Laws and deadlines
International framework
1943Inter-Allied Declaration against Acts of Dispossession (London Declaration)Declaration · non-binding
Seventeen Allied governments and the French National Committee warned that they reserved the right to declare invalid transfers of property in territories under enemy occupation or control. The warning covered open looting as well as transactions apparently legal in form, 'even when they purport to be voluntarily effected'. It underpins the post-war restitution laws, such as the French ordinance of 1945.
1970UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural PropertyTreaty
It obliges States Parties to prohibit the import of property stolen from museums or monuments of another State Party and, at the request of the State of origin, to recover and return it, paying just compensation to an innocent purchaser. Claims run State to State through diplomatic channels, not from individuals. It rarely helps with Nazi looting because it is not retroactive: art. 7(b) only covers property imported after the Convention entered into force for both States.
Deadlines: It sets no limitation period. In force since 24-4-1972, prospectively only.
1995UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural ObjectsTreaty
It lets the owner of a stolen cultural object claim its return directly before the courts of another State Party, and requires return even by a good-faith possessor, who may receive compensation. It generally does not reach Nazi-era looting either: art. 10 limits the stolen-objects chapter to thefts after its entry into force in the States concerned, while stating that it does not legitimise earlier illegal transactions.
Deadlines: Art. 3: three years from when the claimant knew the object's location and possessor, and in any case fifty years from the theft. For objects from monuments, archaeological sites or public collections only the three-year limit applies, unless the State declares a limit of 75 years or longer.
1998Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated ArtDeclaration · non-binding
Eleven principles endorsed by 44 governments at the close of the Washington Conference on Holocaust-Era Assets. They call for identifying confiscated, unrestituted art, opening archives, publicising works to find owners or heirs, accepting unavoidable provenance gaps and reaching a 'just and fair solution' promptly. They also encourage alternative dispute resolution. They are non-binding: each country acts within its own legal system.
Deadlines: Sets no deadlines.
- 05-03-2024 · Supplemented by the Best Practices (see separate entry). ↗
1999Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly Resolution 1205 (1999) on looted Jewish cultural propertyDeclaration · non-binding
Adopted by the Standing Committee on behalf of the Assembly. It urges States to change their laws to ease return: extend or remove statutory limitation periods, lift restrictions on alienating items from public collections, annul titles acquired after dispossession and protect those who return items. It sets no figures and does not bind States.
Deadlines: Recommends extending or removing limitation periods; sets none of its own.
2000Vilnius International Forum Declaration on Holocaust-Era Looted Cultural AssetsDeclaration · non-binding
Agreed by 38 governments. It calls for every reasonable effort to return looted cultural assets to their owners or heirs, implementation of the Washington Principles and Resolution 1205, information sharing and open archives. Each government was to keep a central point of inquiry.
Deadlines: Sets no deadlines.
2009Terezin Declaration on Holocaust Era Assets and Related IssuesDeclaration · non-binding
Agreed by 46 governments at the close of the Prague conference. For art, it asks that claims be resolved expeditiously and on the facts and merits of each case, reviewing rules that hinder restitution. For real property, it calls for restitution of communal and religious property and for handling private claims in a fair, expeditious, simple and cost-free way for the claimant. It declares itself legally non-binding.
Deadlines: Sets no deadlines and does not mention limitation periods.
2014Directive 2014/60/EU on the return of cultural objects unlawfully removed from the territory of a Member StateGuideline
It recasts Directive 93/7/EEC and requires EU (and EEA) States to cooperate and return cultural objects classified as national treasures that were unlawfully removed from another Member State. The requesting State, not the individual, brings the action, and a possessor who exercised due care may be compensated. It does not cover 1933-1945 looting: it only applies to unlawful removals on or after 1-1-1993.
Deadlines: Return proceedings must be brought within three years after the requesting State's central authority became aware of the object's location and possessor. Applicable from 19-12-2015.
2024Best Practices for the Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated ArtGuideline · non-binding
They refine the 1998 Principles on their 25th anniversary. They define confiscated art to include forced sales and sales under duress between 1933 and 1945, make restitution the primary solution, ask current possessors not to seek repayment of the purchase price and any compensation to be tax-exempt. They also reach private collectors and dealers. Morally important but legally non-binding.
Deadlines: They ask States to consider lifting barriers such as statutes of limitation, usucapion, good-faith acquisition and rules barring deaccession from public collections.
