Case dossier: property stolen under Nazism with an Argentine connection
This dossier gathers the cases that, according to the research of limbral.com, today have a concrete path to recovering property stolen under Nazism that is in Argentina or passed through it, or that belongs to heirs who live here. Each case states what happened, what evidence exists, who could file a claim, with what tool, what to do first and where it is weak.
We are not looking for «el tesoro nazi»: there are no documents proving that Nazi leaders' fortunes were hidden in Argentina. What can be recovered is specific property, with an identifiable dispossessed owner and a locatable holder. Without an heir with standing there is no case: half the work is finding that heir or partnering with whoever already represents them.
The linked records (artworks, hypotheses, people) are on limbral.com and require an account: it can be requested on the site's entry page.
Framework: the tools that already exist
The Mar del Plata precedent (2025-2026)
The first court-ordered restitution of looted art in Argentina: a federal criminal case for aggravated concealment connected to crimes against humanity, with Interpol and Customs as complainants, and an agreement (suspension of the trial on probation) that returned the work to the Goudstikker heir. See case 1. (Infobae, 4-9-2026)
No statute of limitations
Crimes against humanity are not subject to any statute of limitations in Argentina (laws 24.584, 25.778 and 27.156), and the Código Civil y Comercial (art. 2561, last paragraph) declares the civil actions derived from them imprescriptible. The Kadgien family argued that the statute of limitations had run, and the argument failed. (La Nación, on why it does not lapse)
Access to information (Law 27.275)
Anyone can request documents from the State without explaining why; the deadline is 15 business days. The law's exceptions do not apply in cases of war crimes or crimes against humanity (art. 8, last paragraph). In What can be done today there are 10 requests already drafted (BCRA, Foreign Ministry, Migraciones, Defense, Air Force, Bellas Artes, AGN, Supreme Court, Presidency). (Ley 27.275, texto actualizado)
International commitments
Argentina took part in the Washington Principles (1998) and signed the Terezín Declaration (2009), which call for provenance research in museums and for «soluciones justas y equitativas» (just and fair solutions). In 2009 the Claims Conference noted that Argentine institutions were not carrying out provenance research. (Terezín Declaration: States · Claims Conference (2009))
Abroad
Germany: an arbitration tribunal for property in public hands, which an heir can approach unilaterally and whose award is binding (since 1-12-2025). United States: the HEAR Act gives six years from the discovery of the work, and since 2026 it no longer expires. Netherlands: the Restitutions Committee. France: the CIVS, free of charge and with no deadline. Switzerland: a new commission in 2026. (German arbitration tribunal · HEAR Act · CIVS, frequently asked questions)
Possible allies
Marei von Saher's lawyers (in Argentina, Herberto Robinson, Guillermo Brady and Juan Ignacio Pascual; in New York, Freedman Normand Friedland), the DAIA (which submitted a report in the Kadgien case), the Museo del Holocausto de Buenos Aires, the Wiesenthal Center, the Claims Conference and New York's Holocaust Claims Processing Office, which works free of charge. (La Nación, 4-9-2026 · Holocaust Claims Processing Office)
What the Kadgien family still holds: Goudstikker's Mignon and the rest
Friedrich Kadgien, head of foreign exchange and precious metals in the Four-Year Plan and of Göring's «Finanz Trust», kept at least two works from the Goudstikker gallery in Amsterdam and took them to Argentina, where he died in 1978. One, the «Retrato de una dama» (now attributed to Ceruti), was returned in 2026. The other, a still life with flowers by Abraham Mignon that Kadgien received on 18 May 1944, is listed as not returned and may have been visible in a family photo from around 2012. Swiss archives also describe him moving Göring's money and diamonds to Switzerland in 1944-1945.
- Who is claiming
- Marei von Saher, heir of Jacques Goudstikker (and Charlene von Saher), private complainants in the Mar del Plata case.
- Who holds it
- Kadgien's daughters (Mar del Plata); the whereabouts of the Mignon are unknown.
- Where
- Juzgado Federal de Mar del Plata (judge Santiago Inchausti; prosecutors Carlos Martínez and Daniel Adler). PROCELAC examined a money-laundering line of inquiry.
- What is sought
- Abraham Mignon, «Bloemstilleven», oil on canvas, 88 × 66.5 cm (NK 18269; Göring database RMG01089); and an expert examination of the other works seized in 2025.
The facts
- 1938-1945Kadgien, who joined the NSDAP in 1932 and the SS in 1935, runs foreign exchange and precious metals in Göring's Four-Year Plan. In 1943 he proposes using diamonds and brilliants to obtain foreign currency. (dodis.ch/24689)
- 1940The Goudstikker gallery passes to Göring and Alois Miedl through forced sales, after Jacques Goudstikker's flight and death.
- 18-5-1944The Mignon, which Göring had handed to Goudstikker-Miedl in an exchange for a Vermeer, passes from Goudstikker-Miedl to Kadgien in Berlin. The «Retrato de una dama» reached him on 8-5-1944 according to Lost Art (in 1940 according to the Dutch register). (DHM Göring database, RMG01089 · Lost Art 584759)
- 2-3-1945Note from the Swiss federal police: «prácticamente todo el dinero nazi» (practically all the Nazi money) was to be taken to Switzerland «con ayuda de Kadgien» (with Kadgien's help) and left in the hands of the German air attaché in Bern. (dodis.ch/20599 (BAR E 4320(B)1968/195/77))
- 13-2-1946The Swiss Federal Prosecutor's Office describes him as head of Göring's «Finanz Trust», alleged to have carried diamonds to Switzerland for Göring; the Dutch office for stolen property names him among the intermediaries for Dutch property. (dodis.ch/20709)
- 1949-1952He leaves Switzerland; in 1951 he is in Rio de Janeiro and in 1952 he represents a Zurich company in Bogotá; the Swiss government advises against dealing with him. (dodis.ch/9182)
- 1978He dies in Argentina. The works remain with the family.
