Limbral
Menú
EN

Museos

National Gallery of Art

Washington · datos del museo: github.com/NationalGalleryOfArt/opendata (CC0) · revisado el 2026-11-15

Cómo leer esta página

El análisis automático leyó la procedencia que publica National Gallery of Art de cada pintura y marcó 711 con alguna pista: un marchante o un organismo del saqueo nazi, un dueño despojado, una confiscación, un hueco entre 1933 y 1945, un número de inventario del saqueo o una coincidencia con una obra buscada de nuestra base.

Una pista no quiere decir que la obra sea robada. Las fuertes y las medias las leímos a mano, una por una, y las clasificamos en cuatro grupos. Cada obra dice por qué, con la frase de la procedencia que importa y sus fuentes. Las pistas débiles (casi siempre sólo un hueco en la cadena) quedan listadas al final, sin revisar todavía.

La procedencia que publica un museo es una afirmación que hay que verificar, no una fuente en sí. Hay museos que omitieron a dueños judíos perseguidos o pusieron en la cadena nombres que no correspondían: Laurel Zuckerman, heredera de Paul y Alice Leffmann, lo documentó con el caso de «El actor» de Picasso en el Met («Detecting Deception in the Art Trade», Springer, 2025; el reclamo de la familia). Por eso separamos dos cosas: una «falsa alarma» la descarta un registro independiente del museo (Lost Art, el ERR, el Collecting Point, o una coincidencia que resultó ser otra obra), y «sin pistas sólo según el museo» quiere decir que el descarte se apoya únicamente en lo que dice el propio museo, sin cotejo con documentos originales.

Casos abiertos · 5

La procedencia del museo omite o contradice otro registro público: un pedido de búsqueda en Lost Art, una ficha del ERR, un reclamo publicado.

  1. Bernhard Strigel, Saint Mary Cleophas and Her Family, c. 1520/1528

    Inventario 1961.9.88 · 125.5 × 65.8 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Caso abierto. Caso publicado. Lost Art tiene un pedido de búsqueda de los herederos de Henry y Hertha Bromberg como bien sustraído por persecución nazi; según Lost Art estuvo con los Bromberg hasta después de 1935 y con Kleinberger en París antes del 20-12-1938. La National Gallery dice sólo «possibly» Bromberg y «Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939», sin el tramo 1907–1939 ni Kleinberger.

    «purchased August 1907 by members of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Saint Mary Cleophas and Her Family» (1961.9.88); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Heilige Sippe mit Maria Cleophae» (526719); Lost Art: «Heilige Sippe mit Maria Salomae» (526720); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Henry Bromberg; Algemeiner, 16-10-2025: la National Gallery of Victoria devuelve un Ter Borch a los herederos Bromberg; The Art Newspaper, 27-03-2019: la comisión alemana recomienda devolver los Bellotto de Max Emden; ALIU, lista de nombres con bandera roja (lootedart.com)

    Ver el caso completo

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel alta)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Heilige Sippe mit Maria Cleophae (hallada sin restituir) — la procedencia del lote nombra a O. Streber (misma colección, no la misma tela); mismo artista; medidas idénticas (125.5×65.8 vs 125.5×65.8 cm); título en común (cleophae≈cleophas, cleophas) · puntaje 100
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Heilige Sippe mit Maria Salomae (hallada sin restituir) — la procedencia del lote nombra a O. Streber (misma colección, no la misma tela); mismo artista; medidas casi idénticas (125.0×65.7 vs 125.5×65.8 cm); título en común (cleophae≈cleophas, cleophas) · puntaje 92
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Emden: …mbers of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939);[8] purchased February 1…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …rtin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939);[8] purchased February 1954 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly O. Streber, Munich.[1] (Haskard Bank, Florence, and Charles Fairfax Murray, as agent, by 1900);[2] sold 1900 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London); sold May 1900 to Rodolphe Kann [d. 1905], Paris;[3] by descent to executors of the Kann estate: Edouard Kann, Paris; Betty Schnaffer [née Kann], Frankfurt; Martin and Eleanore [née Kann] Bromberg, Hamburg; Jacob and Mathilde [née Kann] Emden, Hamburg, and Edmond and Madeline [née Kann] Bickard See, Paris.[4] (Duveen Brothers, Paris, August 1907);[5] purchased August 1907 by members of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939);[8] purchased February 1954 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[9] Denver Art Museum, Colorado, 1954-1958; at the NGA from February, 1958;[10] gift 1961 to NGA. [1] Unverified, cited by Alfred Stange, _Kritisches Verzeichnis der deutschen Tafelbilder vor Dürer_. 3 vols. (Munich, 1970), 2:204, no. 899. [2] Letter of 24 January 1969, from Richard Kingzett, Thos. Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London, to Colin Eisler, in NGA curatorial files. [3] Kingzett letter of 24 January 1969 cited above. [4] Duveen stockbook in archives at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; see letter of 23 February 1987 from Guy Bauman, Department of European Paintings to John Hand in NGA curatorial files. [5] Guy Bauman letter cited above and Edward Fowles, _Memories of Duveen Brothers_ (London, 1976), 36-43. [6] Bauman letter, cited in note 4, notes that in both the stockbook and the salesbook, the paintings are listed only as having been sold to "Kann relations." [7] Wildenstein & Co. brochure in NGA Kress files lists Bromberg and Dr. Emden as previous owners. [8] Letter of 14 September 1988 from Ay-Whang Hsia, Wildenstein & Co., to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files. [9] The bill of sale (copy in NGA curatorial files, see also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/1873) is dated February 10, 1954, and was for a total of fourteen paintings; payments by the Foundation continued to March 1957. [10] William E. Suida, _Paintings and Sculpture of the Samuel H. Kress Collection_. (Denver, 1954), 64, no. 28; letter of 10 November 1987 to John Hand from Louise H. Kliopov, Denver Art Museum, in NGA curatorial files. Eisler 1977, 26, reversed the exhibition dates for this and the _Saint Mary Salome and Her Family_ also by Strigel.

  2. Bernhard Strigel, Saint Mary Salome and Her Family, c. 1520/1528

    Inventario 1961.9.89 · 125 × 65.7 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Caso abierto. Caso publicado. Lost Art tiene un pedido de búsqueda de los herederos de Henry y Hertha Bromberg como bien sustraído por persecución nazi; según Lost Art estuvo con los Bromberg hasta después de 1935 y con Kleinberger en París antes del 20-12-1938. La National Gallery dice sólo «possibly» Bromberg y «Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939», sin el tramo 1907–1939 ni Kleinberger.

    «purchased August 1907 by members of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Saint Mary Salome and Her Family» (1961.9.89); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Heilige Sippe mit Maria Cleophae» (526719); Lost Art: «Heilige Sippe mit Maria Salomae» (526720); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Henry Bromberg; Algemeiner, 16-10-2025: la National Gallery of Victoria devuelve un Ter Borch a los herederos Bromberg; The Art Newspaper, 27-03-2019: la comisión alemana recomienda devolver los Bellotto de Max Emden; ALIU, lista de nombres con bandera roja (lootedart.com)

    Ver el caso completo

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel alta)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Heilige Sippe mit Maria Salomae (hallada sin restituir) — la procedencia del lote nombra a O. Streber (misma colección, no la misma tela); mismo artista; medidas idénticas (125.0×65.7 vs 125.0×65.7 cm); título en común (salomae≈salome, salome) · puntaje 100
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Heilige Sippe mit Maria Cleophae (hallada sin restituir) — la procedencia del lote nombra a O. Streber (misma colección, no la misma tela); mismo artista; medidas casi idénticas (125.5×65.8 vs 125.0×65.7 cm); título en común (salomae≈salome, salome) · puntaje 92
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Emden: …mbers of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939);[8] purchased February 1…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …rtin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939);[8] purchased February 1954 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly O. Streber, Munich.[1] (Haskard Bank, Florence, and Charles Fairfax Murray, as agent, by 1900);[2] sold 1900 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London); sold May 1900 to Rodolphe Kann [d. 1905], Paris;[3] by descent to executors of the Kann estate: Edouard Kann, Paris; Betty Schnaffer [née Kann], Frankfurt; Martin and Eleanore [née Kann] Bromberg, Hamburg; Jacob and Mathilde [née Kann] Emden, Hamburg, and Edmond and Madeline [née Kann] Bickard See, Paris.[4] (Duveen Brothers, Paris, August, 1907);[5] purchased August 1907 by members of the Kann family, possibly Martin and Eleanore Bromberg, Hamburg.[6] Probably Dr. Max Emden, Switzerland, by 1939.[7] (Wildenstein & Co., New York, by 1939);[8] purchased February 1954 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[9] at the NGA from 1956; gift 1961 to NGA. [1] Unverified, cited by Alfred Stange, _Kritisches Verzeichnis der deutschen Tafelbelder vor Dürer_. 3 vols. (Munich, 1970), 2: 204, no. 899. [2] Letter of 24 January 1969, from Richard Kingzett, Thos. Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London, to Colin Eisler, in NGA curatorial files. [3] Kingzett letter of 24 January 1969 cited above. [4] Duveen stockbook in archives at the Metropolitan Musuem of Art, New York; see letter of 23 February 1987 from Guy Bauman, Department of European Paintings to John Hand in NGA curatorial files. [5] Guy Bauman letter cited above and Edward Fowles, _Memories of Duveen Brothers_ (London, 1976), 36-43. [6] Bauman letter, cited in note 4, notes that in both the stockbook and the salesbook, the paintings are listed only as having been sold to "Kann relations." [7] Wildenstein & Co. brochure in NGA Kress files lists Bromberg and Dr. Emden as previous owners. [8] Letter of 14 September 1988 from Ay-Whang Hsia, Wildenstein & Co., to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files. [9] William E. Suida, _Paintings and Sculpture of the Samuel H. Kress Collection_. (Denver, 1954), 64, no. 28; letter of 10 November 1987 to John Hand from Louise H. Kliopov, Denver Art Museum, in NGA curatorial files (see also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/1875). Eisler 1977, 26, reversed the exhibition dates for this and the _Saint Mary Salome and Her Family_ also by Strigel. The bill of sale (copy in NGA curatorial files) is dated February 10, 1954, and was for a total of fourteen paintings; payments by the Foundation continued to March 1957.

  3. Edgar Degas, Fallen Jockey (study for "Scene from the Steeplechase: The Fallen Jockey"), c. 1866

    Sumada a mano: no salió del escaneo automático de la colección

    Inventario 1999.79.11 · 26.6 × 35.2 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Fuente principal

    Caso abierto. En Lost Art hay un pedido de búsqueda (614980) como «NS-verfolgungsbedingt entzogenes Kulturgut» (bien sustraído por persecución nazi), dentro de «Die Sammlung Armand DORVILLE». La ficha da el número de inventario 1999.79.11. La procedencia que publica la National Gallery para ese dibujo no nombra a Dorville: pone «Collection Pellet, Paris» entre la venta de René de Gas de 1927 y la subasta del Palais Galliera de 1972. Las dos versiones coinciden en esa subasta de 1972 (lote 38), en Otto Wertheimer y en los Mellon, así que hablan de la misma hoja. Además, el museo nombra a Dorville en otra hoja del mismo tema (1999.79.7), no en esta.

    «Collection Pellet, Paris; (sale, Palais Galliera, Paris, 29 November 1972, no. 38, repr.)» — de la fuente principal

    National Gallery of Art: «Fallen Jockey» (1999.79.11); National Gallery of Art: «Head of the Fallen Jockey» (1999.79.7); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Etude de jockey mort / Studie eines toten Jockeys» (614980); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Armand Dorville; Le Club des juristes: «Spoliations sous l'Occupation : un arrêt majeur de la Cour de cassation»; Pinsent Masons (Out-Law): fallo sobre la venta Dorville

    Ver el caso completo

    Procedencia según las fuentes

    Atelier Degas (Lugt 657), Paris; Collection René de Gas, Paris, until 1927; (his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 10 November 1927, no. 21, repr.); Collection Pellet, Paris; (sale, Palais Galliera, Paris, 29 November 1972, no. 38, repr.); Otto Wertheimer; Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, Upperville, VA, 1972; gift to NGA, 1999.

  4. Karl Stauffer-Bern, Adolph Menzel, 1885

    Sumada a mano: no salió del escaneo automático de la colección

    Inventario 2007.111.41 · 29.1 × 21.8 cm · Wolfgang Ratjen Collection, Purchased as the Gift of Merritt P. Dyke · Fuente principal

    Caso abierto. Lost Art tiene un pedido de búsqueda (518828) a nombre de Adele Paechter: el dibujo fue de su marido Hermann Paechter, el marchante berlinés al que Stauffer-Bern se lo dedicó, y Lost Art dice «NS-verfolgungsbedingter Verlust vermutet» (se presume una pérdida por persecución nazi). La procedencia de la National Gallery empieza en la subasta de Kornfeld de 1990. No nombra a los Paechter, aunque la dedicatoria está en el propio dibujo.

    «(sale, Galerie Kornfeld, Bern, 22 June 1990, no. 984); Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich; purchased 2007 by NGA.» — de la fuente principal

    National Gallery of Art: «Adolph Menzel» (2007.111.41); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Porträt Adolph Menzel» (518828); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»

    Ver el caso completo

    Procedencia según las fuentes

    (sale, Galerie Kornfeld, Bern, 22 June 1990, no. 984); Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich; purchased 2007 by NGA.

  5. Max Liebermann, The Artist's Daughter Käthe Reading in a Chair, 1893/1895

    Sumada a mano: no salió del escaneo automático de la colección

    Inventario 2007.111.119 · 27.5 × 33 cm · Wolfgang Ratjen Collection, Patrons' Permanent Fund · Fuente principal

    Caso abierto. En Lost Art hay un pedido de búsqueda (417888) a nombre de Max y Martha Liebermann como bien sustraído por persecución nazi, con «Verlust nach 1935» (pérdida después de 1935, el año en que murió el pintor). La procedencia de la National Gallery empieza recién en «Egon Meilicke, Berlin» y la subasta Neumeister de 1986. No nombra a los Liebermann, aunque el dibujo es un retrato de la hija del pintor.

    «Egon Meilicke, Berlin. (sale, Neumeister, Munich, 10 December 1986, no. 844); Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich; purchased 2007 by NGA.» — de la fuente principal

    National Gallery of Art: «The Artist's Daughter Käthe Reading in a Chair» (2007.111.119); National Gallery of Art, datos abiertos (GitHub, CC0); Lost Art: «Lesendes Mädchen (Tochter Käthe) im Sessel» (417888); Open Art Data, 18-04-2026: «Lost Art Search Requests for artworks currently in the National Gallery of Art»; Wikipedia: Martha Liebermann

    Ver el caso completo

    Procedencia según las fuentes

    Egon Meilicke, Berlin. (sale, Neumeister, Munich, 10 December 1986, no. 844); Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich; purchased 2007 by NGA.

Pendientes de documentos · 20

Hay un dueño perseguido o un marchante del saqueo en los años del nazismo y no alcanza lo publicado para saber qué pasó. Cada una dice qué documento falta.

  1. André Derain, Mountains at Collioure, 1905

    Inventario 1982.76.4 · 81.3 × 100.3 cm · John Hay Whitney Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Derain, «Montañas en Collioure»: Vollard hasta al menos 1935, luego Paul Pétridès (marchante del mercado de la ocupación) hasta 1951. Vollard no era perseguido, pero el hueco pasa por Pétridès. Falta saber cómo pasó del stock de Vollard (después de 1935) a Pétridès, marchante del mercado de la ocupación.

    «Possibly purchased from the artist by (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris), until at least 1935.[1] (Paul Pétridès, Paris); acquired June 1951» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Mountains at Collioure» (1982.76.4)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ambroise Vollard: Possibly purchased from the artist by (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris), until at least 1935.[1] (Paul Pétridès, Paris); acquired June 1951 o…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly purchased from the artist by (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris), until at least 1935.[1] (Paul Pétridès, Paris); acquired June 1951 on joint account by (M. Knoedler & Co., New York) and (Sidney Janis Gallery, New York); full ownership acquired October 1951 by (Sidney Janis Gallery, New York);[2] sold 1951 to John Hay Whitney [1904-1982], Manhasset, New York; deeded 1982 to the John Hay Whitney Charitable Trust, New York; gift 1982 to NGA. [1] Letter of 17 April 1985 from Michel Kellerman, in NGA curatorial files. Two labels on the stretcher of the painting include Vollard's name, and appear to indicate he lent to the painting to exhibitions in 1935 (recorded in NGA conservation report, in NGA curatorial files). [2] Although a letter of 9 July 1984 from Sidney Janis Gallery, now in NGA curatorial files, states that they acquired the painting from Knoedler in 1950, a letter of 9 January 1985 from Nancy Little, librarian at M. Knoedler & Co., also in NGA curatorial files, gives the more precise dates. The Knoedler number to which Ms. Little refers, A4642, is recorded in blue pencil on the stretcher of the painting. Ms. Little also confirms Pétridès as Knoedler's source. A letter of 5 March 1985 from the Galerie Pétridès, in NGA curatorial files, indicates that they have no additional information about the picture.

