger KunsthalleHamburg | 718 | 1 | 1 | 7 | 0 |
| Museum LudwigCologne | 1,636 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 |
| Musée d'OrsayParis | 4,908 | 11 | 2 | 81 | 46 |
| Museo Nacional Thyssen-BornemiszaMadrid | 1,113 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 |
| Gallerie degli UffiziFlorence | 967 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 |
| Museo Nacional del PradoMadrid | 6,420 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Museo Reina SofíaMadrid | 1,631 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| BelvedereVienna | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Click a number to see those works, one by one, with the explanation and sources. Read by hand: every strong and medium lead; weak ones (almost always just a gap in the chain) are listed for a second pass.
The cases
- Two Strigel panels at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the Bromberg heirs
- A Degas study at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Armand Dorville
- A Max Liebermann drawing of his daughter Käthe at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Max and Martha Liebermann
- A Feininger at the Art Institute of Chicago that Eugen Buchthal's heirs are searching for on Lost Art
- A Vienna porcelain figure at the V&A, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Herbert Gutmann
- Willem Kalf's 'Nautilus Cup' in the Bührle collection is lot 45 of the 1935 Berlin auction that the Oppenheimer heirs list on Lost Art
- Toulouse-Lautrec's 'Messaline': the Kunsthaus says 'provenance clear', but it has been on Lost Art since 2006 and the Gross report says that classification does not hold
- Four Bührle paintings the foundation offered to settle with heirs in 2024, still without agreement
- Henri Rousseau's 'The Muse Inspiring the Poet': Kunstmuseum Basel admits it bought it cheaply from an exiled Jewish collector, but will not return it
- A Largillière in the Montreal museum that the ERR seized from the Rothschilds in 1941
- A High Museum Sisley that Max Braunthal's heirs seek in Lost Art
- The Pushkin Museum’s catalogue names German museums as former owners of five paintings those museums are searching for on Lost Art
- Lost Art places 182 works from Gotha, the Prussian palaces and the Berlin museums in the Pushkin Museum; the museum’s online catalogue does not show them
- Lost Art places 6 works lost by Gotha, the Alte Nationalgalerie and the Siemens collection in the Hermitage
- Munich's Pinakotheken have restitutions decided but not carried out since 2020, and two cases the state proposed for arbitration
- A Klee the Städel bought in 1961 matches the title and size of a Lost Art search request
- A Courbet apple branch at the Orsay that Hugo Simon's heirs are searching for on Lost Art
- A Lotto that Hitler bought for Linz in 1940 is in Copenhagen, and the museum does not say so
- Klimt's «The Blind Man» at the Leopold Museum: Lost Art seeks it for the Hellmann heirs; the museum says it was sold in 1932
- An Ashmolean Poussin that Hugo Simon's heirs seek on Lost Art
- A Toulouse-Lautrec at the Kröller-Müller sought on Lost Art: it belonged to the Berlin collector Oskar Skaller
- Two Friedrichs at the Belvedere that Hugo Simon's heirs seek on Lost Art, although Austria declined to return them
- Eight Nationalgalerie paintings the museum itself recognises as Nazi-looted and keeps because it found no heirs
- Works of the dealer Annie Caspari, murdered in 1941, still in the Berlin museums: eight passed to the bank after the Nazis took power
- Four paintings of Abraham Adelsberger that Lost Art lists as Nazi-looted are in the Nationalgalerie
- An MNR painting at the Louvre that, according to its own record, came from a Jewish collection in Vienna
- Four MNR works whose wartime owner or seller is named in the Louvre's record
- A Payen the Rijksmuseum bought in 1942 from a Jewish woman in Amsterdam
- A Jan Ekels pledged to a bank in 1940 and sold by the bank to the State in 1944
- Matisse's «Les anémones»: sold by a Bernheim during the Occupation and bought by Bern in 1945
- A Slevogt the museum itself places in the looted category, still without a decision
- A Goya «Carnival Scene» requisitioned from the Jewish Herzog family in 1944 is at the Pushkin; Hungary also claims works of the Hatvanys
- About 307 Koenigs drawings that Hitler bought for Linz have been at the Pushkin since 1945; the Netherlands claims them
- Gerstenberg, Koehler, Siemens: paintings of Berlin collectors at the Hermitage that their families still seek
- A Frederick the Great hanging in Halberstadt that the Bavarian state posted on Lost Art as Nazi loot
- A Greek relief in Hanover that the museum describes as confiscated from Jews in France and given to Göring
- The bottle the Hagen museum director took from Cläre Bachrach in 1939; she was murdered in Auschwitz
- Two candelabra the Beirat ordered returned in 2021 that the MAK still holds
- A Courbet at the Art Institute of Chicago with the same measurements as a painting sought on Lost Art as a forced sale by “W. Westfeld, Düsseldorf”
- A portrait of Adolph Menzel by Karl Stauffer-Bern at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Adele Paechter
- Two Guardis at the Cleveland Museum of Art: from a Jewish banker who fled in 1933 to a Berlin gallery in 1944
- A Bonnard in Cleveland: from the Kapferer brothers, looted by the ERR, to the Pétridès gallery in occupied Paris
- A Ruysdael in Minneapolis: from a Berlin banker forced to emigrate to a New York gallery in 1944
- A Dorville-collection watercolour at Yale, sought on Lost Art: the 1942 Nice auction a French court called spoliative
- An Engebrechtsz at Yale that appears on Belgium's list of works stolen by the Germans
- A marble angel by Simone Bianco at the V&A, sought on Lost Art as part of Jakob Goldschmidt's collection
- Monet's 'Poppy Field near Vétheuil': Max Emden's grandson has claimed it since 2012, the foundation says it was not a persecution sale, and the Kunsthaus records 'indications'
- The Rubens sketch Gotha has sought since 1945: the Kunsthaus labels it 'provenance clear'
- The Kunsthaus purchases from Charlotte von Wesdehlen in 1940 and 1942: Basel has recognised her sale as a persecuted seller's; the Zurich records do not say so
- What the Gross report found in three Bührle paintings and how the Kunsthaus shows them today
- Delacroix's 'The Raising of Lazarus': from the Behrens family of Jewish bankers in Hamburg to New York, nobody knows how
- Twelve paintings the Kunsthistorisches bought between 1939 and 1945 that Austria publishes as of doubtful provenance: the museum's records do not say so
- A Pushkin Adriaen van de Velde, registered in 1950, has the same size as the one the ERR seized from the Rothschilds and gave to Göring
- 12 works in Russian museums match in painter and size pictures that museums in Kyiv, Kharkiv and Simferopol are searching for as war losses
- A Neff portrait of Empress Alexandra Feodorovna in Irkutsk measures the same as the one the Prussian Palaces lost in 1946
- A Dresden Isaac van Ostade bearing the Goudstikker gallery label, which the museum itself lists as of unclear origin
- A Nerly the Hamburger Kunsthalle bought from Haberstock in 1942 and itself declares seized through Nazi persecution
- Lilly Cassirer's Pissarro remains at the Thyssen and the case reopened in 2025; the museum's web page gives no provenance
- A Tiepolo bought in Berlin in 1948, now at Helsinki's Sinebrychoff, with gaps in its history
- An early Schiele at the Leopold Museum that Lost Art seeks in the name of Leopold Popper-Podhragy
- Two Klimt drawings from the Lederer collection at the Leopold Museum, sought on Lost Art
- A Flinck at the Mauritshuis listed on Lost Art as seized through Nazi persecution, with the museum's inventory number
- Sheets from the Julius Freund collection at the Albertina: bought for Linz in 1942, Austria declined to return them and they are still sought on Lost Art
- 13 MNR works seized from Paris homes, with the looting acknowledged and the owner unknown
- A Deodato Orlandi panel that was in the Goudstikker gallery and that the Louvre bought in 1945
- Two paintings from Armand Dorville's bequest that entered the Louvre during the Occupation
- 8 MNR works stolen or lost at the museums where the State deposited them
- Three works that entered the Rijksmuseum or changed hands in 1942–1943 and that the Dutch survey flags
- A Van de Venne allegory whose provenance says «forced sale» to Göring
- Three works with an undocumented Nazi-era stretch: Arnhold, Koenigs and Galerie Sanct Lucas
- A Gavarni from the Gurlitt bequest sold by a Jewish collector in 1942 Paris
- Thirteen works from the Gurlitt bequest claimed by the heirs of Fritz Salo Glaser
- Bequest works that went through Raphaël Gérard in occupied Paris
- The museum's own collection: ten works with indications still under research
- Since 1996 the Pushkin has shown Schliemann’s Trojan treasures that Berlin lost in 1945
- The Krebs collection at the Hermitage: 78 paintings of a German industrialist, removed from Holzdorf after 1945
- Frankfurt's Goethe museum declares restitution cases and still holds them
- Two ceramic dishes at the MAKK in Cologne that the museum declares «clearly tainted»
- The objects bought for Goebbels's guest house in Rheydt
- A Potsdam glass goblet that turned up in a 1937 sale and that the museum wants to restitute
- Silver bought at the Dorotheum in 1941–42 that the MAK lists as of unknown ownership (13 objects)
- Furniture, textiles and objects exchanged with the dealer Oskar Hamel in 1941–44 (59 objects)
- Objects assigned by the Zentralstelle für Denkmalschutz (1940) and tapestries received from the Allies (1954)
- A Makart that Wolfgang Gurlitt bought at the Vienna Dorotheum in December 1940, from an unknown owner
- A Liebermann from the collection of Ottmar Strauss, auctioned by Helbing in 1934–35
- A Trübner drawing with the same title as one sought by the heirs of Max Silberberg
- Two Faistauers from the Schwarz collection that Gurlitt bought from the son after the war
- A Sisley in Minneapolis with 79 undocumented years in France, and a “Bridge at Moret” confiscated in Paris sought on Lost Art
- The 13 works Linz restituted between 1999 and 2015
Two Strigel panels at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the Bromberg heirs
National Gallery of Art, Washington


Images: Wikimedia Commons, public domain (photos by the National Gallery of Art).
They are the two wings of a Holy Kinship altarpiece, painted by Bernhard Strigel around 1520–1528. Since 1961 they have belonged to the National Gallery of Art in Washington, which received them from the Kress Foundation.
On the German Lost Art database, each panel has a search request as «cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution», filed under «Bromberg, Dr. Henry und Hertha». Henry Bromberg was a judge in Hamburg; he and his wife, who were Jewish, fled Germany in 1938. The Lost Art entries cite the National Gallery's inventory numbers.
The provenance the National Gallery publishes says the Brombergs «possibly» owned them from 1907, and jumps to «probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939». It says nothing between 1907 and 1939 and does not name the Paris dealer Lost Art lists for 1938. Emden was also a Jewish collector from Hamburg who emigrated to Switzerland in 1933. In either version, the panels leave a Jewish family during the Nazi years.
We found no press report or National Gallery statement on these requests. Open Art Data published in April 2026 the list of National Gallery works with Lost Art requests, these two among them.
Two versions of the same story
The National Gallery publishes an annotated provenance in its online collection and open data. The heirs filed another on Lost Art. The table sets them side by side, with the original text in quotes (the museum's in English, Lost Art's in German). It is the same for both panels.
| Item | National Gallery of ArtPublished provenance (open data, 14 Nov 2026) | Lost ArtSearch request, «Bromberg, Dr. Henry und Hertha» |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | «Possibly O. Streber, Munich» (possibly; the museum says it is unverified) | «möglich Sammlung O. Streber, München» |
| Rodolphe Kann, Paris | Bought May 1900 from Agnew; at his death, to his heirs | «Sammlung Rodolphe Kann (gest. 1905), Paris, Mai 1900 -» |
| Martin Bromberg, HamburgDiffers | «purchased August 1907 by members of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg» (possibly) | «Sammlung Martin Bromberg (und Erben), Hamburg, August 1907 - 1935 (nach)» (with his heirs, until after 1935) |
| What it rests onDiffers | Duveen's books, which say only «Kann relations», and a Wildenstein brochure that «lists Bromberg and Dr. Emden as previous owners» | «Album „Haus Bromberg, Nonnenstieg 9“. Privatbesitz, 1935 (nach)» (a photo album of the Bromberg house, from after 1935) |
| 1907–1938Differs | Nothing | With the Brombergs until after 1935 |
| Max Emden | «Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939» (probably) | «Sammlung Dr. Max Emden, Schweiz (?)» |
| Kleinberger, ParisDiffers | Not mentioned | «Kunsthandel F. Kleinberger (Allan Loebl), Paris vor 20.12.1938» (before 20 December 1938) |
| Wildenstein & Co.Differs | «New York, by 1939» | «Paris 1939» |
| Kress Foundation and National Gallery | Bought February 1954; at the National Gallery from 1956–58; given in 1961 | The same dates |
| How they left the familyDiffers | Not stated | «NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut» (cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution) |
«Wildenstein & Co. brochure in NGA Kress files lists Bromberg and Dr. Emden as previous owners.» The National Gallery's own files hold a document naming the Brombergs and Emden as previous owners, yet its provenance lists them as «possibly» and «probably».
What we found
- Both panels match the Lost Art entries in title, artist and size to the millimetre (125.5 × 65.8 and 125 × 65.7 cm), and the entries cite inventory numbers 1961.9.88 and 1961.9.89 and the National Gallery's pages. There is no doubt they are the same works.
- The 1938 dealer Lost Art names, Kleinberger of Paris, was run by Allen Loebl. The Allied investigators' red-flag list (ALIU, 1945–46) says that during the Occupation the firm was «aryanised» and became the centre of an informal dealers' syndicate that sold «chiefly to Lohse, Hofer and Haberstock», the buyers for Göring and Hitler. That is after 1940; the panels went through it earlier, in 1938.
- Max Emden, the other possible owner, was a Jewish businessman from Hamburg who emigrated to Switzerland in 1933. In 2019 the German advisory commission on looted art recommended returning to his heirs two Bellottos he sold from exile and Hitler bought: the German government had argued that a sale made after emigrating was not subject to restitution.
- Henry Bromberg's heirs have already recovered other works: two paintings returned by the French Ministry of Culture in 2016 and 2018, a portrait attributed to Cranach from the Allentown Art Museum (2024 settlement) and a Ter Borch from the National Gallery of Victoria in Australia in 2025.
What the museum should answer
- Has the National Gallery responded to the search requests on Lost Art? Has it contacted the Bromberg heirs?
- Why does its provenance not mention Kleinberger (Paris, 1938), which appears on Lost Art?
- What documents does it hold on how and when the panels left the Bromberg family, between 1935 and 1938, the year they fled?
Sources
National Gallery of Art: «Saint Mary Cleophas and Her Family» (1961.9.88); National Gallery of Art: «Saint Mary Salome and Her Family» (1961.9.89); National Gallery of Art, open data (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Heilige Sippe mit Maria Cleophae» (526719); Lost Art: «Heilige Sippe mit Maria Salomae» (526720); Kress Collection Digital Archive: 1961.9.88; Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Henry Bromberg; Algemeiner, 16 Oct 2025: the National Gallery of Victoria returns a Ter Borch to the Bromberg heirs; The Art Newspaper, 27 Mar 2019: German panel urges return of Max Emden's Bellottos; ALIU red-flag names list (lootedart.com)
A Degas study at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Armand Dorville
National Gallery of Art, Washington
A black chalk and pastel study by Degas for «The Fallen Jockey» (the painting is also at the NGA, 1999.79.10). It came to the NGA in 1999 with the gift of Paul and Rachel Mellon.
Lost Art lists a search request (614980) as «NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut» (cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution), within «Die Sammlung Armand DORVILLE». The entry cites inventory number 1999.79.11.
The NGA provenance for that sheet does not name Dorville: it gives «Collection Pellet, Paris» between the René de Gas sale of 1927 and the Palais Galliera sale of 1972. Both versions agree on that 1972 sale (lot 38), on Otto Wertheimer and on the Mellons, so they describe the same sheet.
Oddly, the NGA does name Dorville, but for another sheet of the same subject, 1999.79.7, «Head of the Fallen Jockey», without the 1942 Nice sale. Either the two sheets have been confused, or both passed through Dorville.
Dorville, a Paris lawyer from a Jewish family, died in 1941. His collection was auctioned in Nice on 24–27 June 1942, and Vichy's Commissariat for Jewish Affairs sent an administrator who seized the proceeds. In November 2025 France's Cour de cassation quashed the ruling that had upheld that sale.
Two versions of the same story
La procedencia de la National Gallery (datos abiertos, 15-11-2026) contra el pedido de búsqueda de Lost Art, con el texto original entre comillas.
| Item | National Gallery of ArtProcedencia de 1999.79.11 (datos abiertos) | Lost ArtPedido 614980, «Die Sammlung Armand DORVILLE» |
|---|---|---|
| Origen | «Atelier Degas (Lugt 657), Paris; Collection René de Gas, Paris, until 1927; (his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 10 November 1927, no. 21, repr.)» | No lo dice (sólo «Atelierstempel "Degas" links») |
| Armand DorvilleDiffers | No figura | «Armand Dorville» |
| Niza, 1942Differs | No figura | «Verkauf "Cabinet d'un amateur parisien", n°265, Nizza, 24.-27. Juni 1942» |
| Entre 1942 y 1972Differs | «Collection Pellet, Paris» | «[...]» (no se sabe) |
| Subasta de 1972 | «(sale, Palais Galliera, Paris, 29 November 1972, no. 38, repr.)» | «Verkauf, Palais Galliéra, Paris, 29. November - 1. Dezember 1972, Nr. 38 (repr.)» |
| Hasta el museo | «Otto Wertheimer; Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, Upperville, VA, 1972; gift to NGA, 1999» | «Otto Wertheimer - M. et Mme Paul Mellon, 1972 - Geschenk an die National Gallery of Art, Washington, USA - Inv. 1999.79.11» |
| Cómo salió de la familiaDiffers | No lo dice | «NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut» |
«Armand Dorville [1875-1941], Paris; (sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 24 November 1964, no. 33)». La National Gallery pone a Dorville en la procedencia de la otra hoja, 1999.79.7, no en la que reclaman los herederos.
What we found
- Dimensions: Lost Art 26 × 34 cm; NGA 26.6 × 35.2 cm for 1999.79.11 and 25.4 × 34 cm for 1999.79.7. The Lost Art entry explicitly cites «Inv. 1999.79.11» and the 1972 lot 38, which the NGA also gives for 1999.79.11.
- Per Wikipedia, the Commissariat «sent an administrator, Amédée Croze, who informed the auctioneer that he would seize the proceeds, which exceeded nine million francs».
- On 26 November 2025 the Cour de cassation quashed the appeal ruling «en ce qu'il rejette la demande en nullité de la vente du 24 au 27 juin 1942» (Le Club des juristes). Per Pinsent Masons, the court held «the 1942 auction sale of artworks belonging to the Parisian lawyer and art collector Armand Dorville was spoliative».
- Open Art Data pointed out in April 2026 the «ABSENCE on the NGA website of any mention of DORVILLE, LIEBERMANN or PAECHTER». Seven months later the provenance of 1999.79.11 in the open data is unchanged.
What the museum should answer
- Which sheet passed through the Dorville collection and the 1942 Nice sale: 1999.79.11, 1999.79.7, or both?
- Who is «Collection Pellet» and when did it acquire the sheet?
- Has the NGA answered the Lost Art request or contacted the Dorville heirs?
Sources
National Gallery of Art: «Fallen Jockey» (1999.79.11); National Gallery of Art: «Head of the Fallen Jockey» (1999.79.7); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Etude de jockey mort / Studie eines toten Jockeys» (614980); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Armand Dorville; Le Club des juristes: «Spoliations sous l'Occupation : un arrêt majeur de la Cour de cassation»; Pinsent Masons (Out-Law): fallo sobre la venta Dorville
A Max Liebermann drawing of his daughter Käthe at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Max and Martha Liebermann
National Gallery of Art, Washington
Black and white chalk on grey paper. The NGA bought it in 2007 with Wolfgang Ratjen's drawings collection.
Lost Art lists a search request (417888) under Max and Martha Liebermann as property seized as a result of Nazi persecution, with «Verlust nach 1935» (lost after 1935, the year the painter died).
The NGA provenance only begins with «Egon Meilicke, Berlin» and the 1986 Neumeister sale. It does not name the Liebermanns, though the drawing portrays the painter's daughter.
Martha Liebermann, the painter's widow, lost her houses and almost all her fortune under Nazism; in 1943 she took her own life the day before her deportation to Theresienstadt.
Two versions of the same story
La procedencia de la National Gallery contra la de Lost Art.
| Item | National Gallery of ArtProcedencia de 2007.111.119 (datos abiertos) | Lost ArtPedido 417888, Martha y Max Liebermann |
|---|---|---|
| Max y Martha LiebermannDiffers | No figuran | «Max Liebermann, Martha Liebermann, Berlin, Verlust nach 1935» |
| Egon Meilicke | «Egon Meilicke, Berlin» | «Egon Meilicke (Berlin)» |
| SubastaDiffers | «(sale, Neumeister, Munich, 10 December 1986, no. 844)» | «10.12.1986 Neumeister, München, Nr. 84» |
| Ratjen y el museo | «Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich; purchased 2007 by NGA» | «Sammlung W. Ratjen, National Gallery of Art, Washington (seit 2007)» |
| Cómo salió de la familiaDiffers | No lo dice | «NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut» |
What we found
- Dimensions match exactly (27.5 × 33 cm) and Lost Art names the NGA as current holder.
- The lot number differs: 844 per the NGA, 84 per Lost Art.
- Wikipedia: «She committed suicide the day before her planned deportation to the Theresienstadt Ghetto»; «she lost her two houses on Pariser Platz and Wannsee, and almost her entire fortune».
- The NGA documents another Liebermann case well: Manet's «George Moore in the Artist's Garden» (2006.128.24) was among 14 pictures sent to the Kunsthaus Zürich in May 1933 and later released to Käthe Riezler. For this drawing it gives nothing before Meilicke.
What the museum should answer
- How and when did the drawing leave the Liebermann household?
- Who was Egon Meilicke and when did he acquire it?
- Has the NGA answered the Lost Art request?
Sources
National Gallery of Art: «The Artist's Daughter Käthe Reading in a Chair» (2007.111.119); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Lesendes Mädchen (Tochter Käthe) im Sessel» (417888); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Martha Liebermann
A Feininger at the Art Institute of Chicago that Eugen Buchthal's heirs are searching for on Lost Art
Art Institute of Chicago
An oil painting by Lyonel Feininger from 1909. It has belonged to the Art Institute of Chicago since 1998, a bequest from Clara Hoover.
Its owner in the 1920s and 1930s was Eugen Buchthal, a Jewish manufacturer in Berlin who collected modern art. In 1938 he and his wife emigrated to London.
Lost Art has a search request for this painting as “cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution”, filed in January 2018. The record names the Art Institute and its accession number: it is certainly the same work.
The provenance the museum publishes says Buchthal owned it until “at least May 4, 1938” and that it was with Buchholz Gallery in New York “by 1951”. It does not say how it left Buchthal.
Two versions of the same story
The Art Institute publishes one provenance in its open data. The heirs filed another on Lost Art. The table puts them side by side, quoting the originals (the museum's in English, Lost Art's in German).
| Item | Art Institute of ChicagoPublished provenance (open-data dump, 18 Oct 2026) | Lost ArtSearch request 574791 (filed 25 Jan 2018) |
|---|---|---|
| Eugen Buchthal, Berlin | “by April 1928–at least May 4, 1938” | “Sammlung Eugen Buchthal, Berlin - Juli/August 1937” |
| Galerie Nierendorf | Only cited as a source (a 2003 letter) | “Juli/August 1937 (nicht verkauft, zurück) - 04.05.1938” (not sold, returned) |
| After May 1938 | Nothing | “Sammlung Eugen Buchthal, 04.05.1938 - [...]” |
| New York | “Buchholz Gallery, New York, by 1951” | Exhibition in New York, 1939; consigned to Curt Valentin, 1941 (MoMA archives) |
| Clara Hoover | “sold to Clare Hoover … June 15, 1955–1988” | “Sammlung Clara Hoover, New York 15.06.1955 - 1988” |
| Why it is on Lost Art | — | “NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut” (seized as a result of Nazi persecution) |
What we found
- Both versions agree on what they do say: in summer 1937 Buchthal consigned the painting to Galerie Nierendorf in Berlin; it did not sell and went back to him on May 4, 1938 (Lost Art cites the gallery's ledger: “4.5.38 an Buchthal”).