- 25-8-2025A journalist from the Algemeen Dagblad recognizes the «Retrato de una dama» in a Mar del Plata real-estate listing. Interpol and Customs file complaints; the case is opened. The Buenos Aires Herald points out that a Facebook photo from around 2012 would also show a still life with flowers like the Mignon. (Buenos Aires Herald)
- Aug.-Sep. 2025Searches: the painting is not there (a tapestry hangs in its place). At another daughter's house, two male portraits from around 1840, drawings and prints are seized. On 3-9 the defense hands over the portrait; on 4-9 charges of aggravated concealment connected to crimes against humanity are brought. (La Nación, 2-9-2025 · MDZ)
- 2-3-2026The investigation is extended: still pending are the expert examination of the other works, cooperation with Germany regarding Kadgien, the money-laundering analysis (PROCELAC) and the DAIA report. (Infobae, 2-3-2026)
- 4-9-2026Suspension of the trial on probation: the accused renounce the work, pay 4.8 million pesos to the Hospital Materno Infantil de Mar del Plata and comply with 24 months of conduct rules. The portrait returns to von Saher. (Infobae, 4-9-2026)
What evidence there is
- The Mignon is recorded with Kadgien as its last known holder in two independent databases: the Dutch register of unreturned works (NK 18269, SNK declaration 7154 of 1946) and the Göring collection database of the German Historical Museum (RMG01089: «am 18.05.1944 an Kadgien … Berlin»; whereabouts: «Fehlt»).
- The photo from around 2012 cited by the Buenos Aires Herald: it must be obtained and compared with the archival image of the Mignon.
- The Swiss files (dodis.ch 20599, 20709, 23989, 24689, 9182) prove Kadgien's role in Göring's finances and in moving valuables to Switzerland; they are not judgments but police and intelligence notes.
- The case itself: the 2026 agreement implicitly acknowledges the provenance; the expert examinations of the other seized works have not been published.
Records on limbral.com
- The Mignon (Dutch register NK 18269)https://limbral.com/obra/nk:18269
- The Mignon (Göring database RMG01089)https://limbral.com/obra/dhm_goering:RMG01089
- The «Retrato de una dama» (Lost Art 584759)https://limbral.com/obra/lostart:584759
- Friedrich Kadgienhttps://limbral.com/persona/friedrich-kadgien
- Hypothesis: Kadgien, Göring's finances and Switzerlandhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/friedrich-kadgien-que-trajo-a-la-argentina-el-retrato-de
- Hypothesis: the family kept more workshttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/la-familia-kadgien-guardaba-en-la-argentina-mas-obras-de
- Hypothesis: the 2026 agreementhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/en-2026-un-acuerdo-ante-el-juzgado-federal-de-mar
- Hypothesis: the Goudstikker collection, to Göring and Miedlhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/la-coleccion-goudstikker-paso-a-goring-y-a-alois-miedl
Under market watch
- Abraham Mignon, naturaleza muerta con flores (Goudstikker → Göring → Kadgien) · no similar lots yet
Legal basis
- Aggravated concealment connected to crimes against humanity (the same offense as in the 2025 case): not subject to any statute of limitations.
- Civil action for restitution: imprescriptible because it derives from a crime against humanity (art. 2561 CCyC).
- Money laundering, if it is proven that Göring's valuables became family assets (the line examined by PROCELAC).
- International cooperation: the Netherlands (NK register, Restitutiecommissie), Germany (Kadgien's records) and Switzerland (Federal Archives files).
Next steps
- Ask the court and the prosecutor's office for the results of the expert examinations of the other seized works (the two portraits from around 1840 and the material «de Frankfurt»).
- Ask for the search to be extended to the Mignon (NK 18269 / RMG01089), submitting the records, the archival image and the photo from around 2012.
- Alert von Saher's lawyers to the Mignon: it is a second Goudstikker work in the same family.
- Submit the Swiss files on Kadgien to the case and request the complete file from the Swiss Federal Archives (BAR E 4320(B)1968/195/77, C.2.10094).
- Ask the prosecutor's office and PROCELAC what became of the money-laundering line of inquiry.
- Ask the Dutch National Archives (SNK fonds, file 756) for the documentation of the 1946 declaration on the Mignon.
Weak points
- The suspension of the trial on probation closed the case with respect to the portrait; reopening it for another work requires a new fact (the Mignon would be one).
- There is no public evidence that the Mignon is in Argentina today: the 2012 photo is an indication, not an identification.
- The Swiss documents are police and intelligence notes from 1945-1946, not convictions.
Goudstikker's «Oude Man», which passed through Buenos Aires in 1962-63
A portrait of an old man (65 × 52 cm), attributed at different times to Rembrandt, Jan Lievens or Jacob Backer, number 3202 in the Goudstikker inventory. It left Amsterdam in 1940, never returned to the Netherlands and has been listed as sought in Lost Art since 2022. Its provenance places it in a «colección Juan Bernhadt, Buenos Aires, 1962-63» before it was sold in Vienna in 1970. It is the same heir and the same network as the Kadgien case.
- Who is claiming
- The Goudstikker heirs (von Saher); in Lost Art it was entered by a private individual in 2022.
- Who holds it
- Unknown since the Dorotheum auction in Vienna (17/20-3-1970, lot 66, as Jan Lievens).
- Where
- Depending on where it turns up: Germany (Lost Art, arbitration tribunal if in public hands), the United States (HEAR Act), the Netherlands or Argentina.
- What is sought
- «Oude Man / Alter Mann», oil on canvas, 65 × 52 cm, Goudstikker 3202 (NK 14608; Lost Art 605497).