Country by country
Argentina
2025Argentina's endorsement of the Best Practices for the Washington PrinciplesDeclaration · non-binding
Argentina became the first Latin American country to endorse the 2024 Best Practices, which complement the Washington Principles (1998) and the Terezin Declaration (2009), both of which it had also endorsed. They are non-binding. No specific Argentine law on restitution of Nazi-looted property was found: claims go through the ordinary courts.
Deadlines: Sets no deadlines.
Austria
1998Austrian Art Restitution Act (KRG) (BGBl. I No. 181/1998)Law
It authorises, but does not oblige, the federal State to return free of charge to original owners or their heirs objects in its collections acquired through Nazi persecution. The Commission for Provenance Research investigates ex officio, the Art Restitution Advisory Board recommends and the minister decides; claimants have no enforceable right. If no heirs are found, the object goes to the National Fund to benefit victims. It covers only federal property: Länder and municipalities have their own rules.
Deadlines: No filing deadline: the procedure is ex officio.
- 2009 · Amendment (BGBl. I No. 117/2009): extends the period to 1933-1945 and the territory to the whole Reich, and covers any object of historical or cultural significance regardless of value. ↗
- 2020 · The Leopold Museum, a privately run, state-funded foundation, voluntarily submits to the Act's regime. ↗
- 2023 · Latest amendment to the consolidated text, according to the Commission for Provenance Research. ↗
2001General Settlement Fund Law for Victims of National Socialism (Entschädigungsfondsgesetz, BGBl. I No. 12/2001)Law · no longer in force
It stemmed from the 2001 Washington Agreement and created a USD 210 million fund for voluntary payments for property losses suffered in Austria between 1938 and 1945. It included an arbitration panel for in rem restitution of real estate and Jewish communal property publicly owned on 17-1-2001. It paid about USD 215 million to some 25,000 people.
Deadlines: Applications were due by 28-5-2003; all deadlines have expired. The fund was dissolved on 26-4-2022.
Belgium
2001Act of 20 December 2001 on compensation for the assets of the Belgian Jewish community plundered, surrendered or abandoned during the 1940-1945 warLaw · no longer in force
It created a Compensation Commission with about EUR 110.6 million from the State, banks and insurers to compensate people who, living in Belgium between 10-5-1940 and 8-5-1945, lost assets through the occupier's anti-Jewish measures and had not been compensated. No citizenship was required. It processed 5,220 claims totalling EUR 35.2 million; the balance went in 2008 to the Belgian Judaism Foundation.
Deadlines: Claims by 9-9-2003; expired. The commission completed its review on 31-12-2007.
2026Flemish draft decree on restitution of Nazi-looted art (Restitutiedecreet naziroofkunst)Decree · non-binding · no longer in force
A draft, not law in force. The Flemish government approved in principle a draft decree creating a permanent commission for requests to return cultural property of the Flemish Community involuntarily lost because of the Nazi regime (1933-1945), setting its mandate, composition, procedure and assessment framework. After opinions from SARC and VTC, the text went to the Council of State.
Deadlines: Pending adoption; no commission or deadlines yet.
- 04-2026 · First in-principle approval of the draft by the Flemish government. ↗
Czechia
2000Act No. 212/2000 Coll. on the mitigation of certain property injustices caused by the HolocaustLaw
Its § 3 provides that artworks taken from individuals between 29-9-1938 and 4-5-1945 through acts annulled by presidential decree 5/1945 or Act 128/1946, and now owned by the State, are transferred free of charge to the original owner or, if deceased, to the spouse or descendants. Transfer is made on request to whoever manages the item; disputes go to the courts. It also transfers communal property to the Federation of Jewish Communities and the Jewish Museum in Prague.
Deadlines: There is currently no deadline to request artworks: the original deadline (31-12-2002) was extended to 31-12-2006 and then abolished. Agricultural real estate had a deadline of 30-6-2001 (amendment to Act 243/1992).
France
1945Ordinance No. 45-770 of 21 April 1945 on the nullity of acts of spoliationDecree
It applies the London Declaration in France: acts of disposal by the occupier or the Vichy regime from 16-6-1940 against victims' property are null as of right at the request of the dispossessed owner or heirs. Successive buyers are deemed bad-faith possessors (art. 4) and 'consensual' sales by persecuted persons are presumed made under duress (art. 11). It remains in force and courts apply it today, also to MNR works.