  2. Antoine Watteau, Ceres (Summer), c. 1717/1718

    Inventario 1961.9.50 · 141.6 × 115.7 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Watteau, «Ceres (Verano)»: Wildenstein desde 1935 hasta 1954 (stock de París, Nueva York o Londres no aclarado). El stock de Wildenstein en París fue saqueado; sin registro en nuestra base. Falta saber en qué sucursal de Wildenstein estuvo la obra en 1940 (París fue saqueada); no aparece en nuestra base del ERR.

    «(Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London), by 1935;[6] sold February 1954 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Ceres (Summer)» (1961.9.50)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …vols., Paris and Brussels, 1928-1930: 1(1928):31, no. 26. [6] The painting was lent by Wildenstein to a 1935 exhibition in Copenhagen. [7] The bill of sale (copy in NGA curatorial files…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Louis Dreyfus: …rges Petit, Paris, 17-18 June 1925, 1st day, no. 160);[4] Batteroze or Betteroze. Charles-Louis Dreyfus [1870-1929], Paris.[5] (Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London), by 1935;[6…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Michel Lévy: …845-1914], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 12-13 May 1919, no. 28); Léon Michel-Lévy [1846-1925], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 17-18 June 1925, 1st day, no…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Commissioned by Pierre Crozat [1665-1740] for the dining room of his hôtel on rue de Richelieu, Paris; by inheritance with the hôtel to his nephew, Louis François Crozat, marquis du Châtel [1691-1750], Paris; by inheritance with the hôtel to his daughter, Louise-Honorine Crozat [1737-1801, married 1750 to the duc de Choiseul], Paris; the hôtel was sold in 1772 and demolished shortly thereafter, before which the painting was removed, probably to the Choiseul's Château de Chanteloup, Touraine; (estate sale of Etienne François, duc de Choiseul [1719-1785], Paillet, Paris, 18 December 1786, no. 3, with _Winter_ from the same series); purchased by Meunier. Jean Baptiste Pierre Le Brun [1748-1813], Paris; (his own sale, Le Brun, Paris, 11 April-8 May 1791, 10th day [April 20], no. 204, with _Winter_); Rebes; (sale, Le Brun, Paris, 15 November 1791, no. 95, with _Winter_).[1] Roehn, Paris.[2] Charles Wertheimer [d. 1911], London. (Charles Sedelmeyer Galleries, Paris), by 1895; sold 1898 to Sir Lionel Phillips, bt. [1855-1936], Tylney Hall, Winchfield;[3] (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods, London, 25 April 1913, no. 72); Nicholson. Henri Michel-Lévy [1845-1914], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 12-13 May 1919, no. 28); Léon Michel-Lévy [1846-1925], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 17-18 June 1925, 1st day, no. 160);[4] Batteroze or Betteroze. Charles-Louis Dreyfus [1870-1929], Paris.[5] (Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London), by 1935;[6] sold February 1954 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[7] gift 1961 to NGA. [1] Annotated copies of the sale catalogue give the name variously as "Rebes," "Mr. le president Rebe," and "de Rebes." See the extended description of this sale in the sale catalogues portion of the Getty Provenance Index Database, J. Paul Getty Trust (photocopy in NGA curatorial files), which includes the comment: "It is not known from which legislative body his title of president is taken, nor has his full name been found." [2] Pierre Rosenberg says this was "probably Adolphe Eugène Gabriel Roehn (1780-1867) and not his son" (Alphonse); Margaret Morgan Grasselli and Pierre Rosenberg, _Watteau 1684-1721_, exh. cat., National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C.; Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, Paris; Schloss Charlottenburg, Berlin; Washington, D.C., 1984: 326. [3] According to the 1895 Sedelmeyer catalogue and the catalogue of the 1935 Copenhagen exhibition, and repeated in William E. Suida and Fern Rusk Shapley, _Paintings and Sculpture from the Kress Collection Acquired by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, 1951-1956_, Washington, D.C., 1956: 204, the painting was supposed to have been in the Hugh A.J. Munro of Novar collection in Ross, Scotland. However, _Spring_, another painting in the series, was actually in the Munro collection (and sold at Christie, Manson & Woods, London, 1 June 1878, no. 149). [4] Pierre Rosenberg, ed., _Vies anciennes de Watteau_, Paris, 1984, erroneously says this sale was in May. [5] Published as with Dreyfus in Louis Dimier, _Les peintres français du XVIIIe siècle. Histoire des vies et catalogue des oeuvres_, 2 vols., Paris and Brussels, 1928-1930: 1(1928):31, no. 26. [6] The painting was lent by Wildenstein to a 1935 exhibition in Copenhagen. [7] The bill of sale (copy in NGA curatorial files, see also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/468) is dated February 10, 1954, and was for a total of fourteen paintings; payments by the Foundation continued to March 1957.

  3. Bernardo Bellotto and Workshop, View of Munich, c. 1761

    Inventario 1961.9.64 · 69.2 × 119.8 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Las propias notas del museo se contradicen: Saemy Rosenberg (1955) dice que un coleccionista privado la compró «from a Dresden collection during World War II»; el museo sugiere que Gustav Mez la compró a Haberstock en 1929. Haberstock vendió la otra versión a Linz. ¿Qué colección de Dresde? Falta identificar la «Dresden collection» de la que la compró Mez durante la guerra (carta de Saemy Rosenberg de 1955, en el legajo del museo) y el registro de Haberstock sobre a quién vendió cuál de los dos Bellotto.

    «the painting was acquired by a private collector from a Dresden collection during World War II.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «View of Munich» (1961.9.64)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Marchante del saqueo: Karl Haberstock: Private collection, Saxony.[1] Possibly (Sabin, London); sold 1928 to (Karl Haberstock, Berlin), possibly until 1936.[2] Acquired by Dr. Gustav Mez [d. 1944], Rorschacherberg,…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Sonderauftrag Linz: …ve handled two Bellotto views of Munich: the Gallery version and one that was sold to the Sonderauftrag Linz, processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point (no. 7573) in 1945, transferred in…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Central Collecting Point: …ery version and one that was sold to the Sonderauftrag Linz, processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point (no. 7573) in 1945, transferred in 1949 to the German government, and sent to the Auswärt…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Sonderauftrag Linz: …ve handled two Bellotto views of Munich: the Gallery version and one that was sold to the Sonderauftrag Linz, processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point (no. 7573) in 1945, transferred in…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Private collection, Saxony.[1] Possibly (Sabin, London); sold 1928 to (Karl Haberstock, Berlin), possibly until 1936.[2] Acquired by Dr. Gustav Mez [d. 1944], Rorschacherberg, Switzerland;[3] (Rosenberg and Stiebel, New York); purchased 1951 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[4] gift 1961 to NGA. [1] A photograph of the painting in the Witt Library, London, is inscribed with the information that the painting was once in the collection of Augustus III, elector of Saxony (see photocopy in NGA curatorial files.) [2] Karl Haberstock appears to have handled two Bellotto views of Munich: the Gallery version and one that was sold to the Sonderauftrag Linz, processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point (no. 7573) in 1945, transferred in 1949 to the German government, and sent to the Auswärtig Amt in 1962 (see photocopies from the Bundesarchiv, Koblenz, in NGA curatorial files). This other version, first published by Andrzej Rottermund in 1998 (see bibliography), was auctioned by Koller International Auctions in Zurich on 1 October 2021. One of the two Bellottos was acquired by Haberstock from Sabin in London in April 1928 (see photocopies from Haberstock-archiv in NGA curatorial files), and at least one was still in his possession as of 1936, per Hellmuth Allwill Fritzsche, Bernardo Bellotto, genannt Canaletto, Burg-bei-Magdeburg, 1936: 116. [3] According to Saemy Rosenberg (letter of 7 December 1955, to NGA curator Fern Rusk Shapley, in NGA curatorial files), the painting was acquired by a private collector from a Dresden collection during World War II. Stefan Kozakiewicz, in his 1972 catalogue raisonné, identified the collector as Gustav Mez, a German resident in Switzerland (see bibliography). It is possible that both this painting and its companion (NGA 1961.9.63) were acquired by Mez from Haberstock in 1929, when the third painting of the group (replicas of the originals in the electoral palace painted for Elector Maximilian III Joseph) was sold. [4] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/2438.

  4. Camille Pissarro, Orchard in Bloom, Louveciennes, 1872

    Inventario 1970.17.51 · 45.1 × 54.9 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Pissarro, «Huerto en flor, Louveciennes»: Alfred Bernheim, París, en 1936; comprado en 1946 por Reid & Lefèvre. Hueco 1936–1946; no encontramos registro. Falta saber dónde estuvo la obra de Alfred Bernheim entre 1936 y 1946 y quién la vendió a Reid & Lefèvre en 1946.

    «Alfred Bernheim, Paris, by 1936.[2] purchased 1946 by (Alex Reid & Lefèvre, London)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Orchard in Bloom, Louveciennes» (1970.17.51)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Léonce y Renée Bernheim: …ed from the artist in 1872 by (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold between 1882 and 1888.[1] Alfred Bernheim, Paris, by 1936.[2] purchased 1946 by (Alex Reid & Lefèvre, London); sold 14 March 1950 to Lady…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Acquired from the artist in 1872 by (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold between 1882 and 1888.[1] Alfred Bernheim, Paris, by 1936.[2] purchased 1946 by (Alex Reid & Lefèvre, London); sold 14 March 1950 to Lady Baillie. (Arthur Tooth and Sons, London); sold June 1959 to (Sam Salz Inc., New York);[3] sold 26 April 1960 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York;[4] bequest 1970 to NGA. [1] See letter dated 20 December 1977 from Charles Durand-Ruel, in NGA curatorial files. [2] The painting was lent by Bernheim to a1936 Paris exhibition. [3] Provenance between Alex Reid & Lefèvre and Arthur Tooth and Sons per Joachim Pissarro and Claire Durand-Ruel Snollaerts, _Pissarro: Critical Catalogue of Paintings_, vol. II, no. 248. Dated receipt from Salz to Mrs. Bruce in NGA curatorial files.

  5. Camille Pissarro, The Fence, 1872

    Inventario 1985.64.31 · 37.8 × 45.7 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Pissarro, «La cerca»: con Paul Rosenberg y César de Hauke en París en 1939; después, Arthur Goldsmith, París, hasta 1955. Hueco 1939–1955 en París; no lo encontramos en ERR, MNR ni Lost Art. Falta el registro de stock de Rosenberg o de De Hauke sobre la venta, y desde cuándo la tenía Arthur Goldsmith.

    «(Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris) and (César de Hauke, Paris), by 1939.[2] Arthur Goldsmith, Paris; sold 1955» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Fence» (1985.64.31)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …er, Mme Ernest Donop de Monchy [née Victorine de Bellio, 1863-1958] until at least 1937. (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris) and (César de Hauke, Paris), by 1939.[2] Arthur Goldsmith, Paris; sold 19…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 18 February 1878, no. 59, as _La Haie_); purchased by Georges de Bellio [1828-1894];[1] by inheritance to his daughter, Mme Ernest Donop de Monchy [née Victorine de Bellio, 1863-1958] until at least 1937. (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris) and (César de Hauke, Paris), by 1939.[2] Arthur Goldsmith, Paris; sold 1955 to (Walter Feilchenfeldt, Zurich);[3] sold that same year to (Georges Seligmann, Inc., New York); sold 1955 to Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia; gift 1985 to NGA. [1] The painting is no. 104 in the inventory of the de Bellio collection, published by Remus Niculescu in _Paragone_ 249 (November 1970): 68. [2] According to Ludovic Rodo Pissarro and Lionello Venturi, _Camille Pissarro. Son Art--Son Oeuvre_, 2 vols., San Francisco, 1989 (reprint of 1939 edition): no. 135. [3] Goldsmith and Feilchenfeldt per Joachim Pissarro and Claire Durand-Ruel Snollaerts, _Pissarro: Critical Catalogue of Paintings_, 3 vols., Milan, Paris, and New York, 2005: 2:no. 231.

  6. Edouard Manet, Tama, the Japanese Dog, c. 1875

    Inventario 1995.47.12 · 61 × 50 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Manet, «Tama, el perro japonés»: Georges Bernheim, París, 1934; Bomford, Londres, desde 1942. No dice cómo ni cuándo cruzó. Falta cuándo y cómo pasó de Georges Bernheim a los Bomford en Londres (antes o después de 1940).

    «(Georges Bernheim, Paris, by 1934).[3] Mr. and Mrs. H.J.P. Bomford, London, from at least 1942» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Tama, the Japanese Dog» (1995.47.12)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …1903 exhibition at Bernheim-Jeune, Paris. [2] Published as Gérard collection in Jamot-Wildenstein's 1932 Manet catalogue. [3] Lent by Bernheim to the 1934 Venice biennale. [4] Lent…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Léonce y Renée Bernheim: …uret [1838-1927], Paris, still in 1903. [1] (Raphael Gérard, Paris), by 1932.[2] (Georges Bernheim, Paris, by 1934).[3] Mr. and Mrs. H.J.P. Bomford, London, from at least 1942 until at least 1948…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Georges Bernheim: …éodore Duret [1838-1927], Paris, still in 1903. [1] (Raphael Gérard, Paris), by 1932.[2] (Georges Bernheim, Paris, by 1934).[3] Mr. and Mrs. H.J.P. Bomford, London, from at least 1942 until at lea…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Théodore Duret [1838-1927], Paris, still in 1903. [1] (Raphael Gérard, Paris), by 1932.[2] (Georges Bernheim, Paris, by 1934).[3] Mr. and Mrs. H.J.P. Bomford, London, from at least 1942 until at least 1948.[4] (Marlborough Fine Arts, London), in 1953.[5] Jean d'Alayer, of the Durand-Ruel family, Paris, by 1957.[6] (Sam Salz, New York); sold May 1959 to Mr. Paul Mellon, Upperville, VA; gift 1995 to NGA. [1]Not included in the 19 March 1894 sale of Duret's collection held in Paris. Lent by Duret to the 1903 exhibition at Bernheim-Jeune, Paris. [2] Published as Gérard collection in Jamot-Wildenstein's 1932 Manet catalogue. [3] Lent by Bernheim to the 1934 Venice biennale. [4] Lent by Bomford to a 1942 exhibition in London; a partial label on the back of the stretcher gives the Bomford name. Exhibited in 1944 in London, Council for the encouragement of music and the arts (C.E.M.A, now the Arts Council of Great Britain) _Paintings of the French School from a Private Collection_ (H.J.P. Bomford). Lent by the "Bomford Collection" to a 1948 exhibition in Dublin; a label for the exhibition is on the back of the stretcher. [5] Published in Eric Newton, "French Painters VII: Edouard Manet," _Apollo_, February 1953. [6] Lent by d'Alayer to a 1957 exhibition in Paris. He was married to Marie-Louise Durand-Ruel, granddaughter of the dealer Paul Durand-Ruel.

  7. Edouard Manet, The Melon, c. 1880

    Inventario 2014.18.29 · 46.67 × 56.52 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Manet, «El melón»: de Max Liebermann a su hija Käthe Riezler, sin fechas ni cómo salió de Alemania (el museo sí lo explica para el «George Moore»). No hay pedido en Lost Art en nuestra base. Falta cualquier documento de cómo salió de Alemania (lista de 1933 de Zúrich, que el museo cita para el «George Moore», o papeles de emigración de los Riezler de 1938) y cuándo la compró Wildenstein.

    «Max Liebermann [1847-1935], Berlin, before 1925; his daughter, Mrs. Kurt Riezler [née Käthe Liebermann, 1885-1952], Berlin and later New York.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Melon» (2014.18.29)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Liebermann: …Drouot, Paris, 5 June 1888, no. 3); bought by Isidore Bloch or Hermann Paechter, Berlin. Max Liebermann [1847-1935], Berlin, before 1925; his daughter, Mrs. Kurt Riezler [née Käthe Liebermann,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Sold by the artist to M. Pertuiset, Paris; (his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 5 June 1888, no. 3); bought by Isidore Bloch or Hermann Paechter, Berlin. Max Liebermann [1847-1935], Berlin, before 1925; his daughter, Mrs. Kurt Riezler [née Käthe Liebermann, 1885-1952], Berlin and later New York.[1] (Wildenstein and Co., New York); sold 1959 to Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia; bequest 1999 to NGA, with life interest to his wife, Rachel Lambert Mellon [1910-2014]. [1] Name mistakenly recorded as Liezler in Paul Jamot and Georges Wildenstein, _Manet_, 2 vols., Paris, 1932: 1:no. 386.