The facts
- 1940Goudstikker inventory 3202. After Goudstikker's flight, it passes to Goudstikker-Miedl.
- 27-7-1940According to the Dutch register, it is bought by «H. Hoffmann» of Munich (probably Heinrich Hoffmann, Hitler's photographer; not verified). Lost Art also mentions Göring in the chain. (Dutch register, NK 14608)
- 1962-63«coll. Juan Bernhadt, Buenos Aires». It was not possible to identify that person.
- 1960sIt passes through the dealer J. O. Leegenhoek in Paris (avenue Kléber).
- 17/20-3-1970It is sold at the Dorotheum in Vienna, lot 66, as Jan Lievens, for 28,000 Austrian schillings. Whereabouts unknown since then.
- 24-10-2022A private individual lists it as sought in Lost Art (property seized as a result of Nazi persecution). (Lost Art 605497)
- 11-7-2008Possible reappearance, unconfirmed: Christie's (South Kensington) sells «An old man, bust-length, in a feigned oval», «follower of Jan Lievens», oil on canvas, 64.8 × 53.4 cm, for 2,500 pounds, with no published provenance. It was flagged by the automated monitoring of limbral.com on the basis of dimensions, technique and title; it must be compared with the photo of Goudstikker 3202. (Christie's, lot 5101482)
What evidence there is
- Dimensions and inventory number match in two independent registers: Lost Art 605497 (Goudstikker 3202, 65 × 52) and the Dutch register of unreturned works NK 14608 (SNK record 3202, 65 × 52).
- The Goudstikker inventory (Stadsarchief Amsterdam, fonds 1341, file 97, p. 33) and Peter van den Brink's monograph on Jacob Backer (2008, no. A6d) document the work and its provenance.
- There is a discrepancy: the Dutch register gives the buyer as H. Hoffmann (Munich), Lost Art as Göring.
Records on limbral.com
- «Oude Man» (Lost Art 605497)https://limbral.com/obra/lostart:605497
- «Kop van een oude man» (Dutch register NK 14608)https://limbral.com/obra/nk:14608
- Alois Miedlhttps://limbral.com/persona/alois-miedl
- Hypothesis: the Goudstikker collection, to Göring and Miedlhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/la-coleccion-goudstikker-paso-a-goring-y-a-alois-miedl
Under market watch
- «Oude Man», Goudstikker 3202 (Rembrandt / Lievens / Backer) · no lot with evidence; 6 similar lots without evidence
Legal basis
- If it turns up in Germany in public hands: the arbitration tribunal (the heir can go alone, the award is binding). If in private German hands: Lost Art and negotiation; the restitution law for private holders has still not been enacted.
- If it turns up in the United States: the HEAR Act (six years from identification of the holder).
- If it turns up in Argentina: the federal criminal route of the Kadgien case and the imprescriptible civil action.
- If it turns up on the market: the auction house must halt the sale when faced with a documented claim.
Next steps
- Compare the 2008 Christie's lot (follower of Jan Lievens, 64.8 × 53.4 cm) with the photo of Goudstikker 3202 (RKD or Goudstikker archive) and, if it matches, ask Christie's for the names of the seller and buyer.
- Ask the Dorotheum for the records of the 1970 sale (consignor and buyer of lot 66).
- Identify «Juan Bernhadt/Bernhardt»: entries in Migraciones, the Boletín Oficial and the Inspección General de Justicia (companies 1955-1965), probate records; and the archive of the Leegenhoek gallery in Paris.
- Ask the RKD (Netherlands) for the image documentation of Goudstikker 3202.
- Consult van den Brink's monograph on Jacob Backer (no. A6d) for the provenance after 1970.
- Contact whoever filed the notice in Lost Art (through the Lost Art coordination office) and von Saher's lawyers.
- Enter the work in auction-house alert systems (Art Loss Register, Interpol) if it is not already there.
Weak points
- Its whereabouts have been unknown since 1970.
- The attribution has changed (Rembrandt, Lievens, Backer): it may circulate under another name and with other dimensions if it was relined.
- «Juan Bernhadt» has not been identified; linking him to Johannes Bernhardt (SOFINDUS) is only a conjecture.
Goudstikker's Redon, auctioned by Lempertz in 2022
An oil on cardboard by Odilon Redon, «Femme parque» (27 × 22 cm), inventory 3073 of the Goudstikker gallery, looted in 1940 and listed as sought in Lost Art since January 2020. The automated monitoring of limbral.com found it through the photo: on 1 June 2022 Lempertz (Cologne) auctioned a Redon of the same composition and size, «Figure en rouge assise sur un rocher», as «private property, Hesse», without mentioning Goudstikker. It sold for 75,600 euros. It is the same documented path: Goudstikker → Göring → Miedl → the dealer Wilhelm Henrich of Frankfurt (Hesse).
- Who is claiming
- The Goudstikker heirs (von Saher). The search notice in Lost Art was filed by a private individual on 17-1-2020.
- Who holds it
- The 2022 buyer (not public). Lempertz knows who it is.
- Where
- Germany: the work was sold in Cologne; with no restitution law for private holders, the route is a claim against the auction house and the buyer, and the prosecutor's office where appropriate. If the buyer is in the United States, the HEAR Act.
- What is sought
- Odilon Redon, «Femme parque» / «Figure en rouge assise sur un rocher», oil on cardboard, 27 × 22 cm (Lost Art 585263; NK 19055; ERR, Goudstikker 3073).
The facts
- 1936Goudstikker buys it («van B.», probably D. G. van Beuningen, Rotterdam). (Lost Art 585263)
- Jul. 1940After Goudstikker's flight and death, the collection passes to Göring and Alois Miedl. The ERR records it under Goudstikker inventory 3073. (ERR card 74152)
- 1940-1943Miedl sells it to the dealer Wilhelm Henrich of Frankfurt; the ERR also records a transfer to H. W. Lange, Berlin (6-10-1943).