Deadlines: Art. 21 set six months from the legal date of cessation of hostilities to seek nullity, with the judge able to lift the bar for anyone who proves they could not act. For movables, the recovery period was one year from that date (art. 10). Even so, the Court of Cassation has applied it to present-day claims (see the 2025 Dorville ruling).
1999Decree No. 99-778 of 10 September 1999 creating the CIVS, and its replacement by Decree No. 2024-11Decree · non-binding
Following the Mattéoli Mission's recommendation, it created an administrative commission attached to the Prime Minister that examines individual requests and recommends restitution or compensation for spoliation caused by antisemitic legislation in France during the occupation (1940-1944). Its recommendations are not binding: the Prime Minister or the public owner of the object decides. It is free and requires no lawyer.
Deadlines: Neither the CIVS nor its official history states a filing deadline. For cultural property under the 2023 law, the commission has 18 months to give its opinion (extendable once by 18); the public owner has four months to decide (silence means refusal) and eight months to return.
- 2018 · Referral routes to the CIVS are extended to cultural property looted in France between 1940 and 1944. ↗
- 05-01-2024 · Decree No. 2024-11: new name (Commission for the restitution of property and compensation of victims of antisemitic spoliation) and jurisdiction over cultural property looted 1933-1945 in any Nazi-dominated country if held in French public collections. In force from 1-2-2024. ↗
2022Law No. 2022-218 of 21 February 2022 on the restitution or handover of certain cultural objects to the rightful heirs of owners who were victims of antisemitic persecutionLaw
A special law for 15 works in public collections: Klimt's 'Rosebushes under the Trees' (Musée d'Orsay), Chagall's 'The Father' (Centre Pompidou), Utrillo's 'Carrefour à Sannois' and 12 works bought by the national museums at the 1942 Dorville auction. A law was needed because French public-domain property is inalienable. It was the direct precursor of the 2023 framework law.
2023Law No. 2023-650 of 22 July 2023 on the restitution of cultural property looted in the context of the antisemitic persecutions of 1933 to 1945Law
Framework law allowing public bodies to remove from their collections, without a law per case, cultural property looted through antisemitic persecution between 1933 and 1945 in any Nazi-dominated territory. It requires the CIVS's prior opinion and covers private museums holding the 'musée de France' label. It does not cover the MNR holdings, which the State does not own, or non-antisemitic persecution. With the rightful owner's consent another remedy can be agreed.
Deadlines: No deadline to apply. Procedural time limits (18 + 18 months for the CIVS, four months to decide, eight to return) are in Decree 2024-11.
- 25-06-2025 · First return under this law: a National Library book handed to August Liebmann Mayer's daughter. ↗
2025French Court of Cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, 26-11-2025, No. 24-11.376 (Dorville auction)Key ruling
Armand Dorville's heirs sought to annul the auction of his collection in Nice (June 1942), held under a provisional 'Aryanisation' administrator. The Court quashed the 2023 appeal ruling and held that a sale can fall under art. 1 of the 1945 ordinance even if the owner or heirs initiated it: where a provisional administrator was appointed, the sale is presumed to result from that measure, and whoever denies it must prove it. It remanded the case to the Paris Court of Appeal.
Germany
1947US Military Government Law No. 59 'Restitution of Identifiable Property' and equivalent rules in the other zonesLaw · no longer in force
It applied in the US zone of Germany (including Bremen, not Berlin) to property taken between 30-1-1933 and 8-5-1945 for reasons of race, religion, nationality, ideology or political opposition. Any transfer by a persecuted person from 15-9-1935 onward was presumed to have been made under duress, and the acquirer had to return it and account for profits. The French zone had its Ordinance No. 120 and the British zone its own law; Berlin had order BK/O (49) 180 (see separate entry).
Deadlines: Petitions were due 31-12-1948 (art. 56): valid if postmarked by that date and received by the Central Filing Agency by 31-3-1949 (Regulation No. 5 of 5-1-1949). Holders had to report suspect property by 15-5-1948. No new claims can be filed under it today.
1949Allied Kommandatura Berlin Order BK/O (49) 180 (restitution in Berlin)Decree · no longer in force
The US, Britain and France issued it for West Berlin, where Law 59 did not apply. It organised restitution of persecutees' property through special agencies and chambers, as in the US zone. Its presumption of persecution-related loss lives on: Germany's 1990 Property Act applies it to claims concerning former East German territory.