  8. Eugène Boudin, Women on the Beach at Berck, 1881

    Inventario 1970.17.15 · 24.8 × 36.2 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Boudin (1970.17.15 y 1970.17.16): de 1906/1899 saltan a Jacques Lindon, Nueva York (1947, 1963), hijo de Alfred Lindon, cuya colección saqueó el ERR. No encontramos estas dos obras en el ERR. Falta la procedencia entre 1906 (Bernheim-Jeune) y 1947 (Jacques Lindon); hay que cruzarla con las obras de Alfred Lindon saqueadas por el ERR.

    «purchased by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris).[1] (Jacques Lindon, New York); sold 4 February 1947» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Women on the Beach at Berck» (1970.17.15)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alfred Lindon: …istie's, London, 23 June 1906, no. 44); purchased by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris).[1] (Jacques Lindon, New York); sold 4 February 1947 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York;[2] gift 197…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Lindon: …ale, Christie's, London, 23 June 1906, no. 44); purchased by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris).[1] (Jacques Lindon, New York); sold 4 February 1947 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York;[2] gift 197…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1906 a 1947
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Adolphe A. Tavernier, Paris; (his sale, by Bernheim-Jeune, experts, Paris, 23 March 1903, no. 14). Albert Pontremoli, London; (Pontremoli sale, Christie's, London, 23 June 1906, no. 44); purchased by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris).[1] (Jacques Lindon, New York); sold 4 February 1947 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York;[2] gift 1970 to NGA. [1] According to Robert Schmit, _Eugène Boudin, 1824-1898_, 3 vols., Paris, 1973: 2:no. 1510. [2] Receipt of sale from Lindon to Mrs. Bruce, dated 4 February 1947, in NGA curatorial files.

  9. Eugène Boudin, Yacht Basin at Trouville-Deauville, probably 1895/1896

    Inventario 1970.17.16 · 45.8 × 37.1 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Boudin, «Dársena de Trouville-Deauville»: de Levaique (después de 1899) salta a Jacques Lindon en 1963; Jacques era hijo de Alfred Lindon, cuya colección saqueó el ERR. No encontramos esta obra en el ERR. Falta la procedencia entre 1899 (Levaique) y 1963 (Jacques Lindon); cruzar con las obras de Alfred Lindon saqueadas por el ERR.

    «Levaique, Paris. (Jacques Lindon); sold 1963 to (Wildenstein & Co., New York)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Yacht Basin at Trouville-Deauville» (1970.17.16)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alfred Lindon: …ist; (Boudin sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 20 March 1899, no. 93). Levaique, Paris. (Jacques Lindon); sold 1963 to (Wildenstein & Co., New York);[1] sold 22 April 1966 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Lindon: The artist; (Boudin sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 20 March 1899, no. 93). Levaique, Paris. (Jacques Lindon); sold 1963 to (Wildenstein & Co., New York);[1] sold 22 April 1966 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1901 a 1963
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The artist; (Boudin sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 20 March 1899, no. 93). Levaique, Paris. (Jacques Lindon); sold 1963 to (Wildenstein & Co., New York);[1] sold 22 April 1966 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York; gift 1970 to NGA. [1]Provenance provided in invoice from Wildenstein's dated 22 April 1966, in NGA curatorial records. Letter from Wildentstein's dated 14 December 1998 gives their acquisition date and source.

  10. Fra Filippo Lippi, Saint Benedict Orders Saint Maurus to the Rescue of Saint Placidus, c. 1445/1450

    Inventario 1952.5.10 · 40 × 69.5 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Filippo Lippi, predela: «Mme Douine, Château de la Boissière»; Wildenstein Nueva York la vendió a Kress en diciembre de 1942. No hay fecha ni lugar de la salida de Francia ocupada. Falta la fecha y el modo de salida de Francia ocupada y la factura de compra de Wildenstein a Mme Douine.

    «Mme Douine, Château de la Boissière, Seine-et-Oise; (Wildenstein & Co., Inc., New York); sold December 1942 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Saint Benedict Orders Saint Maurus to the Rescue of Saint Placidus» (1952.5.10)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …n paintings, including "Scenes from the Life of St. Benoit" by Fra Filippo Lippi, between Wildenstein & Co. and the Kress Foundation is dated 31 December 1942 (copy in NGA curatorial files).…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Part of a predella, possibly that of the main altarpiece of the church of San Bernardo in Arezzo, which was subsequently removed from the altar and dismembered, but remained in the adjacent monastery of the Olivetans until at least 1767.[1] probably Michele Cavaleri, Milan, by the mid-nineteenth century or later;[2] acquired 1873 by Enrico (Henri) Cernuschi [1821-1896], Paris and Menton.[3] Édouard Aynard [1837-1913], Lyons, by 1900;[4] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 1-4 December 1913, 1st day, no. 52); Hoentschel.[5] Mme Douine, Château de la Boissière, Seine-et-Oise; (Wildenstein & Co., Inc., New York); sold December 1942 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[6] gift 1952 to NGA. [1] In an important essay, Jeffrey Ruda ("Style and Patronage in the 1440s: Two Altarpieces of the Coronation of the Virgin by Filippo Lippi," _MittKIF_ 28 [1984]: 384) succeeded in identifying the altar panel, then still in its original frame and considered a single piece, in a 1767 inventory of the monastery of San Bernardo (Archivio di Stato, Florence, Compagnie Religiose Soppresse in Arezzo, B. XLVIII, no. 10, f. 190r.). In 1782 the Olivetans were transferred to the monastery of Santa Maria in Grado, also in Arezzo, and three years later their new house was suppressed and its belongings dispersed. The _Coronation_ probably remained in the city in private hands, perhaps until 1842 when it was purchased by Pope Gregory XVI from the Aretine merchant Carlo Baldesci (see Jeffrey Ruda, _Fra Filippo Lippi. Life and Work with a Complete Catalogue_, London, 1993: 418). Robert Oertel, _Fra Filippo Lippi_, Vienna, 1942: 67, and other scholars linked the execution of the altar panel to the death of Gregorio Marsuppin (represented knealing on the other side), who commissioned the painting. Gregorio, a famous jurist, died in 1444; this date can be considered a probable _terminus post quem_ for the commission. [2] That the painting came from the Cavaleri collection is only a hypothesis. Apparently no complete list has ever been published of the paintings in that collection. A. Mazzoleni (_Il Museo Cavaleri_, Milan, 1870) and Giuseppe Ferrari (_Il Museo Cavaleri_, Milan, 1871) limit themselves to citing just some of the works, for the most part Lombard, and referring to the presence of Tuscan paintings. A Milanese lawyer, Michele Cavaleri began collecting around 1845 and from 1870 on opened to the public what by then had come to be called the Cavaleri Museum. The owner hoped that the collection would be purchased by the city of Milan, but when negotiations fell through, he sold the entire collection to Enrico Cernuschi on 13 April 1873 (see Alessandra Mottola Molfino, "Collezionismo e mercato artistico a Milano," _Zenale e Leonardo. Tradizione e rinnovamento della pittura lombarda_, Milan, 1982: 247-248). [3] On the provenance from the Cernuschi collection see Fern Rusk Shapley, _Catalogue of the Italian Paintings_, 2 vols., Washington, D.C., 1979: 1:264, and the Getty Provenance Index. As Cernuschi otherwise collected mainly objects of Asian art (see Caroline Gyss-Vermande, "Cernuschi, Henri," in _Dictionary of Art_, 1996: 6:345), one may surmise that he obtained his early Italian paintings from the Cavaleri collection; see note 2. Lippi's panel is not listed in the sale catalogue for the collection (_Catalogue des tableaux anciens des écoles primitives..._, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 25-26 May 1900). It seems likely that the painting was sold privately sometime earlier, probaby after the collector's death in 1896. [4] On this collection, see Jean-François Garmier, "Le Goût du moyen-âge chez les collectionneurs lyonnais du XIXe siècle," _RArt_ 47 (1980): 59, 64 n. 153. [5] According to annotated copies of the Aynard sale catalogue and a newspaper account of the sale (copies in NGA curatorial files), in one of which the name is also spelled Hoentchell. A letter of 17 April 1979 from Jean-François Garmier spells the name Hohentchell (in NGA curatorial files). It is possible the buyer was Georges Hoentschel (1855-1915), a collector in Paris, who made other purchases at the Aynard sale. [6] The sales agreement for eleven paintings, including "Scenes from the Life of St. Benoit" by Fra Filippo Lippi, between Wildenstein & Co. and the Kress Foundation is dated 31 December 1942 (copy in NGA curatorial files). See also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/1804.

  11. Georges Braque, Fruit, Glass, and Mandolin, 1938

    Inventario 1995.47.4 · 81 × 100 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Braque, «Fruta, vaso y mandolina» (1938): en la galería de Paul Rosenberg en París en 1938, luego «private collection, New York» sin fechas. El stock de Rosenberg fue saqueado en 1940–41. No aparece en las fichas del ERR de nuestra base (la «Mandoline, fruits et bouteille» restituida en 1947 es de 1936, otra obra). Falta el registro de stock de Paul Rosenberg (fondo Rosenberg del Musée d'Orsay / MoMA) que diga si la obra seguía en París en 1940 y a quién se vendió.

    «(Paul Rosenberg & Co., New York and Paris), in 1938. [1] Private collection, New York.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Fruit, Glass, and Mandolin» (1995.47.4); ERR (Jeu de Paume): Braque, «Mandoline, fruits et bouteille», 1936, restituida a Rosenberg en 1947 (otra obra)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …y Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, Upperville, Virginia; gift 1995 to NGA. [1] Exhibited at Paul Rosenberg Galerie, Paris, in 1938. [2] Per _Catalogue de L'Oeuvre de Georges Braque, Peintures 193…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Paul Rosenberg & Co., New York and Paris), in 1938. [1] Private collection, New York.[2] Purchased by Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, Upperville, Virginia; gift 1995 to NGA. [1] Exhibited at Paul Rosenberg Galerie, Paris, in 1938. [2] Per _Catalogue de L'Oeuvre de Georges Braque, Peintures 1936-1941_, Paris, 1961: 33.

  12. Georges Seurat, Haymakers at Montfermeil, c. 1882

    Inventario 2014.18.48 · 15.56 × 24.77 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Seurat, «Segadores en Montfermeil»: Georges Lévy, París, 1937 (expuesto en Seligmann en 1938); «private collection, Paris, in 1957». Hueco en París durante la ocupación. Falta el destino de la obra después de la exposición de Seligmann de 1938 (el museo dice que no hay documentos en el archivo Seligmann) y la identidad de la colección privada de 1957.

    «Georges Lévy, Paris, in 1937.[1] private collection, Paris, in 1957.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Haymakers at Montfermeil» (2014.18.48)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann: …owever, to date no documents concerning the Seurat have been discovered in the records of Jacques Seligmann and Co. at the Archives of American Art, Washington, D.C. [2] Lent from a private coll…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Georges Lévy: …ris; his son, Ari Redon [1889-1972], Paris. (Galerie Jacques Rodrigues-Henriques, Paris). Georges Lévy, Paris, in 1937.[1] private collection, Paris, in 1957.[2] Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upper…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Odilon Redon [1840-1916], Paris; his son, Ari Redon [1889-1972], Paris. (Galerie Jacques Rodrigues-Henriques, Paris). Georges Lévy, Paris, in 1937.[1] private collection, Paris, in 1957.[2] Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia; bequest 1999 to NGA, with life interest to his wife, Rachel Lambert Mellon [1910-2014]. [1] The painting was exhibited at Seligmann’s in Paris in 1938. In 1937, Lévy was selling through Seligmann two Renoirs now in the collection of the NGA (1956.4.1-2) so it is possible he sold the Seurat through Seligmann as well. However, to date no documents concerning the Seurat have been discovered in the records of Jacques Seligmann and Co. at the Archives of American Art, Washington, D.C. [2] Lent from a private collection in Paris to _Seurat_, Musée Jacquemart-Andre, Paris, 1957, no. 6.

  13. Georges de La Tour, The Repentant Magdalen, c. 1635/1640

    Inventario 1974.52.1 · 113 × 92.7 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Georges de La Tour, «La Magdalena penitente»: André Fabius, París, desde 1936 hasta 1974. Si los Fabius (familia de marchantes judíos) la tuvieron durante la ocupación, hace falta saber dónde estuvo. Falta saber dónde estuvo la obra durante la ocupación (1940–44) en manos de André Fabius y si hubo incautación o restitución.

    «art market, Paris; André Fabius, Paris, by 1936;[2] purchased 1974 by NGA.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Repentant Magdalen» (1974.52.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: André Fabius: …y 1877; by inheritance to his sister, comtesse de Andigné, by 1911.[1] art market, Paris; André Fabius, Paris, by 1936;[2] purchased 1974 by NGA. [1] On the back of the stretcher is the s…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Marquise de Caulaincourt, by 1877; by inheritance to his sister, comtesse de Andigné, by 1911.[1] art market, Paris; André Fabius, Paris, by 1936;[2] purchased 1974 by NGA. [1] On the back of the stretcher is the stencil of Etienne-François Haro (1827-1897) and his son Henri (1855-1911), important Parisian restorers and vendors of art supplies, as well as artists themselves. An entry in the Haro account book for 9 October 1877 provides the early provenance, information that was first published by Pierre Rosenberg and Jacques Thuillier, "George de La Tour," _Revue du Louvre et des Musées de France_ 22, no. 2 (1972): 161, followed, with slightly differing details, by Pierre Rosenberg and François Macé de l'Épinay, _Georges de La Tour: vie et oeuvre_, Fribourg, 1973: 140, and Benedict Nicolson and Christopher Wright, _Georges de La Tour_, London, 1974: 175. [2] The three references to the painting that discuss its provenance (see note 1) provide differing accounts of when and where Fabius acquired the painting: Rosenberg and Thuillier 1972 say 1936; Rosenberg and Macé de l'Épinay 1973 say a public sale in 1936; Nicolson and Wright 1974 say the Paris art market before 1936.

  14. Henri Matisse, Lorette with Turban, Yellow Jacket, 1917

    Inventario 1963.10.39 · 61.3 × 49.4 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Matisse, «Lorette con turbante»: en cuenta conjunta Durand-Ruel / Paul Rosenberg (París) de 1930 a 1950. Sin dato de dónde estuvo en la guerra. Falta saber dónde estuvo la obra entre 1940 y 1945 (stock de Durand-Ruel o de Rosenberg en París).

    «purchased 15 October 1930 by (Durand-Ruel, Paris) on joint account with (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris); full ownership acquired 7 February 1950» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Lorette with Turban, Yellow Jacket» (1963.10.39)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …hauser, Berlin); purchased 15 October 1930 by (Durand-Ruel, Paris) on joint account with (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris); full ownership acquired 7 February 1950 by (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Lond…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1950
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Galerie Thannhauser, Berlin); purchased 15 October 1930 by (Durand-Ruel, Paris) on joint account with (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris); full ownership acquired 7 February 1950 by (Paul Rosenberg and Co., London, New York and Paris);[1] sold October 1952 to Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York;[2] bequest 1963 to NGA. [1] Letter of 27 March 1987 from Durand Ruel & Cie., in NGA curatorial files. [2] See bill of sale dated 23 October 1952 in NGA Gallery Archives, Chester and Maud Dale Papers, Artist & Dealer Files, Box 3, Folder 6, copy in NGA curatorial files.

  15. Jacob van Ruisdael, Dunes by the Sea, 1648

    Inventario 2017.55.1 · 45.4 × 61.6 cm · The Lee and Juliet Folger Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. La regla saltó por una palabra de confiscación o incautación que se refiere a otra época, no al nazismo. La confiscación es la de Prusia en 1866. Hay un hueco entre la subasta de 1925 y «private collection, Cologne, in 1948», sin dueño nombrado; la National Gallery la compró en 2017 con estudio de procedencia. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo. Lo dejamos como pendiente: falta saber quién lo tuvo entre la subasta de 1925 y 1948, en Alemania.