- Lost Art adds facts the museum does not publish: the painting appears in an exhibition of “banned” German art in New York in 1939 and in Curt Valentin's (Buchholz Gallery) consignment records in 1941. So it was in New York ten years earlier than the museum says.
- In 2017 the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation returned nine works from the Buchthal collection to his heirs, stating that the family was persecuted and emigrated to London in 1938.
What the museum should answer
- Has the Art Institute responded to the Buchthal heirs' search request, on Lost Art since 2018?
- What does the museum know about how the painting went from Buchthal to Curt Valentin, between May 1938 and 1939–1941?
- Why does its provenance start in New York “by 1951” when there are records from 1939 and 1941?
Sources
Art Institute of Chicago, open-data dump (provenance of 1998.357); Lost Art: “Longueil (Normandie)” (574791) — copy in our database; the page now requires an anti-bot check; Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation: restitution of works from the Buchthal collection (15 Aug 2017)
A Vienna porcelain figure at the V&A, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Herbert Gutmann
Victoria and Albert Museum, London
A tall white porcelain figure made at Claudius Du Paquier's factory in Vienna around 1720. The V&A bought it in April 1966 from the London dealer David Drey.
The V&A's published provenance starts with Herbert M. Gutmann (1879–1942) of Potsdam and continues: "1934, Sammlung Herbert M. Gutmann, Paul Graupe, Berlin, 12-14 April 1934, lot. 494". It says nothing more about that sale.
Lost Art holds a search request for that same lot 494 of the Gutmann sale, filed as "NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut" (cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution). It gives the same dimensions and the same 1965 sales and ends with "Victoria & Albert Museum, London", linking to the object's page.
Gutmann was a Jewish banker. The firm researching his collection for the family writes that he was "forced to auction his art collection at the auction house Paul Graupe in Berlin" and that the 1934 sale "can be characterized as persecution-related". In 2019 the Dutch Restitutions Committee recommended returning to his heirs fourteen Meissen pieces sold at that same auction, calling it a forced sale.
Two versions of the same story
The V&A and Lost Art give the same chain of owners. What differs is how the figure left Gutmann's hands. Original wording quoted.
| Item | Victoria and Albert MuseumPublished provenance (V&A API, 15-11-2026) | Lost ArtSearch request for lot 494 of the Gutmann sale |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 41.4 × 14.5 × 12.7 cm | "H 41/41,4 cm; B 14,5 cm; T 12,7 cm" |
| Before Gutmann | Not stated | "aus dem Johanneum, Dresden" |
| Herbert M. Gutmann | "Probably by the 1920s, Herbert M. Gutmann (b. 1879 - d. 1942), Potsdam, Germany" | "Herbert M. Gutmann" |
| 1934 sale | "Paul Graupe, Berlin, 12-14 April 1934, lot. 494" | "Auktion Paul Graupe 12.-14. April 1934, Los 494" |
| 1965 | Mak van Waay, Amsterdam, lot 1149; Sotheby's London, lot 76 | The same, with sellers, buyers (Hellinger, Stodel, E. van Dam, Clemente) and prices |
| Arrival at the museum | "1966, David Drey of 114 King’s Road, London, sold to the Victoria & Albert Museum in April" | "David Drey; Victoria & Albert Museum, London" |
| How it left Gutmann | Not stated | "NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut" (seized as a result of Nazi persecution) |
What we found
- It is certainly the same piece: the Lost Art request links to the V&A page and gives the same dimensions, lot number and 1965 sales.
- Our copy of Lost Art dates the request March 23, 2021. The V&A knows the chain of owners, but its record mentions neither the request nor the context of the sale.
- The Dutch Restitutions Committee (report RC 1.157, October 14, 2019) found the April 1934 Graupe sale "involuntary due to circumstances directly related to the Nazi regime" and recommended restituting fourteen Meissen pieces.
- Our detector missed it: the Lost Art record has no artist and the V&A record has no title. We found it by checking a Graupe-sale flag by hand.
What the museum should answer
- Does the V&A know this figure is the subject of a Lost Art search request? Has it contacted Gutmann's heirs?
- Why does the published provenance not say the 1934 sale was that of a persecuted Jewish collector, as the Dutch committee found?
- Would it take the case to the UK Spoliation Advisory Panel?
Sources
V&A: Du Paquier porcelain figure (C.24-1966); V&A, API pública: registro O187025; Lost Art: «Harlekin / Chinese» (594705); Facts & Files: investigación de procedencia de la colección de Herbert M. Gutmann; Comisión de Restituciones de Países Bajos: recomendación Herbert Gutmann (RC 1.157, 2019)
Willem Kalf's 'Nautilus Cup' in the Bührle collection is lot 45 of the 1935 Berlin auction that the Oppenheimer heirs list on Lost Art
Kunsthaus Zürich
The painting hangs in the Kunsthaus on loan from the Bührle Foundation. The museum's provenance says it belonged to the House of Hohenzollern and was sold at Paul Graupe's auction in Berlin on 26–27 April 1935, 'Lot 45'. Then there is a gap until 1950.
Lost Art holds a search request for a matching Kalf: 'Auktionskatalog Graupe Teil 2/45', 'Ehemaliger kaiserlicher Besitz', a gold-mounted nautilus cup on a stone table, 68.5 × 56 cm. It was filed by the Oppenheimer heirs as 'NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogen' and has been public since 2005.
That auction liquidated the stock of the Margraf group (Galerie van Diemen), whose Jewish managing director Jakob Oppenheimer fled in April 1933. The 2024 independent review (Raphael Gross) says a lawyer for the Oppenheimer and Beer heirs first asked for the painting's return in April 2000.
The Kunsthaus record gives it no category and mentions neither the claim nor Lost Art; it only says the provenance is 'under review'.
What we found
- Our detector missed it: the Lost Art title is just 'Stilleben'. We found it by matching the auction lot number by hand.
- According to the Gross report, in 2015 the UK Spoliation Advisory Panel concluded, for other works from the same auctions, that the sale was due to the 1929 crisis rather than persecution. Gross replies that the sales are still 'in engem Zusammenhang mit antisemitisch motivierter Ausgrenzung' and that the foundation's category A is 'nicht haltbar'.
- The report also says the correspondence with the heirs' lawyer ended with a letter from the foundation in December 2010.
What the museum should answer
- Will the Kunsthaus mention the Lost Art entry and the 2000 claim on the record?
- What happened between 1935 and 1950? Who bought the painting at Graupe's sale?
- Is the Oppenheimer and Beer heirs' claim still open?
Sources
Kunsthaus Zürich: Willem Kalf, «Nautilusschale» (BU/0153); Lost Art: Willem Kalf, «Stilleben» (308702); Raphael Gross y otros: Überprüfung der Provenienzforschung der Sammlung E. G. Bührle (2024), cap. 3.2
Toulouse-Lautrec's 'Messaline': the Kunsthaus says 'provenance clear', but it has been on Lost Art since 2006 and the Gross report says that classification does not hold
Kunsthaus Zürich
The painting belonged to the Katzenellenbogens, Jewish collectors in Berlin. According to the Kunsthaus, it went to Estella Katzenellenbogen at the couple's divorce in 1930; she emigrated to California in 1940 and sold it between 1948 and 1951 to Walter Feilchenfeldt, who sold it to Bührle.
Lost Art has a search request for 'Szene aus Messalina', same dimensions, under the Estella Katzenellenbogen collection, as 'NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogen'. It has been public since 2006 and is handled by a New York law firm.
The Kunsthaus record classifies it as 'Provenienz klar' (provenance clear) and does not mention Lost Art.
Two versions of the same story
The Kunsthaus record and the independent report commissioned by the city, the canton and the Kunsthaus itself, side by side (both in German).
| Item | Kunsthaus ZürichRecord BU/0103 (read 15 Nov 2026) | Gross report (2024)'Überprüfung der Provenienzforschung', ch. 2.4.1.3 |
|---|---|---|
| AssessmentDiffers | 'Provenienz klar' | 'ist die Einordnung in die Kategorie A … nicht haltbar' |
| Estella KatzenellenbogenDiffers | '1930 – mindestens bis 1948, Estella Katzenellenbogen (*1886, +1991), Berlin/Santa Monica (Kalifornien)' | 'Darüber hinaus müsste bestätigt werden, dass das Werk tatsächlich das Eigentum von Estella Katzenellenbogen war' |
| Sale to FeilchenfeldtDiffers | 'frühestens ab 1948 – 14.11.1951, Walter Feilchenfeldt' | No original documents in the Kunsthaus files |
| Lost ArtDiffers | Not mentioned | 'in der Lost-Art-Datenbank unter der ID 312894 als NS-verfolgungsbedingter Verlust gemeldet' |
'Da jedoch die Nachweise nicht vorliegen, ist die Einordnung in die Kategorie A, die eine lückenlos erforschte, unproblematische Provenienz voraussetzt, nicht haltbar.' (Since the evidence is lacking, classifying it in category A, which requires a fully researched, unproblematic provenance, is untenable.)
What we found
- Ludwig Katzenellenbogen was arrested by the Gestapo in 1941 and died in 1944 in Berlin's Jewish Hospital. Gross says it is not proven that the painting belonged to Estella rather than Ludwig, and that if it was his, it must be established who inherited it.
- Gross writes that the files the Kunsthaus gave him contain no original documents for the transfer from Estella to Feilchenfeldt.
What the museum should answer
- Why does the record still say 'Provenienz klar' when the report the Kunsthaus itself commissioned says otherwise?
- What document proves the painting was Estella's and not Ludwig Katzenellenbogen's?
- Have the Kunsthaus or the foundation answered the Lost Art request?
Sources
Kunsthaus Zürich: Toulouse-Lautrec, «Messaline» (BU/0103); Lost Art: «Szene aus Messalina» (312894); Informe Gross (2024), cap. 2.4.1.3
Four Bührle paintings the foundation offered to settle with heirs in 2024, still without agreement
Kunsthaus Zürich
On 14 June 2024 the Bührle Foundation announced it would seek 'fair and just solutions' with the heirs of the Jewish former owners of five paintings and took them off display. One, Richard Semmel's Gauguin, was settled in June 2025. No settlement has been published for the other four.
The Monet and the Courbet belonged to Franz Ullstein, of the Jewish Berlin publishing family whose firm was sold under compulsion in 1934. The Monet was sold in Zurich in 1941 by the Aktuaryus gallery to Bührle for CHF 16,800. The Courbet was sent to Geneva in 1941 and surfaced in 1942 at Fritz Nathan's gallery, which sold it to Bührle. In both cases the Kunsthaus writes that it is not known whether the Ullsteins received the money.
The Van Gogh and the Toulouse-Lautrec were stock of the Paul Cassirer gallery, run by Walter Feilchenfeldt, who fled Berlin in 1933 and was stranded in Switzerland without a work permit. Fritz Nathan bought the Van Gogh from him in 1942 (selling it to Bührle in 1945) and sold the Toulouse-Lautrec on his behalf the same year.
The Kunsthaus records tell all this, label the works 'Hinweise auf NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut' (indications of property confiscated through Nazi persecution) and repeat the 2024 announcement. The Art Newspaper reported in April 2026 that for the Van Gogh 'no agreement has been reached'.
What we found
- The two settlements that did happen (Manet's 'La Sultane' with the Silberberg family in April 2025, and Gauguin's 'La Route montante' with the Semmel heirs in June 2025) kept the paintings in the museum. The record shows the date of the agreement.
- In May 2025 the Kunsthaus and the foundation agreed on five years of provenance research on the 205 works on loan.
What the museum should answer
- What has happened with the negotiations over the four paintings?
- Is it now known whether Franz Ullstein and his children were paid for the Monet and the Courbet?
Sources
Kunsthaus Zürich: Monet, «Le Jardin de Monet à Giverny» (BU/0072); Kunsthaus Zürich: Courbet, «Louis-Joseph Lebœuf» (BU/0025); Kunsthaus Zürich: Van Gogh, «Le Vieux Clocher» (BU/0051); Kunsthaus Zürich: Toulouse-Lautrec, «Georges-Henri Manuel» (BU/0105); The Art Newspaper, 17-06-2024: la Fundación Bührle buscará acuerdos por cinco cuadros; The Art Newspaper, 17-04-2026: la colección Bührle se vuelve a colgar; ArtDependence, 27-05-2025: el Kunsthaus y la fundación definen los próximos pasos
Henri Rousseau's 'The Muse Inspiring the Poet': Kunstmuseum Basel admits it bought it cheaply from an exiled Jewish collector, but will not return it
Kunstmuseum Basel
Kunstmuseum Basel bought the painting in September 1940 from Countess Charlotte von Wesdehlen, née Reichenheim, formerly married to Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy. The museum itself writes that she was 'a German-Swiss woman of Jewish origin who was forced to leave her hometown of Berlin', and that she sold because of financial hardship in exile.
It paid CHF 12,000. The director at the time, Georg Schmidt, called it 'shamefully cheap' and estimated it could fetch CHF 30,000 to 40,000 on the open market.
An heir asked for restitution. In January 2024 the museum announced that its commission had decided against returning it, treating the sale as 'flight assets' (Fluchtgut), where restitution is an exception. As of November 2026 the case is still listed among the museum's ongoing projects, with negotiations for a 'just and fair solution'.
The object record in the online collection says none of this: only that it was bought from the countess in Geneva through Christoph Bernoulli.
Two versions of the same story
The museum publishes two versions: the provenance on the online record and a summary of its historical research. The table sets them side by side, quoting the originals (the record in German, the summary in English).
| Item | Online collection recordProvenienz, inv. 1774 (read 15 Nov 2026) | Museum's research summary'Summary of historical findings' |
|---|---|---|
| SellerDiffers | 'Charlotte Gräfin von Wesdehlen, Genf' | 'Countess Charlotte von Wesdehlen (1877-1946), née Reichenheim… a German-Swiss woman of Jewish origin' |
| Why she soldDiffers | Not stated | 'Due to the financial difficulties she faced in exile in Switzerland' |
| PersecutionDiffers | Not mentioned | 'Charlotte von Wesdehlen's entire personal fortune was used to pay the Jewish property tax and the Reich Flight Tax' |
| PriceDiffers | Not stated | CHF 12,000; Schmidt called it 'shamefully cheap' |
| DateDiffers | '2.9.1940' | 'September 1, 1940' (per the invoice) |
| ClaimDiffers | Not mentioned | Case page: restitution request rejected; negotiations for a 'just and fair solution' |
'As she was in urgent need of money, she continued to lower her demands during the negotiations until, of the CHF 25,000 she had originally hoped for, only CHF 12,000 remained and was ultimately paid.' The museum wrote this itself; the object record does not say it.
What we found
- The same summary says the countess sold other works to the Kunsthaus Zürich in 1940–42: Rousseau's 'Pierre Loti avec le chat' and a flower still life (CHF 43,000 for both), and in 1942 a Picasso ('Saltimbanque assise avec garçon') for CHF 11,000. What the Kunsthaus says about those purchases is covered in the Kunsthaus review.
- The museum does not dispute the facts; it disputes the rule. For the commission, a sale in Switzerland by someone who fled is restitutable only as an exception, and in this case such an exception 'is neither obvious nor justified', according to the museum.
- The countess died in Geneva in 1946. Her widower and then his brother received German compensation for the discriminatory taxes, but not for the artworks or what was left in Berlin.
What the museum should answer
- What came of the negotiations for a 'just and fair solution' opened in 2024?
- Why does the object record not say that the seller was a persecuted Jewish woman selling in exile, when the museum has researched and published this?
- Has the Kunsthaus Zürich applied the same standard to the works it bought from the same seller in 1940 and 1942?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Basel: ficha de «La Muse inspirant le poète» (inv. 1774); Kunstmuseum Basel: «Summary of historical findings» (PDF); Kunstmuseum Basel: «A painting by Henri Rousseau»; Kunstmuseum Basel: proyectos de procedencia en curso; Swissinfo: el Kunstmuseum Basel rechaza devolver el Rousseau
A Largillière in the Montreal museum that the ERR seized from the Rothschilds in 1941
Musée des beaux-arts de Montréal
A Largillierre portrait the Montreal museum bought in 1977. The museum includes it on its list of works with incomplete provenance.
Its provenance has three steps: Comte Léon de Valon, Baron Edmond de Rothschild in 1928, and Galerie Kurt Meissner in Zurich.
The ERR, the Nazi looting agency in France, has a record of the same painting: it was seized in April 1941 at Alexandrine de Rothschild's house in Boulogne and repatriated to France in December 1945.
The museum mentions neither the seizure nor how the painting went from the Rothschilds to the Zurich gallery.
What we found
- The ERR record (R 860) gives the old title, 'Marquise de Dreux-Brézé as a shepherdess', 139 × 106.5 cm, and says it had belonged to Edmond de Rothschild: it matches the museum's title and size.
- The ERR record notes the repatriation to France, but no return to the family.
What the museum should answer
- Is the museum aware that the ERR seized the painting in 1941?
- Was it returned to the Rothschilds after 1945, and when did the family sell it?
Sources
MBAM, «Works with Incomplete Provenance»: Nicolas de Largillierre, «Portrait of a Woman as Astrea, Probably Mary Josephine Drummond, Condesa de Castelblanco» (1977.1); ERR Project, ficha 18279 (R 860): Largillière, «Bildnis der Marquise de Dreux-Brezé als Schäferin»
A High Museum Sisley that Max Braunthal's heirs seek in Lost Art
High Museum of Art, Atlanta
A Sisley landscape of 1884 that entered the High Museum in 2019 with the Doris and Shouky Shaheen gift.
Since July 2023 Lost Art has carried a search request filed by the heirs of Max Braunthal, a German Jewish collector living outside Paris.
According to the request, Braunthal offered it under duress at the Hôtel Drouot in May 1939, it went unsold, and he sold it privately before December 1939, already stripped by Germany.
The museum's record publishes no provenance for the work.
What we found
- The Lost Art request links to the High's own record: it is the same work.
- In 2026 the same heirs sued the Met in France over a Pissarro sold in 1941; the Met says the sale was legitimate.
What the museum should answer
- Is the High Museum aware of the Braunthal heirs' search request?
- What provenance does the museum have between 1939 and the Shaheen collection?
Sources
High Museum of Art: Sisley, «Barges at Saint-Mammès» (2019.160); Lost Art 614091 — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots (Anubis); AGI: los herederos Braunthal demandan al Met por un Pissarro (06-02-2026)
The Pushkin Museum’s catalogue names German museums as former owners of five paintings those museums are searching for on Lost Art
Museo Pushkin de Bellas Artes, Moscú
The Pushkin Museum publishes its online catalogue with a «former owner» field (владелец) and the date of inventory registration. For five paintings that owner is a German collection, or the intermediary Lost Art names.
All five are on Lost Art as war losses their museums are still searching for: the Weimar collections (Preller), the Kunsthalle Bremen (Carstens), the Alte Nationalgalerie in Berlin (Menzel) and the Prussian Palaces Foundation (Hummel and Limborch).
The Pushkin registrations date from 1948, 1954, 1955, 1965 and 1986. We found no restitution in any case.
Two versions of the same story
Lo que dice cada fuente, con el texto original entre comillas (el del Pushkin en ruso, el de Lost Art en alemán).
| Item | Museo Pushkin | Lost Art |
|---|---|---|
| Preller, «Wartburg» (147 × 114 cm) | «Владелец: Государственное художественное собрание, Веймар»; registro 26-10-1965 | «Am 9.3.1946 auf Befehl der sowjetischen Militärregierung aus dem Weimarer Schlossmuseum nach Berlin abtransportiert» |
| Carstens, «Adán y Eva»Differs | «Владелец: Кунстхалле, Бремен»; registro 29-12-1955; 22 × 26,8 cm | Kunsthalle Bremen, «Das erste Elternpaar», «Vermächtnis J. F. Lahmann 1937»; 21,5 × 26,5 cm |
| Menzel, «El hermano del artista desayunando»Differs | «Владелец: Национальная галерея Берлина»; registro 15-03-1948; 26 × 29 cm | Alte Nationalgalerie, «1906 Ankauf, 1945 im Flakturm Zoo verschollen»; 24 × 29 cm |
| Hummel, «Arpistas en el Schlackenburg» | «Владелец: Государственные дворцы Берлина»; registro 31-12-1954; 58 × 48 cm | SPSG, «jetzt im Staatlichen Puschkin-Museum Moskau (1954 erworben)»; 58 × 49 cm |
| Limborch, «El hallazgo de Moisés» | «Владелец: Вишневский Феликс Евгеньевич»; registro 12-06-1986; 44,5 × 37,3 cm | SPSG, «1970 von F.J. Wischnewski, Moskau, dem Kulturministerium der UdSSR übergeben; 1985 in das Puschkin-Museum»; 44 × 37 cm |
What we found
- In two cases the Pushkin gives sizes one or two centimetres off Lost Art’s (Menzel: 26 vs 24 cm high). Title and former owner match.
- The Pushkin catalogue also names the Königsberg City Museum (Liebermann, Agricola), the Albertinum in Dresden, the Dresden Gallery of Modern Masters and the Anhalt ducal collection as former owners. We found no search requests for those in our database.
What the museum should answer
- Has the Pushkin ever answered the search requests from Weimar, Bremen, Berlin and Potsdam?
- What records does the museum hold on how these paintings arrived in 1948–1965?
Sources
Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea: Ж-3935; Lost Art: «Landgraf Friedrich der Gebissene bringt sein Töchterchen von der Wartburg zur Ta»; Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea: Ж-3734; Lost Art: «Das erste Elternpaar»; Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea: Ж-3560; Lost Art: «Der Bruder des Künstlers am Frühstückstisch (Richard Menzel)»; Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea: Ж-3712; Lost Art: «Harfenspielerinnen auf der Schlackenburg bei Teplitz» (36768); Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea: Ж-4479; Lost Art: «Auffindung Mosis» (59378)
Lost Art places 182 works from Gotha, the Prussian palaces and the Berlin museums in the Pushkin Museum; the museum’s online catalogue does not show them
Museo Pushkin de Bellas Artes, Moscú
In 182 Lost Art search requests, the German museum that lost the work itself states where it is now: «heutiger Standort: Puschkin-Museum Moskau», often with the Pushkin inventory number (ЭЖ-…) or the date it was registered there in 1946.
They are mostly paintings from the Friedenstein Palace Museum in Gotha (54) and the Prussian Palaces Foundation (112), plus works from the Alte Nationalgalerie in Berlin, lost in 1945–46 when Soviet trophy brigades removed them.
We count them as open cases (169): works lost by German museums that, according to the record, sit in a Russian museum without restitution. Another 13 are pending, because the record says «probably» or because in 1946 they were on a list of paintings for the Georgian Republic.
None appears in the Pushkin’s online catalogue, which publishes about 1,800 paintings, nor in the Goskatalog, the state catalogue of Russian museums.
Two versions of the same story
Un ejemplo: la tabla de Willem van Mieris de Gotha.
| Item | Lost Art (Gotha) | Museo Pushkin |
|---|---|---|
| Dónde está | «heutiger Standort: Puschkin-Museum Moskau, Objekt 1010174, Nr. ЭЖ-958 (40 x 33 cm)» | No figura en el catálogo en línea |
| Exhibición | «auf der Ausstellung 'Kriegsbedingt verbrachte Kulturgüter' im Frühjahr 1995 in Moskau im Puschkinmuseum gezeigt» | — |
What we found
- These are losses of German public museums. We found no works of collectors persecuted by the Nazis on this list.
- Many Prussian palace records say the Pushkin registered them «am 22./30. März 1946» or «am 10. Oktober 1946».
What the museum should answer
- Why does the Pushkin’s online catalogue leave out the paintings numbered ЭЖ?
- Where are the works that in July 1946 were on the list for Georgia?