- 27-5-1946The Dutch restitution agency records that the work left the country; it never returned. (Dutch register NK 19055)
- 17-1-2020A private individual lists it as sought in Lost Art (property seized as a result of Nazi persecution).
- 1-11-2021The Wildenstein Plattner Institute issues a report on the work; it does not appear in the Wildenstein catalogue raisonné (1992).
- 1-6-2022Lempertz, Cologne, auction 1200, lot 40: «Figure en rouge assise sur un rocher», oil on cardboard, 27 × 22.2 cm, signed upper right. Provenance: «Private property, Hesse». Estimate €60,000-80,000; sold for €75,600. (Lempertz, lot 40)
What evidence there is
- Same composition (hooded figure seated on a rock, mountains behind) in the Dutch archival photo and in the Lempertz catalogue photo.
- Same dimensions: 27 × 22 cm in Lost Art and in the Dutch register; 27 × 22.2 cm at Lempertz.
- Compatible provenance: the last known holder is a Frankfurt (Hesse) dealer, and Lempertz lists it as private property from Hesse.
- The Lost Art search notice dates from January 2020: before the sale. German auction houses consult that database.
- Still missing: confirmation by an expert (comparing the archival photo in good resolution with the work or with detail photos) and the chain between 1943 and 2022.
Records on limbral.com
- The Redon (Lost Art 585263)https://limbral.com/obra/lostart:585263
- The Redon (Dutch register NK 19055)https://limbral.com/obra/nk:19055
- Hypothesis: Goudstikker's Redon at Lempertzhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/el-redon-femme-parque-de-la-coleccion-goudstikker-buscado-en
- Jacques Goudstikkerhttps://limbral.com/persona/jacques-goudstikker
- Alois Miedlhttps://limbral.com/persona/alois-miedl
- Wilhelm Henrichhttps://limbral.com/persona/wilhelm-henrich
Legal basis
- Germany does not yet have a restitution law for works in private hands; the route is a direct claim against the auction house and the buyer, supported by the Lost Art notice that predates the sale (which weighs on good faith).
- German auction houses that adhere to the Washington Principles usually mediate between buyer and heirs when a documented claim arises.
- If the work went to the United States: the HEAR Act (six years from identification of the holder). If it is in public hands in Germany: the arbitration tribunal.
- If it were shown that a known provenance was concealed: possible liability of the seller.
Next steps
- Alert von Saher's lawyers and whoever filed the search notice in Lost Art (through the Lost Art coordination office).
- Ask Lempertz, on behalf of the heirs, for the names of the consignor and the buyer, the Wildenstein Plattner Institute report and the provenance documentation they had before them.
- Obtain the archival photo in high resolution (RKD or the RCE archive) and request a comparative expert examination.
- Review Wilhelm Henrich's archive and the Frankfurt sales of 1940-1950 (city archive, Hesse reparation files).
- Add the work to the Art Loss Register and Interpol alerts, in case it returns to the market.
Weak points
- The match comes from comparing photos; Redon repeated motifs and this could be another version. An expert has to confirm it.
- The 2022 buyer may claim good faith; the Lost Art notice that predates the sale weighs against that defense, but does not defeat it on its own.
- Lempertz may refuse to give names without a court order or a mandate from the heirs.
Trübner's «Weiße Rosen»: seized by the Gestapo, sold in 1948 to two private individuals in Argentina
A small still life of roses by Wilhelm Trübner (c. 1876, oil on paper, 30 × 40 cm) that the Gestapo seized in Hamburg on 26 January 1940 and that the dealer Karl Heumann auctioned in 1942-43. In 1948 it was resold «an zwei Privatpersonen in Argentinien» («to two private individuals in Argentina»). Since 2008 an heir, represented by a Berlin law firm, has been searching for it, together with three other works seized the same day.
- Who is claiming
- A private heir, represented by the firm von Trott zu Solz Lammek (Berlin), according to the public Lost Art record.
- Who holds it
- Unknown: «two private individuals in Argentina» since 1948.
- Where
- If it turns up in Argentina: federal criminal proceedings and a civil action not subject to a statute of limitations, as in the Kadgien case.
- What is sought
- Wilhelm Trübner, «Rosen / Weiße Rosen» (also «Kleiner Rosenstrauß»: one red and one yellow rose in a vase), signed «W. Trübner, München» (Lost Art 400256).
The facts
- 26-1-1940The Gestapo leaves four works belonging to the same family seized at the house of the Hamburg dealer Karl Heumann: this Trübner, a Corinth, a Díaz de la Peña and a Thomas Herbst.
- 1942-43Heumann auctions them. The pattern matches the auctions of persecuted people's property in Hamburg.
- PostwarThe Trübner appears with an «Eigentümer Wendt», probably a postwar buyer (not the victim).
- 1948«Weiterverkauf an zwei Privatpersonen in Argentinien»: it is resold to two private individuals in Argentina.
- 2008The heir registers it as sought on Lost Art, with the law firm as contact. (Lost Art 400256)
What evidence there is
- Lost Art record 400256, with the full chain and the law firm's contact details.
- The other three records from the same claimant (Lost Art 400253 to 400255) confirm the seizure of 26-1-1940 and Karl Heumann's auctions of 1942-43.
- It remains to be established where the «1948, Argentina» information comes from: the law firm will have it.
Records on limbral.com
- «Rosen / Weiße Rosen» (Lost Art 400256)https://limbral.com/obra/lostart:400256
Under market watch
Legal basis
- If it is in Argentina: concealment of property derived from a crime against humanity (as in Mar del Plata) and a civil action not subject to a statute of limitations (art. 2561 CCyC).