    «From 1866 until 1893, the royal collection was confiscated by the State of Prussia following the annexation of Hanover» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Dunes by the Sea» (2017.55.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: confiscación: …cation, but not correctly its owner. [3 From 1866 until 1893, the royal collection was confiscated by the State of Prussia following the annexation of Hanover, and placed under the contr…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Richter Oelrich, Bremen, c. 1820; purchased 1928 by Bernhard Hausmann [1784-1873], Hanover;[1] private sale 1 October 1857 to King George V of Hanover [1819-1878];[2] by inheritance to his son, Ernest August II, Crown Prince of Hanover and 3rd Duke of Cumberland [1845-1923];[3] (his estate sale, Rudolph Lepke Kunst-Auctions-Haus, Berlin, 31 March 1925, no. 63, sold for 16,500 Reichsmarks). art market, Düsseldorf. private collection, Cologne, in 1948; (Kunsthandel K. & V. Waterman, Amsterdam), in 1982; purchased 1983 by Norman and Suzanne Hascoe, Greenwich, Connecticut; (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods, New York, 4 June 2014, no. 38); (Richard Green Fine Paintings, London); purchased May 2017 by NGA. [1] See Joachim Petersen, _Bernhard Hausmann: Burger, Fabrikant, Kunstsammler_, Gottingen, 2009: 241: “The [four] landscapes by [Jacob van Ruisdael] were very highly regarded by Hausmann, especially ‘_Dunes by the Sea_’, purchased in 1828 in Bremen for 100 Thaler [then follows a quote, presumably from Hausmann]: 'Seit langem gekanntes kapital-Bild von erstem Range, von der seltensten Ausführung und Erhaltung' (Long since a well-known capital painting of the first order, of exceptional execution and preservation)." [2] On a small piece of wood, inserted at the lower center of the cradle on the reverse of the panel, is painted all in red a monogram of the initials GR, surmounted by a crown, with a small V below the initials. These are the initials of King George V of Hanover. See Petersen 2009, 182-183: “The complete collection of paintings was sold to [King George V of Hannover] on 1 October 1857 for the--according to Hausmann’s (very accurate) opinion, not high--price of 48,000 Thaler, payable in annual installments of 5,000 Thaler, but it was to remain in Hausmann’s house until further notice. … Until the death of Hausmann [13 May 1873], [the painting collection] stayed in his house and was open to the public as the ‘George V Collection of Paintings’.” The painting’s owner and location was listed as “Hannover, Hausmann” by G. Parthey in _Deutscher Bildersaal – Verzeichniss der in Deutschland vorhandenen Oelbilder verstorbener Maler aller Schulen_, 2 vols. in 4, Berlin, 1864: 2:461, no. 135, which thus identified the work’s location, but not correctly its owner. [3 From 1866 until 1893, the royal collection was confiscated by the State of Prussia following the annexation of Hanover, and placed under the control of the Fideikommiss-Galerie des Gesamthauses Braunschwieg und Lüneburg. Despite the confiscation, from 1866 until Hausmann’s death in May 1873, the collection remained at his residence. For the timeline of the confiscation, see Helmut R. Leppien, “Die Bilder der Bürger,” in _Verschollener Ruhm – Bilder aus dem Depot der Landesgalerie Hannover zeigen den Kunstgeschmack des 19. Jahrhunderts_. Exh. cat. Kunstverein Hannover, 1975: 6, 9. From 1893, the painting was on long-term loan to the Provinzial-Museum Hannover as part of the “Cumberland-Galerie.” See _Katalog der zur Fideikommiss-Galerie des Gesamthauses Braunschwieg und Lüneburg gehörigen Sammlung von Gemälden und Skulpturen im Provinzial-Museum_, Hanover, 1905: 118, no. 357; https://hdl.handle.net/2027/gri.ark:/13960/t0vq6882x, accessed 30 June 2017. In _A Catalogue Raisonné of the Works of the Most Eminent Dutch Painters of the Seventeenth Century_, 8 vols., translated by Edward G. Hawke, London, 1907-1927: 4(1912):285, no. 925, Cornelis Hofstede de Groot erroneously lists the painting as actually belonging to the Provinzial-Museum instead of Ernst August II, the Duke of Cumberland.

  16. Pablo Picasso, A Glass on a Table, 1913

    Inventario 2014.136.164 · 19.05 × 24.13 cm · Corcoran Collection (Gift of Ingrid and Morton Leeds) · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Picasso, «Un vaso sobre una mesa»: pasó por Flechtheim y lo tenía en Alemania «by 1940» Lise Bernheimer Rheinstrom, judía, que emigró a La Habana. No se sabe de quién lo compró ni cuándo exacto. Falta saber de quién y cuándo la compró Lise Bernheimer Rheinstrom en Alemania (la carta de 1970 sólo dice «seit über 30 jahren»).

    «(Galerie Flechtheim, Düsseldorf).[2] Acquired in Germany by 1940 by Lise Bernheimer Rheinstrom [1902-1980], Munich, Havana, and New York» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «A Glass on a Table» (2014.136.164)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alfred Flechtheim: (Galerie Kahnweiler, Paris).[1] (Galerie Flechtheim, Düsseldorf).[2] Acquired in Germany by 1940 by Lise Bernheimer Rheinstrom [1902-1980], M…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Otto Bernheimer: …iler, Paris).[1] (Galerie Flechtheim, Düsseldorf).[2] Acquired in Germany by 1940 by Lise Bernheimer Rheinstrom [1902-1980], Munich, Havana, and New York;[3] by inheritance to her daughter,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Galerie Kahnweiler, Paris).[1] (Galerie Flechtheim, Düsseldorf).[2] Acquired in Germany by 1940 by Lise Bernheimer Rheinstrom [1902-1980], Munich, Havana, and New York;[3] by inheritance to her daughter, Ingrid Rheinstrom Leeds [1925-1997], New York and Bethesda; by inheritance to her husband, Morton Harold Leeds [1921-1998], Bethesda; his estate; gift 14 April 1998 to the Corcoran Gallery of Art, Washington; acquired 2014 by the National Gallery of Art. [1] A Kahnweiler sticker is on the painting's stretcher. The painting was possibly part of Daniel-Henry Kahnweiler's collection when it was sequestered by the French government after World War I, but It is unclear whether this painting was included in the Kahnweiler sales held between 1921 and 1923. [2] There is a Galerie Flechtheim sticker on the back of the painting's frame, probably dating from his time in Düsseldorf from 1913 to 1921. [3] In a letter dated September 1970 to Kahnweiler, Bernheimer Rheinstrom writes: "ich habe seit uber 30 jahren;" transcript in NGA curatorial files.

  17. Paul Gauguin, Te Pape Nave Nave (Delectable Waters), 1898

    Inventario 1973.68.2 · 74 × 95.3 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Gauguin, «Te Pape Nave Nave»: colección privada de Bernheim-Jeune hasta al menos 1935; Wildenstein la compró «directamente» a Bernheim-Jeune en 1947 según el catálogo del Wildenstein Plattner Institute. Las colecciones Bernheim-Jeune fueron saqueadas en la ocupación; la compra de 1947 sugiere que la conservaron, pero no se dice dónde estuvo. Falta un documento de Bernheim-Jeune o de Wildenstein que diga dónde estuvo la obra entre 1935 y 1947 (las colecciones Bernheim-Jeune fueron saqueadas en la ocupación).

    «The private collection of Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, by 1919 until at least 1935;[3] Acquired 1947 by (Wildenstein & Co., London, New York and Paris)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Te Pape Nave Nave (Delectable Waters)» (1973.68.2); Wildenstein Plattner Institute: Gauguin, «Te Pape Nave Nave» (citado por el museo)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: The artist until at least 1898.[1] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie, Paris).[2] The private collection of Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, by 1919 until at leas…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Bernheim-Jeune: …tist until at least 1898.[1] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie, Paris).[2] The private collection of Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, by 1919 until at least 1935;[3] Acquired 1947 by (Wildenstein & Co., London, New…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The artist until at least 1898.[1] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie, Paris).[2] The private collection of Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, by 1919 until at least 1935;[3] Acquired 1947 by (Wildenstein & Co., London, New York and Paris);[4] sold 1947 to Leigh B. [1905-1987] and Mary Lasker Block [1904-1981], Chicago,[5] until at least 1964.[6] Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, VA, by 1966;[7] gift 1973 to NGA. [1] According to the digital Gauguin catalogue raisonné of paintings 1891-1903 published by the Wildenstein-Plattner Institute in 2021, the painting was possibly on consignment with several dealers over the course of three months in 1898: George-Daniel de Monfreid in September; Georges-Alfred Chaudet in November; and Ambroise Vollard in November 1898. See entry for painting at https://digitalprojects.wpi.art/gauguin/artworks/detail?title=te%20pape%20nave&a=71741-te-pape-nave-nave [2] See the inventory list from the Rosenberg records (as _La scène religieuse_), available at the Musée d’Orsay website under Fonds de la galerie Rosenberg: https://www.musee-orsay.fr/en/node/199562 [3] The painting was published in Bernheim-Jeune's _L'Art Moderne et quelques aspects de l'art d'autrefois_ in 1919. It was lent in 1927 by Bernheim-Jeune to _The Classics of Modern Paintings_, at De Hauke & Co., New York, and then published by Bernheim-Jeune in Arsène Alexandre, _Paul Gauguin, sa vie et le sens de son oeuvre_ in 1930, and in Bernheim-Jeune's 1935 catalogue, _Quelques tableaux d'Ingres à Gauguin_, no. 7, reproduced. [4] According to the provenance on the Wildenstein-Plattner Institute's _Gauguin: Catalogue Raisonné of the Paintings 1891–1903_, Wildenstein acquired the work directly from Bernheim-Jeune (Reference number PGNWOI). See also letter dated 18 June 1999 from Wildenstein & Co., in NGA curatorial files. [5] See letter dated 18 June 1999 from Wildenstein & Co., in NGA curatorial files. [6] The painting was published as in the Block collection in Wildenstein's 1964 catalogue raisonné. It was not included in the 20 May 1981 sale of the Block collection held at Sotheby's, New York. [7] Exhibited with Paul Mellon Collection at the National Gallery of Art in 1966.

  18. Richard Parkes Bonington, Seapiece: Off the French Coast, c. 1823/1824

    Inventario 1982.55.1 · 37.7 × 52 cm · Paul Mellon Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Bonington, «Marina»: «Baron Henri de Rothschild» (colección saqueada por el ERR) y luego Astor, Londres, para 1951. Sin fechas; el museo cree que pudo heredarse de Charlotte de Rothschild. Falta la fecha en que Henri de Rothschild se desprendió de ella y cuándo la compró Astor (la colección de Henri de Rothschild fue saqueada por el ERR).

    «Baron Henri de Rothschild. John, 1st Baron Astor of Hever [1866-1971], Hever Castle, Kent, by 1951» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Seapiece: Off the French Coast» (1982.55.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Henri de Rothschild: Baron Henri de Rothschild. John, 1st Baron Astor of Hever [1866-1971], Hever Castle, Kent, by 1951;[1] by descent,…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Baron Henri de Rothschild: Baron Henri de Rothschild. John, 1st Baron Astor of Hever [1866-1971], Hever Castle, Kent, by 1951;[1] by descent,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Baron Henri de Rothschild. John, 1st Baron Astor of Hever [1866-1971], Hever Castle, Kent, by 1951;[1] by descent, through his wife, Lady Violet Nairne [d. 1965], to George, 8th Marquess of Lansdowne [b. 1912];[2] sold 1979 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, London); purchased February 1980 by Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, Upperville, Virginia; gift 1982 to NGA. [1] Possibly inherited from his grandmother, Charlotte [1824-1899], who owned a number of Boningtons, according to letter from the Rothschild Archive dated 30 July 1998 in NGA curatorial files. The painting is listed in _The First Hundred Years of the Royal Academy 1769-1868_, Royal Academy, (London, 1951-1952), 94, no. 208, as "Lent by Colonel the Hon. J.J. Astor". [2] Son of the Lady Violet, Baroness Astor of Hever, by her first marriage to Lord Charles George Francis Mercer Nairne (killed in World War I), according to Townsend, Peter, ed., _Burke's Peerage and Baronetage_, 104th ed. (London, 1967), 122, 1446.

  19. Workshop of Hans Mielich, Christ in Limbo, c. 1550/1575

    Inventario 1952.5.85 · 108.4 × 41.2 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Con su par 1952.5.84 (Crucifixión). Stefan von Auspitz, banquero judío vienés (m. 1945): según el museo, estas dos tablas no entraron en la venta de 1931 y quedaron «held as security at the firm of Fa. Bäume in Vienna». Después, nada hasta Rosenberg & Stiebel, Nueva York, en 1951. El hueco cubre la Viena de 1938. No encontramos pedido en Lost Art ni registro en la base; hay que preguntar al museo y a la Comisión austríaca de procedencia. Falta el documento de la firma Bäume de Viena (o de los acreedores) sobre a quién y cuándo se entregaron las tablas entre 1931 y 1951, y la factura de Rosenberg & Stiebel con el vendedor.

    «Instead they were held as security at the firm of Fa. Bäume in Vienna.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Christ in Limbo» (1952.5.85)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Otto Fröhlich: …mmunication from Lilly Fröhlich, London, 1956, in NGA curatorial files, which states that Otto Fröhlich acquired the paintings in 1916 from an unspecified museum in Breslau through de Burlet an…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly a museum in Breslau (now Wroclaw).[1] (Charles de Burlet, Berlin, 1916.); Dr. Otto Fröhlich, Vienna, 1916;[2] sold to Stefan Auspitz [1869-1945], Vienna, until 1931.[3] (Rosenberg & Stiebel, Inc., New York, owned jointly with Pinakos, Inc. [Rudolf Heinemann], by 1951);[4] purchased 1951 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[5] gift 1952 by exchange to NGA. [1] Unverified. There are no records of the paintings having been in the Muzeum Narodowe, letter of 11 April 1989 from Mariusz Hermansdorfer to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files, or the Muzeum Archidiecezjalne, letter of 25 June 1989 from Józef Pater to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files. [2] Memorandum of a communication from Lilly Fröhlich, London, 1956, in NGA curatorial files, which states that Otto Fröhlich acquired the paintings in 1916 from an unspecified museum in Breslau through de Burlet and sold them to Stefan von Auspitz. [3]Stefan Auspitz was a Viennese banker who was forced by the Austrian financial crisis of 1931 to forfeit most of his collection to creditors of the Austrian government, by whom it was sold to the Dutch collector van Beuningen, who consigned the works for sale over a period of time through the Bachstitz gallery. This painting and its companion, 1952.5.84, do not appear to have been part of those transactions. Instead they were held as security at the firm of Fa. Bäume in Vienna. [4] Letter of 13 April 1989 from Gerald G. Stiebel to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files. The invoice is dated 23 October 1951. [5] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/520.

  20. Workshop of Hans Mielich, The Crucifixion, c. 1550/1575

    Inventario 1952.5.84 · 107.5 × 41 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Pendiente de documentos. Con su par 1952.5.85 (Cristo en el Limbo). Stefan von Auspitz, banquero judío vienés (m. 1945): según el museo, estas dos tablas no entraron en la venta de 1931 y quedaron «held as security at the firm of Fa. Bäume in Vienna». Después, nada hasta Rosenberg & Stiebel, Nueva York, en 1951. El hueco cubre la Viena de 1938. No encontramos pedido en Lost Art ni registro en la base; hay que preguntar al museo y a la Comisión austríaca de procedencia. Falta lo mismo que en 1952.5.85: el registro de Fa. Bäume y el vendedor a Rosenberg & Stiebel.

    «Instead they were held as security at the firm of Fa. Bäume in Vienna.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Crucifixion» (1952.5.84)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Otto Fröhlich: …mmunication from Lilly Fröhlich, London, 1956, in NGA curatorial files, which states that Otto Fröhlich acquired the paintings in 1916 from an unspecified museum in Breslau through de Burlet an…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly a museum in Breslau (now Wroclaw).[1] (Charles de Burlet, Berlin, 1916); Dr. Otto Fröhlich, Vienna, 1916;[2] sold to Stefan Auspitz [1869-1945], Vienna, until 1931.[3] (Rosenberg & Stiebel, Inc., New York, owned jointly with Pinakos, Inc. [Rudolf Heinemann], by 1951);[4] purchased 1951 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[5] gift 1952 by exchange to NGA. [1] Unverified. There are no records of the paintings having been in the Muzeum Narodowe, letter of 11 April 1989 from Mariusz Hermansdorfer to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files, or the Muzeum Archidiecezjalne, letter of 25 June 1989 from Józef Pater to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files. [2] Memorandum of a communication from Lilly Fröhlich, London, 1956, in NGA curatorial files, which states that Otto Fröhlich acquired the paintings in 1916 from an unspecified museum in Breslau through de Burlet and sold them to Stefan von Auspitz. [3]Stefan Auspitz was a Viennese banker who was forced by the Austrian financial crisis of 1931 to forfeit most of his collection to creditors of the Austrian government, by whom it was sold to the Dutch collector van Beuningen, who consigned the works for sale over a period of time through the Bachstitz gallery. This painting and its companion, 1952.5.85, do not appear to have been part of those transactions. Instead they were held as security at the firm of Fa. Bäume in Vienna. [4] Letter of 13 April 1989 from Gerald G. Stiebel to John Hand, in NGA curatorial files. The invoice is dated 23 October 1951. [5] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/2118.

Resueltos por el museo · 41

La obra tuvo un pasado de saqueo o de venta forzada, y el museo lo investigó y lo cuenta: restitución, acuerdo con los herederos o compra a ellos.