Deadlines: Its post-war filing deadlines have expired.
1953Federal Compensation Act (BEG) for victims of National Socialist persecutionLaw
It compensates people persecuted for political opposition or on grounds of race, religion or ideology who suffered harm to life, body, health, liberty, property, assets or career. It does not return objects: it pays compensation and pensions. The current version dates from 1956, retroactive to 1-10-1953.
Deadlines: Applications by 1-4-1958 (§ 189). The 1965 Final Act (BEG-Schlussgesetz, art. VIII) closed the system: no new claims after 31-12-1969, save narrow exceptions (medical costs for recognised injuries, survivors' pensions).
1957Federal Restitution Act (BRüG)Law
It governs restitution money debts of the German Reich and equivalent bodies (Prussia, the NSDAP and its organisations, the Reichsbahn, the Reichspost, among others) for property taken from persecutees that could no longer be returned. It complemented the Allied restitution laws. Its files are kept today by the BADV, which also reclaims BRüG payments if a work is later returned.
Deadlines: Claims had to reach the competent central filing office by 1-4-1959 (§§ 27-29). Some filings lapsed on 8-10-1965, and descriptions of individual items were due by 5-9-1970 (§ 30b). No new claims are accepted today.
- 29-06-2015 · Latest amendment to the consolidated text (art. 21, Act of 29-6-2015). ↗
1990Property Act (VermG) on unresolved property issuesLaw
It governs the return of property expropriated in the former GDR. Under § 1(6) it also applies to people persecuted between 30-1-1933 and 8-5-1945 who lost property through forced sales, expropriation or otherwise, and it presumes persecution-related loss under the 1949 Allied Berlin order. Where there are no heirs or none claimed, the Claims Conference acts as successor for Jewish property.
Deadlines: Preclusive deadline (§ 30a): claims by 31-12-1992; for movable property, by 30-6-1993. Both have expired.
1999Joint Declaration of the Federal Government, the Länder and the municipal associations on finding and returning cultural property seized as a result of Nazi persecution (Gemeinsame Erklärung)Declaration · non-binding
It is how Germany committed to implement the Washington Principles. Public museums, archives and libraries must search their collections and, after examining each case, return items identified as looted to the rightful owners or heirs, or negotiate another remedy. It invites private institutions to join. It is a self-commitment without legal force, though with high moral and political weight.
Deadlines: Sets no deadlines.
2003Advisory Commission on Nazi-Looted Cultural Property (Beratende Kommission)Guideline · non-binding · no longer in force
Alternative dispute-resolution mechanism set up in 2003 by agreement between the Federation, the Länder and the municipal associations. It issued recommendations in disputes between institutions holding cultural property and claimants. It ceased work on 30-11-2025; its website keeps the 2003-2025 recommendations.
Deadlines: Closed since 30-11-2025: no longer takes cases.
- 30-11-2025 · Closure; succeeded by the Arbitration for Nazi-Looted Cultural Property from 1-12-2025. ↗
2024Federal Government bill to facilitate restitution of Nazi-looted art (Drucksache 20/13258)Law · non-binding · no longer in force
A bill, not a law. It proposed a right to information against sellers and dealers of property lost through persecution between 1933 and 1945, and a narrower limitation defence: only a good-faith acquirer could refuse return, even after the limitation period. It also provided for a special venue in Frankfurt am Main. It left adverse possession untouched, which experts at the hearing criticised as making it largely ineffective.
Deadlines: Not in force: no evidence was found that it was passed. In February 2026 Culture Minister Wolfram Weimer announced that draft bills for a restitution law are being prepared.
- 14-02-2026 · Weimer announces a restitution law for this legislative term, also covering Nazi-era property; preliminary talks and drafts under way, no cabinet approval. ↗
2025Administrative Agreement on Arbitration for Nazi-Looted Cultural Property (Schiedsgerichtsbarkeit NS-Raubgut)Regulation
The agreement between the Federation, the Länder and the municipal associations creates five-member arbitral tribunals (three lawyers and two with art-history or history qualifications) that replace the Advisory Commission. They decide bindingly under the assessment framework (Bewertungsrahmen). A claimant can start proceedings alone if the institution has issued a 'standing offer' or agrees to the case; a preliminary procedure with the institution comes first.
Deadlines: Operating since 1-12-2025. Neither the website nor its FAQ states a filing deadline.