- If it is offered for sale: the auction house must halt the sale given a claim registered on Lost Art.
Next steps
- Write to the firm von Trott zu Solz Lammek (Berlin): whether the mandate still stands, who the persecuted owner was and where the 1948 information comes from.
- Request from the Hamburg State Archive the Finance Office and foreign-exchange files on the family, the records of Karl Heumann's auctions of 1942-43 and the restitution file, which may name Wendt.
- Search in Argentina from 1948 onward: Customs import records, Migration entry records, gallery archives (Witcomb, Müller), Buenos Aires auction catalogues 1948-1970, donations to the Bellas Artes museum by German-Argentine collectors.
- Register the work with the Art Loss Register and publicize it in Argentina (with an image, if the family has one).
Weak points
- There is no public photograph on Lost Art: identifying it requires the family's image or the Trübner catalogue raisonné (Rohrandt).
- Since 1948 it may have changed hands many times; the two buyers are unnamed.
- It is a small work of moderate value: the cost of the search may exceed its market value (though not its value to the family).
Paintings from Hitler's Linz museum sent to the German embassy in Buenos Aires (1962)
In 1962 the German government furnished its embassies with paintings bought for Hitler's museum in Linz and for Göring: 222 records with destinations at more than 40 missions. Four went «an AA Bonn, Ref. 111 (Buenos Aires)». One of them, a portrait by Hans Canon, belonged to Baroness Gabriele Oppenheimer of Vienna and was sold by the Neue Galerie in May 1941; in 2009 Germany already returned to her heirs another work with the same chain. Today those four records do not appear in the German State's public provenance database.
- Who is claiming
- The heirs of Gabriele Oppenheimer (1854-1943) for the Canon; those for the other three are yet to be identified.
- Who holds it
- The Federal Republic of Germany (Kunstverwaltung des Bundes / Federal Foreign Office). Whether they are still at the embassy in Buenos Aires has not been verified.
- Where
- The German arbitration tribunal: since this is federal property, the heir can initiate proceedings unilaterally and the award is binding.
- What is sought
- Hans Canon, «Knabe im Matrosenanzug», 1860, 158 × 111 cm (Mü 11096, Linz 1695/942); and Bettera (Mü 11321), Mali (Mü 11723) and Voltz (Mü 9251).
The facts
- Until 1938The Canon belongs to Baroness Gabriele Oppenheimer of Vienna (a relative of Otto Kallir, owner of the Neue Galerie, who emigrates in 1938).
- 22-4 / 5-1941Maria Almas-Dietrich, Hitler's dealer, buys it through the Neue Galerie in Vienna and sells it to the Linz project for 9,000 Reichsmark. (Central Collecting Point database, Mü 11096)
- 1949-1951In Munich, Almas declares a «free sale»; letters from 1951 by the gallery and by a Dr. Hermann Oppenheimer maintain there was no duress. The Allied officer transfers it to Bavaria as German property «on condition that research into its origin continue».
- 13-8-1962It leaves the Munich depot «an AA Bonn, Ref. 111 (Buenos Aires)», with three other works for the same embassy. (Mü 11321 (Bettera) · Mü 11723 (Mali) · Mü 9251 (Voltz))
- 2009Germany restitutes to the heirs of Gabriele Oppenheimer a Makart («Siesta am Hofe der Mediceer», Mü 9420) with the same chain (Neue Galerie, 1940), deeming it taken as a result of persecution. (Lost Art 220905)
- 3-10-2026The records of the four works are not in the German State's public provenance database (the expected address returns a 404 error); other works of the same origin are.
What evidence there is
- The four Central Collecting Point records (German Historical Museum database) showing their dispatch to Buenos Aires in 1962.
- The 2009 restitution of the Makart from the same owner and the same gallery: the German State has already acknowledged that those sales were due to persecution.
- The «free sale» statements of 1949-1951 come from Hitler's dealer and from the gallery that took over Kallir's business: they are not independent evidence.
- The Bettera carries a low risk (the Alte Pinakothek deaccessioned it around 1923-24, before Nazism); the Mali and the Voltz have no recorded prior owner.
- The Munich database records the BADV (the German federal office for property matters) as owner of the Bettera and keeps a photograph of the painting. A similar Bettera sold by Christie's in Paris in 2011 (106 × 143 cm) is not the same one: the composition is different.
Records on limbral.com
- Hans Canon, «Knabe im Matrosenanzug» (Mü 11096)https://limbral.com/obra/ccp_munich:11096a
- Bartolomeo Bettera, «Stillleben mit Musikinstrumenten» (Mü 11321)https://limbral.com/obra/ccp_munich:11321
- Christian Mali, «Heuwagen am Wasser» (Mü 11723)https://limbral.com/obra/ccp_munich:11723
- Friedrich Voltz, «Kuhherde am Bach» (Mü 9251)https://limbral.com/obra/ccp_munich:9251a
- Maria Almas-Dietrichhttps://limbral.com/persona/maria-almas-dietrich
Under market watch
- Hans Canon, «Knabe im Matrosenanzug» («Niño con traje de marinero»; Gabriele Oppenheimer → Linz → embajada en Buenos Aires) · no similar lots yet
- Bartolomeo Bettera, naturaleza muerta con instrumentos (Linz → embajada en Buenos Aires) · no lot with evidence; 1 similar lot without evidence
- Christian Mali, carro de heno junto al agua (Linz → embajada en Buenos Aires) · no similar lots yet
- Friedrich Voltz, vacas en el arroyo (Linz → embajada en Buenos Aires) · no similar lots yet
Legal basis
- German arbitration tribunal for cultural property taken under Nazism (since 1-12-2025): the heir initiates proceedings unilaterally against the federal State and the award is binding.
- The Washington Principles and the Terezín Declaration, signed by Germany.