  1. Caspar Netscher, A Woman Feeding a Parrot, with a Page, 1666

    Inventario 2016.118.1 · 45.7 × 36.2 cm · The Lee and Juliet Folger Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Confiscado por el ERR a la colección Andriesse en 1941 (ERR HA 9). En 2014 el Von der Heydt-Museum de Wuppertal lo restituyó a los herederos de Hugo y Elisabeth Andriesse, que lo vendieron en Christie's Nueva York; la National Gallery lo compró en 2016 a un marchante de Londres. Lo cuenta en su procedencia. Caso ya publicado en limbral.

    «by 1938.[8] (Kunsthandlung Abels, Cologne), in 1950; Rudolf Ziersch [1887-1962], Wuppertal; gift 1952 to the Von der Heydt-Museum, Wuppertal;[9] restituted 2014 to the heirs of Hugo and Elisabeth Andriesse;[10] (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods, New York, 4 June 2014, no. 16); (Richard» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «A Woman Feeding a Parrot, with a Page» (2016.118.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel alta)
    • Número de inventario del saqueo (ERR HA 9): …of the Andriesse collection on 3 December 1941 by the Einsatztab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR no. HA 9), and on 12 March 1942 transferred to the Jeu de Paume, in Paris. On 20 March 1944 it was… → Frau mit Papagei. (restituida)
    • Marchante del saqueo: Theodor Fischer: …1932 to the Kunsthandel AG Lucerne (a sibling firm of Böhler) with a half share owned by Theodor Fischer. However, Lucerne index card L 10404 (http://boehler.zikg.eu/content/604f5b931415b), whic…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Julius Böhler: …avarian collections; transfered 1836 to the Alte Pinakothek, Munich;[5] traded 1936 with (Julius Böhler, Munich/Kunsthandlung AG Lucerne and the Galerie Fischer, Lucerne) in exchange for a pain…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Hermann Goering: …e Jeu de Paume, in Paris. On 20 March 1944 it was acquired for the Nazi’s Reichsmarschall Hermann Goering (RM no. 1203), and transferred to Goering’s “Kurfürst” bunker, a command center for the N…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Ernst Buchner: …ook place in 1936. Furthermore, a postwar accounting of the exchange in the papers of Dr. Ernst Buchner, former General Director of the Staatliche Gemäldesammlung, Munich, also confirmed the 19…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Galerie Fischer: …thek, Munich;[5] traded 1936 with (Julius Böhler, Munich/Kunsthandlung AG Lucerne and the Galerie Fischer, Lucerne) in exchange for a painting by Giuseppe Maria Crespi;(6) sold 1 January 1937 to…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: ERR: …of the Andriesse collection on 3 December 1941 by the Einsatztab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR no. HA 9), and on 12 March 1942 transferred to the Jeu de Paume, in Paris. On 20 March 19…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Jeu de Paume (depósito del ERR): …Einsatztab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR no. HA 9), and on 12 March 1942 transferred to the Jeu de Paume, in Paris. On 20 March 1944 it was acquired for the Nazi’s Reichsmarschall Hermann Goerin…
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: confiscación: …ing in New York. After the Germans occupied Belgium during World War II, the painting was confiscated with the rest of the Andriesse collection on 3 December 1941 by the Einsatztab Reichsle…
    • Menciona una restitución: restitución: …dolf Ziersch [1887-1962], Wuppertal; gift 1952 to the Von der Heydt-Museum, Wuppertal;[9] restituted 2014 to the heirs of Hugo and Elisabeth Andriesse;[10] (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods,…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Kunsthandel Katz (Nathan y Benjamin Katz): …ne) in exchange for a painting by Giuseppe Maria Crespi;(6) sold 1 January 1937 to (Firma D. Katz, Dieren, Netherlands).[7] Hugo Daniel [1867-1942] and Elisabeth J. Spanjaard [1871-1963]…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Elisabeth Andriesse: …med. The painting was number 659 in the Von der Heydt-Museum collection. [10] Hugo and Elisabeth Andriesse had no children; the heirs were the charities named in Mrs. Andriesse's will.
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Gerrit Uylenburgh: The artist.[1] Purchased 1674 for 140 guilders by (Gerrit Uylenburgh [1625 – 1679], Amsterdam);[2] consigned by 19 April 1675 to Sir Peter Lely [1618-1680], L…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The artist.[1] Purchased 1674 for 140 guilders by (Gerrit Uylenburgh [1625 – 1679], Amsterdam);[2] consigned by 19 April 1675 to Sir Peter Lely [1618-1680], London.[3] possibly Pierre Plongeron [d. 1694], The Hague.[4] Johann Wilhelm II [1658-1716], Elector Palatine, Düsseldorf; by inheritance to Karl III Philipp [1661-1742], Elector Palatine, and transferred 1730 with the collection to the elector’s palace in Mannheim; by inheritance to Karl Theodor [1724-1799], Elector Palatine and Elector of Bavaria, Mannheim and Munich; transferred 1799 to Royal Bavarian collections; transfered 1836 to the Alte Pinakothek, Munich;[5] traded 1936 with (Julius Böhler, Munich/Kunsthandlung AG Lucerne and the Galerie Fischer, Lucerne) in exchange for a painting by Giuseppe Maria Crespi;(6) sold 1 January 1937 to (Firma D. Katz, Dieren, Netherlands).[7] Hugo Daniel [1867-1942] and Elisabeth J. Spanjaard [1871-1963] Andriesse, Brussels, by 1938.[8] (Kunsthandlung Abels, Cologne), in 1950; Rudolf Ziersch [1887-1962], Wuppertal; gift 1952 to the Von der Heydt-Museum, Wuppertal;[9] restituted 2014 to the heirs of Hugo and Elisabeth Andriesse;[10] (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods, New York, 4 June 2014, no. 16); (Richard Green Fine Paintings, London); purchased October 2016 by NGA. [1] Inscribed on the verso of the _ricordo_ (study drawing) for the painting (now in the Department of Prints and Drawings, British Museum, London, number Oo,11.250), in the artist’s hand, is the following: “Het steen byde Jonge moet hee.. maeesen / gelyck aende andre zyde / Geschildert voor h..d..[crossed out] guldens / 1666” (The stone[work] next to the boy [possibly ‘has to be whole’] / just like the other side / Painted for h..d..[crossed out] guilders / 1666). The “h” can only stand for “honderd” (hundred), while the “d” represents either the middle “d” of the word honderd, or the start of the word “dertig” (thirty), indicating that the artist sold the painting for either one hundred or one hundred and thirty guilders. See: Marjorie E. Wieseman, _Caspar Netscher and Late Seventeenth-Century Dutch Painting, Doornspijk_, 2002: 207, no. 54. [2] Uylenburgh was both a painter and an art dealer, having taken over the business of his father, Hendrick Uylenburgh (1584/1589-1661). Following a dispute over the sale of art to the Elector of Brandenburg in the early 1670s, Uylenburgh’s fortunes declined and claims by creditors resulted in his case being referred to the Amsterdam Bankruptcy Chamber in early 1675. In April a complete inventory and appraisal of his possessions, including paintings, was made, in which Uylenburgh lists as no. 89 “Young woman with a parrot by Netscher, the same as I paid in cash last year – 140” (Amsterdam Municipal Archives, archive o.5072, inv. no. 1573, item 340; the appraisal is undated, but the accompanying agreement between Uylenurgh and his creditors is dated 19 April 1675). See Friso Lammertse and Jaap van der Veen, _Uylenburgh & Son: Art and Commerce from Rembrandt to De Lairesse_, 1625-1675, Zwolle and Amsterdam, 2006: 301-302, no. 89, 303 n. 1, 305 n. 84. [3] In the appraisal of 1675 (see note 2), the Netscher is included in a list of eight paintings described as being “with Mr. Pieter Lelij in England.” Lely trained as a painter in Haarlem and left for England in 1641. Appointed court painter to King Charles II in 1661, he was also an art collector as well as being known as a “trusty and well beloved friend” of the Uylenburgh family; he served as their representative when Gerrit’s brother Abraham died in Dublin in 1668. See: Lammertse and Van der Veen 2006, 70, 77. The eight paintings seem to have been with Lely on commission, and he may have purchased one or more for his own collection, although the Netscher does not appear to be listed in the catalogue of Lely’s collection when it was sold at auction on 18 April 1682, unless it was one of the many paintings titled _A Woman_. See: Diana Dethloff, “The Executors’ Account Book and the Dispersal of Sir Peter Lely’s Collection,” _Journal of the History of Collections_ 8, no. 1 (1996): 15-51. [4] Plongeron was agent and chamberlain to the Elector Palatinate. His estate inventory of 27 September 1694 lists “een vrouwtien geschildert op peneel met papegaij op de hant, van Netsgaer” (a woman on panel with parrot on the hand, by Netsger). See: Wieseman 2002, 207, no. 54, 142, document 98 (incorrectly indicated as document 95 on p. 207). [5] The painting was published an undated inventory (1719?) of the Elector’s collection, _Detail des Peintures du Cabinet Électoral de Dusseldorff_, no. 80. It then appears in the lower left corner of a 1731 drawing of the Elector’s picture cabinet in Mannheim made by Jan Philips van der Schlichten (Paris, Institut national d’histoire de l'art, inv./cat.nr. MS 409) and was published in the 1736 catalogue of the Mannheim cabinet, _Detail des Peintures des deux Cabinets Électoraux à Mannheim_, no. 71. The painting was inventory no. 417 in the collection of the Alte Pinakothek (catalogue number 1399 in museum publications up through 1930). [6] Various documents in the Archiv Julius Böhler, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, Munich (copies in NGA curatorial files) for the Netscher and the Italian painting it was exchanged for (originally identified as by Pietro Longhi) present an uncertain timeline for the Netscher leaving the Pinakothek. Both an annotated photograph (http://boehler.zikg.eu/content/604f5d4342c2f) and index card number K 183-32 (http://boehler.zikg.eu/content/6048fa545a7c4) suggest that the painting may have been sent already in 1931 or 1932 to the Kunsthandel AG Lucerne (a sibling firm of Böhler) with a half share owned by Theodor Fischer. However, Lucerne index card L 10404 (http://boehler.zikg.eu/content/604f5b931415b), which documents the subsequent 1937 sale of the Netscher painting, confirms the exchange for the Crespi painting took place in 1936. Furthermore, a postwar accounting of the exchange in the papers of Dr. Ernst Buchner, former General Director of the Staatliche Gemäldesammlung, Munich, also confirmed the 1936 date (Bayerisches Hauptstaatsarchiv, Munich, MK 44778, copy in NGA curatorial files) The Netscher no longer appears in the 1936 Alte Pinakothek collection catalogue. [7] See index card no. L 10404 in the Archiv Böhler, ZI (permalink in footnote 6). Katz included the painting in an exhibition of Dutch art from 3 July to 15 September 1937 (no. 56). [8] Hugo Andriesse, a Dutch industrialist and philanthropist living in Brussels, lent the painting to an exhibition in Rotterdam that opened in late 1938 (on Andriesse, see email dated 26 August 2022 from family member in curatorial file). In 1939 he deposited it, with other paintings from his collection, with the Musées Royaux des Beaux-Arts, Brussels, before fleeing Europe with his wife and eventually settling in New York. After the Germans occupied Belgium during World War II, the painting was confiscated with the rest of the Andriesse collection on 3 December 1941 by the Einsatztab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR no. HA 9), and on 12 March 1942 transferred to the Jeu de Paume, in Paris. On 20 March 1944 it was acquired for the Nazi’s Reichsmarschall Hermann Goering (RM no. 1203), and transferred to Goering’s “Kurfürst” bunker, a command center for the Nazi Luftwaffe, in Potsdam. See the record for the painting at the Cultural Plunder by the ERR website: https://www.errproject.org/jeudepaume/ (accessed 30 June 2017). [9] How and when the Kunsthandlung Abels acquired the painting is not known. The 1985 catalogue of 17th-century Dutch paintings in the Von der Heydt-Museum, Wuppertal, lists the Wallraf-Richartz-Museum in Cologne in the provenance; this has not yet been confirmed. The painting was number 659 in the Von der Heydt-Museum collection. [10] Hugo and Elisabeth Andriesse had no children; the heirs were the charities named in Mrs. Andriesse's will.

  2. Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller, The Cartographer Professor Josef Jüttner and His Wife, 1824

    Inventario 2006.157.1 · 40.5 × 32.5 cm · Gift of Marlene, Paul and John Herring · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Hay una versión casi igual que compró Hitler para el museo de Linz y que sigue en custodia del Estado alemán. La National Gallery explica en su procedencia que la de Linz es la otra versión, no la suya. Caso ya publicado en limbral.

    «_Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller 1793-1865_, Vienna and Munich, 1996: no. 137, the Eissler picture was later acquired by Hitler's Sonderauftrag Linz. However, this Linz provenance should be associated instead with Feuchtmüller no. 136, "Portrait of a Cartographer and his Wife," now» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Cartographer Professor Josef Jüttner and His Wife» (2006.157.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel alta)
    • Número de inventario del saqueo (Linz 2306): …lecting Point as no. 9536. The property card for no. 9536 indicates that the painting was Linz no. 2306 and had been acquired for Linz from the Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, in 1942 (copy in NGA c… → Bildnis eines Ehepaars (Prof. Jüttner, Kartograph) (hallada sin restituir)
    • Número de inventario del saqueo (Collecting Point de Múnich 9536): …government after World War II and still in German Federal custody. On the website the Waldmüller is listed as Munich no. 9536, meaning that it was recovered by the Allies and processed through the Munich Central Col… → Bildnis eines Ehepaars (Prof. Jüttner, Kartograph) (hallada sin restituir)
    • Número de inventario del saqueo (Collecting Point de Múnich 9536): …as Munich no. 9536, meaning that it was recovered by the Allies and processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point as no. 9536. The property card for no. 9536 indicates that the painting was Linz no. 2306 and had bee… → Bildnis eines Ehepaars (Prof. Jüttner, Kartograph) (hallada sin restituir)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Bildnis eines Ehepaars (Prof. Jüttner, Kartograph) (hallada sin restituir) — mismo artista; medidas casi idénticas (41.0×33.0 vs 40.5×32.5 cm); título en común (juttner, kartograph≈cartographer) · puntaje 80
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Sonderauftrag Linz: …65_, Vienna and Munich, 1996: no. 137, the Eissler picture was later acquired by Hitler's Sonderauftrag Linz. However, this Linz provenance should be associated instead with Feuchtmüller no. 136, "P…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: número de Linz: …lecting Point as no. 9536. The property card for no. 9536 indicates that the painting was Linz no. 2306 and had been acquired for Linz from the Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, in 1942 (copy in…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Central Collecting Point: …ch no. 9536, meaning that it was recovered by the Allies and processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point as no. 9536. The property card for no. 9536 indicates that the painting was Linz no. 2306…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: número del Central Collecting Point de Múnich: …ld War II and still in German Federal custody. On the website the Waldmüller is listed as Munich no. 9536, meaning that it was recovered by the Allies and processed through the Munich Centr…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Vally Roeren (Honig): …. The name Honig may refer to the Jewish Viennese collectors Josef (d. 1930) and Vally Honig. Vally had remarried in 1938, to a Norwegian; nonetheless she was deported to the Auschwi…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Galerie Sanct Lucas: …536 indicates that the painting was Linz no. 2306 and had been acquired for Linz from the Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, in 1942 (copy in NGA curatorial files). The picture was turned over to the Germa…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Sonderauftrag Linz: …65_, Vienna and Munich, 1996: no. 137, the Eissler picture was later acquired by Hitler's Sonderauftrag Linz. However, this Linz provenance should be associated instead with Feuchtmüller no. 136, "P…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly (sale, Wawra, Vienna, 17 December 1900, no. 204). Dr. Hermann [1860-1953] and Dr. Gottfried [1862-1924] Eissler, Vienna, by 1908.[1] Possibly Honig collection, Vienna. (sale, Wawra, Vienna, 17 March 1917, no. 165).[2] Acquired 1970s in Switzerland by John and Paul Herring, New York. [1] The picture is first associated with the Eissler collection of Vienna in Arthur Roessler, _Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller_, Vienna, 1908. According to Rupert Feuchtmüller, _Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller 1793-1865_, Vienna and Munich, 1996: no. 137, the Eissler picture was later acquired by Hitler's Sonderauftrag Linz. However, this Linz provenance should be associated instead with Feuchtmüller no. 136, "Portrait of a Cartographer and his Wife," now in the possession of the Westfälisches Landesmuseum in Münster. No. 136 is another version of the dual portrait from the same year with almost identical dimensions as the NGA picture. Although similar, the compositions are distinguished by the dress of the woman, what she is holding in her hand, and the background, among several other differences. Feuchtmüller no. 136 is illustrated on the website lostart.de, which lists those objects returned from the Allies to the German government after World War II and still in German Federal custody. On the website the Waldmüller is listed as Munich no. 9536, meaning that it was recovered by the Allies and processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point as no. 9536. The property card for no. 9536 indicates that the painting was Linz no. 2306 and had been acquired for Linz from the Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, in 1942 (copy in NGA curatorial files). The picture was turned over to the German government in 1948 and remains the property of the Federal government, on loan to the Münster museum. This information is confirmed by communication with Birgit Schwarz, author of _Hitler's Museum_, in which the Waldmüller figures as no. XVI/34. There is no doubt that the Feuchtmüller catalogue erroneously associates the Eissler picture with the version that was in the Linz collection. [2] The NGA, Feuchtmüller no. 137, figures in a 1917 sale at Wawra, Vienna, of an "important Viennese collector." In a copy of the catalogue in the archives of the Österreichische Galerie Belvedere, Vienna, the painting is annotated as having sold for 26.000 Kronen. The files at the Belvedere also include another annotation to this sale as follows: "Auktion Wawra 1917 (Honig)." This suggests that Honig was either the buyer or the seller in 1917. In either case, the picture would have left the Eissler collection by that time. In Frimmel's 1913 _Lexikon der Wiener Gemäldesammlungen_ it is already noted that of the many Waldmüllers owned by the Eisslers, some had already left the collection. The 1925 estate sale of Dr. Gottfried Eissler included several Waldmüllers, but not the one in question, and there is no reason to suspect that the Waldmüller re-entered the Eissler collection after 1917. The name Honig may refer to the Jewish Viennese collectors Josef (d. 1930) and Vally Honig. Vally had remarried in 1938, to a Norwegian; nonetheless she was deported to the Auschwitz concentration camp in 1942. The director of the Österrichische Galerie, Bruno Grimschitz, prepared the property declaration of her collection, which included a few Waldmüllers, but not the one in question (see Sophie Lillie, _Was Einmal War_, Vienna, 2003: 521-523), and as Grimschitz was an expert on Waldmüller's work, there is little chance he would have misidentified the paintings in the Honig collection at the time of Mrs. Honig's deportation. It is therefore possible that Honig was the seller of the painting in question in 1917. In 1957 Grimschitz lists the location of the painting in question as unknown (_Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller_, Salzburg, 1957: 287, no. 130).