2025Bewertungsrahmen: assessment framework for cultural property seized through Nazi persecution (Annex 2 to the arbitration agreement)Guideline
It sets the criteria that arbitral tribunals and institutions must apply. It covers losses between 30-1-1933 and 8-5-1945 due to racial, political, religious or ideological persecution or sexual orientation, where the object is now in Germany. It eases proof ('high probability' suffices; circumstantial evidence and affidavits are admitted) and presumes the collective persecution of Jews, Sinti and Roma. It also presumes their sales were persecution-related; after 15-9-1935 that presumption yields only in narrow cases, and Jewish sellers are presumed not to have freely disposed of the price after 14-5-1938.
Deadlines: Sets no filing deadline.
Hungary
1991Hungarian partial compensation Acts XXV of 1991 and XXIV of 1992Law · no longer in force
They gave partial compensation, not return, through vouchers of limited transferability, capped at about HUF 5 million (about USD 21,000). The 1992 Act extended coverage to takings based on rules adopted between 1-5-1939 and 8-6-1949, which included wartime dispossession of Jews. They excluded bank accounts, securities, insurance and most art claims, and limited heirs to spouses and direct descendants.
Deadlines: Claim filing closed in 1994.
- 12-03-1993 · The Constitutional Court (decisions 15/1993 and 16/1993) upholds partial compensation. ↗
1997Act X of 1997 implementing art. 27(2) of the Paris Peace Treaty (Jewish Heritage of Hungary Public Endowment, MAZSÖK)Law
The 1947 Peace Treaty obliged Hungary to use heirless Jewish property to assist the communities; in 1993 the Constitutional Court found this had not been done. This Act created MAZSÖK, with a HUF 4 billion bond and some heirless real estate and artworks, to pay annuities to survivors and support Jewish heritage. It is not a claims route for individual heirs.
Deadlines: Not an individual claims regime.
Israel
2006Holocaust Victims' Assets Law (Restitution to Heirs and Endowment for Commemoration and Education), 5766-2006Law
It created the Company for Location and Restitution of Holocaust Victims' Assets (Hashava), a State-owned non-profit, to find victims' assets in Israel (land, accounts, shares) and their heirs. Unclaimed assets went to aid for needy survivors, education and commemoration. By 2017 it had located assets worth NIS 2.1 billion and identified heirs for NIS 718 million.
Deadlines: The company closed on 31-12-2017. What it had not distributed passed to the Administrator General and a non-profit to complete its work.
- 31-12-2017 · Hashava closes, brought forward by an amendment from the original 2021 end date. ↗
Italy
1944Royal Decree-Law No. 26 of 20 January 1944 on restoring the property rights of citizens deemed of 'Jewish race'Decree · no longer in force
It repealed the Fascist racial laws and regulated the return of property confiscated under the 1939 rule, managed by EGELI, the same body that had administered it. A later 1944 decree (No. 249) declared the Italian Social Republic's confiscations null. According to the Anselmi Commission report (2001), private property was generally returned, though owners were charged wartime administration costs.
Deadlines: Art. 3 allowed one year from the conclusion of peace (1947 Peace Treaty) to request return; expired.
1997Law No. 233 of 1997 on heirless property of persecuted Jewish citizensLaw
It assigns to the Union of Italian Jewish Communities property taken from Jews through racial persecution that could not be returned because owners and heirs were missing or untraceable, and that the State still holds. It also allocated ITL 3 billion to the community. Italy has no specific law or commission for restitution of looted art.
Deadlines: Sets no deadlines for individual claims.
Lithuania
2011Law on Good Will Compensation for the Immovable Property of Jewish Religious Communities (No. XI-1470)Law
It compensates, without in-kind return, Jewish communal property with LTL 128 million (about EUR 36-37 million) paid over ten years from 2013, roughly 30 % of the official value of 152 properties. It extinguishes future communal claims. Funds go to the Good Will Foundation for religious, cultural and social purposes and one-off payments to Jews who lived in Lithuania during the war.
Deadlines: One-off symbolic payment of 2012: by 30-6-2013. Compensation for private real estate added in 2022: by 31-12-2023. Both expired.