- Freedom-of-information request in Germany (Informationsfreiheitsgesetz) to the Federal Foreign Office for the embassy's inventory.
Next steps
- Write to the Kunstverwaltung des Bundes ([email protected]) about Mü 11096, 11321, 11723 and 9251: current location, trustee administration file and 1962 records.
- Ask the German Federal Foreign Office, under its freedom-of-information law, for the art inventory of the embassy in Buenos Aires since 1962, and ask the Office's Political Archive for the papers of Referat 111 from that year.
- Contact the heirs of Gabriele Oppenheimer (or whoever represented them in 2009) and file the claim for the Canon; if there is no agreement, go to the arbitration tribunal.
- Ask the German State to research the provenance of the Mali and the Voltz.
- If the Argentine foreign ministry cooperates, request a list of the works at the embassy (Villanueva 1055).
Weak points
- It has not been verified that the works are still in Buenos Aires: they may have returned to Germany, been lost or been returned.
- The 1951 letters denying duress will be the State's argument; the 2009 precedent contradicts them.
- For the Mali and the Voltz no persecuted owner has yet been identified.
The victims' Argentine heirs: property in Europe that belongs to them
Argentina officially admitted some 24,000 Jewish refugees between 1933 and 1943, and another 20,000 entered irregularly. Many came from Germany and Austria and left behind real estate, businesses, accounts, insurance policies and art. Their grandchildren in Argentina hold those rights, and many have already gathered the family documents when applying for German or Austrian citizenship. The Freund case shows that it is possible to win, and also that the outcome depends on the country where the property is.
- Who is claiming
- Argentine descendants of persecuted people who emigrated between 1933 and 1945.
- Who holds it
- European museums and States, collectors, banks and insurers.
- Where
- Depending on where the property is: the German arbitration tribunal, the Austrian Kunstrückgabebeirat, the French CIVS, the Dutch Restitutions Committee, the Swiss commission, the British Spoliation Advisory Panel, US courts.
- Cost
- Several routes are free: the CIVS, New York's Holocaust Claims Processing Office, Lost Art, the Arolsen Archives.
The facts
- 1933-1943Argentina officially admits some 24,000 Jews; another 20,000 enter irregularly. (USHMM, «Refuge in Latin America»)
- 1933-1942Julius Freund, a Jewish industrialist from Berlin, transfers to his daughter Gisela (the photographer Gisèle Freund) the works he held in Switzerland. In 1942, by then in Buenos Aires, she has them auctioned in Lucerne and the proceeds are wired to a Buenos Aires bank. (Kunstmuseum Basel, «The Julius Freund case»)
- 2005Germany returns to the Freund heirs four works that Hans Posse had bought at that auction for Hitler's museum in Linz.
- 23-6-2016Austria (Albertina) refuses to return other works from the same collection, because the sale took place outside Nazi territory. (Kunstrückgabebeirat, Freund 2016)
- 2-12-2025The Kunstmuseum Basel compensates the heirs for seven drawings and a lithograph (confidential amount). (Kunstmuseum Basel, press release)
What evidence there is
- The documentation already exists in many families: German (art. 116 of the Basic Law) or Austrian citizenship files, civil records, Reich passports.
- In Germany, the restitution files (Entschädigungsakten) of each federal state record what was taken from each family; in Austria, the 1938 property declarations (Vermögensanmeldungen).
- The limbral.com database holds 28 works whose chain of owners passes through Argentina, 13 of them unresolved.
Records on limbral.com
- Blechen from the Freund collection, returnedhttps://limbral.com/obra/linz:2278
- What can be done today: routes country by countryhttps://limbral.com/acciones?pais=todos
- Aryanizations in the databasehttps://limbral.com/arianizaciones
Legal basis
- Germany: the arbitration tribunal for property in public hands; the BADV for some property; the restitution files.
- France: the CIVS, free and with no deadline; it covers spoliation in France between 1940 and 1944, and works in French public collections despoiled anywhere between 1933 and 1945.
- Austria: the Kunstrückgabebeirat acts on its own initiative; the heir provides evidence to the Commission for Provenance Research. Beware of sales outside Nazi territory («Fluchtgut»), which Austria rejected in the Freund case.
- US: the HEAR Act; and New York's Holocaust Claims Processing Office, free for families from any country.
Next steps
- Together with the DAIA, the Museo del Holocausto de Buenos Aires and Generaciones de la Shoá, reach out to families who hold papers on property left in Europe.
- For each family: request the restitution file from the relevant German state archive (Archivportal-D search engine), consult the Arolsen Archives and, if the family was Austrian, request the 1938 property declaration.
- Cross-check the list of property against Lost Art, Proveana, the Dutch and French databases, the limbral.com database and auction catalogues from 1933 to 1945.
- Ask New York's Holocaust Claims Processing Office for free help with accounts, insurance and art.
- Choose the forum according to where the property is; if it was a sale outside Nazi territory, start with Germany or Switzerland rather than Austria.
- Search the commissions' decisions (Netherlands, France, United Kingdom, Austria) by hand for claimants residing in Argentina: they are usually anonymized.
Weak points
- Many compensation programs have already closed (Swiss accounts, insurance).
- The criteria for sales outside Nazi territory vary by country.
- The chain of inheritance must be proven; it can take months.
The Credit Suisse accounts linked to the Argentine network: preserve the evidence and wait for the names
The investigation by the Credit Suisse ombudsman, Neil Barofsky, found 890 accounts with Nazi links, some seventy of them Argentine and opened after 1945, and found that the bank was both landlord and banker to almost all the staff of the Argentine office in Bern that got Nazis out of Europe (1947-1950). One of the likely account holders would be Theodor Malbranc, the manager in whose house Mengele lived. Today it is more useful for obtaining documents than for recovering money: the 1998-99 settlement and its claims tribunal have closed, and there is not yet an identifiable victim whose funds went into those accounts.