  3. Pierre Bonnard, Work Table, 1926/1937

    Inventario 2006.128.12 · 121.9 × 91.4 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Saqueada por el ERR a Paul Rosenberg, pasó por la colección Göring y el Collecting Point de Múnich, y en 1946 se expuso en París entre las obras recuperadas. La National Gallery lo cuenta en su procedencia. Caso ya publicado en limbral.

    «1937 from the artist by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris); sold to Pierre Loeb.[1] Paul Rosenberg, Paris.[2] private collection, Switzerland, in 1965. Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia; bequest 1999 to NGA, with» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Work Table» (2006.128.12)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel alta)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Work Table (hallada sin restituir) — mismo artista; medidas idénticas (121.9×91.4 vs 121.9×91.4 cm); mismo título; la procedencia del lote nombra a Paul Rosenberg (misma colección, no la misma tela) · puntaje 100
    • Marchante del saqueo: Gustav Rochlitz: …/Entry 73/Box 78, copy in NGA curatorial files). Goering traded the picture to the dealer Gustav Rochlitz, from whom it was recovered after the war. The records of the Munich Central Collecting P…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Hermann Göring: …lection, 15 September 1945, Attachment 5, Liste der für die Sammlung des Reichsmarschalls Hermann Göring abgegebenen Kunstgegenstände, dated 20 October 1942, 1 Nachtrag, no. 31, National Archive…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Hermann Goering: …from the National Archives in Washington indicate that the painting had been selected by Hermann Goering on 9 July 1941 from the Jeu de Paume (OSS Consolidated Interrogation Report #2, The Goeri…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: ERR (Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg): …uring World War II the painting was confiscated from the Rosenberg collection by the Nazi Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR). Documents from the National Archives in Washington indicate…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: ERR: …confiscated from the Rosenberg collection by the Nazi Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR). Documents from the National Archives in Washington indicate that the painting had been…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Jeu de Paume (depósito del ERR): …n indicate that the painting had been selected by Hermann Goering on 9 July 1941 from the Jeu de Paume (OSS Consolidated Interrogation Report #2, The Goering Collection, 15 September 1945, Att…
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Central Collecting Point: …aler Gustav Rochlitz, from whom it was recovered after the war. The records of the Munich Central Collecting Point indicate that the painting was restituted to France on 27 March 1946 (Munich property car…
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: confiscación: …e raisonné_, 4 vols., Paris, 1966: no. 1356. [2] During World War II the painting was confiscated from the Rosenberg collection by the Nazi Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR). Doc…
    • Menciona una restitución: restitución: …he war. The records of the Munich Central Collecting Point indicate that the painting was restituted to France on 27 March 1946 (Munich property card #8046, National Archives RG260/Box 503…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Bernheim-Jeune: Acquired 1937 from the artist by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris); sold to Pierre Loeb.[1] Paul Rosenberg, Paris.[2] private collection, Switzerlan…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Acquired 1937 from the artist by (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris); sold to Pierre Loeb.[1] Paul Rosenberg, Paris.[2] private collection, Switzerland, in 1965. Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia; bequest 1999 to NGA, with life interest to Mrs. Mellon; life interest released 2006. [1] Early provenance and Swiss collection per Jean Dauberville, _Bonnard: catalogue raisonné_, 4 vols., Paris, 1966: no. 1356. [2] During World War II the painting was confiscated from the Rosenberg collection by the Nazi Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR). Documents from the National Archives in Washington indicate that the painting had been selected by Hermann Goering on 9 July 1941 from the Jeu de Paume (OSS Consolidated Interrogation Report #2, The Goering Collection, 15 September 1945, Attachment 5, Liste der für die Sammlung des Reichsmarschalls Hermann Göring abgegebenen Kunstgegenstände, dated 20 October 1942, 1 Nachtrag, no. 31, National Archives RG239/Entry 73/Box 78, copy in NGA curatorial files). Goering traded the picture to the dealer Gustav Rochlitz, from whom it was recovered after the war. The records of the Munich Central Collecting Point indicate that the painting was restituted to France on 27 March 1946 (Munich property card #8046, National Archives RG260/Box 503, copies in NGA curatorial files). It was exhibited in 1946 in _Les Chefs-d'oeuvre des collections privées françaises retrouvés en Allemagne par la Commission de Récuperation artistique et les Services allies_, no. 52.

  4. Aelbert Cuyp, River Landscape with Cows, 1645/1650

    Inventario 1986.70.1 · 68 × 90.2 cm · Gift of Family Petschek (Aussig) · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Fue de Ignaz Petschek, de la familia judía de industriales checos. Pasó por herencia a su hijo Frank, que emigró a Nueva York, y a sus nietas, que lo donaron en 1986. Nunca salió de la familia. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «by inheritance to his son, Frank C. Petschek [d. 1963], Aussig (Ústí nad Labem), and New York;[6] by inheritance to his daughters» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «River Landscape with Cows» (1986.70.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ignaz Petschek: …3] possibly (Steinmeyer, Lucerne), in 1923;[4] (Paul Cassirer & Co., Berlin), by 1924.[5] Ignaz Petschek, Aussig (Ústí nad Labem), Czechoslovakia, by 1927; by inheritance to his son, Frank C. Pe…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Caroline Anne, 4th marchioness of Ely [1856-1917, née Caroline Anne Caithness], Eversley Park, Winchmore Hill, London; (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods, London, 3 August 1917, no. 43); (C. Huggins, London);[1] sold 9 August 1917 to (Thos. Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London, and the dealer H.M. Clark); sold September 1919 to Gaston Neuman, Brussels.[2] (sale, Frederik Muller & Co., Amsterdam, 30 November–6 December 1920, 1st day, no. 1024, bought in); (Frederik Muller & Co., Amsterdam), until at least 1922;[3] possibly (Steinmeyer, Lucerne), in 1923;[4] (Paul Cassirer & Co., Berlin), by 1924.[5] Ignaz Petschek, Aussig (Ústí nad Labem), Czechoslovakia, by 1927; by inheritance to his son, Frank C. Petschek [d. 1963], Aussig (Ústí nad Labem), and New York;[6] by inheritance to his daughters, Elisabeth de Picciotto, New York, and Maria Petschek Smith, Falls Church, Virginia; gift 1986 to NGA. [1] Letter, 12 November 1952, Christie, Manson & Woods Ltd. to Frank Petschek, copy in NGA curatorial files. [2] Many details of the provenance, in particular the specifics of Agnew’s ownership and sale of the painting, were researched by Alan Chong, and provided to Arthur Wheelock in letters from 1988 and 1990 (some undated), in NGA curatorial files. [3] Muller lent the painting to exhibitions in 1921 and 1922. [4] Steinmeyer’s possible ownership is cited in the files at the Rijksbureau voor Kunsthistorische Documentatie, The Hague; see their letter of 21 April 1951 to Frank Petschek, copy in NGA curatorial files. [5] Cassirer lent the painting to a 1924 exhibition. [6] The picture was removed from Czechoslovakia in, or shortly before, 1938 by Frank Petschek.

  5. Alfred Sisley, Meadow, 1875

    Inventario 1970.17.83 · 54.9 × 73 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Jules Strauss la vendió en 1902; desde 1933 era del senador argentino Antonio Santamarina, en Buenos Aires. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Jules Strauss [1861-1943], Paris; (Strauss sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 3 May 1902, no. 60)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Meadow» (1970.17.83)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Bernheim-Jeune: …aris, 4 May 1899, no. 224); purchased by (Durand-Ruel, New York and Paris); sold 1900 to (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris). Jules Strauss [1861-1943], Paris; (Strauss sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 3 May 1902…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Armand-François-Paul des Frisches, Comte Doria [1824-1896], Paris; (his sale, Galeries Georges Petit, Paris, 4 May 1899, no. 224); purchased by (Durand-Ruel, New York and Paris); sold 1900 to (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris). Jules Strauss [1861-1943], Paris; (Strauss sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 3 May 1902, no. 60); purchased by Joubert, possibly for (Galeries Georges Petit, Paris)[1] Senator Antonio Santamarina, Buenos Aires, by 1933;[2] sold 1957 to (Wildenstein and Co., New York);[3] by whom sold 4 October 1957 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York;[4] bequest 1970 to NGA. [1] Joubert is recorded as purchaser in an annotated copy of sales catalogue in NGA curatorial files, and in the _Gazette de l'Hotel Drouot_. Galerie Georges Petit according to Françoise Daulte, _Alfred Sisley, Catalogue Raisonné de l'oeuvre peint_, Lausanne, 1959, no. 190. [2] Santamarina lent _Meadow_ (_La Prairie_) to an exhibition in Buenos Aires in 1933. It was included in the 3-5 October 1955 sale of the Santamarina collection held at Adolfo Bullrich Y Cia in Buenos Aires, no. 79. [3] Wildenstein date and source of acquisition according to letter dated 14 December 1998, in NGA curatorial files. [4] Receipt dated 4 October 1957 from Wildenstein to Mrs. Bruce, in NGA curatorial files.

  6. André Derain, Charing Cross Bridge, London, 1906

    Inventario 1982.76.3 · 80.3 × 100.3 cm · John Hay Whitney Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. La marchante Käthe Perls, judía alemana emigrada a París, la compró allí entre 1932 y 1938 y probablemente ella misma se la vendió a Walter Chrysler, que la tenía en 1939. La vendedora era la perseguida, en Francia y antes de la guerra. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Acquired in Paris between 1932 and 1938 by Mme. Kaethe Perls, Paris;[5] possibly by whom sold to Walter P. Chrysler, Jr., New York, Warrenton and Richmond, VA, who owned the painting by 1939» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Charing Cross Bridge, London» (1982.76.3)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ambroise Vollard: From the artist 1906 to (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris);[1] sold December 1918 through Walter Pach and (Carroll Galleries, Ne…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    From the artist 1906 to (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris);[1] sold December 1918 through Walter Pach and (Carroll Galleries, New York) to John Quinn [1870-1924], New York;[2] his estate; probably from which purchased by (Paul Guillaume [1891-1934], Paris); sold 1927 to (Alex Reid & Lefèvre, Glasgow and London);[3] sold 1931 to (Galerie Etienne Bignou, Paris); sold 1932 to G. Keller, Paris for (M. Knoedler and Co., London, New York and Paris).[4] Acquired in Paris between 1932 and 1938 by Mme. Kaethe Perls, Paris;[5] possibly by whom sold to Walter P. Chrysler, Jr., New York, Warrenton and Richmond, VA, who owned the painting by 1939;[6] (Chrysler sale, part II, Parke-Bernet Galleries, New York, 16 February 1950, no. 54); (Julius H. Weitzner [1896-1986], London); sold 12 April 1950 to John Hay Whitney [1904-1982], Manhasset, New York;[7] deeded 1982 to the John Hay Whitney Charitable Trust, New York; gift 1982 to NGA. [1] Receipt to Vollard from Derain dated 6 July 1906 in Vollard Archives, Documentation, Musée d'Orsay, Paris (microfilm reel III, copy in NGA curatorial files). [2] Judith Zilczer, _"The Noble Buyer:" John Quinn, Patron of the Avant-Garde_, Washington, D.C., 1978: 155. [3] Letter dated 27 July 1984 from Alex Reid & Lefevre, in NGA curatorial files, outlines ownership between Guillaume and Knoedler. [4] This may be the painting which figured in Knoedler's 1933 exhibition of paintings from the Vollard Collection. [5] According to handwritten note from Klaus Perls in response to letter dated 11 July 1984 from the National Gallery of Art, Perls' mother, Kaethe, acquired the painting in Paris between 1932-1938. [6] Lent by Chrysler to the 1939 San Francisco exhibition. [7] See letter dated 26 July 1984 from John Rewald, in NGA curatorial files. Receipt from Weitzner dated 12 April 1950 in NGA curatorial files.

  7. André Derain, Still Life, 1913

    Inventario 1972.9.10 · 91.3 × 72.8 cm · Gift of the W. Averell Harriman Foundation in memory of Marie N. Harriman · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Las dos estaban en el Museo Folkwang de Essen y el régimen nazi las sacó como «arte degenerado» en 1937; el Derain se vendió por la Galería Buchholz, una de las autorizadas. Son confiscaciones a un museo público, no a un dueño perseguido, y Alemania nunca anuló esa ley. La National Gallery lo cuenta (con el número del inventario de confiscación en el caso de Feininger). Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Confiscated on 25 August 1937 by the German government as "degenerate art," and sold through the Buchholz Gallery in Berlin» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Still Life» (1972.9.10)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: confiscación: …the French government (13 June 1921; 17 November 1921; 4 July 1922; 7 May 1923). [2] Confiscated on 25 August 1937 by the German government as "degenerate art," and sold through the Bu…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Galerie Kahnweiler, Paris).[1] Carl Hagemann [1867-1940], Frankfurt am Main, by 1915. Museum Folkwang, Essen, by 1934, until 1937; (Buchholz Gallery, Berlin).[2] (Valentine Gallery, New York); by exchange 1943 to Marie N. Harriman [1903-1970] and W. Averell Harriman [1891-1986], New York;[3] W. Averell Harriman Foundation; gift 1972 to NGA. [1] According to Michel Kellerman, _André Derain: Catalogue raisonné de l'oeuvre peint_, 3 vols., Paris, 1992: I:no. 329, and confirmed by a Galerie Kahnweiler label, annotated "No. 1477," in the center of the painting's middle stretcher bar. The painting does not appear to have been included in any of the four sales of the Galerie Kahnweiler conducted by the French government (13 June 1921; 17 November 1921; 4 July 1922; 7 May 1923). [2] Confiscated on 25 August 1937 by the German government as "degenerate art," and sold through the Buchholz Gallery in Berlin, one of the agents appointed by the German government's Commission for the Exploitation of Degenerate Art to sell objects purged from German museums. [3] According to Harriman collection records in NGA curatorial files.