Sources
Lost Art: «Spielende Kinder» (4353); Lost Art: «Die heiligen drei Könige» (4371); Lost Art: «Die Waage in Haarlem» (4405); Lost Art: «Heilige Genoveva (?)» (109937); Lost Art: «Stillleben mit Früchten und Blumen» (108679); Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea
Lost Art places 6 works lost by Gotha, the Alte Nationalgalerie and the Siemens collection in the Hermitage
Museo del Hermitage, San Petersburgo
The Hermitage’s online collection does not respond from outside Russia. We used the Goskatalog, where the Hermitage lists 46,036 paintings, drawings, prints and sculptures, nearly all drawings and prints. There is no provenance there.
The strong leads come from Lost Art. Gotha is searching for a Cranach «Lucretia» and writes that it is in the Hermitage as ГЭ-8539, quoting the museum itself: «Entered the Hermitage in 1946; handed over by Colonel-General N.E. Chibisov».
Gotha also places a baptismal basin by Hans Schebel (Э-16113, entered 1951 from Gokhran) and a ring with a watch (Э-17116) in the Hermitage. The Alte Nationalgalerie says two paintings lost in 1945 at the Zoo flak tower, a Lenbach (portrait of Reinhold Begas) and a Leys, are «heute in der Staatlichen Ermitage».
A private person is searching for Delacroix «Zinnias» from Friedrich Carl Siemens’s collection, lost at the Pergamonmuseum in 1945, and writes «Standort: EREMITAGE (ausgestellt 1995)».
Two versions of the same story
Lo que dicen las fichas de Lost Art.
| Item | Lost Art | Госкаталог |
|---|---|---|
| Cranach, «Lucretia» | «jetziger Standort: Eremitage St. Petersburg, Inv.Nr. ГЭ-8539» | No figura |
| Lenbach, «Reinhold Begas» | «1945 im Flakturm Zoo verschollen, heute in der Staatlichen Ermitage» | No figura |
What we found
- None of these works is in the part of the Goskatalog the Hermitage publishes.
- The automatic match against the Goskatalog produced six hits; all six are false alarms (another painter, another subject, or works identified in another country).
What the museum should answer
- Why does the Hermitage not list these works in the state catalogue, when its own website says they entered in 1946 and 1951?
Sources
Lost Art: «Taufbecken» (208643); Lost Art: «Ring mit Uhr» (210332); Lost Art: «Lucretia» (530312); Lost Art: «Bildnis Reinhold Begas» (533499); Lost Art: «Dürer den Erasmus zeichnend» (533501); Lost Art: «Blumenstück, Zinnien» (5000000551)
Munich's Pinakotheken have restitutions decided but not carried out since 2020, and two cases the state proposed for arbitration
Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Múnich
The museum's provenance research page lists works “pending restitution” that have not yet been returned.
Ochtervelt's “Das Zitronenscheibchen”: the Advisory Commission recommended returning it to Carl Hagen's heirs in July 2020. Therese Brettauer's Waldmüller and two Venetian paintings of Edith Weinberger have had restitution decided since 2023, the Jochsberger Zimmermann since 2025.
Two disputed cases were proposed by the minister in 2024 for the new arbitration tribunal: the Amerling the museum received in 1935 from the Lion dealers, and Picasso's “Madame Soler”, claimed by Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy's heirs.
In addition, the museum publishes chains for dozens of works which, by its own records, were confiscated from unidentified Jewish owners, including goods stored at Munich's Funkerkaserne that the Bavarian state transferred to it in 1955.
What the museum should answer
- Why is the restitution recommended in 2020 still “in preparation”?
- What heir searches were carried out for works confiscated from “unknown Jewish owners”?
Sources
Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen: Provenienzforschung (restituciones y casos abiertos); Pinakotheken, Sammlung Online: «Das Zitronenscheibchen» (Inv. 16217); Pinakotheken, Sammlung Online: «Junge Bäuerin mit drei Kindern im Fenster» (Inv. 12895); Pinakotheken, Sammlung Online: «Am Wirtshaustisch» (Inv. 13053); Pinakotheken, Sammlung Online: «Junges Mädchen mit Strohhut» (Inv. 9999)
A Klee the Städel bought in 1961 matches the title and size of a Lost Art search request
Städel Museum, Fráncfort
A small 1919 oil by Paul Klee. According to its online record, the Städel bought it in 1961; the record gives no provenance.
Lost Art has a search request filed in 2008 by a private person for Klee's “Das Haus zur Distelblüte”, 34.5 × 29.5 cm, as “cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution”, lost between 1933 and 1945.
Title and dimensions are identical. The request names neither the owner nor where the work is.
What the museum should answer
- From whom did the Städel buy the painting in 1961?
- Is the museum aware of the 2008 search request?
Sources
Städel, Digitale Sammlung: «Das Haus zur Distelblüte» (SG 1207); Lost Art: «Das Haus zur Distelblüte» (399250)
A Courbet apple branch at the Orsay that Hugo Simon's heirs are searching for on Lost Art
Musée d'Orsay, París
A small Courbet oil of a flowering apple branch. Max and Rosy Kaganovitch gave it to the Louvre in 1973; since 1986 it has been at the Orsay.
Hugo Simon's heirs are seeking it on Lost Art as “cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution”. Simon was a Berlin banker and former Prussian finance minister who fled to Paris in 1933. The request names the Orsay and cites the catalogue raisonné (Fernier no. 782): it is certainly the same work.
According to the request, Simon had the painting on deposit at the Kunsthaus Zürich, and on 6 November 1936 it was sent to Max Kaganovitch in Paris, “probably on consignment”. The request cites letters in the Kunsthaus archive.
The Orsay's web page cannot be read by a program (captcha). We found no public response from the museum.
What the museum should answer
- Did Kaganovitch pay Hugo Simon for the painting, or receive it on consignment and never return it?
- Has the Orsay or the CIVS responded to the heirs' request?
Sources
Lost Art: «Apfelblüten» (392542); Wikidata: «Branche de pommier en fleurs» (RF 1973 14, Musée d'Orsay)
A Lotto that Hitler bought for Linz in 1940 is in Copenhagen, and the museum does not say so
Statens Museum for Kunst, Copenhague
A portrait of a bearded man in a cap and fur coat, attributed to Lorenzo Lotto. The Statens Museum for Kunst bought it in 1954.
It is the same painting listed as Linz 1314 in the Deutsches Historisches Museum's database: Hitler bought it in 1940 for his Linz museum, delivered by the dealers Nathan and Benjamin Katz of Dieren for RM 25,000 via Hans Posse. The Linz photograph and SMK's image show the same pose, coat, letter in hand and ring; the dimensions match too.
After the war it went through the Munich Collecting Point (no. 4378) and was returned to the Netherlands in 1946.
SMK's published history names only Böhler (1917), Boltenweizer (1925) and the Hague dealer G. Cramer, through whom it reached the museum in 1954. It does not mention Linz, Katz or the Collecting Point.
What we found
- Our copy of the Dutch (SNK) record says “G. Cramer: claim terzijde gelegd”: Cramer claimed the painting after the war and the claim was set aside. That record is no longer online (410).
- The heirs of Nathan and Benjamin Katz claimed 189 NK works the firm had sold during the occupation before the Dutch Restitutions Committee; in 2013 one was returned and the rest rejected (upheld in 2017). This Lotto was not in that claim: the Dutch state no longer held it.
What the museum should answer
- Does SMK know its Lotto is Linz 1314?
- Who owned it before the Katz brothers sold it to Hitler, and what was Cramer claiming?
- How did it pass from the Dutch state to Cramer, and from Cramer to the museum in 1954?
Sources
SMK: KMS4855; SMK, API: historia del objeto; DHM, Sonderauftrag Linz: LI001321; DHM, Central Collecting Point München: 4378; Wikimedia Commons: foto de Linz 1314; Restitutiecommissie: Katz, RC 4.168 (15-11-2017)
Klimt's «The Blind Man» at the Leopold Museum: Lost Art seeks it for the Hellmann heirs; the museum says it was sold in 1932
Leopold Museum, Viena
An early portrait by Gustav Klimt, around 1896. It is at the Leopold Museum, which received it with Rudolf Leopold's collection in 1994; Leopold had bought it at a Christie's New York sale in 1981.
Lost Art lists a search request for it as «seized as a result of Nazi persecution». It says it belonged to Paul and Irene Hellmann of Vienna, who on 26 August 1938 declared it among the assets they wanted to export, and that its whereabouts are unknown until the Leopold Museum, named with its inventory number.
The museum publishes another history: the Hellmanns bought it at the Dorotheum in 1917, Irene Hellmann sold it at a Vienna auction in November 1932 and it was in unknown hands until 1981. It cites a dossier by Sonja Niederacher of January 2018 but publishes no advisory-board decision.
Two versions of the same story
Las dos versiones, con el texto original entre comillas.
| Item | Leopold MuseumProcedencia publicada en la colección en línea | Lost ArtPedido de búsqueda 569160 |
|---|---|---|
| Paul e Irene Hellmann | «Dr. Paul und Irene Hellmann, Wien (1917-1926)»; «Irene Hellmann, Wien (1926-1932)» | «Dr. Paul und Irene Hellmann, Wien» |
| 1932Differs | «Auktion: 03.-05.11.1932, Buch- und Kunstantiquariat Dr. Ignaz Schwarz, Wien» | Nada |
| 1938Differs | Nada | «26.08.1938 Anmeldung der Vermögensgegenstände zur Ausfuhr bei der Zentralstelle für Denkmalschutz in Wien» |
| 1932–1981 | «unbekannter Privatbesitz (1932-1981)» | «Verbleib unbekannt» |
| Hoy | «Leopold Museum-Privatstiftung, Wien (1994)» | «Leopold Museum, Wien (Inv. Nr. 4144)» |
What we found
- If the 1932 sale is documented, the work left the Hellmanns before the «Anschluss»; if it is in their 1938 declaration, it was still theirs. Both cannot be true of the same painting.
- The museum published the reference to the 2018 dossier but not its content or a decision.
What the museum should answer
- What document proves the 1932 sale at Ignaz Schwarz, and what does the Hellmanns' 1938 asset declaration say?
- Has the case gone to the advisory board?
Sources
Leopold Museum: «Der Blinde» (LM 4144); Lost Art: «Der Blinde» (569160) (copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots)
An Ashmolean Poussin that Hugo Simon's heirs seek on Lost Art
Ashmolean Museum, Oxford
One of the Ashmolean's most important paintings: Poussin painted it in 1654 for Jacques Stella. The museum bought it in 1950 with help from Sir Edward Fry's daughters and the Art Fund.
Lost Art lists a search request for it as «seized as a result of Nazi persecution». It says it belonged to Hugo Simon, a Berlin banker and former Prussian minister who fled to Paris in 1933, at least from 1925 to 1936, and that on 6 November 1936 it was on consignment with the dealer Max Kaganovitch; the reference comes from a letter by the director of the Kunsthaus Zürich.
The museum's record publishes no provenance: only the 1950 credit line.
What we found
- It is the same collector as the Belvedere's two Friedrichs: Austria declined to return them in 2008 because Simon sold them in Switzerland, outside Nazi territory. Here the sale would have gone through Paris in 1936, also from exile.
- Lost Art gives smaller dimensions (136 × 190 cm) than the museum (149.5 × 204.5); it may be a sight or unlined measurement, but this needs checking.
What the museum should answer
- Is the Ashmolean aware of the Hugo Simon heirs' search request?
- What does the museum know about how the work went from Simon to Kaganovitch and on to the 1950 sale?
Sources
Ashmolean: «The Exposition of Moses» (WA1950.169); Lost Art: «Findung Moses» (392611) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots; Kunstrückgabebeirat (Austria): decisión sobre otras dos obras de Hugo Simon, con su biografía (21-11-2008)
A Toulouse-Lautrec at the Kröller-Müller sought on Lost Art: it belonged to the Berlin collector Oskar Skaller
Kröller-Müller Museum, Otterlo
A Toulouse-Lautrec portrait from 1884. It has belonged to the Kröller-Müller Museum since 1957, a gift from Wilhelm Weinberg.
Lost Art lists a search request for this painting as «cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution». The record places it with Oskar Skaller of Berlin before 1924 and with Bernard Houthakker of Amsterdam in 1938, ending with the gift to the Kröller-Müller.
The museum's page publishes no provenance or acquisition details.
What we found
- We found no Dutch Restitutions Committee ruling on the work.
- The move from Skaller to Houthakker in 1938 is exactly the stretch a museum should document.
What the museum should answer
- Has the Kröller-Müller researched how the work passed from Oskar Skaller to Bernard Houthakker in 1938?
- Has it responded to the search request published on Lost Art?
Sources
Wikidata: «Jeanne» (Q24019486), KM 101.915; Lost Art: «Jeanne» (530298) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots
Two Friedrichs at the Belvedere that Hugo Simon's heirs seek on Lost Art, although Austria declined to return them
Belvedere, Viena
Two small seascapes by Caspar David Friedrich, painted around 1807. They have belonged to the Belvedere since 1939, received from Galerie Fischer in Lucerne in exchange for four works by Segantini.
They belonged to Hugo Simon, a Berlin banker and former Prussian finance minister, persecuted as a Jew and as an opponent, who fled to France in March 1933 and died in Brazil in 1950. He kept them on deposit at the Kunsthaus Zürich and the Kunstmuseum Basel, and in August 1939 sold them to Theodor Fischer.
In 2008 the Austrian Art Restitution Advisory Board did not recommend returning them: it accepted that Simon might not have sold them without the persecution, but said the sale took place in Switzerland, outside Nazi territory, and that the law does not cover it.
The heirs keep two search requests on Lost Art listing them as «seized as a result of Nazi persecution» and naming the Belvedere and its inventory numbers.
What we found
- The Board quotes a letter from Simon of 4-1-1933: «circumstances force me to take this step».
- According to the Board, the Berlin dealer Karl Haberstock was the one who in February 1939 put the Österreichische Galerie in touch with the paintings.
What the museum should answer
- Has the Belvedere re-examined the case under the Washington Principles, which are not limited to sales inside Nazi territory?
- What role did Haberstock play in the exchange with Fischer?
Sources
Belvedere: «Meeresstrand mit Fischer» (objects/2496) — bloqueada a pedidos automáticos; Kunstrückgabebeirat: Beschluss Hugo Simon (21-11-2008); Lost Art: «Meeresstrand mit Fischer, Seestück» (392547) — copia en nuestra base; Lost Art: «Schiffe im Nebel» (392548) — copia en nuestra base
Eight Nationalgalerie paintings the museum itself recognises as Nazi-looted and keeps because it found no heirs
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Nationalgalerie
They are eight paintings that belonged to Rudolf Wiltschek of Berlin (Dix, Degner, Wollheim, Hellwag and Walter Jacob). They passed to the Dresdner Bank, and in 1935 the Prussian state bought them from the bank, along with some 4,400 other works, for the Berlin museums.
On each record the museum writes that it identified the work as a loss caused by Nazi persecution («NS-verfolgungsbedingter Entzug») and that, since the search for heirs failed, it posted it on Lost Art as a found object.
All eight remain in the Neue Nationalgalerie.
What we found
- The Lost Art entries (found-object reports 618168 to 618179) repeat the chain: Wiltschek from 1926/1928, the Dresdner Bank until 15 August 1935, the Prussian Finance Ministry and the Nationalgalerie.
- None of the records explains who Wiltschek was or how he lost the works.
What the museum should answer
- What search for heirs was made, and when was it closed?
- Why does the museum not publish who Rudolf Wiltschek was, if it has concluded that he was persecuted?
Sources
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Bildnis eines Bauern» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 635); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Stillleben mit gebratenem Geflügel» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 216); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Blumenstrauß in Kanne Verso: Weiblicher Akt mit Ornamenten» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 167); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Auf der Themse» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 638); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Fischerboot im Hafen» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 637); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Heiligenhafen» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 639); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Bildnis einer Bäuerin Verso: Männlicher Halbakt» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 634); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Meerfrau» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 633); Lost Art 618175: «Bauer / Bildnis eines Bauern»; SMB Central Archive: research into the works bought from the Dresdner Bank in 1935
Works of the dealer Annie Caspari, murdered in 1941, still in the Berlin museums: eight passed to the bank after the Nazis took power
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Nationalgalerie y Gemäldegalerie
Annie Caspari ran Munich's Galerie Caspari after her husband Georg died in 1930. She was Jewish; in 1941 she was deported to Kaunas and murdered.
The gallery owed money to Bankhaus Hardy and the Dresdner Bank and pledged paintings to them as collateral. In 1935 the bank sold Prussia all its art, some 4,400 works, which Prussia distributed among the Berlin museums.
According to the chains the museum itself publishes, 28 Caspari works remain in the Nationalgalerie and the Gemäldegalerie. Eight passed to the bank on 31 July or 1 August 1933, with the Nazis already in power; under German guidelines, a persecuted person's losses after 30 January 1933 are presumed to be persecution-related.
Kokoschka's «Pariser Platz in Berlin» was pledged to the bank in March 1932. In 2017 the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation said it was researching it with the Commission for Looted Art, on behalf of Caspari's heirs, under a confidentiality agreement. No outcome has been published.
What we found
- Among the works pledged in August 1933 is Kokoschka's «Herr Hirsch», owned half by Caspari and half by the dealer Hugo Perls.
- In 2024 the museum returned five Galerie Matthiesen works that had arrived the same way, although those debts also predated 1933.
- On none of the 28 records does the museum publish an assessment of the case.
What the museum should answer
- What did the joint research on the «Pariser Platz» conclude?
- Why does the museum not assess the works that passed to the bank after January 1933?
Sources
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Pariser Platz in Berlin» (Ident.-Nr. A III 465); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Herr Hirsch» (Ident.-Nr. A III 448); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Jacques de Menasce» (Ident.-Nr. D.B. 61); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Tänzerin in der Bar» (Ident.-Nr. A III 658); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Madonna. Triptychon» (Ident.-Nr. A III 688); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Landschaft am See» (Ident.-Nr. A IV 169); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Hafen von Cannes» (Ident.-Nr. A III 593); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Ruhender Mann» (Ident.-Nr. A III 660); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Ferdinand von Österreich, Kardinal-Infant von Spanien (1609-1641)» (Ident.-Nr. B.132); SPK (7-11-2017): «Kunst durch Kredit», sobre el «Pariser Platz» de Kokoschka y los herederos de Annie Caspari; Jüdische Allgemeine (11-4-2014): «Zweifel an der Herkunft»; Sebastian Peters: «Die Galerie Caspari in München» (tesis, LMU Múnich); SMB (22-10-2024): restitución de cinco obras a los herederos de la Galerie Matthiesen; SMB, Zentralarchiv: investigación de las obras compradas a la Dresdner Bank en 1935
Four paintings of Abraham Adelsberger that Lost Art lists as Nazi-looted are in the Nationalgalerie
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Nationalgalerie
Abraham Adelsberger of Nuremberg owned a collection of 19th-century German painting catalogued in 1925. Five of his paintings reached the Nationalgalerie in 1935 with the purchase of the Dresdner Bank's holdings.
For four of them (Heyden, Heffner, Boller and Hofelich) Lost Art holds search requests as property «seized as a result of Nazi persecution», with the full chain: a pledge to the Isay brothers in 1930, a failed Helbing auction that year and, in November 1932, a pledge by Abraham and Paul Adelsberger to the Dresdner Bank.
The museum's records give the same chain but mention neither the requests nor the persecution.
What we found
- The fifth work, «Herbst», comes from the same group and the same loan; we found no request of its own on Lost Art.
- Lost Art lists about a hundred search requests from the Adelsberger collection.
What the museum should answer
- Has the museum answered the Lost Art search requests?
- How does the museum assess a November 1932 pledge that the bank realised in 1935?
Sources
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Strohgedeckter Bauernhof» (Ident.-Nr. A III 613); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Abendstimmung» (Ident.-Nr. A III 611); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Sommer» (Ident.-Nr. A III 846); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Abendwolken» (Ident.-Nr. A III 873); Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Sammlung Online: «Herbst» (Ident.-Nr. A III 665); Lost Art 238758: «Strohgedeckter Bauernhof»; Lost Art 238751: «Abendstimmung»; Lost Art 238724: «Sommer»; Lost Art 238761: «Abendwolken»; SMB, Zentralarchiv: investigación de las obras compradas a la Dresdner Bank en 1935
An MNR painting at the Louvre that, according to its own record, came from a Jewish collection in Vienna
Musée du Louvre, París
«Couple dansant devant une maison. Fête familiale» is one of the MNR works: recovered in Germany after the war, never returned to their owners, and held by the French State ever since. It does not belong to the Louvre.
The Louvre's record says it was returned to France because it was believed to come from an unknown French collection, and then adds that, according to the German archives in Koblenz, in 1944 it was in Kajetan Mühlmann's office in Austria and «proviendrait d'une collection juive viennoise».
If the archives are right, the work has spent more than seventy years waiting for a French owner who never existed.
What we found
- The record's own words: «Le tableau est considéré comme provenant d'une collection française inconnue et restitué pour cette raison à la France ; mais selon les archives de Coblence, ce tableau qui se trouvait en 1944 dans le "Bureau Mühlmann" en Autriche, proviendrait d'une collection juive viennoise».
- The Ministry of Culture's Rose-Valland database classifies it as «Oeuvre probablement spoliée».
- Kajetan Mühlmann ran art looting in annexed Austria and later in Poland and the Netherlands.
What the museum should answer
- Did anyone ask Austria (the Commission for Provenance Research or the National Fund) about this work?
- What exactly does the Koblenz document (Bundesarchiv B323/571) say about the Viennese collection?
Sources
Musée du Louvre: «Couple dansant devant une maison. Fête familiale» (MNR 941); Base Rose-Valland (POP): MNR 941; Musée du Louvre: álbum «Musées Nationaux Récupération»
Four MNR works whose wartime owner or seller is named in the Louvre's record
Musée du Louvre, París
Most MNR works have no known owner, which is why they remain unreturned. These four do carry a name in the history the Louvre publishes, and the Rose-Valland database classifies them as «probablement spoliée».
A Van Kessel that Karl Haberstock bought in 1941 from «Arthur Goldschmidt, Nice»; the Boucher from the Bellevue chapel, owned by the Destrem family, which the Germans took in 1944 against the will of the dealer Dequoy, according to his statement; a Jules Dupré the SS took in Berlin from Major B. Teifel after a «Volksschädling» trial; and a Van Goyen that went from the Van Diemen gallery in Berlin to the 1938 Guy Stein sale and to Haberstock.
The Dupré is also lost: it was deposited at the Ministry of Justice and no one has found it since 1977.
What we found
- This is an MNR work (MNR 738), on deposit at the Musée Baron-Martin in Gray. The Louvre's record says Karl Haberstock, Hitler's dealer, bought it in 1941 «à Arthur Goldschmidt, Nice», and earlier names the H. Winterfeld collection in Nice and, from a photograph, the dealer Graupe. In other words, the 1941 seller has a name. The Rose-Valland database classifies it as «probablement spoliée». An open case: who Arthur Goldschmidt was, under what conditions he sold in the Vichy zone and whether anyone looked for his heirs are all unknown.
- This is an MNR work (MNR 823), the Boucher painted for the chapel at Bellevue, on deposit at the Musée des Beaux-Arts in Lyon. The record says it belonged to Henri Destrem (died 1941), passed in 1943 to the notary Raymond Destrem, was bought by the dealer Roger Dequoy and in 1944 was sold to Maria Dietrich through Fabiani and then to the Linz museum (no. 3334). It quotes Dequoy's statement: the Germans «ont passé outre et ont enlevé le tableau». The Rose-Valland database classifies it as «probablement spoliée». An open case: there is a named family (Destrem) and a sale under pressure, and the work still has no owner.
- This is an MNR work (MNR 906) with an unusual history: according to the record, in 1944 it belonged to Major B. Teifel of Berlin and was taken by the SS after a «Volksschädling» («enemy of the people») trial; it ended up at Alt Aussee and was sent to France in 1950. It was deposited at the Ministry of Justice, where it was seen in 1976 but not in 1977: it is now listed as missing and a complaint has been filed. The Rose-Valland database classifies it as «probablement spoliée». Open on two counts: the dispossessed owner has a name and the work is lost.