- Who is claiming
- Today, no one with clear standing. Potentially, heirs of victims whose assets ended up in those accounts.
- Who holds it
- UBS, which absorbed Credit Suisse in 2023.
- Where
- US Senate Judiciary Committee (Senator Grassley); case 96-cv-4849 in New York (Judge Korman).
- When
- Final report promised for the end of 2026, in one version with names and another anonymized.
The facts
- 2020The Wiesenthal Center publishes some 12,000 names of Nazi sympathizers who wired money from Buenos Aires to Switzerland between 1938 and 1943.
- 15-2-2023Barofsky report: likely accounts of some 80 members of the Argentine Nazi party or of the Unión Alemana de Gremios, most of them opened after the war. (2023 report)
- 3-2-2026Testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee: 890 accounts; the «Argentine Office for Immigration» in Bern (Marktgasse 49) rented its premises from Credit Suisse, which held accounts for almost all its key staff. (Barofsky testimony)
- 7-4-2026Judge Korman declines to hold that the 1999 settlement shields UBS from new claims: «until an actual case or controversy arises». (Insurance Journal)
- 17-7-2026Grassley sends UBS 62 questions (public since 3-9); UBS denies Barofsky an extension and withholds some 150 documents from the 1990s litigation. (SwissInfo, 3-9-2026)
What evidence there is
- Barofsky's testimony and written answers (2026), and his 2023 report, public at the Senate.
- The 1941 membership roll of the Unión Alemana de Gremios (Congressional Investigative Commission), which makes it possible to put names to account holders described without names, such as Theodor Malbranc.
- The transfers from Fabricaciones Militares to the Bern office (1947-1950), documented by the CEANA and by the Argentine archives that Barofsky cites.
Records on limbral.com
- Hypothesis: Credit Suisse, banker and landlord of the Bern officehttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/credit-suisse-fue-a-la-vez-el-banco-y-el
- Hypothesis: Theodor Malbranchttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/el-gerente-de-banco-anonimo-del-informe-de-credit-suisse
- Hypothesis: the final report that has not come outhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/al-3-de-octubre-de-2026-el-informe-final-sobre
- Hypothesis: the 12,000 transfers to Switzerlandhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/entre-1938-y-1943-unos-12-000-simpatizantes-nazis-giraron
- Hypothesis: the Wehrli bank, now part of UBShttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/los-clientes-y-cuentas-del-banco-johann-wehrli-de-zurich
Legal basis
- Case 96-cv-4849 (New York): the April 2026 ruling leaves the door open to a concrete claim; UBS will argue that the 1999 settlement covers it. The settlement's classes and release clauses must be read.
- The Argentine State has no property title (the Bern office's funds were its own); its role is to contribute archives and request information.
- Third parties can approach the case through the Wiesenthal Center, the Claims Conference or the WJRO, which are already active.
Next steps
- Follow case 1:96-cv-04849 on PACER or CourtListener and read the order of 7-4-2026.
- Write to the Senate Judiciary Committee and to Barofsky asking for publication of the version with names and of the Argentine accounts.
- Offer the Wiesenthal Center the Argentine documents: the 1941 roll, the records found at the Supreme Court in 2025, the Kadgien case.
- File the Law 27.275 requests to Defense, the Air Force and the Foreign Ministry on the Bern office's funds (already drafted in What can be done today).
- Preserve: keep a copy of everything published, in case it is withdrawn.
Weak points
- Without the final report there is no identifiable victim and no amount.
- UBS litigates with ample resources and maintains that everything was covered in 1999.
- Swiss banking secrecy may limit the names even in the final report.
What we would not take on, and why
Widely circulated accounts that today have no documentary basis for a claim. For each, we explain what they assert, what evidence they offer, what contradicts them and what it would take to change the conclusion.
Eva Perón's Swiss accounts (1947 tour)
What they assert
That during her stay in Switzerland (4 to 9 August 1947), on the tour paid for and organized by Alberto Dodero, Eva Perón opened accounts or placed Nazi funds or bribes in safe-deposit boxes, and that Juan Duarte traveled in 1952 to claim them. The story begins with Silvano Santander («Técnica de una traición», 1953) and is followed by Georg Hodel (1999), Jorge Camarasa (1997), Paul Manning (1981) and Marcelo García (2017, who claims Evita returned a treasure to Bormann).
What evidence they offer
No banking evidence at all: no bank, no account number, no statement, no safe-deposit contract. The «document» reproduced by Manning (signed by one Egidio Esparza) has no verifiable provenance and places it in a «Deutsche Bank of Buenos Aires». The sources cite one another in a chain going back to Santander, who used material from Heinrich Jürges, a known forger. Hodel, for example, cites gold accounts of the Swiss National Bank and of a diplomat, none of them Eva's.
What contradicts it
The ambassador in Bern, Benito Llambí: «Eva Perón no pisó un banco» («Eva Perón never set foot in a bank»). The Revolución Libertadora, which had every interest in finding something, listed Perón's assets and abroad found only shares in a Uruguayan company; it put on record that it could not investigate outside the country. The Eizenstat report (1998) concluded that Argentina was not a haven for looted gold or assets. The list of dormant accounts published in 2001 contains no Duarte or Perón (although it only includes accounts of probable victims). Jorge Antonio, Perón's envoy, said that after twenty years of searching they found only a few gold coins in a box belonging to Juan Duarte.
What it would take
A Swiss bank record (account opening, safe-deposit box or signing authority in the name of Duarte, Perón, Ibarguren or a proxy). Ruling it out entirely is impossible because of banking secrecy and because retention periods have expired, but today it has no basis.