- 01-12-2011 · Entry into force. ↗
- 20-12-2022 · The Seimas expands the law: payments to private claimants previously excluded by citizenship rules and extended annual payments to the foundation for heirless property (nearly USD 40 million in total). ↗
- 14-07-2025 · The foundation completes payment of EUR 7.5 million (about EUR 20,000 per approved property) to survivors and certain heirs. ↗
Netherlands
2020'Striving for Justice' report by the restitution policy evaluation committee (Kohnstamm committee)Guideline · non-binding
The Council for Culture committee chaired by Jacob Kohnstamm found Dutch policy had become formalistic and insensitive. It recommended ending the weighing of the claimant's interest against the museum's, resuming systematic provenance research (dormant since 2007), writing a clear assessment framework based on the Washington Principles into the committee's decree, and creating a helpdesk that proactively contacts owners and heirs.
2021Decree Establishing the Restitutions Committee and its assessment framework (Instellingsbesluit Restitutiecommissie)Decree
It replaced the decree of the advisory committee created in 2001 and implemented the Kohnstamm report: it dropped the balancing of interests and set three criteria: original ownership, involuntary loss of possession and, only for non-State collections, good-faith acquisition by the current holder. For the national collection the committee advises the minister to return unconditionally if the criteria are met; for other collections it issues a binding opinion.
Deadlines: No filing deadline. The procedure can take over two years. In force since 22-4-2021, with transitional rules for earlier cases.
Norway
1998White Paper No. 82 (1997-98) to the Storting on the historical and moral settlement for the economic liquidation of the Jewish minority, and the 1999 settlementDecree · no longer in force
Based on the Reisel/Bruland minority report, the government acknowledged that post-war restitution had not made good the dispossession of Norwegian Jews and proposed a comprehensive settlement, which the Storting approved in March 1999. It allocated NOK 250 million to the Jewish community (in Norway and abroad) and one-off individual payments of NOK 200,000 to those who suffered anti-Jewish measures; if deceased, spouses and direct heirs could receive them. It covered private, communal and heirless property.
Deadlines: Individual payments: applications by 1-11-1999; expired. By 11-8-2000, 987 applications had been received and 40 rejected.
- 03-1999 · The Storting approves the settlement proposed in the White Paper. ↗
Poland
2021Act of 11 August 2021 amending the Code of Administrative Procedure (Dz.U. 2021 item 1491)Law
It bars declaring an administrative decision null once ten years have passed since its notification, and bars opening proceedings once thirty years have passed. Nullity proceedings opened more than thirty years after the decision and not yet resolved were discontinued by operation of law. In practice, it closed the administrative route that owners and heirs, including heirs of Holocaust victims, used to annul post-war expropriation decisions.
Deadlines: Thirty years from notification of the decision to bring a nullity request (art. 158 § 3). Published 16-8-2021; in force 16-9-2021.
Switzerland
2023Ordinance on the Independent Commission for Historically Burdened Cultural HeritageRegulation · non-binding
The Federal Council adopted it to implement motion Pult 21.4403, which called for an independent commission to recommend 'just and fair solutions' for cultural property lost through Nazi persecution, under the Washington and Terezin principles. The commission advises the government on Nazi-era and colonial-context property and issues non-binding recommendations.
Deadlines: No filing deadline stated.
2025Amendment to the Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural Property (CPTA), art. 18a: Commission for Historically Burdened Cultural HeritageLaw · non-binding
It gives the commission a statutory basis. Besides advising the government, it may issue non-binding recommendations at the parties' request and, for Nazi-related property in publicly funded museums or collections, at the request of an individual alone or of the museum. It only admits requests where the ownership claim is credible and reasonable efforts at settlement and provenance research have been made.
Deadlines: The Act sets no filing deadline. The Federal Council sets the entry into force.
United Kingdom
2009Holocaust (Return of Cultural Objects) Act 2009Law
It lets certain national museums in England and Scotland, which were legally barred from deaccessioning, transfer objects lost between 1933 and 1945. Two conditions apply: a recommendation by the Spoliation Advisory Panel and the Secretary of State's approval. It does not compel return and does not reach private collectors.
Deadlines: The original version expired after ten years: museums could use these powers only until November 2019 (s. 4(7)). The 2019 amendment removed the sunset: the Act now applies indefinitely.
United States
1976Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA), expropriation exception — 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(3)Law
A foreign State has no immunity before US courts when 'rights in property taken in violation of international law are in issue' and the property, or property exchanged for it, has a commercial nexus with the US. It is the route for suing foreign State museums or foundations. A 2016 amendment (§ 1605(h)) shielded exhibition loans, except for works taken by Germany or its allies between 30-1-1933 and 8-5-1945.