- This is an MNR work (MNR 438) kept at the Louvre. The record follows it through Sedelmeyer, the De Ridder collection, Kleinberger, Heinemann and Van Diemen (Berlin, c. 1932) to the «vente Guy Stein, Paris, 1938» and Karl Haberstock's Berlin gallery around 1938. The Rose-Valland database classifies it as «probablement spoliée». The record does not say who sold it at the Stein sale or how it reached Haberstock. An open case: the 1932–1938 stretch between Van Diemen, a Berlin gallery with Jewish owners, and Haberstock is what needs documenting.
What the museum should answer
- Were the heirs of Arthur Goldschmidt, the Destrem family and B. Teifel sought?
- What happened to the Dupré deposited at the Ministry of Justice?
Sources
Musée du Louvre: «Paysage boisé» (MNR 738); Base Rose-Valland (POP): MNR 738; Musée du Louvre: «La Lumière du monde (Adoration des bergers)» (MNR 823); Base Rose-Valland (POP): MNR 823; Musée du Louvre: «Paysage sous l'orage» (MNR 906); Base Rose-Valland (POP): MNR 906; Musée du Louvre: «Plage près d'Egmond (Pays-Bas)» (MNR 438); Base Rose-Valland (POP): MNR 438
A Payen the Rijksmuseum bought in 1942 from a Jewish woman in Amsterdam
Rijksmuseum, Ámsterdam
In November 1942, as the Jews of Amsterdam were being deported, the Rijksmuseum bought for 800 guilders from Jadwiga Vuijk, née Reich Rosenblatt, a view of the Dutch resident's house in Banyuwangi (Java) painted by Antoine Payen in 1828.
The provenance the museum publishes is a single line: «from the dealer Jadwiga Vuijk - Reich Rosenblatt, Amsterdam, fl. 800, to the museum, 1942».
The Dutch museums' survey of acquisitions since 1933 (Museale Verwervingen) says its provenance is «not clear» because it is unknown since when «the Jewish Jadwiga Vuijk» owned it and it cannot be shown that the sale was voluntary and at a reasonable price. It records that no restitution request has been filed.
What we found
- The museum bought it in November 1942, for 800 guilders, from Jadwiga Vuijk, née Reich Rosenblatt, of Amsterdam. The Dutch survey of museum acquisitions since 1933 (Museale Verwervingen) says its provenance is «not clear» because it is unknown since when this Jewish woman owned it and it cannot be shown that the sale was voluntary and at a reasonable price. The same record notes that no restitution request has been filed («Geen verzoek»). A purchase from a persecuted person, in the middle of the Occupation, that the museum itself cannot justify: an open case.
What the museum should answer
- What happened to Jadwiga Vuijk-Reich Rosenblatt after 1942? Were her heirs sought?
- What does the museum's 1942 inventory say about the price and terms of the purchase?
Sources
Rijksmuseum: «View of the house of the resident, Mr. J. Ph. van Zuylen van Nyevelt, in Banyuwangi (East Java)» (SK-A-3452); Museale Verwervingen: SK-A-3452
A Jan Ekels pledged to a bank in 1940 and sold by the bank to the State in 1944
Rijksmuseum, Ámsterdam
According to the provenance, it belonged to Robert Heinrich May (Huis ter Heide) and in 1940 was pledged as security for a loan from the Lippmann, Rosenthal & Co. bank on the Spiegelstraat; in 1942 it was deposited for safekeeping at the museum and in 1944 the bank sold it to the Ministry for 6,000 guilders. It passed to the museum in 1946. It is listed in Museale Verwervingen, the Dutch museums' list of works acquired since 1933 with unclear provenance. A 1944 sale by the bank of an item a private person had pledged is exactly the kind of transaction that needs review: open until it is known whether May was persecuted and whether he was paid.
What we found
- The museum's provenance: «collection Robert Heinrich May (1873-1962), Huis ter Heide, 1940;{RMA Archive May, R., List 12 November 1940, as Stork.} as security for a loan from the Lippmann Rosenthal Bank Spiegelstraat, Amsterdam;{RMA Archive R. May, List 12 November 1940, as Stork.} by whom placed in the custody of the»
What the museum should answer
- Who was Robert Heinrich May and was he persecuted?
- Was May paid anything from the 1944 sale?
Sources
Rijksmuseum: «The so-called Boerenverdriet on the Spui, Amsterdam» (SK-A-3475); Museale Verwervingen: SK-A-3475
Matisse's «Les anémones»: sold by a Bernheim during the Occupation and bought by Bern in 1945
Kunstmuseum Bern
Gaston Bernheim de Villers, of the Jewish dealer family Bernheim-Jeune, owned the painting from 1924. On 15 December 1943, with France occupied, he sold it in Cannes to Raphaël Gérard, a Paris dealer who traded in looted works.
Gérard resold it to the publisher Albert Skira in March 1944, and the Kunstmuseum Bern bought it through the Rosengart gallery in Lucerne in February 1945.
The museum publishes the chain from Gérard's purchase and sales books, rates the work «Gelb-rot» (indications of looting) and says the circumstances of the sales need research. In June 2025 it listed it for further research and a search for possible claimants.
What we found
- The 1943 sale is by a Jewish owner in occupied territory to a dealer in the looted-art market. Under the policy the museum itself adopted in 2025, in doubtful cases it presumes in favour of victims. The painting remains in the collection and no solution with the heirs has been published.
What the museum should answer
- What price did Gérard pay in 1943 and who received it?
- Has the museum contacted the heirs of Gaston Bernheim de Villers?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Bern, informes de procedencia 2023–2024 (PDF), «Les anémones»; Kunstmuseum Bern, dossier de prensa del 11-06-2025; Kunstmuseum Bern: Provenienzkategorien (Berner Ampel)
A Slevogt the museum itself places in the looted category, still without a decision
Kunstmuseum Bern
«Pfalzlandschaft» (1930) by Max Slevogt belonged to Robert Neumann of Berlin-Wannsee from 1930 until probably 1938. It then appears at the Kunsthaus Luzern and with Ilse Neumann in Los Angeles, and in 1941 the dealer Fritz Nathan sold it to the Canton of Bern, which deposited it in the museum.
In the final report of its 2023–2024 project the museum writes that the state of research corresponds to category D (Nazi-looted), that the report is under expert review and will be published when finished.
In June 2025 it listed the work among decisions in preparation for its own collection. We found no later published decision.
What we found
- It is the only work in the museum's own collection that the museum rates as looted, and it remains on view with no published restitution or settlement.
What the museum should answer
- Who were Robert and Ilse Neumann and how did the painting leave Berlin around 1938?
- When will the museum publish the report and its decision?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Bern, informes de procedencia 2016–2017 (PDF), «Pfalzlandschaft»; Kunstmuseum Bern, informe final del proyecto BAK 2023–2024; Kunstmuseum Bern, dossier de prensa del 11-06-2025
A Goya «Carnival Scene» requisitioned from the Jewish Herzog family in 1944 is at the Pushkin; Hungary also claims works of the Hatvanys
Museo Pushkin de Bellas Artes, Moscú
The collections of Mór Lipót Herzog and Ferenc Hatvany, two Jewish families in Budapest, were confiscated in 1944; in 1945 the Red Army took what it found. In January 1995 the Russian Ministry of Culture admitted holding 132 paintings from both collections, most of them in Nizhny Novgorod.
Goya’s «Carnival Scene» passed from Herzog to his son András, was requisitioned in 1944, taken in 1945 to the Grabar restoration centre and has been at the Pushkin since 1995, according to the Fundación Goya en Aragón catalogue.
The Pushkin showed it in 1995 in «Twice Saved» alongside Renoir’s «Chrysanthemums and a Japanese Fan», also from Hungarian Jewish collectors according to Apollo. In 1998 Hungary also named a Corot portrait of a woman at the Pushkin as coming from Hatvany.
Russia’s 1998 law exempts from nationalisation property lost because of race or religion, but we found no return of these works.
Two versions of the same story
Lo que dice cada fuente sobre la «Escena de carnaval».
| Item | Fundación Goya en Aragón | Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea |
|---|---|---|
| Dueño anteriorDiffers | «Mor Lipot Herzog Collection, Budapest. Latter passes his son Baron András Herzog Csepel» | Sin ficha |
| 1944–1945Differs | «the requisition all Jewish families artworks. In 1945 the picture is recovered by the Russian army» | Sin ficha |
| UbicaciónDiffers | «since 1995 the work is in its current location at the Pushkin Museum in Moscow» | No figura entre las 4.347 obras publicadas |
What we found
- The Pushkin’s online catalogue (4,347 records read) has neither the «Carnival Scene», the Renoir, nor any Goya painting: the works brought in 1945 are not published.
- Hatvany works that left Russia by other routes did go back to his heirs: Courbet’s «Femme nue couchée» surfaced in Slovakia and was restituted around 2005 (it is not the Hermitage’s «Reclining Woman»).
What the museum should answer
- What inventory numbers do the «Carnival Scene» and the Renoir have at the Pushkin, and what does their internal record say about the 1944 confiscation?
- Did Hungary file its claim for these works within the 18-month window of the 1998 law, and how did Russia answer?
Sources
Fundación Goya en Aragón: «Escena de carnaval», ficha y procedencia; Apollo, 6-1-2020: «Haul of shame – the ‹trophy art› taken from Germany by the Red Army» (Jessica Loudis); The Moscow Times, 24-1-1995: «Moscow Confirms Art Hoards»; JTA, 29-12-1998: «Russia reaffirms pledge to return Nazi looted art» (Gabriel Eschenazi); Ley federal rusa n.º 64-FZ del 15-4-1998 (texto en inglés en lootedart.com); AP vía NBC News, 12-10-2007: «Happy ending for looted Courbet painting»
About 307 Koenigs drawings that Hitler bought for Linz have been at the Pushkin since 1945; the Netherlands claims them
Museo Pushkin de Bellas Artes, Moscú
The banker Franz Koenigs pledged his drawings collection to an Amsterdam bank in April 1940; D. G. van Beuningen bought it and sold part to Hans Posse for Hitler’s Linz museum.
The DHM Linz database records «Sammlung Koenigs mit 304 deutschen Handzeichnungen» and notes the Soviet occupation authorities took them on 19 June 1945. In 1992 the Russian culture minister said they had been «found» in Russia; they are at the Pushkin.
The Dutch State claims 307 or 308 drawings (depending on the source); Russia does not return them. Ukraine, by contrast, returned the 139 Koenigs drawings held in Kyiv in 2004.
This is not persecution-related loot: the Dutch Restitutions Committee rejected the Koenigs grandchildren’s claim in 2003 and 2013 because the loss was not due to the Nazi regime. It is an occupied state’s claim for works sold under occupation.
Two versions of the same story
Las fuentes sobre los dibujos de Koenigs.
| Item | DHM, base de Linz | Museo Boijmans |
|---|---|---|
| CantidadDiffers | «304 deutschen Handzeichnungen» | «another 308 missing drawings that are in the Pushkin Museum» |
| Camino | «Sammlung Koenigs / Haarlem» → «Sammlung Beuningen / Rotterdam 2.8.1941» | «Van Beuningen felt obliged to sell one fifth of the drawings to the German occupiers» |
| 1945 | «von den sowjetischen Besatzungsbehörden übernommen am 19.6.1945» | — |
What we found
- On the same day, 19 June 1945, the Soviet authorities also took 41 Rembrandt etchings from the Gutmann collection in Vienna, which had entered Linz in 1942. We could not find where they are.
- The Linz database lists 16 more paintings with «Verbleib: Russland» (among them a Coques bought in Paris in 1943 and an Everdingen from the Six collection), with no museum. None matches the Pushkin’s online catalogue.
What the museum should answer
- Will the Pushkin publish the inventory of the Koenigs drawings?
- Did the Gutmann Rembrandt etchings reach the Pushkin?
Sources
DHM, base «Sonderauftrag Linz»: LI004791 (colección Koenigs, 304 dibujos alemanes); DHM, base «Sonderauftrag Linz»: LI005267 (41 aguafuertes de Rembrandt, colección Gutmann); Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen: «The Koenigs Collection»; Restitutiecommissie: «Koenigs collection claim rejected» (2013); The Art Newspaper, 1-11-1992: «All right, we have got the Koenigs collection, but we still won’t tell you where» (Olga Rumyantseva y Jacob Voorthuis)
Gerstenberg, Koehler, Siemens: paintings of Berlin collectors at the Hermitage that their families still seek
Museo del Hermitage, San Petersburgo
Otto Gerstenberg, director of the Victoria insurance company, died in 1935; his collection was divided among his heirs and Soviet troops took what remained in 1945. The Hermitage holds Degas’s «Place de la Concorde» (ГЭ-10622) and three Renoirs; in 1996 35 of his Goya drawings also surfaced. By 1997 two descendants had lodged a claim.
Six paintings in the Hermitage’s trophy series (ЗКсэ-/ЗКРсэ-) match in artist, title and size searches that a private individual filed in Lost Art: a Courbet, two Cézannes, a Seurat and two Renoirs. Wikidata names Bernhard Koehler as owner of «Mont Sainte-Victoire».
Delacroix’s «Flowers» (ЗКсэ-924) belonged to Friedrich Carl Siemens and were lost in 1945 at the Pergamonmuseum; the family searches for them in Lost Art.
None of these collectors was persecuted by the Nazis: these are claimed war losses, not Nazi looting. Russia’s 1998 law only admits claims from states, not from German private owners.
Two versions of the same story
Cuadros del Hermitage y búsquedas de Lost Art, lado a lado (medidas en cm).
| Item | Hermitage (vía Wikidata) | Lost Art |
|---|---|---|
| Courbet, «Mujer recostada» | ЗКсэ-1394; 77 × 128 | 233859; 77 × 127; cita la muestra del Hermitage de 1995 |
| Cézanne, «Manzanas, duraznos, peras y uvas» | ЗКсэ-1580; 37 × 44 | 233856; 37 × 44 |
| Cézanne, «Montaña Sainte-Victoire»Differs | ЗКсэ-1395; 81 × 100,5 | 233858; 78 × 96 |
| Seurat, «Fort Samson»Differs | ЗКсэ-1577; 65 × 81,5 | 233863; 69 × 81 |
| Renoir, «Manzanas y flores» | ЗКсэ-1528; 32,8 × 41,4 | 233866; 32,8 × 41,4; cita la muestra de 1995 |
| Renoir, «Mujer peinándose» | ЗКРсэ-507; 65,3 × 54 | 233874; 65,3 × 54; cita la muestra de 1995 |
| Delacroix, «Flores» | ЗКсэ-924 | 5000000551; 130 × 100 (con marco); «Standort: EREMITAGE (ausgestellt 1995)» |
What we found
- Lost Art also lists, from the same individual, an El Greco Saint John the Baptist, two Van Goghs, a Manet («Rosita Mauri») and a Cézanne «Still Life with Mirror»; we did not find them at the Hermitage.
- Our database had Courbet’s «Femme couchée» as Nazi loot; Lost Art says «Kriegsbedingt verbrachtes Kulturgut» (war loss). It needs correcting.
- The Baldin collection (362 drawings and 2 paintings of the Kunsthalle Bremen) was shown at the Hermitage in 1992; its return, decided in 2003 by the Ministry of Culture, was blocked by the Duma and the Prosecutor General.
What the museum should answer
- How did Russia answer the Gerstenberg descendants’ claim?
- Who filed Lost Art searches 233856–233874, and which collection do they come from?
Sources
The Art Newspaper, 31-3-1997: «Twenty-five Hermitage ‹treasures› gained as war loot still unclaimed» (Martin Bailey); The Art Newspaper, 1-12-1996: «The Gerstenberg Goyas resurface at the Hermitage»; The Washington Post vía The Spokesman-Review, 30-3-1995: «Russia displays masterpieces seized from Germans»; Lost Art: «Femme couchée» (233859); Lost Art: «Blumenstück, Zinnien» (5000000551); Universidad de Ginebra, ArThemis: «Baldin Collection – Kunsthalle Bremen, Germany and State Hermitage Museum, Russia»; PubHist: obras de «Hidden Treasures Revealed» (Hermitage, 1995)
A Frederick the Great hanging in Halberstadt that the Bavarian state posted on Lost Art as Nazi loot
GLEIMHAUS Museum der deutschen Aufklärung (Halberstadt)
The Gleimhaus in Halberstadt shows a portrait of Frederick the Great by Gottfried Hempel as a permanent loan from the Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen (Munich). Its record discusses Gleim and Hempel but says nothing about where the painting was in the 20th century.
The Staatsgemäldesammlungen posted that painting on Lost Art as a found object with the circumstance «NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut»: until 1945 it was in the Nazi party buildings in Munich, went through the Central Collecting Point (no. 7539) and was not inventoried because it was not certain it had been in Germany before the war.
The dimensions match almost to the millimetre: 137 × 106 cm in Halberstadt, 136 × 105.8 cm on Lost Art.
What we found
- The owner before the Nazi party is not identified. The Gleimhaus displays the painting without mentioning its own lender's Lost Art report.
What the museum should answer
- Does the Gleimhaus know its lender posted the painting as a possible loss?
- Who owned it before it reached the party buildings in Munich?
Sources
Gleimhaus, ficha en museum-digital (A 210 DLG); Lost Art 527007: «König Friedrich der Große von Preußen»; DHM, Central Collecting Point de Múnich, n.º 7539
A Greek relief in Hanover that the museum describes as confiscated from Jews in France and given to Göring
Museum August Kestner (Hannover)
The Museum August Kestner writes in its record that the relief was confiscated from Jewish owners during the German occupation of France and offered on the Paris market from 1943.
According to the museum, the Munich dealer Walter Bornheim sold it to Robert Ley, head of the German Labour Front, who gave it to Hermann Göring for his 50th birthday. The inventory number indicates the museum has held it since 1964.
The record does not name the dispossessed owners and mentions neither a Lost Art report nor a restitution.
What we found
- It is a case the museum itself identifies as looting and keeps without a published solution.
What the museum should answer
- Who were the owners in France?
- How did the relief go from Göring's collection to Hanover in 1964?
- Did the museum report it to Lost Art or to the French CIVS?
Sources
The bottle the Hagen museum director took from Cläre Bachrach in 1939; she was murdered in Auschwitz
Stadtmuseum Hagen
The Stadtmuseum Hagen writes in the record that the bottle belonged to Cläre Bachrach, widow of the Jewish family that owned a well-known porcelain and glass shop, «aryanized» in 1937.
After the November 1938 pogrom, the museum director and the mayor took pieces from her collection. In May 1939 the director «confiscated» this bottle, which she had offered for sale; he paid her 100 RM that she had to hand to the tax office.
Cläre Bachrach fled to Brussels in July 1939 and was murdered in Auschwitz in 1943. The museum says its post-war director concealed the bottle's origin.
What we found
- The record mentions no restitution, agreement with heirs or Lost Art report.
What the museum should answer
- Has the museum searched for the heirs of Cläre Bachrach and the Seligmann family?
- What happened to the other pieces taken in November 1938?
Sources
Two candelabra the Beirat ordered returned in 2021 that the MAK still holds
MAK – Museum für angewandte Kunst, Viena
The MAK bought these candelabra at the Dorotheum on 4 February 1942. On 29 June 2021 the Kunstrückgabebeirat established that they had belonged to Alfred Kirchenberger, a St. Pölten physician classed as Jewish under the Nuremberg laws, who surrendered them in 1939, and recommended returning them to his heirs.
The National Fund's Kunst-Datenbank still shows them in the museum, with the status «Heirs being sought».
What we found
- They are not on the MAK's restitution list (updated November 2020, before the decision).
What the museum should answer
- Have Alfred Kirchenberger's heirs been found? Have the candelabra been handed over?
Sources
Kunstrückgabebeirat, Beschluss «Alfred Kirchenberger», 29-6-2021; Kunst-Datenbank: «Two candelabras», GO 1844
A Courbet at the Art Institute of Chicago with the same measurements as a painting sought on Lost Art as a forced sale by “W. Westfeld, Düsseldorf”
Art Institute of Chicago
A Courbet landscape of 1868, at the Art Institute of Chicago since 1956, a gift of Morris and Rose Kaplan.
Lost Art has a search request, filed in January 2014, for a Courbet titled “Le Puits Noir”, oil, 111 × 138 cm, with this provenance: “W. Westfeld, Düsseldorf, Zwangsverkauf um 1938” (forced sale around 1938).
The measurements match the Chicago painting to within two millimetres. Courbet painted several views of the Puits-Noir, so the match alone does not prove it is the same canvas, but it is the strongest lead we found in this museum.
The museum's provenance jumps from an auction in Paris in 1890 to “Paul Du Sartay, by 1940”, who lent it to an exhibition in New York. It says nothing about the fifty years in between and does not name Westfeld.
Two versions of the same story
What the Art Institute publishes and what Lost Art records, side by side (originals in quotation marks).
| Item | Art Institute of ChicagoPublished provenance (open-data dump, 18 Oct 2026) | Lost ArtSearch request 478559 (filed 16 Jan 2014) |
|---|---|---|
| Title | “The Valley of Les Puits-Noir” | “Le Puits Noir” |
| Measurements | 111.1 × 137.8 cm | 111 × 138 cm |
| 1868–1890 | A. Gavet (1868); Mazaroz-Ribalier sale, Paris, 1890 | — |
| 1890–1940 | Nothing | “W. Westfeld, Düsseldorf, Zwangsverkauf um 1938” |
| Afterwards | “Paul Du Sartay, by 1940 [lent to New York 1940]”; Morris and Rose Kaplan, Chicago, by 1956 | Whereabouts unknown |
What we found
- Walter Westfeld was a Jewish dealer with a gallery in Wuppertal-Elberfeld until 1936; he then moved to Düsseldorf. He was arrested in November 1938 while trying to leave Germany; what remained of his collection was confiscated and auctioned by Lempertz in Cologne in December 1939. He was deported to Theresienstadt and murdered in Auschwitz in 1943.
- The Lost Art record says “W. Westfeld, Düsseldorf”, not the full name. Walter Westfeld is the most likely owner, but it is not confirmed.
- Our copy of the Lost Art record has no photograph or catalogue number; without them, the identification remains open.
What the museum should answer
- Does the Art Institute know about Lost Art search request 478559? Has it compared its painting with the one being sought?
- Where was the painting between 1890 and 1940? Who was “Paul Du Sartay”, and when and from whom did he buy it?
Sources
Art Institute of Chicago, open-data dump (provenance of 1956.762); Lost Art: “Le Puits Noir” (478559) — copy in our database; the page now requires an anti-bot check; Wikipedia: Walter Westfeld
A portrait of Adolph Menzel by Karl Stauffer-Bern at the National Gallery in Washington, sought on Lost Art by the heirs of Adele Paechter
National Gallery of Art, Washington
Charcoal and graphite portrait of the painter Adolph Menzel, bought by the NGA in 2007 with the Ratjen collection.
Lost Art lists a search request (518828) under Adele Paechter: the drawing belonged to her husband Hermann Paechter, the Berlin dealer to whom Stauffer-Bern dedicated it, and Lost Art says «NS-verfolgungsbedingter Verlust vermutet» (loss due to Nazi persecution presumed).
The NGA provenance starts with the 1990 Kornfeld sale. It does not name the Paechters, although the dedication is on the drawing itself.
Two versions of the same story
La procedencia de la National Gallery contra la de Lost Art.
| Item | National Gallery of ArtProcedencia de 2007.111.41 (datos abiertos) | Lost ArtPedido 518828, Adele Paechter |
|---|---|---|
| Hermann y Adele PaechterDiffers | No figuran | «Hermann Paechter (Pächter) bis 1902; Adele Paechter (Pächter); NS-verfolgungsbedingter Verlust vermutet» |
| Antes de 1990Differs | Nada | «Familie Tschamper (Nähe Zofingen/Schweiz)» |
| Subasta | «(sale, Galerie Kornfeld, Bern, 22 June 1990, no. 984)» | «Galerie Kornfeld, Bern, Auktion 204, 20.-22.6.1990; Nr. 984» |
| Ratjen y el museo | «Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich; purchased 2007 by NGA» | «Wolfgang Ratjen, Vaduz; seit 2007 National Gallery of Art, Washington» |
Lost Art transcribe la dedicatoria del dibujo: «Herrn H. Paechter/freundschaftl. von/Stauffer Bern/85».