What remains to be done
Check the Swiss Banking Ombudsman's public list of dormant assets for «Duarte», «Perón» and «Ibarguren» (a central search requires being an heir). Ask the Swiss Federal Archives for the file on the 1947 visit (according to Goñi, it records that Colonel Jeckeln, the same man who received funds from Fabricaciones Militares in Bern, attended the reception in Lucerne). Ask the Archivo General de la Nación for the files of the Junta de Recuperación Patrimonial, to see whether any letter rogatory was sent abroad.
Records on limbral.com
- Hypothesis: the Swiss accounts from the 1947 tour (disputed)https://limbral.com/hipotesis/durante-la-gira-de-1947-pagada-y-organizada-por-alberto
- Hypothesis: Dodero financed the tourhttps://limbral.com/hipotesis/dodero-financio-total-o-parcialmente-la-gira-europea-de-eva
Sources
- Santander, «Técnica de una traición» (1953)
- Hodel, «Evita, the Swiss and the Nazis» (1999)
- JTA, 26-6-1997
- Infobae 2017, Llambí
- Manning, «Martin Bormann: Nazi in Exile» (1981)
- «Libro Negro de la Segunda Tiranía» (1958)
- Eizenstat report, Argentina (1998)
- 2001 list of dormant accounts (D)
- Swiss Banking Ombudsman, search for assets
Nazi funds in Alberto Dodero's companies
What they assert
That Nazi or Axis funds, gold or assets passed through the Dodero shipping line, which brought immigrants (and some fugitives) after the war and paid for Eva Perón's tour.
What evidence they offer
No source documents it: Santander and Manning, who built the «Nazi treasure» story, do not even mention Dodero. The only documented link to capital on the Axis side is a different one: according to a 1949 CIA report, Fritz Mandl held 120,000 non-voting shares in the Dodero group. But Mandl, an Austrian arms manufacturer, had taken his own fortune out of the Reich: it is not the regime's money.
What contradicts it
The CIA report (25-5-1949) explains the sale of the shipping line to the State by Dodero's imminent bankruptcy (a promised subsidy that was never paid, the loss of cargo) and does not mention German funds. The CEANA records some collaborators on the group's ships, but Mengele and Eichmann arrived on ships that were not Dodero's.
What it would take
The shipping line's books: shareholders, freight, passages paid by third parties. If they exist, they are in the ELMA collection at the Archivo General de la Nación and at the Inspección General de Justicia.
What remains to be done
Ask the AGN for the ELMA collection and the Inspección General de Justicia for the corporate files of the Dodero group (1945-1952); request from the US National Archives the Safehaven files of the embassy in Buenos Aires and the Allied blacklist, to see whether any Dodero company appeared on it; consult the Uruguayan registry of the Compañía de Navegación Dodero, which Dodero kept.
Records on limbral.com
- Alberto Doderohttps://limbral.com/persona/alberto-dodero
- Hypothesis: Axis funds and Dodero (open, no source)https://limbral.com/hipotesis/fondos-oro-o-activos-nazis-o-del-eje-pasaron-por
- Hypothesis: the profits from postwar transport (supported)https://limbral.com/hipotesis/dodero-obtuvo-grandes-ganancias-del-trafico-humano-de-posguerra-gracias
- Hypothesis: Mengele and Eichmann on Dodero ships (refuted)https://limbral.com/hipotesis/mengele-y-eichmann-viajaron-a-la-argentina-en-barcos-de
«Bormann's treasure», the submarines and the leaders hidden in Patagonia
What they assert
That Martin Bormann (and, for some, Hitler) escaped to South America with a treasure; that German submarines landed gold and artworks on the Patagonian coast in 1945 («Operation Tierra del Fuego»); and that Bormann lived in Argentina, Brazil or Paraguay. This is maintained by Santander (1953), Ladislas Farago («Aftermath», 1974), Paul Manning (1981) and, for Hitler, Dunstan and Williams («Grey Wolf», 2011).
What evidence they offer
Sightings, police bulletins of uncertain origin (the reports «DAE 356/48» and «481/50» cited by Manning) and documents that Farago presented as authentic. Ronald Newton described this field as full of deceptions and forgeries; Goñi documented that the papers sold to Farago were fakes.
What contradicts it
U-530 reached Mar del Plata on 10-7-1945 and its commander stated that it never carried passengers or treasure; U-977 arrived on 17-8-1945 and the US Navy reports record no landings. The Eizenstat report (1998) concluded that the interrogations did not confirm that Nazi leaders had hidden gold or assets in Argentina. Bormann's remains were found in Berlin in 1972 and DNA testing in 1998 confirmed them: he died in May 1945.
What it would take
To take submarine-borne gold seriously, at least one bar with Reichsbank markings identified in Argentina would be needed: none is on record. As for Bormann, the question is settled by DNA.
What remains to be done
Only to close the subject: ask the Federal Police, under Law 27.275, for the reports «DAE 356/48» and «481/50», to find out whether they exist and what they say; and ask the Archivo General de la Armada for the 1945 inquiry file on U-530 and U-977. There is nothing to claim.
Records on limbral.com
- Martin Bormannhttps://limbral.com/persona/martin-bormann
- Hypothesis: Hitler or Bormann in Argentina (refuted)https://limbral.com/hipotesis/hitler-o-martin-bormann-escaparon-a-la-argentina-y-se
- Hypothesis: Nazi leaders' fortunes in Argentina (refuted)https://limbral.com/hipotesis/los-jerarcas-nazis-goring-bormann-y-otros-escondieron-grandes-fortunas
This dossier is a journalistic and historical investigation, not legal advice. Statements about living people are limited to what has been published in court cases and the press; relatives of those involved are not named. Every piece of data has its source; where the information is incomplete or contradictory, that is stated. Corrections and contributions: through the anonymous form on each record at limbral.com.
More proposals, country by country, in What can be done today (login required).