Deadlines: No limitation period of its own; timing depends on the HEAR Act and applicable law.
- 16-12-2016 · § 1605(h) added (immunity for exhibition loans, with a Nazi-era exception). ↗
- 03-02-2021 · In Germany v. Philipp the Supreme Court requires a violation of the international law of expropriation: a State's taking of its own nationals' property does not qualify. ↗
- 13-04-2026 · The HEAR Act of 2025 provides that any claim covered by the HEAR Act is deemed an action in which rights in violation of international law are in issue for this exception, regardless of the victim's nationality. ↗
1998Holocaust Victims Redress Act (Public Law 105-158)Law
It authorised funds for survivors for heirless assets seized by the US during the war, and asked countries with claims on the Tripartite Commission gold to donate it to survivors. Its Title II states the sense of Congress that all governments should make good-faith efforts to return art confiscated under Nazi rule where there is reasonable proof of ownership. That part is declaratory: it creates no cause of action.
Deadlines: Budget authorisations for fiscal years 1998-2000; sets no claim deadlines.
2016Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016 (HEAR Act, Public Law 114-308)Law
Federal law that replaces State and federal limitation periods for suits over art or other property lost to Nazi persecution between 1933 and 1945. Suit may be brought up to six years after the claimant's actual discovery of the work's identity and location and of a possessory interest. It creates no new cause of action: it applies to actions that already exist under federal or State law.
Deadlines: Six years from actual discovery. The original text only covered suits filed by 31-12-2026, and the Act was to cease to have effect on 1-1-2027 except for pending cases. It excluded claims already time-barred where the claimant knew the facts on or after 1-1-1999 and let six years pass.
- 13-04-2026 · The HEAR Act of 2025 strikes the 1-1-2027 sunset clause and the 31-12-2026 filing cut-off. ↗
2018Justice for Uncompensated Survivors Today (JUST) Act of 2017 (Public Law 115-171)Law
It requires the State Department to report to Congress on the laws and policies of Terezin participants it deems of particular concern regarding return of or compensation for Holocaust-era assets, including communal and heirless property. It covers confiscations, forced sales and sales under duress during the Holocaust and the Communist period. It gives claimants no rights: it is a reporting law.
Deadlines: The report was due within 18 months of enactment.
2021Federal Republic of Germany v. Philipp, 592 U.S. 169 (2021) — Guelph TreasureKey ruling
Heirs of German Jewish art dealers sued Germany and the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation over the 1935 forced sale of the Guelph Treasure. The Supreme Court unanimously held that the FSIA expropriation exception refers to the international law of expropriation, which includes the 'domestic takings rule': what a State takes from its own nationals does not violate that law. This closed the route for victims who were nationals of the State that despoiled them.
- 13-04-2026 · The HEAR Act of 2025 overrides this rule for claims covered by the HEAR Act, 'without regard to the nationality or citizenship of the alleged victim', expressly citing Philipp. ↗
2024California AB 2867 (2024) on recovery of art lost through persecutionLaw
A response to the Ninth Circuit's January 2024 Cassirer ruling, which applied Spanish law and left the Pissarro with the Thyssen Museum. It provides that California substantive law applies in actions by California residents or their heirs over personal property, including HEAR Act claims, also in pending cases. It also creates a cause of action to recover art lost through political persecution, in which good faith, acquisitive prescription and laches are unavailable.
Deadlines: Six years from the plaintiff's actual discovery of the work's whereabouts and of facts indicating a possessory interest.
- 17-11-2025 · California's Attorney General moves to intervene in Cassirer to defend the law; the Supreme Court had vacated the Ninth Circuit ruling and remanded for consideration of AB 2867. ↗
2026Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2025 (S. 1884)Law
It amends the 2016 HEAR Act so that claims are decided on the merits. It bars, for timely claims, defences based on the passage of time (laches, adverse possession, acquisitive prescription, usucapion) and discretionary non-merits dismissals (act of state, international comity, forum non conveniens, prudential exhaustion). It overrides Philipp's domestic-takings rule for the immunity exception and allows nationwide service of process.
Deadlines: Keeps the six years from actual discovery and removes the 2026/2027 expiry, with no new end date. It applies to cases pending at enactment (including those still appealable) and to those filed afterwards.
See also: where to get help · what works · how to claim in each country