What we found
- Near-identical dimensions (29.1 × 21.7 cm vs 29.1 × 21.8), same Kornfeld lot (984), and Lost Art links to the NGA.
- Lost Art presumes rather than asserts the loss («vermutet») and leaves a gap («[…]») between Adele Paechter and the Tschamper family in Switzerland. Open, but weaker than the other two.
- The NGA does name Hermann Paechter elsewhere: Manet's «The Melon» (2014.18.29), «bought by Isidore Bloch or Hermann Paechter, Berlin» in 1888.
What the museum should answer
- When and how did the drawing leave Adele Paechter's hands?
- Does the NGA know how it reached the Tschamper family?
- Has it answered the Lost Art request?
Sources
National Gallery of Art: «Adolph Menzel» (2007.111.41); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Porträt Adolph Menzel» (518828); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»
Two Guardis at the Cleveland Museum of Art: from a Jewish banker who fled in 1933 to a Berlin gallery in 1944
Cleveland Museum of Art
Two Venetian views by Francesco Guardi that the Cleveland Museum of Art bought in 1949 from Jacques Seligmann & Co., New York.
Their provenance, as the museum publishes it, has three steps: Jakob Goldschmidt, “Berlin, 1929, and New York”; “Galerie Matthiessen, Berlin, 1944”; Seligmann, New York, which sold them in 1949.
Jakob Goldschmidt was one of Germany's leading bankers. He was Jewish: he fled to Switzerland in April 1933 and to New York in 1936. Much of his collection stayed in Berlin and was auctioned in those years; German state museums have already returned several works to his heirs, treating them as sales forced by persecution.
The Cleveland museum places the paintings in a Berlin gallery in the middle of the war, while their owner was in exile, and does not explain how they got there.
What we found
- In 2023 the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation returned to Goldschmidt's heirs a Madonna bought in 1936, stating that he “was forced to accept” the sale of a large part of his collection.
- The museum has a third painting with the same chain: Corot's “Woman Meditating” (1949.189) passed through Galerie Matthiesen in Berlin and Goldschmidt in New York “by 1941”, and was also sold by Seligmann in 1949. The record adds that the Berlin gallery's files were destroyed in the war.
- We did not find the Guardis on Lost Art or in our databases of sought works.
What the museum should answer
- What document places the paintings at Galerie Matthiesen in Berlin in 1944?
- When and how did they stop belonging to Jakob Goldschmidt? Did they come back to him in New York before the sale to Seligmann?
- Has the museum researched these works in light of the restitutions to Goldschmidt's heirs?
Sources
Cleveland Museum of Art: 1949.187.1; Cleveland Museum of Art: 1949.187.2; Cleveland Museum of Art, Open Access API (CC0); Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation: restitution of a Maria Lactans to the heirs of Jakob Goldschmidt (24 Jan 2023)
A Bonnard in Cleveland: from the Kapferer brothers, looted by the ERR, to the Pétridès gallery in occupied Paris
Cleveland Museum of Art
The Cleveland Museum of Art bought this Bonnard in 1949 from Paul Rosenberg & Co., New York.
Its provenance says it belonged to Henri and Marcel Kapferer, Paris, “by 1924”, and that in 1943 it was at Galerie O. Pétridès in Paris, which exhibited it that year. It does not say how it went from the Kapferers to Pétridès.
The Kapferer collection was looted by the ERR, the Nazi agency that confiscated Jewish collections in France: the Jeu de Paume database holds hundreds of records of works from “Madame Kapferer” and Marcel Kapferer, among them several Bonnards and a Vuillard portraying the two brothers at table.
During the occupation Paul Pétridès bought works confiscated by the ERR, including from the Paul Rosenberg collection, from the German dealer Gustav Rochlitz, according to the INHA directory of the art market under the occupation.
What we found
- We did not find “The Dessert” among the ERR records we hold (the ERR did not record everything it took and used German titles), nor on Lost Art.
- The museum notes that the Bonnard catalogue raisonné misdates to 1932 an exhibition to which the Kapferers lent the painting (it was 1924), and that there is no evidence it was with Pétridès in 1932.
What the museum should answer
- When and how did the painting leave the Kapferer collection? Was it in Paris in 1940–41, when the ERR took the collection?
- From whom did Pétridès buy it?
Sources
Cleveland Museum of Art: 1949.18; ERR, Jeu de Paume database: record KAP 7, Vuillard, “Henry et Marcel Kapferer à table”; INHA, Directory of art-market actors in France under the Occupation: ROCHLITZ Gustav
A Ruysdael in Minneapolis: from a Berlin banker forced to emigrate to a New York gallery in 1944
Minneapolis Institute of Art
The Minneapolis Institute of Art (Mia) bought this Ruysdael in January 1945 from Knoedler, New York, which co-owned it with Pinakos, Rudolf Heinemann's firm.
The museum's provenance says it belonged to Dr. Paul Kempner, Berlin, “before 1925, and possibly still in 1938”. A note adds that Kempner was a partner in the bank Mendelssohn & Co. and that “the aryanization of the bank forced him to emigrate”, first to England and in 1939 to the United States.
The next step is “Pinakos, Inc. (Rudolf Heinemann), New York, by 1944”. The museum does not say how or when the painting left Kempner.
What we found
- The museum itself acknowledges that the owner was persecuted and that the work may have stayed with him until 1938: the museum leaves the case open in writing.
- We did not find the painting on Lost Art or in our databases. It should be checked on the museum's website, which now puts automated requests behind an anti-bot check (Vercel).
What the museum should answer
- How did the painting pass from Paul Kempner to Rudolf Heinemann? Did Kempner take it into exile and sell it himself, or did it stay in Germany?
- Has the museum looked for Kempner's heirs?
Sources
Mia, public collection search (provenance of 45.9); Mia: “River Landscape with a Ferry” (the website requires an anti-bot check)
A Dorville-collection watercolour at Yale, sought on Lost Art: the 1942 Nice auction a French court called spoliative
Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven
A small watercolour of a reclining woman in Spanish costume, after Manet's composition. Yale catalogues it as an anonymous copy; John S. Thacher gave it in 1959.
Yale publishes the full provenance: it belonged to Armand Dorville, a Paris collector who died in 1941, and was sold at the auction of his collection at the Hall du Savoy in Nice, June 24–28, 1942, lot 341. Yale lists it on its 'Artworks with Nazi-Era Provenance Documentation Gaps' page.
Since 2023 Lost Art has held a search request for the work, attributed to Manet, as "NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut", with the same chain and Yale's accession number.
In December 2025 the French Cour de cassation held that the auction was spoliative even though the executor organised it: during the sale, Vichy's Commissariat-General for Jewish Affairs appointed a provisional administrator who seized the proceeds.
Two versions of the same story
Yale and Lost Art tell the same story. They differ on the attribution and on how they describe the 1942 sale.
| Item | Yale University Art GalleryPublished provenance (LUX, 15-11-2026) | Lost ArtSearch request, Armand Dorville collection |
|---|---|---|
| Author | "Unknown", "Copy of Reclining Young Woman in Spanish Costume" | "Manet, Edouard" |
| Dimensions | 16.4 × 23.5 cm (sheet) | "H: 15,00 cm ; B: 24,00 cm" |
| Before Dorville | Fauchier-Magnan; Bignou; "Sold to Armand Dorville (1875-1941), Paris" | The same |
| 1942 | "Hall du Savoy, Nice, June 24-28, 1942 lot 341;Sold to Monsieur Cima, Monte Carlo, France (2300 francs)" | "Hall du Savoy, Nizza, 24. bis 28. Juni 1942, Los 341" |
| Afterwards | John S. Thacher, to 1959; given to Yale | The same, with "inv. 1959.63" |
| How it left Dorville | Not characterised; listed on the Nazi-era gaps page | "NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut" |
What we found
- It is the same work: Lost Art gives Yale's accession number, 1959.63, and the same chain of owners and lot.
- Our copy of Lost Art dates the request September 8, 2023.
- In 2022 France restituted to the Dorville heirs twelve works the State had bought at that auction (Act 2022-218). According to Pinsent Masons (December 16, 2025), the Cour de cassation overturned the rulings against the claim for the others and held the sale spoliative because of the Vichy-imposed provisional administrator.
- Yale classifies it under 'Watercolors', so it was not in our paintings run. We found it by searching Lost Art for records that name Yale.
What the museum should answer
- Has Yale responded to the Lost Art request? Has it contacted the Dorville heirs?
- Does the Cour de cassation ruling on the Nice auction change anything for Yale?
- Does it still hold that the work is an anonymous copy rather than a Manet?
Sources
Yale University Art Gallery: «Copy of Reclining Young Woman in Spanish Costume» (1959.63); LUX (Yale): registro de la obra; Lost Art: «Jeune femme couchée en costume espagnole» (614981); Pinsent Masons: fallo de la Cour de cassation sobre el remate Dorville (16-12-2025)
An Engebrechtsz at Yale that appears on Belgium's list of works stolen by the Germans
Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven
A panel by Cornelis Engebrechtsz., an early-16th-century Leiden painter. Yale received it in 2019 by bequest of Herbert and Monika Schaefer, who had lent it to the museum since 1981.
Yale's provenance states that at a Brussels auction on January 31–February 1, 1944 it was bought by dealer Maurice Lagrand, who sold it to Walter Andreas Hofer, Göring's buyer. According to Hofer's post-war testimony, Göring rejected it and it was given to a 'Dr. Meyer' in Berlin.
Yale writes that 'Lagrand a Bruxelles' is listed as the owner on Belgium's official list of works of art stolen by the Germans during the occupation (March 15, 1947) and in 'Missing Works of Art Belgium' (1994). It resurfaced in 1973 on the Swiss and German market.
The museum says research is ongoing and that it is in contact with the Belgian State Archives. We found no published resolution.
What we found
- The museum discloses the case: the Belgian list and the Hofer link are in its own provenance, with archival references (Bundesarchiv B323/403; ORE no. 375/1).
- What remains open is whether Belgium claims the work. Lagrand was a dealer investigated for selling to Hitler's and Göring's agents, so it is unclear whether the list records him as a victim or merely as the last known owner.
- The work is not in our database, which does not include the Belgian lists. Our detector rated it medium because of the names Hofer, Göring, Böhler and the ERR.
What the museum should answer
- What did the Belgian State Archives tell Yale?
- Is the work still on Belgium's list of missing works? Is there a formal Belgian claim?
Sources
Yale University Art Gallery: Cornelis Engebrechtsz., «The Deposition» (2020.37.3); LUX (Yale): registro de la obra
A marble angel by Simone Bianco at the V&A, sought on Lost Art as part of Jakob Goldschmidt's collection
Victoria and Albert Museum, London
A kneeling marble angel holding a candlestick by Simone Bianco, a sculptor active in Venice. Sir Thomas Barlow gave it to the V&A in 1960.
The V&A's provenance, updated in May 2025, says it all: Camillo Castiglioni, Vienna; "Jakob Goldschmidt [1882-1955], by 1936; listed for sale in Frankfurt (Hugo Helbing), 1936; sold in Cologne (Kunsthaus Lempertz), 1938"; then Eugene Garbáty and a Sotheby's sale in 1956.
Lost Art holds a search request for a 60 cm marble "Kniender Leuchterengel" by Simone Bianco from the Jakob Goldschmidt collection, auctioned by Lempertz in Cologne on March 11–12, 1938, filed as "NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut". It also names Castiglioni and his 1930 sale. It is the same sculpture.
Goldschmidt, a Jewish banker, emigrated to Switzerland in April 1933 and to New York in 1936. Whether those sales were forced by persecution is disputed: in 2024 two Bavarian museums returned works from the collection to his descendants, but in 2006 the UK Spoliation Advisory Panel rejected a claim for a painting from the 1936 sale, finding it was sold to pay his bank's debts.
Two versions of the same story
The V&A and Lost Art tell the same story up to 1938. Lost Art stops there: for the heirs, the work is missing.
| Item | Victoria and Albert MuseumPublished provenance (updated May 2025) | Lost ArtSearch request, Jakob Goldschmidt collection |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 58.1 cm (58.5 cm, measured 11/2025) | "H: 60,00 cm" |
| Castiglioni | "Camillo Castiglioni [1879-1957], Vienna, by 1924; sold in Vienna (Hermann Ball and Paul Graupe), 1930" | "Früher: Slg. Castiglioni, Wien. Aukt. Katalog, Berlin 1930, Nr. 119" |
| Goldschmidt and 1936 | "listed for sale in Frankfurt (Hugo Helbing), 1936" | "Katalognummer: 71 (Auktionshaus Hugo Helbing, 1936)" |
| 1938 | "sold in Cologne (Kunsthaus Lempertz), 1938" | "Versteigerung am 11./12. März 1938 durch Math. Lempertz, Köln … 183 (Math. Lempertz, 1938)" |
| Afterwards | Eugene Garbáty; Sotheby's, 1956; Alfred Spero; given to the V&A in 1960 | Whereabouts unknown |
| How it left Goldschmidt | Not stated | "NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut" |
What we found
- The identification is firm: same sculptor, subject and material, the same Castiglioni–Goldschmidt–Helbing–Lempertz chain and nearly the same height (60 vs 58.1–58.5 cm).
- Our copy of Lost Art dates the request October 24, 2017. The V&A updated the provenance in May 2025 with the Goldschmidt chain but does not mention the request.
- Kulturgutverluste, the German Lost Art Foundation's site, reported in March 2024 that the Bavarian State collections restituted a painting and two sculptures to Goldschmidt's descendants. It says he "was clearly forced to accept the economic exploitation of part of his art collection" and that sculptures unsold in 1936 were offered again at Lempertz in 1938.
- The UK Spoliation Advisory Panel (report of March 1, 2006, on an Ashmolean painting) found the 1936 sale "was not a sale forced by the Nazi regime" but part of a 1932 arrangement to pay debts to the Danatbank and Thyssen, and recommended rejecting the claim. It notes the 1938 vendor is listed as "Th", presumed by the Ashmolean to be Thyssen.
- Our detector rated this alert medium because of the names (Goldschmidt, Graupe, Helbing), without matching it to the Lost Art record.
What the museum should answer
- Does the V&A know this sculpture has been the subject of a Lost Art search request since 2017?
- Having updated the provenance in 2025, why does it not mention that Goldschmidt was an emigré Jewish collector, or his heirs' request?
- Does the 2006 Panel finding on the 1936 sale also apply to the 1938 sale, or would it be revisited in light of Bavaria's 2024 restitutions?
Sources
V&A: Simone Bianco, «Angel with a candlestick» (A.14-1960); V&A, API pública: registro O313487; Lost Art: «Kniender Leuchterengel» (570659); Kulturgutverluste: restitución de una pintura y dos esculturas a los descendientes de Jakob Goldschmidt (20-3-2024); Spoliation Advisory Panel: informe sobre una pintura del Ashmolean (HC 890, 1-3-2006)
Monet's 'Poppy Field near Vétheuil': Max Emden's grandson has claimed it since 2012, the foundation says it was not a persecution sale, and the Kunsthaus records 'indications'
Kunsthaus Zürich
The painting belonged to Max Emden, a Hamburg businessman of Jewish origin who settled on the Brissago islands in Ticino. He died in 1940. His son Hans Erich, stripped of German citizenship in 1940 and without a work permit in Switzerland, left for Chile in 1941 after asking Walter Feilchenfeldt to sell it; Bührle bought it through Fritz Nathan for CHF 35,000.
In 2012 a grandson, Juan Carlos Emden, asked for its return.
In 2023 the Bührle Foundation published a study concluding that the sale 'war nicht ein Ergebnis von NS-Verfolgung'. The Kunsthaus record, by contrast, labels it 'Hinweise auf NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut' and says it is disputed whether it was an ordinary estate liquidation or a forced sale to fund his escape.
Two versions of the same story
The Bührle Foundation's study and the Kunsthaus record, side by side.
| Item | Bührle FoundationStudy on H. E. Emden's sale (version 30 Apr 2023) | Kunsthaus ZürichRecord BU/0071 (read 15 Nov 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| ConclusionDiffers | 'Der Verkauf … war nicht ein Ergebnis von NS-Verfolgung' | 'Hinweise auf NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut' |
| Seller's situationDiffers | 'zu keinem Zeitpunkt in einer finanziellen Zwangslage' | Stripped of German citizenship, no Swiss work permit; fled to Chile |
| Price | CHF 35,000 | CHF 35,000 |
'There is dispute as to whether the sale by Emden constituted a ‘conventional’ liquidation of his father’s estate or whether, as a Jew, he was acting under duress because of Nazi persecution and was compelled to sell the work to fund his escape.'
What we found
- In 2019 the German advisory commission recommended returning to the Emden heirs two Bellottos sold from exile and bought for Hitler.
- The Kunsthaus record shows both 'Hinweise auf…' and 'Provenienz klar'.
What the museum should answer
- Which position does the Kunsthaus, which has the painting on display, hold today: the foundation's study or its own category?
- Did the 2012 claim receive a formal reply?
Sources
Kunsthaus Zürich: Monet, «Champ de coquelicots près de Vétheuil» (BU/0071); The Local, 01-11-2012: el nieto de Max Emden reclama el Monet; Fundación Bührle: estudio sobre la venta de Hans Erich Emden (2023); The Art Newspaper, 27-03-2019: la comisión alemana recomienda devolver los Bellotto de Max Emden
The Rubens sketch Gotha has sought since 1945: the Kunsthaus labels it 'provenance clear'
Kunsthaus Zürich
It is one of Rubens's sketches for the Jesuit church in Antwerp that were in the ducal museum in Gotha. In March 1945 they were moved to Coburg to keep them from the Soviets, and never came back.
Gotha's Schloss Friedenstein Foundation lists it on Lost Art as a war loss ('Kriegsbedingt verbrachtes Kulturgut'). The Lost Art entry says a former Gotha director recognised it in 1977 at an Antwerp exhibition, lent by the Bührle Foundation, and that the foundation's lawyer refused the request to return it.
The Kunsthaus record documents the Gotha and Coburg stages, writes 'Verbleib unbekannt' (whereabouts unknown) for 1945–1953 and classifies it as 'Provenienz klar'. It mentions neither Lost Art nor the 1977 claim.
What we found
- This is not a persecution case: the Kunsthaus category measures Nazi looting, and a German museum's war loss falls outside it. Still, there is a public claim and the record does not mention it.
- According to the record itself, in 1953 Bührle paid Feilchenfeldt CHF 200,000 for this sketch and a Cézanne: 30,000 by transfer and 170,000 in cash, with a note reading 'discret'.
What the museum should answer
- Has there been any contact between Gotha and the foundation or the Kunsthaus since 1977?
- Why does the record not mention that the sketch is on Lost Art?
Sources
Kunsthaus Zürich: Rubens, «Der heilige Augustin» (BU/0160); Lost Art: Rubens, «St. Augustinus» (4238)
The Kunsthaus purchases from Charlotte von Wesdehlen in 1940 and 1942: Basel has recognised her sale as a persecuted seller's; the Zurich records do not say so
Kunsthaus Zürich
Charlotte von Wesdehlen, née Reichenheim and formerly married to Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy, was a German Jew who emigrated to Geneva in 1938–40. Kunstmuseum Basel bought a Rousseau from her in 1940 and now acknowledges that she sold out of need in exile, after paying the regime's discriminatory taxes (see the Basel review).
Basel's research summary says the countess also sold to the Kunsthaus Zürich, in 1940, Rousseau's 'Pierre Loti' and a flower still life (CHF 43,000 for both), and in 1942 a Picasso for CHF 11,000.
The Kunsthaus holds the 'Pierre Loti' (bought 1940) and a Picasso bought from her in 1942. Both records say 'Hinweise auf NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut' and 'Provenienz in Arbeit', but the provenance mentions neither her exile nor the persecution.
Two versions of the same story
The Kunsthaus record and Kunstmuseum Basel's summary about the same seller.
| Item | Kunsthaus ZürichRecord 2508 (read 15 Nov 2026) | Kunstmuseum Basel'Summary of historical findings' |
|---|---|---|
| SellerDiffers | 'Charlotte von Wesdehlen (*1877, +1946) (Sammler/-in), Berlin, Scheidung' | 'a German-Swiss woman of Jewish origin who was forced to leave her hometown of Berlin' |
| IntermediaryDiffers | '1940, Claus Vogel (Sammler/-in), Zürich, Kauf' | 'via the dealer Max Dreyfus (Antiquariat Emile/Henri Dreyfus)' |
| PriceDiffers | 'Kauf, 22'000 CHF' | 'a cheque for CHF 43,000 for the sale of both paintings' |
| PersecutionDiffers | Not mentioned | Reich Flight Tax and Jewish property tax |
'The reduced price did not deter the countess from offering further works to the Kunsthaus.' Basel tells the story of the Zurich sales; Zurich does not say who the seller was.
What we found
- The two versions disagree on the intermediary and the price of the 'Pierre Loti'.
- Basel names the Picasso 'Saltimbanque assise avec garçon'; the Kunsthaus records a single Picasso bought from the countess in 1942, 'Joueur de vielle et jeune arlequin'. It may be the same work under another title; we could not confirm this.
What the museum should answer
- Will the Kunsthaus assess these purchases under the 'flight assets' standard that Basel uses?
- Who was the intermediary for the 'Pierre Loti': Claus Vogel or Max Dreyfus?
Sources
Kunsthaus Zürich: Rousseau, «Pierre Loti» (2508); Kunsthaus Zürich: Picasso, «Joueur de vielle et jeune arlequin» (2588); Kunstmuseum Basel: «Summary of historical findings» (Rousseau)
What the Gross report found in three Bührle paintings and how the Kunsthaus shows them today
Kunsthaus Zürich
In 2024 Raphael Gross's team made an in-depth review of five Bührle paintings. Two have their own case here (the Kalf, and Semmel's Gauguin, now settled). This compares the other three with the current records.
Van Gogh, 'Tête de paysanne': Gross found that in 1932 it went unsold at auction and that its owner, the Jewish collector Gustav Schweitzer, still had it after 1933. The record already includes this and labels it 'Hinweise auf…'.
Cézanne, 'Paysage': it belonged to Berthold and Martha Nothmann, who fled to London and sold it in exile after the war. The record classifies it 'Provenienz klar', but the museum's own text says that sale was 'unquestionably' caused by persecution.
Cézanne, 'Madame Cézanne à l'éventail': it belonged to Gertrude Stein, who sold it in 1943 in occupied France to César de Hauke. Gross says that dealer exploited Jewish refugees' plight. The record has no category.
Two versions of the same story
What the Gross report says (in German) and what the Kunsthaus record says today.
| Item | Gross report (2024)Summary and ch. 3 | Kunsthaus ZürichRecords read 15 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Van Gogh, 'Tête de paysanne' | 'Offen bleibt, ob Kopf einer Bäuerin Gustav Schweitzer nach 1933 verfolgungsbedingt entzogen wurde' | 'Hinweise auf NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut'; under review |
| Cézanne, 'Paysage'Differs | 'dass die Kategorie des NS-verfolgungsbedingten Entzugs womöglich nicht ausreicht, um historisches Unrecht zu erfassen' | 'Provenienz klar', and in the text: 'Unquestionably, it was caused by the Nazi state’s policy of persecution and looting' |
| Cézanne, 'Madame Cézanne à l'éventail'Differs | 'Gertrude Stein verkaufte es an einen Kunsthändler, der nachweislich die Notlage jüdischer Flüchtlinge ausnutzte' | No category; '1943 – o.D., César Mange de Hauke (Kunsthändler/-in), Paris, Kauf' |
What we found
- Of the 178 Bührle paintings we read, 103 have no category at all on the record and say the provenance is under review.
- In May 2025 the Kunsthaus and the foundation agreed on five years of research on the 205 works on loan.
What the museum should answer
- When will each of the 103 Bührle paintings without a category get one?
- Why is the Nothmann Cézanne listed as 'Provenienz klar' when the museum's own text says the sale was caused by persecution?