  8. Arnold Böcklin, The Sanctuary of Hercules, 1884

    Inventario 1976.36.1 · 113.8 × 180.5 cm · Andrew W. Mellon Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Fue de Arthur von Weinberg, de familia judía, que murió en Theresienstadt en 1943. Según la National Gallery pasó por herencia a sus hijas adoptivas y a una nieta, y en 1975 lo vendía una galería de Zúrich, con una carta de un príncipe Lobkowicz en el legajo. Siguió en la familia; sería bueno que el museo publicara esa carta. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Dr. Arthur von Weinberg [1860-1943], Frankfurt-am-Main, by 1904; by inheritance to his adopted daughters» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Sanctuary of Hercules» (1976.36.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Arthur von Weinberg: …Kunsthandlung Fritz Gurlitt, Berlin), in 1886.[2] Julie Ginsberg, Berlin, by 1897.[3] Dr. Arthur von Weinberg [1860-1943], Frankfurt-am-Main, by 1904; by inheritance to his adopted daughters, Charlot…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Dr. Carl Steinbart [1852-1923], Berlin, by 1885.[1] (Kunsthandlung Fritz Gurlitt, Berlin), in 1886.[2] Julie Ginsberg, Berlin, by 1897.[3] Dr. Arthur von Weinberg [1860-1943], Frankfurt-am-Main, by 1904; by inheritance to his adopted daughters, Charlotte Frederike, Princess Ferdinand Lobkowicz [1896-1973], Frankfurt-am-main, and Marie Elisabeth, Gräfin von Spreti [1892-1969]; presumably by inheritance to Marie Elisabeth's daughter, Alexandra-Beatrix Scherping [b. 1929, née Countess von Spreti], Schloss Pähl, Bavaria. (Galerie Bruno Meissner, Zurich), by 1975;[4] purchased 1976 by NGA. [1] Steinbart's name is written three times in various locations on the reverse of the panel; see notes and photos in NGA curatorial files. [2] The Gurlitt name is given in Rolf Andree, _Arnold Böcklin: Die Gemälde_, Basel and Munich, 1977: 451, no. 378, repro. [3] Mrs. Ginsberg lent the painting to an 1897 exhibition in Berlin. [4] Provenance provided by Galerie Bruno Meissner. See also letter dated 3 August 1976 from Prince Edouard de Lobkowicz in NGA curatorial files.

  9. Auguste Renoir, Girl with a Basket of Fish, c. 1889

    Inventario 1956.4.1 · 130.7 × 41.8 cm · Gift of William Robertson Coe · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Georges Lévy las vendió en 1937 por Jacques Seligmann, en París, y ese mismo mes las compró un coleccionista de Nueva York. Venta anterior a la ocupación. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Girl with a Basket of Fish» (1956.4.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …nheim-Jeune, Paris); sold 11 December 1911 to (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold 2 April 1917 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2]…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann & Co. (André Seligmann): …);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe [1869-1955],…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …] bequest 1956 to NGA. [1] Possibly the painting lent by Rosenberg to an exhibition at Wildenstein's, New York, in 1921. [2] Lent by Lévy to an exhibition in Paris in 1933. [3] See 1…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann: …);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe [1869-1955],…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Georges Lévy: …to (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold 2 April 1917 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co.,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    From the artist 19 April 1891 to the private collection of Paul Durand-Ruel, Paris; sold 13 April 1909 to Eugène Hirsch, Paris; sold 28 September 1911 to (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris); sold 11 December 1911 to (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold 2 April 1917 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe [1869-1955], Oyster Bay, Long Island, NY; [4] bequest 1956 to NGA. [1] Possibly the painting lent by Rosenberg to an exhibition at Wildenstein's, New York, in 1921. [2] Lent by Lévy to an exhibition in Paris in 1933. [3] See 1937 correspondence between Seligmann and Levy regarding the Rosenberg provenance in Seligmann papers at the Archives of American Art, Box 57, folder 28 (copies NGA curatorial records). [4] Coe acquired the pair of Renoirs and a pair of Hubert Robert paintings for a cash sum and the exchange of a portrait by Tocqué which he had previously acquired from Seligmann; see Seligmann papers at the Archives of American Art, Box 23, folder 8 (copies NGA curatorial records).

  10. Auguste Renoir, Girl with a Basket of Oranges, c. 1889

    Inventario 1956.4.2 · 128.8 × 41.8 cm · Gift of William Robertson Coe · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Georges Lévy la vendió en 1937 por Seligmann y ese mismo mes la compró un coleccionista de Nueva York. Venta anterior a la ocupación. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Girl with a Basket of Oranges» (1956.4.2)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …nheim-Jeune, Paris); sold 11 December 1911 to (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold 2 April 1917 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2]…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann & Co. (André Seligmann): …);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe [1869-1955],…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …] bequest 1956 to NGA. [1] Possibly the painting lent by Rosenberg to an exhibition at Wildenstein's, New York, in 1921. [2] Lent by Lévy to an exhibition in Paris in 1933. [3] See 1…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann: …);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe [1869-1955],…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Georges Lévy: …to (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold 2 April 1917 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co.,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    From the artist 19 April 1891 to the private collection of Paul Durand-Ruel, Paris; sold 13 April 1909 to Eugène Hirsch, Paris; sold 28 September 1911 to (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris); sold 11 December 1911 to (Durand-Ruel, Paris); sold 2 April 1917 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris);[1] sold to Georges Lévy, Paris and chateau Meslay-le-Vidame, by 1933;[2] sold 1937 to (Jacques Seligmann and Co., Paris and New York);[3] sold 27 April 1937 to William Robertson Coe [1869-1955], Oyster Bay, Long Island, NY; [4] bequest 1956 to NGA. [1] Possibly the painting lent by Rosenberg to an exhibition at Wildenstein's, New York, in 1921. [2] Lent by Lévy to an exhibition in Paris in 1933. [3] See 1937 correspondence between Seligmann and Levy regarding the Rosenberg provenance in Seligmann papers at the Archives of American Art, Box 57, folder 28 (copies NGA curatorial records). [4] Coe acquired the pair of Renoirs and a pair of Hubert Robert paintings for a cash sum and the exchange of a portrait by Tocqué which he had previously acquired from Seligmann; see Seligmann papers at the Archives of American Art, Box 23, folder 8 (copies NGA curatorial records).

  11. Auguste Renoir, Girl with a Hoop, 1885

    Inventario 1963.10.58 · 125.7 × 76.6 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Fueron de Max Silberberg, de Breslau, asesinado en el Holocausto. Pero los vendió en su subasta de París del 9 de junio de 1932, antes de que los nazis llegaran al poder; Chester Dale los compró ahí. Venta anterior a 1933 y fuera de Alemania. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau;[3] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 9 June 1932, no. 29); purchased by Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Girl with a Hoop» (1963.10.58)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Silberberg: …heim-Jeune, Paris);[2] by whom sold to (Galerie Thannhauser, Berlin); sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau;[3] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 9 June 1932, no. 29); pur…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …Galerie George Petit, Paris, 4 March 1920, no. 208, withdrawn); sold 1920 by Chapuis to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., London, New York and Paris); sold to Marquis de Rochecouste, Paris; sold to (Ber…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Commissioned by the sitter's father, Sénateur Étienne Goujon [Etienne Devilliers], Paris; by inheritance to E. Chapuis, Paris, the husband of the sitter; (Chapuis sale, Galerie George Petit, Paris, 4 March 1920, no. 208, withdrawn); sold 1920 by Chapuis to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., London, New York and Paris); sold to Marquis de Rochecouste, Paris; sold to (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris);[1] on joint account 1928/1929 with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris); sold December 1929 to (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris);[2] by whom sold to (Galerie Thannhauser, Berlin); sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau;[3] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 9 June 1932, no. 29); purchased by Chester Dale [1882-1962], New York; bequest 1963 to NGA. [1]See letter from Paul Rosenberg to Chester Dale, dated 5 August 1932, in NGA curatorial files, in which the Marquis' name is spelled Rochegouste. According to a letter from François Daulte dated 30 January 1965, in NGA curatorial files, the name is correctly spelled Rochecouste. [2]See notes of David Rust's conversation with Knoedler & Co., dated 15 October 1964, in NGA curatorial files. [3]Published in "Die Sammlung Max Silberberg," _Kunst und Kunstler_, October 1931, p. 12.

  12. Auguste Renoir, Madame Henriot, c. 1876

    Inventario 1961.3.1 · 65.8 × 49.5 cm · Gift of the Adele R. Levy Fund, Inc. · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Maurice de Rothschild la compró en 1929 y para 1934 la tenía Rosenberg; para 1941 era de los Levy de Nueva York. Salió de manos de los Rothschild antes de 1934. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris), by 1934.[4] Acquired by 1941 by Dr. David M.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Madame Henriot» (1961.3.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …cel Kapferer); sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris), by 1934.[4] Acquired by 1941 by Dr. David M. [1892-1977] and Adele Rosen…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Édouard de Rothschild: …ondon, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris), by 1934.[4] Acquired by 1941 by D…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Maurice de Rothschild: …er & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris), by 1934.[4] Acquired by 1941 by D…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Marcel Kapferer: …èvre, London); on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenbe…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Baron Maurice de Rothschild: …Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris), by 1934.[4] Acquired by 1941 by D…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly Doctor Vaucaire, Paris. Possibly Mme Berne-Bellecour, Paris.[1] Probably Dr. Georges de Bellio [1828-1894], Paris; probably by inheritance to M et Mme [she, née Victorine de Bellio, 1863-1958] Ernest Donop de Monchy, Paris; sold probably 1906 to Alexandre Berthier [1883-1918], 4th Prince de Wagram, Paris;[2] probably by inheritance to his sister, Élisabeth Marguerite, Princesse de La Tour d'Auvergne-Lauraguais, Paris; sold by Wagram heirs though (Canadeesche Hypothek Bank) through (Étienne Bignou, Paris) to (Alex Reid & Lefèvre, London); on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold September 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris.[3] (Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris), by 1934.[4] Acquired by 1941 by Dr. David M. [1892-1977] and Adele Rosenwald [1892-1960] Levy, New York;[5] gift 1961 to NGA. [1] Vaucaire and Mme Berne-Bellecour according to the he Bignou albums at the documentation center of the Musée d'Orsay (copy in NGA curatorial files). The latter is possibly the wife of the artisit Eitenne Prosper Berne-Bellecour [1838-1910]. [2] According to Léa Saint-Raymond, Monchy seems to have commissioned a Madame Bresnard, the mother of architect Alfred-Jean Besnard, to sell the portrait; she contacted Berthier, and when he was slow to decide, the dealer Edouard Jonas, who was also interested in acquiring the painting, demanded on 13 March 1906 that Berthier inform Mme Bresnard of his decision. This spurred Berthier to purchase it. See Saint-Raymond, “Coulisses et Ficelles du Métier: Dans les Pas du Prince de Wagram,” Alice Ensabella, et al., _Histoire des galeries d’art en France du XIXe au XXIe siècle_, Paris: 2024: 144. See also Saint-Raymond and Hadrien Viraben, "Alexandre Berthier, the 4th Prince de Wagram: documentation on his collection (1904-1917)", 2019, https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/TIFXCH, Harvard Dataverse, V1. [3] Reid & Lefèvre Paintings Sold, sheet no. 211, #28/29 B1424 gives acquisition source and partial share information (Lefèvre archives, Hyman Kreitman Research Centre, Tate Britain, London, TGA 2002/11, Box 283). [4] Reproduced in Carroll Carstairs, _Postscript to Criticism_, London, 1934, crediting Paul Rosenberg. [5] The painting was lent by Dr. and Mrs. Levy to a 1941 exhibition in New York.

  13. Auguste Renoir, Mlle Charlotte Berthier, 1883

    Inventario 1969.10.1 · 92.1 × 73 cm · Gift of Angelika Wertheim Frink · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Maurice de Rothschild la compró en 1929 y para 1933 la había pasado a Wildenstein; en 1941 era de una coleccionista de Nueva York. El texto no dice dónde estuvo en 1940; lo damos por resuelto porque salió de los Rothschild antes de 1933, pero no verificamos el tramo 1939–41. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris; [3] probably sold or consigned by 1933 to (Wildenstein and Co., London, New York and Paris) by 1933 until at least 1939» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Mlle Charlotte Berthier» (1969.10.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Édouard de Rothschild: …sold 5 October 1929 to (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); [2] sold 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris; [3] probably sold or consigned by 1933 to (Wildenstein and Co., Londo…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Maurice de Rothschild: …Kapferer); sold 5 October 1929 to (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); [2] sold 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris; [3] probably sold or consigned by 1933 to (Wildenstein and Co., Londo…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …aron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris; [3] probably sold or consigned by 1933 to (Wildenstein and Co., London, New York and Paris) by 1933 until at least 1939. [4] Angelica Wertheim F…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Marcel Kapferer: …èvre, London); on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold 5 October 1929 to (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); [2] sold 1929 to Baron Maurice d…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Baron Maurice de Rothschild: …Marcel Kapferer); sold 5 October 1929 to (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); [2] sold 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris; [3] probably sold or consigned by 1933 to (Wildenstein and Co., Londo…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly Gustave Caillebotte [1848-1894], Paris. [1] Alexandre Berthier [1883-1918], Prince de Wagram, Paris; probably by inheritance to his sister, Élisabeth Marguerite, Princesse de La Tour d'Auvergne-Lauraguais; sold by Wagram heirs though (Canadeesche Hypothek Bank) through (Étienne Bignou, Paris) to (Alex Reid & Lefèvre, London); on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold 5 October 1929 to (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); [2] sold 1929 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris; [3] probably sold or consigned by 1933 to (Wildenstein and Co., London, New York and Paris) by 1933 until at least 1939. [4] Angelica Wertheim Frink [1884-1969], New York, by 1941;[5] gift 1970 to NGA. [1] Per François Daulte, _Auguste Renoir, catalogue raisonne de l'oeuvre peint_, Vol.I. Figures 1860-1890, Lausanne, 1971: no. 432. [2] Reid & Lefèvre Paintings Sold, sheet no. 207, #20/29 B1413 gives acquisition source and partial share information (Lefèvre archives, Hyman Kreitman Research Centre, Tate Britain, London, TGA 2002/11, Box 283). [3] M. Knoedler & Co. Records, accession number 2012.M.54, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: Painting Stockbook no. 5, London 1928-1939, and Stockbook no. 8, New York, no. A623; copies in NGA curatorial files. [4]Lent by Wildenstein to exhibitions in Philadelphia in 1933 and Hartford in 1937. [5]Lent by Frink to two exhibitions in New York in 1941.

  14. Auguste Renoir, Odalisque, 1870

    Inventario 1963.10.207 · 69.2 × 122.6 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Hugo Perls la compró en 1928 y Hans Wendland la tuvo en 1916; Rosenberg se la vendió a Chester Dale para abril de 1933. Todos antes del nazismo o en Nueva York. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold 1928 to (Hugo Perls, New York);[4] from 1931 with (Paul Rosenberg & Co., London, New York and Paris); sold by April 1933 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Odalisque» (1963.10.207)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Marchante del saqueo: Hans Wendland: Anonymous collection, Paris.[1] (Galerie Heinemann, Munich) from 1913; sold 1916 to Hans Wendland [b. 1880]. [2] (Dr. Gottlieb Friedrich Reber [1880-1959], Barmen, Germany); sold to (Paul…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …London, New York, and Paris); [3] sold 1928 to (Hugo Perls, New York);[4] from 1931 with (Paul Rosenberg & Co., London, New York and Paris); sold by April 1933 to Chester Dale [1882-1963], New Y…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Hugo Perls: …Germany); sold to (Paul Rosenberg & Co., London, New York, and Paris); [3] sold 1928 to (Hugo Perls, New York);[4] from 1931 with (Paul Rosenberg & Co., London, New York and Paris); sold by…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Anonymous collection, Paris.[1] (Galerie Heinemann, Munich) from 1913; sold 1916 to Hans Wendland [b. 1880]. [2] (Dr. Gottlieb Friedrich Reber [1880-1959], Barmen, Germany); sold to (Paul Rosenberg & Co., London, New York, and Paris); [3] sold 1928 to (Hugo Perls, New York);[4] from 1931 with (Paul Rosenberg & Co., London, New York and Paris); sold by April 1933 to Chester Dale [1882-1963], New York;[5] bequest 1963 to NGA. [1] Letter from Paul Rosenberg to Chester Dale, dated 31 March 1942, in which Rosenberg described having seen the picture in an apartment in Paris before 1914 (copy NGA curatorial files). [2] Galerie Heinemann records, no. 12082 (copies NGA curatorial files). [3] Letter from Paul Rosenberg to Chester Dale, dated 31 March 1942, in which Rosenberg explains that Reber was an intermediary for a German private collection. This is likely Wendland, who had bought the painting in 1916.The painting is included in the list of Reber's collection compiled by Peter Kropmanns and Uwe Fleckner, "Von Kontinentaler Bedeutung: Gottlieb Freidrich Reber und seine Sammlungen," in _Die Moderne und ihre Sammler_ (Berlin, 2001), p 392, but was not lent by Reber to any known exhibitions of his collection. [4] See letter from Hugo Perls dated 25 November 1968, in NGA curatorial files. [5] See documentation in NGA Gallery Archives Chester and Maud Dale Papers, Artist & Daler Files, Box 3, Folder 5 (copies in NGA curatorial files).