Sources
Informe Gross (2024), cap. 3; Kunsthaus Zürich: Van Gogh, «Tête de paysanne» (BU/0052); Kunsthaus Zürich: Cézanne, «Paysage» (BU/0012); Kunsthaus Zürich: Cézanne, «Madame Cézanne à l'éventail» (BU/0016); ArtDependence, 27-05-2025: el Kunsthaus y la fundación definen los próximos pasos
Delacroix's 'The Raising of Lazarus': from the Behrens family of Jewish bankers in Hamburg to New York, nobody knows how
Kunstmuseum Basel
The painting belonged from 1894 to the Behrens family, owners of the Hamburg bank L. Behrens & Söhne. The bank was 'Aryanized' and closed in 1938, and George Eduard Behrens was arrested after Kristallnacht. According to the museum itself, the heir left Germany in 1939 (Belgium, France, Cuba) and returned in 1948.
The museum's provenance places the painting with the Behrens family until 'at least' October 1939. The next entry is Kurt M. Stern, New York, 'date unknown', until 1954. Nothing says how or when it left the family.
In the work list of its 2021–2022 research project (funded by the Federal Office of Culture), the museum gave it category C and wrote that the circumstances of Stern's acquisition are unknown ('Erwerbsumstände unbekannt'). The online record shows neither the category nor that phrase.
Two versions of the same story
The online record and the same museum's research-project list give two versions of the 1925–1954 stretch.
| Item | Online collection recordProvenienz, G 1964.2 (read 15 Nov 2026) | BAK project list 2021–2022'Liste der untersuchten Werke', as of September 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Owners from 1925Differs | 'Franziska Behrens (1856–1951) und George Eduard Behrens (1881–1956) und Elisabeth Emma Behrens (1883–1950), als Erbengemeinschaft „E. L. Behrens Gesamtgut“, Hamburg' | 'George Behrens (1907–1956), Hamburg, seit 1939 Belgien/Frankreich/Kuba, seit 1948 wieder Hamburg' |
| Last record with the BehrensDiffers | 'mind. 12.10.1939' | 'mind. 13.10.1939' |
| EmigrationDiffers | Not mentioned | 'seit 1939 Belgien/Frankreich/Kuba' |
| Kurt M. SternDiffers | 'Datum unbekannt – 23.04.1954: Kurt M. Stern (1895–1962), New York' | 'Kurt M. Stern (1895–1962), Frankfurt a. Main/ seit 1933 New York, Erwerbsumstände unbekannt' |
| AssessmentDiffers | Not shown | Category 'C' |
'Erwerbsumstände unbekannt' (circumstances of acquisition unknown): this is how the museum itself describes the painting's passage from a persecuted Jewish family to a buyer in New York.
What we found
- Wikipedia says the bank was 'Aryanized' in 1938, that its main owner was 'de facto expropriated', and that at least 57 works from his collection are listed in Lost Art. This one is not among those we found in our database.
- The museum's two versions disagree on who the owner was (the heirs' community including George Eduard Behrens, born 1881, or a George Behrens born 1907) and on the date of the last record.
- We found no public claim and no Lost Art entry for this painting.
What the museum should answer
- Which document places the painting with the Behrens family in October 1939, and where was it then: in Hamburg or already abroad?
- How did it reach Kurt M. Stern? Are there records of a sale of the Behrens collection in 1939–1940?
- Why does the online record not show category C or the phrase 'Erwerbsumstände unbekannt'?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Basel: ficha de «La résurrection de Lazare» (G 1964.2); Kunstmuseum Basel: lista de obras del proyecto BAK 2021–2022 (PDF); Wikipedia: L. Behrens & Söhne
Twelve paintings the Kunsthistorisches bought between 1939 and 1945 that Austria publishes as of doubtful provenance: the museum's records do not say so
Kunsthistorisches Museum, Viena
Austria's National Fund for Victims of National Socialism publishes a database (Kunstdatenbank) of works in federal museums whose provenance is doubtful, so that owners or heirs can claim them. We read the section of that database holding the Kunsthistorisches paintings.
We found twelve Gemäldegalerie paintings bought or received between 1939 and 1945: at Vienna's Dorotheum (the database has its own category for 'Purchase from the Dorotheum 1938-45'), from the Galerie Sanct Lucas and Galerie Welz in Vienna, from dealers in Berlin and Bremen, and from a private seller. For all twelve the database says 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified': the provenance commission has examined or is examining them, the Restitution Advisory Board has not yet dealt with them, and they remain in the museum.
The museum's online records say at best who sold them ('1942 erworben von der Galerie St. Lucas'), and several give only the year ('1944 erworben', '1945 erworben'). None says that the provenance is in doubt or that the work is listed in the National Fund's database.
Two versions of the same story
The provenance on the museum's record (in German) and in the National Fund's Kunstdatenbank (in English), work by work.
| Item | Kunsthistorisches Museum'Provenienz' field on the online record (read 15 Nov 2026) | Kunstdatenbank (Austrian National Fund)'Provenance according to museum / collection' and status |
|---|---|---|
| Dirck Stoop (GG 9064)Differs | '1943 vom Dorotheum, Wien, erworben;' | 'September 29, 1943, Dorotheum'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Nicolas Neufchatel (nach) (GG 9080)Differs | '1944 erworben' | 'July 11, 1944, Dorotheum'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Isaak Soreau (GG 9081)Differs | '1944 erworben;' | 'Autumn 1944: Karoline Nehammer (Piaristengasse 11, Vienna 1080)'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Januarius Zick (GG 9082)Differs | '1945 erworben;' | 'January 08, 1945: 'Bremer Werkschau GmbH, Bremen' … Dr. Jantzen'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Januarius Zick (GG 9083)Differs | '1945 erworben;' | 'January 08, 1945: 'Bremer Werkschau GmbH, Bremen' … Dr. Jantzen'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Ludolf Backhuizen (GG 9069)Differs | '1944 erworben;' | 'January 1944, C.F. Ernst Schmidt, Berlin … via the 'Ausweichstelle' Vienna, Grand Hotel'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Ferdinand Bol (GG 9050)Differs | '1921 Slg. Jules Porgés; Kunsthandlung Otto Schatzker, Wien; 1942 erworben' | 'December 14, 1943, art dealer Otto Schatzker, Köllnerhofgasse 2, Vienna 1010'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Valentin de Boulogne (GG 9044)Differs | '1942 erworben von der Galerie St. Lucas, Wien;' | 'July 1942, Gallery 'Sankt Lukas''; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Adriaen Bloemaert (GG 9034)Differs | 'Museum Kunstliefde, Utrecht; 1941 von der Galerie St. Lucas, Wien gewidmet' | 'September 1941, gift from Gallery 'Sankt Lukas''; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Esaias van de Velde (GG 6991)Differs | '1940 von der Galerie St. Lucas gewidmet;' | 'July 04, 1940, Gallery 'Sankt Lukas''; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Bartolomeo Bettera (GG 6990)Differs | '1939 Ankauf von der Galerie Welz, Wien;' | '1939/40, Gallery Welz'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
| Giuseppe Zonodo (GG 9084)Differs | No record read | 'Before April 1945: 'Neue Galerie' (New Gallery), Mrs. Dr. Vita M. Künstler'; 'Dubiousness is still to be clarified' |
'The questionable nature of the provenance of the art or cultural object is being or has been examined by the museum/the collection/the Commission for Provenance Research. So far, the case has not been dealt with by the Art Restitution Advisory Board.' The database says this for each of the twelve.
What we found
- One painting from the same series has already been returned: Adriaen van Ostade's 'Farmers' room' (GG 9038), bought in December 1941 from the Vugesta (the database classifies it as 'Acquisition from the VUGESTA/GESTAPO'). In 2007 the Board recommended its return to the heirs of Bruno Jellinek, and it was returned.
- For the Bol (GG 9050) the two versions disagree on the date: the museum record says '1942 erworben', the database 'December 14, 1943'.
- The two Januarius Zick canvases came in January 1945 from the 'Bremer Werkschau GmbH' in Bremen, run by a 'Dr. Jantzen'. The same name appears as seller of two Kunstkammer objects bought in 1942, also marked as doubtful.
- The museum says on its provenance-research page that it systematically checks all acquisitions since 1933, but it publishes no list of doubtful works.
What the museum should answer
- Why do the online records not indicate that these works are listed in the Kunstdatenbank as of doubtful provenance?
- When will the Restitution Advisory Board deal with these twelve cases?
- Who owned the works auctioned at the Dorotheum in 1943 and 1944?
Sources
Kunstdatenbank: Kunsthistorisches Museum; Kunstdatenbank: Dirck Stoop, GG 9064; Kunstdatenbank: Nicolas Neufchatel (nach), GG 9080; Kunstdatenbank: Isaak Soreau, GG 9081; Kunstdatenbank: Januarius Zick, GG 9082; Kunstdatenbank: Januarius Zick, GG 9083; Kunstdatenbank: Ludolf Backhuizen, GG 9069; Kunstdatenbank: Ferdinand Bol, GG 9050; Kunstdatenbank: Valentin de Boulogne, GG 9044; Kunstdatenbank: Adriaen Bloemaert, GG 9034; Kunstdatenbank: Esaias van de Velde, GG 6991; Kunstdatenbank: Bartolomeo Bettera, GG 6990; Kunstdatenbank: Giuseppe Zonodo, GG 9084; Kunstdatenbank: Adriaen van Ostade (GG 9038), restituida; Kunstdatenbank: Deschler (atribuido), Kunstkammer 9872 (Dr. Jantzen, 1942); Kunsthistorisches Museum: investigación de procedencia
A Pushkin Adriaen van de Velde, registered in 1950, has the same size as the one the ERR seized from the Rothschilds and gave to Göring
Museo Pushkin de Bellas Artes, Moscú
The Pushkin has a «Landscape» by Adriaen van de Velde dated 1662, oil on canvas, 34.5 × 31.5 cm. It was registered on 15 January 1950 and the record does not say where it came from.
In Paris the ERR seized from the Rothschilds a Van de Velde «Herd in a forest clearing», «angeblich signiert und 1662 datiert», 34.5 × 31.5 cm (R 293), and handed it to Göring. The DHM database of the Göring collection gives its whereabouts after 1945 as «missing»; the ERR card says it was not restituted.
This is a lead, not an identification. The ERR card says «Oel auf Holz» (panel) and the DHM «Lwd.» (canvas), as does the Pushkin. The ERR photograph needs comparing with the Moscow picture.
Two versions of the same story
Las tres fichas lado a lado.
| Item | Museo Pushkin | ERR Project, R 293 |
|---|---|---|
| Medidas | «34,5х31,5 см» | «H. 34,5 - Br. 31,5 cm» |
| Fecha | 1662 | «Angeblich signiert und 1662 datiert» |
| SoporteDiffers | «холст» (lienzo) | «Oel auf Holz» (tabla); el DHM dice «Lwd.» |
| Historia | Registrado el 15-01-1950; sin dueño anterior | Rothschild, París; ERR; «Verbleib: HG.»; «Restituted? No» |
What we found
- The ERR description: a forest clearing with two cows lying and one grazing, a grey horse seen from behind, three lambs, a seated dog, a woman with two children and another milking a goat.
What the museum should answer
- Where did the picture the Pushkin registered in January 1950 come from?
- Does the image match the ERR photograph (Bundesarchiv B 323)?
Sources
Museo Pushkin, catálogo en línea: Ж-3252; DHM, colección Göring: «Herde auf einer Waldlichtung»; ERR Project, ficha R 293 (Rothschild)
12 works in Russian museums match in painter and size pictures that museums in Kyiv, Kharkiv and Simferopol are searching for as war losses
Museos rusos (Госкаталог)
Lost Art holds about 8,000 search requests from Ukrainian museums, most filed in 2003 (the National Museum of Russian Art and the National Art Museum in Kyiv, the Kharkiv Art Museum, the Simferopol museum): works lost during the German occupation.
Matching them against the Goskatalog’s 225,110 foreign paintings, drawings and sculptures turns up pictures by the same painter with equal or nearly equal sizes in Russian museums: a 1909 Dubovskoy at Ivan Pavlov’s museum, a Platonov in Perm, a Bogolyubov in Saratov, Kuindzhi in Kazan and Perm, Vasylkivsky in Voronezh, Moscow and Nizhny Tagil.
None is identified. In several the title fits («Sea» and «Sea», «Girl» and «Young woman with braids»), but the Goskatalog offers no downloadable images or accession history.
Two versions of the same story
El caso más parecido.
| Item | Госкаталог | Lost Art |
|---|---|---|
| Pintor y título | Дубовской, «Море. Картина худ. Н.Н. Дубовского, оригинал.» | Dubowskoij, «Meer» |
| Año y medidas | 1909 г., 26 х 34 см | «N. Dubowskoij 1909», H 26 × B 34 cm |
| DóndeDiffers | Museo-apartamento de I. P. Pávlov (Instituto de Fisiología, RAN) | Museo Nacional de Arte Ruso, Kiev; perdido en la guerra |
What we found
- The same Pavlov museum has a second 1909 Dubovskoy of 26 × 34 cm («Surf»): at most one can be the Kyiv picture.
What the museum should answer
- When and from where did these pictures reach the Russian museums?
Sources
Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Am Meeresufer»; Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Studie»; Lost Art: «Am Kuban»; Lost Art: «Landschaft»; Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Studie»; Lost Art: «Am Kuban»; Lost Art: «Landschaft»; Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Landschaft»; Lost Art: «Landschaft»; Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Vorwerk Koropiw»; Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Winterlandschaft»; Lost Art: «Landschaft»; Lost Art: «Landschaft mit Bäumen im Vordergrund»; Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025)
A Neff portrait of Empress Alexandra Feodorovna in Irkutsk measures the same as the one the Prussian Palaces lost in 1946
Museo de Arte de Irkutsk V. P. Sukachov
The Goskatalog lists at the Irkutsk museum a Neff «Portrait of Alexandra Feodorovna», oil on canvas, 141 × 107 cm (Ж-1005).
The Prussian Palaces Foundation is searching on Lost Art for a Timoleon von Neff «Zarin Alexandra Feodorowna von Rußland», 141 × 106 cm (GK I 1000), from Charlottenburg Palace, «nach dem 27. März 1946 in die Sowjetunion abtransportiert».
Same painter, same sitter, almost the same size. The image and the Irkutsk accession history are missing.
Two versions of the same story
| Item | Госкаталог | Lost Art |
|---|---|---|
| Medidas | 141х107 | H: 141,00 cm ; B: 106,00 cm |
| Historia | Sin datos | «Schloss Charlottenburg … nach dem 27. März 1946 in die Sowjetunion abtransportiert (Kiste 3)» |
What the museum should answer
- When did the portrait enter the Irkutsk museum?
Sources
Госкаталог, datos abiertos del Ministerio de Cultura de Rusia (copia del Internet Archive, 13-03-2025); Lost Art: «Zarin Alexandra Feodorowna von Rußland»
A Dresden Isaac van Ostade bearing the Goudstikker gallery label, which the museum itself lists as of unclear origin
Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden
A small panel, a peasant reading a sheet, attributed to Isaac van Ostade. It has been in Dresden's Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister since 1959.
The SKD themselves reported it on Lost Art: the back bears the label “Collectie Goudstikker / Amsterdam - Heerengracht 458 / No. 5754”. It was offered for sale by the Goudstikker gallery after Alois Miedl took it over, and in 1945 it was in a Berlin bank vault.
Jacques Goudstikker, a Jewish Amsterdam dealer, fled in May 1940 and died on the ship. Göring and Miedl divided his gallery. In 1953 the GDR transferred the panel to the Berlin museums and in 1959 to Dresden.
We found no report that it has been returned to Goudstikker's heirs.
What the museum should answer
- Have the SKD contacted Goudstikker's heirs about this panel?
- What do the gallery's books say about number 5754?
Sources
Lost Art: «Lesender Mann» (415545), Fundmeldung de las SKD; Wikidata: «Lesender Mann» (SKD, S 1356)
A Nerly the Hamburger Kunsthalle bought from Haberstock in 1942 and itself declares seized through Nazi persecution
Hamburger Kunsthalle
An Italian landscape by Friedrich Nerly. The Kunsthalle bought it in 1942 from the dealer Karl Haberstock, one of Hitler's suppliers.
The museum itself reported it on Lost Art under “NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut”: until 3 December 1940 it belonged to a Hans Thiel of Berlin, from whom Haberstock bought it.
We found no report that Thiel's heirs have been identified or of a restitution.
What the museum should answer
- Who was Hans Thiel and what happened to him?
- Has the Kunsthalle searched for his heirs?
Sources
Lost Art: «Blick auf Terracina und den Monte Circeo / Italienische Landschaft» (5000000771); Wikidata (Q71534163)
Lilly Cassirer's Pissarro remains at the Thyssen and the case reopened in 2025; the museum's web page gives no provenance
Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza, Madrid
This is the Pissarro that Lilly Cassirer surrendered in Berlin in 1939 so that she could leave Germany. Since 1993 it has belonged to the Spanish state, which bought it with the Thyssen collection.
Her heirs have been litigating in the US since 2005. In January 2024 the Ninth Circuit held the museum owns it under Spanish law. In March 2025 the Supreme Court vacated that ruling and sent the case back to be decided under California's new law (AB 2867).
The museum's page gives title, medium, size and inventory number. It has no provenance: no Cassirer, no 1939, no lawsuit.
What the museum should answer
- Why does the museum publish no provenance for a work in litigation over Nazi looting?
- What has the Ninth Circuit decided since the Supreme Court remanded the case?
Sources
Ficha: «Rue Saint-Honoré por la tarde. Efecto de lluvia.» (712 (1976.74)); Wikidata (Q21191272); Corte Suprema de EE.UU., expediente 24-652, Cassirer v. Thyssen-Bornemisza Collection Foundation (10-03-2025: anulado y devuelto); Los Angeles Times (Yahoo), 10-03-2025: «Supreme Court revives family's claim to recover Pissarro painting stolen by the Nazis»
A Tiepolo bought in Berlin in 1948, now at Helsinki's Sinebrychoff, with gaps in its history
Kansallisgalleria (Sinebrychoff), Helsinki
A canvas by Giandomenico Tiepolo from his Trojan War cycle. The Sinebrychoff, the Finnish National Gallery's old masters museum, bought it at auction in 1996.
In 2014 Finnish public TV's MOT reported that diplomat Tauno Sutinen bought it in Berlin in 1948 and that its ownership history has gaps.
The National Gallery does not publish provenance: its open data only says “purchase, 28-04-1996”.
What we found
- No Lost Art search request in our database matches this work.
- MOT does not claim it is looted; it presents it as an example of an unresolved provenance.
What the museum should answer
- What does the National Gallery know about where the canvas was before 1948, in Berlin?
- Has the museum published any research since the 2014 programme?
Sources
Kansallisgalleria: S-1996-105; Yle (MOT), «Ryöstötaidetta ehkä Suomessakin» (1-9-2014)
An early Schiele at the Leopold Museum that Lost Art seeks in the name of Leopold Popper-Podhragy
Leopold Museum, Viena
A small 1908 oil, among Schiele's earliest. The Leopold Museum has held it since 1994; Rudolf Leopold bought it at the Dorotheum in 1984.
Lost Art lists a search request for it as property seized through persecution in the name of Leopold Freiherr Popper-Podhragy, «until 1939». The record says that, according to Jane Kallir's catalogue raisonné, it is the Leopold Museum's work (inv. 4140).
The museum's record starts with «Dr. Leopold Popper, Wien (vor 1930)» and continues with the Dorotheum sale of July 1955: nothing from 1930 to 1955. It cites a December 2009 dossier by Michael Wladika, with no published decision.
What we found
- Popper-Podhragy appears in our database as a dispossessed collector: Lost Art also lists dozens of his arms and armour lost in Vienna in 1938.
What the museum should answer
- What did the 2009 dossier find about what happened to the painting between 1930 and 1955?
Sources
Leopold Museum: «Häuser auf dem Klosterneuburger Rathausplatz» (LM 4140); Lost Art: «Häuser am Rathausplatz in Klosterneuburg» (274156) (copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots)
Two Klimt drawings from the Lederer collection at the Leopold Museum, sought on Lost Art
Leopold Museum, Viena
Two Klimt drawings that belonged to August and Serena Lederer, Vienna's foremost Klimt collectors. They have been at the Leopold Museum since 1994.
On Lost Art, the Lederer heirs seek them as seized through persecution: they say the Gestapo confiscated them in March 1938 at Serena Lederer's home, that they were sold by Galerie Wolfgang Gurlitt in Munich (which «demonstrably sold drawings stolen from the Lederers in 1938») and that they entered the Leopold Museum in 1994.
The museum publishes a different chain: the drawings were «secured» under Nazism, stored in the Altaussee salt mine, handed to Erich Lederer in 1948 and later sold by him through Gurlitt. It cites a January 2018 dossier by Michael Wladika on LM 1289, 1296 and 1319, with no published decision.
What we found
- Lost Art gives «LM Nr. 1318» for the Water Serpents study; at the Leopold, 1318 is another sheet, and the description matches LM 1319.
- The key is the 1948 hand-over: if the drawings went back to Erich Lederer, the later sale was his; if not, it was not.
What the museum should answer
- What document proves the 1948 hand-over to Erich Lederer?
- Is the museum aware that the heirs keep their Lost Art requests?
Sources
Leopold Museum: «Liegender weiblicher Akt mit geschlossenen Augen. Studie zu Die Jungfrau» (LM 1296); Lost Art: «Akt mit eingebeugten Knien nach rechts» (586457) (copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots); Lost Art: «Liegender Akt mit Halskrause nach rechts» (586462) (copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots)
A Flinck at the Mauritshuis listed on Lost Art as seized through Nazi persecution, with the museum's inventory number
Mauritshuis, La Haya
A portrait painted by Govert Flinck in 1637. It has been at the Mauritshuis since 1948 under number 866; legally it belongs to the Dutch state, as part of the NK collection of works recovered from Germany (NK2553).
Lost Art lists a search request for it as «seized as a result of Nazi persecution». The record says it belonged to Frits Lugt's collection and was bought by Goudstikker-Miedl at the Frederik Muller sale of 23 March 1943; it ends at the Mauritshuis with its inventory number.
German records list it as bought for the Linz museum (no. 2894). After the war the SNK recorded its departure as a «voluntary sale».
What we found
- We found no Dutch Restitutions Committee ruling on this work (searches for «NK 2553» and «Lugt» on restitutiecommissie.nl).
- The Lost Art record and the SNK record disagree on how the work was lost: one speaks of persecution, the other of a voluntary sale.
What the museum should answer
- Is the Mauritshuis aware of the Lost Art search request naming its number 866?
- Who consigned the painting to the Frederik Muller sale of March 1943?
Sources
Mauritshuis: «Portret van een 44-jarige man» (866) — el sitio no respondió desde acá; Wikidata: «Portrait of a 44-year-old man» (Q17276125); Herkomst Gezocht / RCE: ficha NK2553 (copia en nuestra base; el sitio respondió 429); Lost Art: «Porträt Samuel Menasseh ben Israël (44-jährig)» (567246) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots; DHM, Datenbank «Sonderauftrag Linz»: LI002903
Sheets from the Julius Freund collection at the Albertina: bought for Linz in 1942, Austria declined to return them and they are still sought on Lost Art
Albertina, Viena
Sheets by Carl Blechen and Carl Graeb that belonged to the Berlin collector Julius Freund. The Albertina publishes their provenance: Julius Freund, Gisèle Freund (Buenos Aires), Galerie Fischer in Lucerne, purchase by the «Sonderauftrag Linz» in 1942 and transfer to the Albertina by the Federal Monuments Office in 1963.
Julius Freund, a Jewish merchant, fled to England in February 1939 with his wife; his daughter Gisela (the photographer Gisèle Freund) was in exile in France. The collection, on deposit at the Kunstmuseum Winterthur, was auctioned at Galerie Fischer on 21 March 1942, and Hans Posse bought these sheets for the museum Hitler planned in Linz.
In 2016 the Austrian Art Restitution Advisory Board did not recommend their return. Search requests remain on Lost Art listing them as «seized as a result of Nazi persecution» and naming the Albertina with their inventory numbers.
What we found
- The Albertina's own record links to the Board's decision and acknowledges the purchase for Linz.
- Lost Art classifies two of the sheets as paintings; the Albertina records them as drawings (watercolour and gouache).
What the museum should answer
- Has the Albertina reviewed the case under the Washington Principles, which are not limited to sales inside Nazi territory?
- Is it in touch with the heirs who keep the Lost Art requests?
Sources
Albertina: «Im Neuen Museum in Berlin» (34811); Kunstrückgabebeirat: Beschluss Julius Freund (23-6-2016); Lost Art: «Treppenhaus des Neuen Museums in Berlin» (522718) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots; Albertina: «Spätgotische Durchfahrtshalle…» (34812); Lost Art: «Schlosshof mit gotischem Gewölbe» (435853) — copia en nuestra base; la página pide verificación antibots
13 MNR works seized from Paris homes, with the looting acknowledged and the owner unknown
Musée du Louvre, París
These works came from Paris flats emptied by the Möbel-Aktion, the Nazi operation that took the furniture and belongings of deported or fled Jewish families, or went through the ERR. The Louvre's records give the date and number of the seizure.
The Rose-Valland database classifies them as «assurément spoliée, propriétaire inconnu»: the looting is proven, the owner is not. They are on deposit in museums all over France.
These are not hidden cases: the State publishes them as works to be returned. What remains open is the search for the families.
What we found
- MNR 660: «saisi le 6 novembre 1942 par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder (MA-B 455) R 28-I-46 (2) et transféré à l'ERR au Jeu de Paume (3), puis envoyé à Nikolsburg le 15 novembre 1943 et mis à l'abri dans la mine d'Alt Aussee (n° 859/2) lor»
- MNR 635: «saisi le 6 novembre 1942 par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder (MA-B 454) (2) ; transféré à l'ERR au Jeu de Paume puis envoyé à Nikolsburg le 15 novembre 1943 et mis à l'abri à Alt Aussee (numéro 860/1) lors de la débâcle du IIIème»
- MNR 651: «Saisi par l' Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg à un propriétaire inconnu ; inscrit après le 30 novembre 1943 sur l'inventaire Unbekannt (1) et attribué alors à Horace Vernet sur sa fiche d'identification (2) ; envoyé à »
- MNR 773: «Avec cadre doré lors de la saisie (3) Le tableau est saisi chez un propriétaire inconnu par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder et transféré à l'ERR en 1942. Au dos de la toile on lit l'inscription « UNB. 21 » à la peinture noire ; l»
- MNR 740: «Le tableau est saisi par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder le 20 mars 1944 (MA-B 1274), transféré à l'ERR (1), puis envoyé à Nikolsburg. Il est attribué au musée du Louvre par l'Office des Biens et Intérêts Privés en 1951. Puis il »
- MNR 767: «Le tableau est saisi à Paris par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder en octobre 1943 sous le n° 1184 ; il est transféré du Jeu de Paume vers l'entrepôt de Seisenegg en Autriche, emballé le 23 novembre 1943 (numéro de caisse MA-B 72) »
- MNR 733: «Le tableau est saisi par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder, tranféré au Jeu de Paume en septembre ou octobre 1942 (inv. MA-B n° 301) (2) et envoyé à Nikolsburg le 15 novembre suivant (3). Il est attribué au musée du Louvre par l'Of»
- MNR 619: «Saisie en septembre 1943 par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder (MA-B 1168, sous le titre: "Scène de carnaval") (1) et transféré à Nikolsburg le 4 mai 1944; enregistré le 19 mars 1946 au Central Collecting Point de Munich sous le n°»
- MNR 810: «Le tableau est saisi par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder le 21 mars 1944 (MA-B 1276) et transféré à l' ERR au Jeu de Paume (1). Il est restauré avant son départ pour Nikolsburg le 4 mai 1944 (2), puis mis à l'abri au Schloss Kögl»
- MNR 682: «Confisqué par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder (MA-B 1241) ; transféré à l'ERR au Jeu de Paume en janvier 1944 (1) ; emporté à Nikolsburg le 4 mai 1944 (2) puis mis à l'abri au Schloss Kögl (numéro 636/11) ; transféré au Central C»
- MNR 615: «Le tableau est saisi le 29 septembre 1943 par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder (MA-B 1151) et transféré à Seissenneg le 23 novembre 1943 (1). Il est attribué au musée du Louvre par l'Office des biens Privés lors de la sixième Comm»
- MNR 777: «Le tableau est saisi par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder le 22 octobre 1943 (MA-B 1185), est transféré au Jeu de Paume en octobre 1943 et envoyé à Seissenegg le 23 novembre 1943 (1). Il est attribué au musée du Louvre par l'Offic»
- MNR 675: «saisi par la Möbel Aktion-Bilder le 6 novembre 1942 (numéro MA-B 118) puis transféré à l'ERR (2) ; envoyé à Nikolsburg puis mis à l'abri à Alt Aussee sous le numéro 1129 (3) ; arrivé au Central Collecting Point de Munich»
What the museum should answer
- Have the Möbel-Aktion MA-B numbers been matched against the inventories of looted flats kept in French archives?
Sources
Musée du Louvre: álbum «Musées Nationaux Récupération»; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00660; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00635; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00651; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00773; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00740; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00767; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00733; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00619; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00810; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00682; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00615; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00777; Base Rose-Valland (POP, Ministerio de Cultura de Francia): MNR00675
A Deodato Orlandi panel that was in the Goudstikker gallery and that the Louvre bought in 1945
Musée du Louvre, París
The record says the panel was in Jacques Goudstikker's gallery catalogue in Amsterdam in 1934 (no. 263), then with one V. Abatti, and that the Louvre bought it in 1945 through the Heim gallery. Goudstikker fled in May 1940 and his stock went to Miedl and Göring; his heirs have recovered hundreds of works. The record does not say whether this one was still in his stock in 1940 or how it reached Abatti. The key document is missing: Goudstikker's 1940 inventory (the «black book») and the Louvre's 1945 purchase file.
What we found
- The Louvre's record: «J. Goudstikker (1897-1940), marchand d'art, Amsterdam, 1934 (cat. n° 263) ; V. Abatti ; acquis de ce dernier par l'intermédiaire de la galerie Heim, 1945. Anciens propriétaires : Abatti, V. ; M. Goudstikker, Jacques ; Ergas, Dr.. Mode d'acquisition : achat (date 1945).»
What the museum should answer
- Is this panel in Goudstikker's 1940 inventory?
- Who was V. Abatti and when did he buy it?
Sources
Two paintings from Armand Dorville's bequest that entered the Louvre during the Occupation
Musée du Louvre, París
It came through the bequest of the lawyer Armand Dorville, who died in 1941; according to the record, the will dates from 1939, the bequest was «empêché sous l'Occupation» (it cites a 2017 Le Monde article) and the painting was handed to René Huyghe on 5 June 1943. The Dorville collection was auctioned in Nice in 1942 under Vichy administration; the Ministry of Culture announced it would return to his heirs twelve works from the national collections bought at that sale, and the heirs are claiming further works in French museums. What is missing is whether this one, which came through the bequest and not the auction, is on the heirs' list, and what the bequest file says.
What we found
- Delacroix, RF 1943 6: «Armand Dorville (1875-1941); 1942, legs d'Armand Dorville, par testament du 2/VI/1939 (empêché sous l'Occupation selon l'article d'E. Pollack dans Le Monde, 19/VIII/2017); 5/VI/1943: remise du tableau à M. Huyghe par Me La Tour. Anciens propriétaires : Me Dorville, Armand. Mode d'acquisition : legs»
- Weenix, RF 1943 7: «Terrisse, expert ou marchand d’art, agissant sans doute pour le compte de Me Dorville. – Me Armand Dorville (1875-1941), avocat, Paris ; legs de ce dernier, 1941 ; entré en 1943 (comme Weenix, sans prénom) mais exposé en 1945 comme Jan Baptist, attribution maintenue jusqu’en 1968. Anciens»
What the museum should answer
- Are these two works on the list of 21 claimed by Dorville's heirs?
- How was the bequest carried out under Vichy's anti-Jewish laws?
Sources
Musée du Louvre: «Pietà» (RF 1943 6); Wikipedia: Armand Dorville; Musée du Louvre: «Personnages de fantaisie dans une barque avec une joueuse de cistre» (RF 1943 7)
8 MNR works stolen or lost at the museums where the State deposited them
Musée du Louvre, París
MNR works do not belong to the State: it holds them in order to return them. These Louvre records say they were stolen from the provincial museums where they were on deposit (in 1972 and 1977) or cannot be found where they were deposited (five Chinese panels at the Musée Guimet; the Dupré at the Ministry of Justice).
What we found
- MNR 458: «Le tableau est acheté à Paris par M. Hofer à la galerie Kleinberger (A. Loebl-Garin) en 1942 pour 40 000 F, à E. Garin (1) et plus précisement le 30 avril 1944 à E. Garin pour 2 000 RM, soit 40 000 F selon la liste des achats de M. Hofer (2»
- MNR 552: «Acheté 220 000 F le 22 février 1944 à la galerie Rochlitz, Paris, [par Rademacher] pour le musée de Bonn et exporté le 16 avril 1944 par Hermsen (inv. 44,224) (1) [archives : MAE carton 118 A 54]. Attribué au musée du Louvre par l'Office de»
- MNR 724: «Est-ce le buveur acheté 160 000 F en 1943 chez Leegenhoek par le musée d'Aix-la-Chapelle (1) ? Attribué au musée du Louvre par l'OBIP en 1950. Déposé à Tourcoing (musée des Beaux-Arts) en 1960 (2). Tableau volé en 1972 au musée des beaux-ar»
- MNR 576: «Une autre source concerne ce même numéro 46161/1-4 : "Chine peinture, panneaux, achetés en France pendant la guerre" conservés sur quatre rouleaux ; les cinq panneaux ont été acquis à Paris auprès de Jansen pour 1000 RM, d'après la "Propert»
- MNR 575: «Une autre source concerne ce même numéro 46161/1-4 : "Chine peinture, panneaux, achetés en France pendant la guerre" conservés sur quatre rouleaux ; les cinq panneaux ont été acquis à Paris auprès de Jansen pour 1000 RM, d'après la "Propert»
- MNR 577: «Une autre source concerne ce même numéro 46161/1-4 : "Chine peinture, panneaux, achetés en France pendant la guerre" conservés sur quatre rouleaux ; les cinq panneaux ont été acquis à Paris auprès de Jansen pour 1000 RM, d'après la "Propert»
- MNR 578: «Une autre source concerne ce même numéro 46161/1-4 : "Chine peinture, panneaux, achetés en France pendant la guerre" conservés sur quatre rouleaux ; les cinq panneaux ont été acquis à Paris auprès de Jansen pour 1000 RM, d'après la "Propert»
- MNR 906: «en 1944 en possession du Major B. Teifel, Berlin, saisi sur le fondement d'un "Volksschädlingsprozess" et pris par les SS (2) ; entreposé à Alt Aussee sous le numéro 8330 et arrive le 31 octobre 1945 au Central Collecting Point de Munich où»
What the museum should answer
- Are these works registered in stolen-art databases (Interpol, the OCBC)?
Sources
Musée du Louvre: «Joueur de Luth ou Guitariste» (MNR 458); Musée du Louvre: «Suzanne et les vieillards» (MNR 552); Musée du Louvre: «Homme à la cruche» (MNR 724); Musée du Louvre: «Peintures décoratives : 5 panneaux décoratifs sur toile» (MNR 576); Musée du Louvre: «Peintures décoratives : 5 panneaux décoratifs sur toile» (MNR 575); Musée du Louvre: «Peintures décoratives : 5 panneaux décoratifs sur toile» (MNR 577); Musée du Louvre: «Peintures décoratives : 5 panneaux décoratifs sur toile» (MNR 578); Musée du Louvre: «Paysage sous l'orage» (MNR 906)
Three works that entered the Rijksmuseum or changed hands in 1942–1943 and that the Dutch survey flags
Rijksmuseum, Ámsterdam
According to the provenance, it was in the A.H. de Haas collection (Wassenaar) from 1923 to 1941, went through the dealer François Parry and the museum bought it in 1942 from the dealer Paul Brandt for 31,000 guilders. It is listed in Museale Verwervingen, the Dutch museums' list of works acquired since 1933 with unclear provenance. An open case: how it left the De Haas collection in the middle of the Occupation is unknown.
According to the provenance, it was sold in September 1943 at a Van Braam auction in Amsterdam («Een collectie schilderijen uit Nederlandsch Kunstbezit») and its whereabouts are unknown until 1948; a private person donated it in 2012. It is listed in Museale Verwervingen, the Dutch museums' list of works acquired since 1933 with unclear provenance. An open case: who sold it in 1943 is unknown.
The only provenance the museum publishes is that O.A. Peters bequeathed it in December 1942. It is listed in Museale Verwervingen, the Dutch museums' list of works acquired since 1933 with unclear provenance. An open case: the history before the bequest is missing.
What we found
- SK-A-3451: «collection A.H. de Haas, Wassenaar, 1923-41;{Note RMA.}...; the dealer François Parry, The Hague;{Note RMA.}...; from the dealer Paul Brandt, Amsterdam, fl. 31,000, to the museum, 1942; on loan to Museum Het Rembrandthuis, Amsterdam, 1971-78»
- SK-A-5009: «A. van Braam), 7 (8) September 1943 sqq., no. 135, as 'Bijbelsche voorstelling', fl. 2,800;{Copy RMA.}…; unknown location, 1948;{Knoef 1948, pp. 68-69.}….; collection Mrs. J.M. de Jager, Amsterdam, 1960’s;{Note RMA.} by descent through the family;{Note RMA.} donated by a private collector to the»
- SK-A-3455: «bequeathed to the museum by O.A. Peters, Amsterdam, December 1942»
What the museum should answer
- What did the museum find about the 1941–1943 sellers (De Haas, the 1943 Van Braam auction, O.A. Peters)?
Sources
Rijksmuseum: «Rembrandt as a Shepherd with a Staff and Flute» (SK-A-3451); Museale Verwervingen: SK-A-3451; Rijksmuseum: «Salome with the Head of John the Baptist» (SK-A-5009); Museale Verwervingen: SK-A-5009; Rijksmuseum: «Esau selling his Birthright» (SK-A-3455); Museale Verwervingen: SK-A-3455
A Van de Venne allegory whose provenance says «forced sale» to Göring
Rijksmuseum, Ámsterdam
The museum's provenance uses the words «forced sale»: the Amsterdam dealer P. de Boer, who had it from before June 1939, had to sell it to Walter Andreas Hofer for Göring on 19 September 1940; in 1944 Göring exchanged it with Miedl. It returned in 1946 and since 1948 it has been on loan at the Rijksmuseum, through the State, from the Stedelijk Museum Het Prinsenhof in Delft. What is missing is whether anyone asked for its restitution and why a sale the museum itself calls forced was not discussed: we found no NK record with its number.
What we found
- The museum's provenance: «purchased by the dealer P. de Boer, Amsterdam, before 8 June 1939;{Ekkart et al. 2002, p. 265.} forced sale to W.A. Hofer, Berlin, for Hermann Göring, 19 September 1940;{Ekkart et al. 2002, p. 265.} exchanged with the dealer A. Miedl, previously J. Goudstikker, Amsterdam, 9 February 1944;{Ekkart et»
What the museum should answer
- Was there a restitution request by P. de Boer's heirs?
- Why is the work on loan rather than in the numbered NK collection?
Sources
Rijksmuseum: «Allegory of the Stadtholdership of Prince Frederick Henry» (SK-C-1343)
Three works with an undocumented Nazi-era stretch: Arnhold, Koenigs and Galerie Sanct Lucas
Rijksmuseum, Ámsterdam
It belonged to Paul von Schwabach, a Berlin banker (died 1938), and in 1939 Kurt and Adolf Arnhold, «Dresden and London», donated it to the museum. The Arnholds were Jewish bankers from Dresden whose bank was «aryanised» and who emigrated. The provenance does not say how it passed from Von Schwabach to the Arnholds or under what conditions the 1939 gift was made, already in exile. The gift file in the museum's archive is missing.
The provenance says it belonged to Franz Koenigs of Haarlem, that the Lisser & Rosenkranz bank redeemed it on 2 April 1940 and that in May 1940 «custodian Goudstikker» sold it to Isaac de Bruijn, who bequeathed it to the museum. It is part of the Koenigs collection pledged to a Jewish Amsterdam bank and sold in the days of the invasion; Koenigs's heirs have claimed works from that collection. What is missing is whether this work was part of any claim and what the Restitutions Committee decided.
According to the provenance, Galerie Sanct Lucas in Vienna bought it in 1937 and had it again in 1946; the museum bought it in 1974 at the Dorotheum. Sanct Lucas was the Glückselig family's gallery, which had to leave Vienna in 1938; the provenance does not say what happened to the work between 1938 and 1946. That stretch is missing: whether the work stayed in the «aryanised» gallery and how it came back.
What we found
- SK-A-3281: «donated by Kurt (1887-1951) and Adolf Arnhold (1884-1950), Dresden and London, to the museum, 1939»
- SK-A-4051: «Koenigs (1881-1941) Haarlem, in or before 1933;{When exhibited in the _Rubens-Tentoonstelling, Catalogus der Rubens-Tentoonstelling ten bate van der Vereeniging ‘Rembrandt’_, dealer cat. Amsterdam (Kunsthandel J. Goudstikker), August-September 1933, no. 30.} from whom on loan to the Boymans Museum»
- SK-A-4654: «purchased by Galerie Sanct Lucas, Vienna, 1937;{Letter to the museum from Galerie Sanct Lucas, Vienna, 16 July 1974; file RMA.} sold to a private collector, Klosterneuburg, near Vienna, March 1942;{Letter to the museum from Galerie Sanct Lucas, Vienna, 16 July 1974; file RMA.}…; Galerie Sanct»
What the museum should answer
- What do the museum's files say about the 1939 Arnhold gift, the De Bruijn purchase of May 1940 and the passage through Sanct Lucas in 1938–1946?
Sources
Rijksmuseum: «Portrait of a Collector, possibly Constantijn Sennepart (1625-1703)» (SK-A-3281); Rijksmuseum: «Cadmus, Guided by Minerva, Observes the Spartoi Fighting» (SK-A-4051); Rijksmuseum: «Allegory of the Farewell of William III from Amalia van Solms following the transfer of Regency to the States General» (SK-A-4654)
A Gavarni from the Gurlitt bequest sold by a Jewish collector in 1942 Paris
Kunstmuseum Bern (legado Gurlitt)
«L'Horticulteur» by Paul Gavarni belonged to Alexandre Dumas's family and then to Alexandre Lippmann, a Jewish Paris collector, who sold it on 4 May 1942 to Raphaël Gérard's gallery. It later reached Hildebrand Gurlitt.
The museum publishes that sale, rates the work «Gelb-Rot» (research status January 2023) and keeps it. It is not on the list of decisions announced in June 2025.
What we found
- Our database has another Lippmann Gavarni that went through Gérard in 1942 (a bequest find published on Lost Art). It is a sale by a persecuted person in occupied territory to a looting-era dealer, and the work remains in the museum with no published solution.
What the museum should answer
- Have Alexandre Lippmann's heirs been sought?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Bern, Catalogue Online (legado Gurlitt): Gavarni, «L'Horticulteur»; Kunstmuseum Bern, dossier de prensa del 11-06-2025
Thirteen works from the Gurlitt bequest claimed by the heirs of Fritz Salo Glaser
Kunstmuseum Bern (legado Gurlitt)
They are drawings and watercolours by Dresden artists (Christoph, Felixmüller, Fraaß, Godenschweg, Griebel, Kretzschmar, Lachnit, Maskos, Voll). The museum rates them «Gelb-Rot» and for two of them (Lachnit) names the Dresden lawyer and collector Fritz Salo Glaser as owner.
In June 2025 the museum announced it was handling the claim of Glaser's heirs for all thirteen. The published chains do not say when or how they passed to Hildebrand Gurlitt; the Allies held them in Wiesbaden in 1945–1950 and returned them.
What we found
- All thirteen are also listed as bequest finds on Lost Art. We found no published decision on the claim.
What the museum should answer
- What did the museum decide on the Glaser heirs' claim?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Bern, dossier de prensa del 11-06-2025; Kunstmuseum Bern, comunicado del 10-12-2021
Bequest works that went through Raphaël Gérard in occupied Paris
Kunstmuseum Bern (legado Gurlitt)
Three Renoirs the Jewish dealer Jos Hessel sold to Gérard on 27 June 1941; a Daumier Gérard bought from André Schoeller in October 1941; a Cambodian dancer (after Rodin) from Claude-René Blum sold at Drouot in December 1943; a Degas Gérard bought in July 1941; a Waldmüller Gérard held in 1944.
Bern rates nearly all «Gelb-Rot» and in June 2025 announced it was preparing decisions on the Renoirs, the Daumier and the dancer.
What we found
- For these works the published provenance already shows the sale in occupied territory; what is missing is the museum's decision or, for the Degas and the Waldmüller, who held the work before Gérard.
What the museum should answer
- What did the museum decide on Hessel's Renoirs, the Daumier and the dancer?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Bern, dossier de prensa del 11-06-2025; Kunstmuseum Bern, comunicado del 10-12-2021
The museum's own collection: ten works with indications still under research
Kunstmuseum Bern
Besides the Gurlitt bequest, the museum has reviewed some 700 of its own works since 2017 and published a report per work. It rated ten «Gelb-rot»: an Amiet from Paul Leffmann (sold in 1940), Courbet's «Réveil» (Wildenstein, Dequoy and Haberstock in 1939–1941), two Soutines (Jos Hessel and Oscar Miestchaninoff), a Corinth from Heinrich Stahl (who died in Theresienstadt), a Kirchner that went through Kurt Feldhäusser in 1943, a panel attributed to Maes that was in Linz and returned to the Netherlands, and a Courbet and a Delacroix with gaps in 1933–1946.
Separately, it is researching a Kirchner («Dünen und Meer») that may be the one seized in Bremen in 1937 from a private lender.
What we found
- Each lacks a specific document (Leffmann's 1940 sale, how the works left Hessel, Stahl or Miestchaninoff, what the Dutch state did with the Maes). The reports are published; the solutions are not.
What the museum should answer
- Has the museum sought the heirs of Leffmann, Stahl and Miestchaninoff?
Sources
Kunstmuseum Bern: Provenienzforschung Sammlung (informes por obra); Kunstmuseum Bern, informe final del proyecto BAK 2023–2024; Kunstmuseum Bern, dossier de prensa del 11-06-2025
Since 1996 the Pushkin has shown Schliemann’s Trojan treasures that Berlin lost in 1945
Museo Pushkin de Bellas Artes, Moscú
Heinrich Schliemann gave his Troy finds to the Berlin museums. In April 1945 Wilhelm Unverzagt, in charge of the collection, handed it to a Soviet officer.
According to the Pushkin itself, 259 items from 13 treasures reached the museum as «partial reparation», were kept hidden as a «special collection» and have been shown since 15 April 1996.
It is a war loss of a German public museum, not Nazi looting. Germany seeks its return; Russia deems it federal property under the 1998 law.
What we found
- The Eberswalde hoard (Bronze Age gold from the same Berlin museums) was also taken to Moscow; we found no open primary source placing it at the Pushkin.
What the museum should answer
- What inventory number did the Pushkin give each Trojan item?
Sources
Museo Pushkin, Departamento de Restauración: «The Gold of Troy»; Apollo, 6-1-2020: «Haul of shame – the ‹trophy art› taken from Germany by the Red Army» (Jessica Loudis)
The Krebs collection at the Hermitage: 78 paintings of a German industrialist, removed from Holzdorf after 1945
Museo del Hermitage, San Petersburgo
Otto Krebs, an industrialist, died in 1941 and left his collection in the cellar of his house at Holzdorf near Weimar, in the zone occupied by the Red Army. When the military left in 1949 nothing remained.
A 1957 Hermitage inventory records 78 Krebs paintings out of the 98 he owned; the museum first showed them in 1995 in «Hidden Treasures Revealed», a 74-painting show. They carry numbers from a separate series, ЗКРсэ-.
Krebs was not persecuted: this is a war loss of a private German collector, not Nazi looting. We found no published claim by his heirs; in 1994 the Weimar collections said they hoped for «full restitution».
What we found
- Wikidata names Krebs as owner of six paintings numbered ЗКРсэ- (five Cézannes and a Gauguin). The ЗКРсэ- series has at least 46 paintings in Wikidata, but we found no source saying which are Krebs’s.
- The Hermitage record has no provenance field: it does not say whom any of these paintings belonged to.
What the museum should answer
- Why does the Hermitage record not name Krebs, when the 1995 catalogue did?
Sources
The Art Newspaper, 1-11-1994: «What future for the looted Krebs Collection?»; The Art Newspaper, 30-4-1994: «Where is the real Van Gogh’s White House at Night?»; The Moscow Times, 19-10-1994: «Hermitage Trophies to Set Art World Afire» (Jean MacKenzie); The Moscow Times, 10-2-1995: «Hermitage Displays Trophy Art»; PubHist: obras de «Hidden Treasures Revealed» (Hermitage, 1995)
Frankfurt's Goethe museum declares restitution cases and still holds them
Freies Deutsches Hochstift / Frankfurter Goethe-Museum
The Freies Deutsches Hochstift (Frankfurt's Goethe museum) researched what it bought between 1933 and 1945 and publishes a «Provenienzampel» per work on museum-digital. «Rot» means a restitution case.
Still in the collection, rated «Rot»: the Fiedler pastel sold in 1934 by Regina Birnbach, who emigrated; the magic-lantern painting from the collection of Arthur Adler-Stiebel, who died after being held in Buchenwald, sold by his mother in 1939; a drawing sold in 1936 by Martha Oppenheimer; two drawings bought from the St. Goar gallery in 1934 and 1936; eight letters Kurt Loewenfeld auctioned in 1937; and a Goethe letter brought from Ukraine in 1943 by a Degussa employee.
The museum says it is in contact with heirs (Birnbach, Adler-Stiebel, Oppenheimer) or looking for them (Loewenfeld). It has settled others: it returned the Vollerdt to Fritz Goldschmidt's heirs in 2024, received the Stresemann family portrait as a donation and bought back Beno Kaufmann's receipt.
What we found
- For the drawings bought from St. Goar the record neither names the previous owner nor explains why they are restitution cases.
- There are also 26 «Orange» works (unresolved indications), such as two Trautmann paintings sold in 1941 by a Leipzig dealer or Arent de Gelder's «Alchemist», which passed through the Dienststelle Mühlmann; they are posted on Lost Art.
What the museum should answer
- When does the museum expect to close the cases open since 2020–2021?
- Who owned the drawings sold by St. Goar?
Sources
Freies Deutsches Hochstift: Restitutionsfälle Kunstwerke; Freies Deutsches Hochstift: Restitutionsfälle Handschriften; Freies Deutsches Hochstift: el proyecto de procedencia
Two ceramic dishes at the MAKK in Cologne that the museum declares «clearly tainted»
MAKK – Museum für Angewandte Kunst Köln
Between 2020 and 2026 the MAKK researched some 500 purchases of 1933–1940. Two dishes belonged to M. Salomon of Dresden, were sold at Lempertz (Cologne) in October 1936 and were bought by the museum's friends' association.
The museum writes that their 1933–1945 provenance is «eindeutig belastet» and posted them on Lost Art. They remain in the collection.
In the same project the museum returned a pair of tables from the Jacques Rosenthal antiquarian firm to the heirs in 2023 and bought them back, and rates seven other pieces «bedenklich» (Lepke and Helbing sales, purchases from unidentified sellers).
What we found
- For M. Salomon the museum gives no full name and does not say whether it searched for heirs.
What the museum should answer
- Who was M. Salomon and what happened to them?
- Is there contact with heirs?
Sources
The objects bought for Goebbels's guest house in Rheydt
Städtisches Museum Schloss Rheydt (Mönchengladbach)
In 1939/40 the city of Mönchengladbach furnished Schloss Rheydt as a guest house intended above all for Joseph Goebbels, who was born in Rheydt. The museum researched its collection in 2024–2026 with a «Provenienzampel».
A painting, two tapestries and a jardinière bought for that house are rated «Rot»: the museum says their provenance is «höchstwahrscheinlich bzw. eindeutig belastet» and posted them on Lost Art.
The museum does not identify the previous owners. It also rates some twenty objects «Rot» or «Orange» because they were bought from firms that profited from Nazism (Weinmüller, Huelsmann, Lockner), and two pieces of Judaica.
What we found
- They remain in the museum; no restitution has been published.
What the museum should answer
- From whom were the objects bought in 1939/40?
- Are there city records of those purchases?
Sources
museum-digital Rheinland: proyecto de procedencia del Museum Schloss Rheydt
A Potsdam glass goblet that turned up in a 1937 sale and that the museum wants to restitute
Potsdam Museum – Forum für Kunst und Geschichte
The goblet was listed as pre-1945 «old stock», with no year of entry. In April 2025 a researcher told the museum it appeared in the catalogue of a Hans W. Lange (Berlin) sale of 1937, lot 351.
The museum writes that it suspects a Nazi persecution-related loss and will report it to the German Lost Art Foundation «to make a restitution possible».
What we found
- The record does not yet say who consigned the goblet in 1937.
What the museum should answer
- Who was the 1937 consignor?
- Has the Lost Art report been filed?
Sources
Silver bought at the Dorotheum in 1941–42 that the MAK lists as of unknown ownership (13 objects)
MAK – Museum für angewandte Kunst, Viena
Between December 1941 and February 1942 the MAK bought jugs, goblets, candelabra, plates and other silver pieces at the Vienna Dorotheum. From 1939 Viennese Jews were required to sell their precious-metal objects there (§ 14 of the decree of 3 December 1938).
Eight lots bought at the same sales have been returned after the Beirat identified their owners (Schütz, Müller, Wunderlich, Gombrich, Kutscher, Iwnicki, Bauer), and a ninth, Kirchenberger's, has been recommended. These 13 remain in the Kunst-Datenbank as «Dubiousness is still to be clarified», with no known owner.
What we found
- The MAK publishes them so that someone may recognise them; the Beirat has not dealt with them.
What the museum should answer
- Are there § 14 delivery receipts at the Dorotheum or the Vermögensverkehrsstelle that would identify the owners?
Sources
Kunst-Datenbank del Nationalfonds: objetos del MAK; Kunstrückgabebeirat, Beschluss «Alfred Kirchenberger», 29-6-2021; MAK, «Restitutionen aus den Sammlungen des MAK 1999 bis heute»
Furniture, textiles and objects exchanged with the dealer Oskar Hamel in 1941–44 (59 objects)
MAK – Museum für angewandte Kunst, Viena
The Kunst-Datenbank lists 59 objects the MAK bought from or exchanged with the Viennese dealer Oskar Hamel between 1941 and 1944, all with unknown previous owners and the case unresolved.
What we found
- The museum does not say where Hamel obtained them.
What the museum should answer
- What did the MAK give Hamel in these exchanges, and where did those objects come from?
Sources
Objects assigned by the Zentralstelle für Denkmalschutz (1940) and tapestries received from the Allies (1954)
MAK – Museum für angewandte Kunst, Viena
4 objects (stove designs and a pattern book) arrived in 1940, assigned by the Zentralstelle für Denkmalschutz, the office that distributed property confiscated from Jews; the MAK lists them as of unknown ownership.
6 tapestries and rugs arrived in 1954 as «items previously secured by the Inter-Allied Commission and approved for release»; the Kunst-Datenbank says heirs are being sought.
What the museum should answer
- Which confiscated collections did they come from?
Sources
A Makart that Wolfgang Gurlitt bought at the Vienna Dorotheum in December 1940, from an unknown owner
Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz
The catalogue published by the Linz City Archive in 1999 notes for this painting: «KA. Dorotheum Wien am 6.12.1940 (Nr. 247, Tf. 13); München, Galerie Gurlitt». Linz bought it from Gurlitt in January 1953.
In the same report, the historian Walter Schuster writes that Gurlitt bought it at auction that day and that «über den Vorbesitzer ist nichts bekannt» (nothing is known about the previous owner). In 1940 the Dorotheum was selling property taken from Viennese Jews on a large scale.
What we found
- No. 46 is not among the 64 works the Lentos says it had researched in its 2019 report.
What the museum should answer
- Who consigned the painting to the auction of 6 December 1940?
- Has the museum researched the work since 2019?
Sources
Archiv der Stadt Linz, Walter Schuster, «Die "Sammlung Gurlitt" der Neuen Galerie der Stadt Linz» (1999), p. 98, cat. IX.1 n.º 63; Archiv der Stadt Linz, Walter Schuster, «Die "Sammlung Gurlitt" der Neuen Galerie der Stadt Linz» (1999), p. 18, cap. II.3 («Über den Vorbesitzer ist nichts bekannt»); Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz, «Provenienzforschung am Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz. Zwischenbericht», octubre de 2019 (lista de obras investigadas, sin el n.º 46)
A Liebermann from the collection of Ottmar Strauss, auctioned by Helbing in 1934–35
Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz
The city's 1999 catalogue gives this provenance: «Ottmar Strauss, Frankfurt am Main (bis 1935?); Hugo Helbing, Frankfurt am Main (1935)». Linz bought it from Gurlitt in January 1953.
The Hugo Helbing house auctioned the collection of the industrialist Ottmar Strauss in November 1934 and May 1935. Lost Art lists hundreds of search requests from his heirs for works from that collection.
What we found
- No. 43 is not among the works the Lentos says it had researched by 2019.
What the museum should answer
- Was the painting in either Helbing sale? Who bought it and how did it reach Gurlitt?
Sources
Archiv der Stadt Linz, Walter Schuster, «Die "Sammlung Gurlitt" der Neuen Galerie der Stadt Linz» (1999), p. 97, cat. IX.1 n.º 59; Proveana: Sammlung Ottmar Strauss; Proveana: remate Hugo Helbing, «Sammlung Geheimrat Ottmar Strauss» II. Teil, mayo de 1935; Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz, «Provenienzforschung am Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz. Zwischenbericht», octubre de 2019 (lista de obras investigadas, sin el n.º 43)
A Trübner drawing with the same title as one sought by the heirs of Max Silberberg
Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz
Linz bought the sheet from Gurlitt in January 1953; the city's catalogue gives neither dimensions nor previous owners.
On Lost Art, the heirs of the Breslau collector Max Silberberg, murdered in the Holocaust, are looking for a Trübner drawing «Zwei weibliche Akte» measuring 39 × 49.5 cm, unsold at Paul Graupe's auction of 12 October 1935 and missing since.
What we found
- Trübner drew many nudes and the title is generic: without dimensions it cannot be said whether it is the same sheet.
What the museum should answer
- What are the dimensions of the Lentos sheet and what marks does it bear on the back?
Sources
Archiv der Stadt Linz, Walter Schuster, «Die "Sammlung Gurlitt" der Neuen Galerie der Stadt Linz» (1999), p. 158, cat. IX.2 n.º 438; Lost Art 414747: Wilhelm Trübner, «Zwei weibliche Akte» (Sammlung Max Silberberg)
Two Faistauers from the Schwarz collection that Gurlitt bought from the son after the war
Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz
The inventory says «Ehemals Sammlung Schwarz, Salzburg. Nach 1945 durch Gurlitt von Hugo Schwarz erworben». Linz bought them from Gurlitt in 1952/53.
Walter Schwarz, co-owner of the Linz department store Kraus & Schober, «aryanised» in 1938, died in Gestapo custody. Part of his collection was returned to his son Hugo in 1948/49; Hugo sold nearly all of it to Gurlitt and said in 1993 that Gurlitt had withheld two paintings from him.
What we found
- The Lentos lists both works among the 64 researched (2019) but has not published its conclusion.
What the museum should answer
- Did Gurlitt pay Hugo Schwarz for these two paintings?
Sources
Archiv der Stadt Linz, Walter Schuster, «Die "Sammlung Gurlitt" der Neuen Galerie der Stadt Linz» (1999), p. 91, cat. IX.1 n.º 23; Archiv der Stadt Linz, Walter Schuster, «Die "Sammlung Gurlitt" der Neuen Galerie der Stadt Linz» (1999), p. 68, cap. V.5 «Die beiden Faistauer aus der Sammlung Schwarz»; Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz, «Provenienzforschung am Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz. Zwischenbericht», octubre de 2019 (lista de obras investigadas)
A Sisley in Minneapolis with 79 undocumented years in France, and a “Bridge at Moret” confiscated in Paris sought on Lost Art
Minneapolis Institute of Art
The Minneapolis Institute of Art bought this Sisley in 2002 from Galerie Daniel Malingue, Paris.
Its provenance reaches an auction in Paris in 1923, where Galerie Georges Petit bought it and sold it to a collector. After that it says only “private collection, France (from 1923)” until 2002: 79 years without names, the occupation included.
Lost Art has a search request for a Sisley titled “Die Brücke von Moret”: bought between 1934 and 1940 from a “Galerie d'Art” in Paris by Mendel Kaplan and “confiscated by German authorities” in Paris around 1942. The record cites a restitution file in the Berlin State Archive.
Sisley painted the bridge at Moret many times and the Lost Art record gives no measurements, so it cannot be said to be the same painting. What can be asked is that the museum say who owned it between 1923 and 2002.
What we found
- The Lost Art record cites “D - LAB, B Rep.025-09-13, Nr. 1184/60”: a file of the Berlin restitution offices, where the dispossessed filed claims against Germany in the 1950s and 1960s.
- Neither the museum's provenance nor the Lost Art record contains data that would confirm or rule out that they are the same work.
What the museum should answer
- Who was the French collector who owned it from 1923? Where was the painting between 1940 and 1944?
- Has the museum compared its Sisley with Mendel Kaplan's “Bridge at Moret”?
Sources
Mia, public collection search (provenance of 2002.67); Lost Art: “Die Brücke von Moret” (533245) — copy in our database; the page now requires an anti-bot check
The 13 works Linz restituted between 1999 and 2015
Lentos Kunstmuseum Linz
All reached the Neue Galerie between 1952 and 1956, twelve from Wolfgang Gurlitt and the Nolde from Friedrich Welz. Six Romakos remain at the Lentos as a permanent loan from the Reichel heir.
What we found
- Ria Munk III had already raised suspicion in 1952: the city set it aside from the purchase («Klimt jüdischer Besitz! Vorbehalt bis Klärung!» — Klimt, Jewish property, reserved until clarified) and bought it anyway in 1956.
Sources
Lentos, Zwischenbericht Provenienzforschung 2019, punto 4; Stadt Linz, «Lentos – Die Sammlung», 5-3-2026
Cases the museum already explains
The cross-check also finds works with a looting past that the museum has already researched and tells in its provenance. We show them too: they prove it can be done.
- Caspar Netscher, «A Woman Feeding a Parrot, with a Page» (2016.118.1)
Seized by the ERR from the Andriesse collection in 1941 (ERR HA 9). In 2014 the Von der Heydt-Museum in Wuppertal restituted it to the heirs of Hugo and Elisabeth Andriesse, who sold it at Christie's New York; the National Gallery bought it in 2016 from a London dealer. Its provenance tells the story.
- Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller, «The Cartographer Josef Jüttner and His Wife» (2006.157.1)
An almost identical version was bought for Hitler's Linz museum and is still in German federal custody. The National Gallery explains in its provenance that the Linz picture is the other version, not its own.
- Pierre Bonnard, «Work Table» (2006.128.12)
Looted by the ERR from Paul Rosenberg, it went through the Göring collection and the Munich Collecting Point, and in 1946 it was shown in Paris among the recovered works. The National Gallery tells the story in its provenance.
- Edouard Manet, «George Moore in the Artist's Garden» (2006.128.24)
Owned by Max Liebermann. The NGA documents it was among 14 pictures sent to the Kunsthaus Zürich in May 1933 for safekeeping and later released to his daughter Käthe Riezler, who emigrated to New York in 1938 and lent it in 1948 and 1949. It left Germany with the family.
- Jan Brueghel the Elder, «Wooded Landscape with Travelers» (2020.26.1)
Bought in 2020 with provenance research from two Munich Zentralinstitut projects (Stern and Böhler). It passed through Max Stern's Düsseldorf gallery in 1936, while he was being forced out, and to Richard Friede, a Jewish collector who held it by September 1938 and took it to New York in 1941; his family sold it around 1992. The NGA documents all of it.
- Jean Siméon Chardin, «Still Life with Game» (1952.5.36)
Owned by David David-Weill, whose collection the ERR looted in 1941. But Wildenstein bought this canvas in 1937 with part of the collection and it was shown in New York that year. The NGA explains it.
- Renoir, «A Girl with a Hoop» (1963.10.58) and Courbet, «A Young Woman Reading» (1963.10.114)
Owned by Max Silberberg of Breslau, murdered in the Holocaust. But he sold them at his Paris auction of 9 June 1932, before the Nazis took power; Chester Dale bought them there.
- Aelbert Cuyp, «River Landscape with Cows» (1986.70.1)
Owned by Ignaz Petschek, of the Jewish Czech industrial family. It passed to his son Frank, who emigrated to New York, and to his granddaughters, who donated it in 1986. It never left the family.
- Paul Cézanne, «Boy in a Red Waistcoat» (1995.47.5)
Owned by the banker Jakob Goldschmidt, who fled Germany. He kept it: it was sold at his estate sale at Sotheby's in 1958.
- Auguste Renoir, «Suzanne Valadon» (1963.10.60)
The «confiscation» is not Nazi: Martin Fabiani shipped part of Vollard's collection out of France and the British seized it in Bermuda; it spent the war at the National Gallery of Canada and was released in 1949. Fabiani was a collaborationist dealer, but the work came from Vollard's heirs, not a persecuted owner.
- Derain, «Still Life» (1972.9.10) and Feininger, «Street of Barns» (2001.129.1)
Both were removed from the Museum Folkwang, Essen, as «degenerate art» in 1937; the Derain was sold through the Buchholz Gallery, one of the authorised agents. Seizures from a public museum, not from a persecuted owner; Germany never annulled that law. The NGA documents it.
- Paul Sérusier, «Farmhouse at Le Pouldu» (2000.95.1)
The Ulm Museum listed it as «degenerate» in 1933 and used it in a show mocking its Jewish director, Julius Baum; but it escaped the 1937 seizure, stayed in the museum and the museum itself sold it in 1955. Documented with the museum's provenance researcher.
- Tiepolo, «Scene from Ancient History» (1939.1.365)
Owned by the Viennese banker Stefan von Auspitz, who lost his collection in the 1931 Austrian banking crisis, before Nazism; via Van Beuningen and Bachstitz, Kress bought it in 1937.
- Lippo Memmi, «Saint John the Baptist» (1939.1.291)
Passed through Jacques Goudstikker, but he sold it in February 1937, via Paul Cassirer, to Duveen; Germany invaded the Netherlands in 1940. An ordinary dealer's sale before the looting.
- Renoir, «Girl with a Basket of Fish» and «… of Oranges» (1956.4.1-2)
Georges Lévy sold them in 1937 through Jacques Seligmann in Paris, and a New York collector bought them that month. Sold before the Occupation.
- André Derain, «Charing Cross Bridge, London» (1982.76.3)
The dealer Käthe Perls, a German Jewish émigré in Paris, bought it there between 1932 and 1938 and probably sold it herself to Walter Chrysler, who had it by 1939. The seller was the persecuted party, in France, before the war.
- Arnold Böcklin, «The Sanctuary of Hercules» (1976.36.1)
Owned by Arthur von Weinberg, of Jewish descent, who died in Theresienstadt in 1943. Per the NGA it passed to his adopted daughters and a granddaughter, and was with a Zurich gallery by 1975, with a letter from a Prince Lobkowicz on file. It stayed in the family.
- Jean Metzinger, “Woman with a Fan” (1959.10)
The museum's provenance says it was most likely sold in Amsterdam in October 1940 as part of the Lewenstein estate. In September 2026 the Art Institute announced it is returning it to the heirs of Emanuel Lewenstein: according to the museum, the work was seized from the family and forcibly sold.
- Gustave Courbet, “The Rock of Hautepierre” (1967.140)
It belonged to Max Silberberg, a Jewish collector from Breslau murdered in the Holocaust, and was sold at one of the auctions of his collection at Graupe in Berlin in March 1935. The museum publishes that sale in its provenance but does not explain it. According to Wikipedia, the Art Institute reached a settlement with Silberberg's heir for this painting (we did not find it confirmed in a museum source).
- Bartolomé Bermejo, “A Bishop Saint” (1947.393), and Netherlandish Crucifixion triptych (1947.394)
Both belonged to Oskar Bondy, a Vienna collector dispossessed in 1938. The museum explains that they were not among the objects sealed in his Vienna apartment in 1938 (Sophie Lillie's list) and that Bondy's widow sold them in New York in 1947.
- Niccolò di Tommaso, triptych (2026.277)
Confiscated in 1939 by the Prussian state from Fritz Thyssen when he fled Germany; the museum says that by 1951 it was back with his wife and daughter, and that the family later sold it.
- François Boucher, “Fountain of Venus” (1979.55)
Confiscated by the ERR from Maurice de Rothschild in 1940 and selected for the Linz museum (Linz 1583). It went back to the Rothschild family, which sold it through Colnaghi in 1974. The museum tells the story in detail.
- Henri Matisse, “Interior with an Etruscan Vase” (1952.153)
Looted by the ERR from Paul Rosenberg, it passed through Göring and Rochlitz, was recovered in Munich and returned to the Rosenberg gallery in 1946. The museum says so. (Our database lists it as “found, not restituted” because its sources do not record the 1946 return: this needs fixing.)
- Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres, “Antiochus and Stratonice” (1966.13)
Owned by Alphonse Kann; “seized by the Germans in 1941”, recovered after the war and sold by Kann's heirs in 1950. The museum's provenance says so.
- Emanuel de Witte, “Interior of a Church” (1971.1)
The provenance cites Munich Central Collecting Point no. 4061, but to explain that the number belongs to a different De Witte (confiscated from the Jaffé collection) with which this one was confused; Cleveland's was with Curt Bohnewand from 1937 to 1969. The database work with that number measures 82 × 66 cm; Cleveland's, 62 × 54.
- Peter Paul Rubens, “Portrait of Isabella Brant” (1947.207)
From the family of Marcus Kappel (Berlin). The museum explains that the heirs sold it in the United States to Rosenberg & Stiebel in November 1945 and that there is no sign it was seized by the Nazis.
- Veronese and workshop, “The Annunciation” (1950.251)
Owned by Leopold Koppel, a Berlin banker; his son Albert took it into exile (Switzerland, Toronto) and sold it through Rosenberg & Stiebel around 1950. The museum says so.
- Edgar Degas, “Frieze of Dancers” (1946.83)
Owned by Max Liebermann, on deposit at the Kunsthaus Zürich until 1935; inherited by his daughter Käthe Riezler, who took it to New York and sold it through Paul Rosenberg in 1946. It is in the museum's provenance.
- Johann Liss, “Cupid” (1971.100)
Owned by Alessandro Basevi, Genoa, from 1936. The museum says the SS seized his silver in 1944 and that the painting stayed in the family until after 1959.
- Bartolomeo di Tommaso, “Way to Emmaus” (77.27.1)
The museum notes that the panel may have belonged to Federico Gentili di Giuseppe, whose collection was auctioned in Paris in 1941 (a sale annulled by the French courts in 1999), and states that these panels were not in that sale; whether they were ever his remains to be confirmed.
- Robert Delaunay, “Saint-Séverin No. 2” (47.7)
Herbert von Garvens fled Germany in 1931 on a fishing boat with this painting; in 2023 the museum corrected the old account that it had been confiscated as “degenerate art”.
A lead in a provenance does not prove a work was looted. We publish only what we have reviewed by hand, with every source. If you are from a museum or a family and have information or a correction, write to us. Corrections
Conversation among account holders. It does not change the record: to correct or add a sourced fact, use “Propose a change”.
You need an account to comment. Sign in · Request an account