  15. Auguste Renoir, Suzanne Valadon, c. 1885

    Inventario 1963.10.60 · 41.3 × 31.8 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. La palabra «confiscación» del texto no es nazi: Martin Fabiani sacó de Francia parte de la colección de Vollard y los británicos la incautaron en Bermudas; pasó la guerra en la National Gallery de Canadá y se la devolvieron en 1949. Fabiani era un marchante colaboracionista, pero esta obra venía de los herederos de Vollard, no de un dueño perseguido. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Fabiani shipped the pictures from France, but the shipment was confiscated in Bermuda by British authorities.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Suzanne Valadon» (1963.10.60)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: confiscación: …the executor of his will. Fabiani shipped the pictures from France, but the shipment was confiscated in Bermuda by British authorities. The pictures spent the war years at the National Gal…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ambroise Vollard: (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris); his heirs; (Martin Fabiani, Paris);[1] sold March 1950 to Chester Da…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris); his heirs; (Martin Fabiani, Paris);[1] sold March 1950 to Chester Dale [1882-1962], New York;[2] bequest 1963 to NGA. [1] After Vollard's death, his brother Lucian sold his share of the collection to Fabiani, who had worked with the dealer and was the executor of his will. Fabiani shipped the pictures from France, but the shipment was confiscated in Bermuda by British authorities. The pictures spent the war years at the National Gallery of Canada in Ottawa, from where they were released to Fabiani and another dealer, Eduoard Jonas, in 1949. On the Vollard collection see: Lynn Nicholas, _The Rape of Europa_, 1995, pp. 92-93, 425; Nancy Caron Karrels, "Reconstructing a Wartime Journey: The Vollard-Fabiani Collection, 1940–1949," _International Journal of Cultural Property_ 22, no. 4 (2015): 505-526, published on-line 8 December 2015: doi:10.1017/S0940739115000296; Maryline.Assante di Panzillo, “The Dispersal of the Vollard Collection,” in _Cézanne to Picasso: Ambroise Vollard, Patron of the Avant-Garde_, Rebecca Rabinow, ed., exh. cat. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 2006: 259–262. [2] Date of purchase according to Chester Dale papers, copies in NGA curatorial files. The painting was shipped from France by Rene Haas, acting for Fabiani, according to consular paperwork (copies NGA curatorial files).

  16. Auguste Renoir, Woman with a Cat, c. 1875

    Inventario 1950.12.1 · 56 × 46.4 cm · Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin E. Levy · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Benjamin Levy la compró para 1932 y él mismo la donó en 1950 desde Connecticut. No la perdió. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold by 1932 to Benjamin E. Levy [d. 1952], Paris, and Ridgefield, Connecticut; gift 1950 to NGA.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Woman with a Cat» (1950.12.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …1878, no. 75); purchased by Count de Rasty, Paris; Countess de Rasty sold 1925/1926 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris); sold by 1932 to Benjamin E. Levy [d. 1952], Paris, and Ridgefield, Conne…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1932 a 1950
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Ernest Hoschedé [1837-1891], Paris; (his sale, Paris, 6 June 1878, no. 75); purchased by Count de Rasty, Paris; Countess de Rasty sold 1925/1926 to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris); sold by 1932 to Benjamin E. Levy [d. 1952], Paris, and Ridgefield, Connecticut; gift 1950 to NGA.

  17. Edgar Degas, The Riders, c. 1885

    Inventario 2014.18.7 · 73.03 × 90.81 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Jules Strauss, coleccionista judío de París, la vendió en su subasta de diciembre de 1932, antes del nazismo; en 1946 era de la colección Schwenck. Hay un hueco 1932–46 en París, pero ya no era de Strauss. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «purchased 1911 by Jules Strauss [1861-1943], Paris;[2] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris,15 December 1932, no. 36)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Riders» (2014.18.7)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ambroise Vollard: The artist; (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris);[1] purchased 1911 by Jules Strauss [1861-1943], Paris;[2] (his sale,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The artist; (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris);[1] purchased 1911 by Jules Strauss [1861-1943], Paris;[2] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris,15 December 1932, no. 36); purchased by (André Schoeller [1879-1955], Paris).[3] Collection Schwenck, Paris, by 1946.[4] Private collection, Swizterland; sold March 1967 through Simon Scheib, New York to Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia;[5] bequest 1999 to NGA, with life interest to his wife, Rachel Lambert Mellon [1910-2014]. [1] The painting is reproduced in _l’Album Degas_, Galerie A. Vollard, Paris, 1914: pl. 54. [2] Pauline Baer, the great-granddaughter of Jules Strauss, kindly shared with NGA the details of her great-grandfather's purchase of the painting (see her e-mail of 6 September 2016, in NGA curatorial files). The purchase is recorded in Strauss's personal papers with the following comment: "de chez Vollard provenant directement de Degas." [3] Annotated sales catalogue in Chester Dale collection, NGA Library. Schoeller was one of the directors at the Galerie Georges Petit and often an expert at sales, so it is possible this painting was bought in at the Strauss sale. [4] Per Lemoisne, Paul André. _Degas et son oeuvre_. 4 vols. Paris: Arts et metiers graphiques, 1946-1949. Vols. 2 and 3, 1946. (Reprinted in 5 vols., New York and London, 1984): no. 859, repro. [5] See letter of 29 February 1967 from John Rewald to Paul Mellon, as well as the annotated letter of 10 March 1967 from Simon Sheib to Mellon, in NGA curatorial files. Sheib was a laywer acting on behalf of the Swiss client who sold the painting..

  18. Edouard Manet, George Moore in the Artist's Garden, c. 1879

    Inventario 2006.128.24 · 54.6 × 45.1 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Era de Max Liebermann. La National Gallery documenta que estaba entre los 14 cuadros que se mandaron al Kunsthaus de Zúrich en mayo de 1933 para ponerlos a salvo y que después se entregaron a su hija Käthe Riezler, que emigró a Nueva York en 1938 y lo prestó a exposiciones en 1948 y 1949. Salió de Alemania con la familia. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «This painting was among 14 from Liebermann's collection that were sent to the Kunsthaus Zürich in May 1933 and later released to his daughter Käthe Riezler.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «George Moore in the Artist's Garden» (2006.128.24)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Liebermann: …tier, Paris). (Durand-Ruel et Cie, Paris and New York), c. 1900. (Paul Cassirer, Berlin). Max Liebermann [1847-1935], Berlin, by 1904;[1] by inheritance to his daughter, Mrs. Kurt Riezler [née K…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Cassirer & Co. (Walter Feilchenfeldt): …uary 1884, no. 59); (Portier, Paris). (Durand-Ruel et Cie, Paris and New York), c. 1900. (Paul Cassirer, Berlin). Max Liebermann [1847-1935], Berlin, by 1904;[1] by inheritance to his daughter,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The artist; (his estate sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 4-5 February 1884, no. 59); (Portier, Paris). (Durand-Ruel et Cie, Paris and New York), c. 1900. (Paul Cassirer, Berlin). Max Liebermann [1847-1935], Berlin, by 1904;[1] by inheritance to his daughter, Mrs. Kurt Riezler [née Käthe Liebermann, 1885-1952], Berlin and later New York, until at least 1949.[2] (Wildenstein and Co., New York). Paul Mellon [1907-1999], Upperville, Virginia, by 1966;[3] bequest 1999 to NGA, with life interest to Mrs. Mellon; life interest released 2006. [1] The early provenance is according to Denis Rouart and Daniel Wildenstein, _Edouard Manet: Catalogue raisonné_, 2 vols., Lausanne and Paris, 1975: I:no. 297, repro. The painting was number 488 in the inventory taken of the artist's possessions after his death in 1883. Published as in Liebermann's collection in Ferdinand Laban, "Im Zwanzigsten Jahre nach Manets Tode." _Zeitschrift für bildende Kunst_ (1904): repro. 35. [2] This painting was among 14 from Liebermann's collection that were sent to the Kunsthaus Zürich in May 1933 and later released to his daughter Käthe Riezler. (See Walther Feilchenfeldt’s letter to Dr. Wartmann of 2 May 1933 published in _Max Liebermann und die französischen Impressionisten_, Düsseldorf, 1997: 239; "In the list of pictures that Max Liebermann is leaving in Zurich for safe keeping is “6. [Manet,] George Moore.”) The Riezlers left Europe for New York in 1938. The painting was lent by them to a 1948 exhibition at Wildenstein, New York, and again to an exhibition of their collection in San Francisco in 1949. See Karl-Heinz Janda and Annegret Janda, "Max Liebermann als Kunstsammler" in _Forschungen und Berichte_ 15 (1973): 103-149. [3] Included in a 1966 exhibition of of the Mellon collection at the NGA.

  19. Eugenio Lucas Villamil, The Bullfight, c. 1890/1900

    Inventario 1954.10.1 · 73.9 × 109.9 cm · Gift of Arthur Sachs · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Maurice de Rothschild la compró en 1925 y para 1928 era de Arthur Sachs. Antes de 1933. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold 1925 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris. Arthur Sachs [1880-1975], New York and Cannes, by 1928» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Bullfight» (1954.10.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Édouard de Rothschild: …Paris, 1910). (E. Gimpel & Wildenstein, Paris), by 1924;[2] sold 1925 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris. Arthur Sachs [1880-1975], New York and Cannes, by 1928;[3] gift 1954…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Maurice de Rothschild: …is; (sale, Paris, 1910). (E. Gimpel & Wildenstein, Paris), by 1924;[2] sold 1925 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris. Arthur Sachs [1880-1975], New York and Cannes, by 1928;[3] gift 1954…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann: …8 exhibition of Spanish paintings at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. See also Jacques Seligmann & Co. Records, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington: Collectors…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Baron Maurice de Rothschild: …], Paris; (sale, Paris, 1910). (E. Gimpel & Wildenstein, Paris), by 1924;[2] sold 1925 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris. Arthur Sachs [1880-1975], New York and Cannes, by 1928;[3] gift 1954…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Probably Édouard Kahn, Paris; (his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 8 June 1895, no. 2); (Goldschmidt).[1] Sigismond Bardac [1856-1919], Paris; (sale, Paris, 1910). (E. Gimpel & Wildenstein, Paris), by 1924;[2] sold 1925 to Baron Maurice de Rothschild [1881-1957], Paris. Arthur Sachs [1880-1975], New York and Cannes, by 1928;[3] gift 1954 to NGA. [1] The dimensions for this painting and its companion piece, now in the Reinhardt Collection, Winterthur, are almost identical. The Kahn sale catalogue (_Catalogue des tableaux par Antoine Watteau, Boucher, Goya, Gustave Moreau, Teniers...Formant la collection K._) contains only one entry for a "course de taureau" by Goya, which is described simply as a "belle esquisse," although it is annotated with a sale price of 2500 francs. Paul Lafond, _Goya_, Paris, 1902:107, however, not only lists both paintings as being in this sale, but without explanation identifies no. 29 (the NGA version) as the one that sold for 2500 francs. See also the provenance for the companion piece, which is documented by Juliet Wilson-Bareau in her entry on the painting in _Sammlung Oskar Reinhart 'Am Römerholz' Winterthur_. Basel, 2003: no. 19, 174-177, repro.; note 5 of the entry (p. 174) provides the name of the buyer at the 1895 sale, taken from the procès verbal. [2] August L. Mayer, _Francisco de Goya_, London and Toronto, 1924: 181. [3] Sachs lent the painting to a 1928 exhibition of Spanish paintings at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. See also Jacques Seligmann & Co. Records, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington: Collectors Files, Box 203, Folder 6; copies in NGA curatorial files.

  20. Follower of Jean Siméon Chardin, Portrait of a Man, 18th century

    Inventario 1943.7.3 · 51 × 41.3 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Alphonse Kann la vendió en su subasta de 1920. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 6-8 December 1920, no. 10)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Portrait of a Man» (1943.7.3)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alphonse Kann: Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 6-8 December 1920, no. 10).…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: …Georges Petit, Paris, 6-8 December 1920, no. 10). Josef Stransky [1885-1936], owned with (Wildenstein & Co., New York); sold 18 March 1929 to Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York;[1] gift 194…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris; (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 6-8 December 1920, no. 10). Josef Stransky [1885-1936], owned with (Wildenstein & Co., New York); sold 18 March 1929 to Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York;[1] gift 1943 to NGA. [1] See Wildenstein bill of sale in NGA Gallery Archives Chester and Maud Dale Papers, Artist & Dealer Files, Box 3, Folder 13 (copy in NGA curatorial files).

  21. Fra Filippo Lippi, The Annunciation, c. 1435/1440

    Inventario 1943.4.35 · 100 × 161 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Kurt Walter Bachstitz, marchante judío de La Haya, la tuvo en 1934 y Duveen para 1937, antes de la invasión de Holanda (1940). Venta normal de un marchante. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «(Bachstitz Gallery, The Hague), by 1934.[6] (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris), by 1937» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Annunciation» (1943.4.35)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Kurt Walter Bachstitz: …1974], New York), by 1925 until at least 1927.[4] Percy S. Straus, New York, by 1932.[5] (Bachstitz Gallery, The Hague), by 1934.[6] (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris), by…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly Tommaso Puccini [1749-1811], Villa a Scornio, near Pistoia.[1] possibly (Sangiorgi, Rome), early 1900s.[2] Achillito Chiesa, Milan.[3] (Piero Tozzi [1882-1974], New York), by 1925 until at least 1927.[4] Percy S. Straus, New York, by 1932.[5] (Bachstitz Gallery, The Hague), by 1934.[6] (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris), by 1937;[7] sold 1940 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[8] gift 1943 to NGA. [1] In commentary on Filippo Lippi, Tommaso Puccini writes ("Dialoghi sulle Vite del Vasari," Archive of the Gallerie Fiorentine, Florence, c. 1800, Ms. no. 46, fol. 199): "Io possiedo di questo Autore un quadretto conservatissimo esprimente l'Annunziata...Genuflette davanti alla Vergine, assorta in contemplazione del S. Spirito che viene a deporla nel seno il Messia, bianco vestito, con un giglio in mano, un grazioso Angeletto che non tocca coi ginocchi il terreno, ma sta sull'ali sospeso. Il fondo rappresenta l'interno della Camera con una prospettiva intesa a meraviglia..." ("I possess by this author a very well preserved little picture representing the Annunciate...Kneeling before the Virgin, rapt in contemplation of the Holy Spirit who comes to place the Messiah in her womb, dressed in white, with a lily in his hand, a lovely little angel who does not touch the ground with his knees but floats on wings. The background represents the interior of a room with a perspective which is marvelously understood"). Apart from the detail concerning the knees which do not touch the floor, the description is quite similar to the NGA painting, but it may refer, of course, to some other of Lippi's paintings on this subject. [2] The name "S. Giorgi" is written on the back of a photograph of the painting belonging to the Biblioteca Berenson at Villa I Tatti near Florence and coming from Bernard Berenson's files, indicating the panel's earliest known location. This was Berenson's customary abbreviation for the name of the Roman dealer Sangiorgi. [3] The art collection of Achille Chiesa in Milan, inherited after his death by his son Achillito, was sold at the American Art Association Galleries in New York at various sales between 1925 and 1927. The NGA painting, however, which is not listed in the auction catalogues, must have been sold privately sometime earlier. [4] According to Odoardo H. Giglioli, "Una pittura ignota di Fra Filippo Lippi," _BdA_, n.s. 6 (1925-1926): 553, the painting was brought to Florence for restoration. Records of the Florentine Soprintendenza dei Beni Artistici e Storici (_pratica_ no. 630 of 27 January 1925) show that the panel, belonging to the dealer Tozzi, entered Italy in January 1925 and left for New York in March 1927. No records concerning this painting have been discovered in The Tozzi Archive, housed in The Onassis Library for Hellenic and Roman Art, Department of Greek and Roman Art, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. [5] See Berenson Berenson, _Italian Pictures of the Renaissance_, Oxford, 1932: 288. Possibly the painting passed through various hands before entering, sometime around 1930, the Straus collection. The annotation on Berenson's photograph, cited in note 2, also records the Florence dealer Albrighi as owner. [6] The painting was illustrated in 1934, in a partially cleaned state, in an advertisement of the Bachstitz Gallery in the December issue of _The Burlington Magazine_ 65, xvi. [7] See Robert Oertel, _Fra Filippo Lippi_, Vienna, 1942: 67. [8] Fern Rusk Shapley, _Catalogue of the Italian Paintings_, 2 vols., Washington, D.C., 1979: 1:263. See also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/2061.

  22. Francesco Guardi, Fanciful View of the Castel Sant'Angelo, Rome, c. 1785

    Inventario 1956.9.2 · 46.8 × 76.3 cm · Gift of Howard Sturges · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Alphonse Kann (saqueado por el ERR en 1940) la vendió en 1914. Mucho antes. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «(Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris); sold 4 June 1914 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, London» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Fanciful View of the Castel Sant'Angelo, Rome» (1956.9.2)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alphonse Kann: (Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris); sold 4 June 1914 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, London, stock no. 4543); s…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1922 a 1948
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris); sold 4 June 1914 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, London, stock no. 4543); sold 27 June 1914 to Calouste Gulbenkian; returned 11 June 1915 to (Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London, stock no. 4668); sold 7 July 1922 to (C.M. Agnew and Ansdell, London);[1] sold to Howard Sturges [d. 1955], Providence, Rhode Island;[2] gift 1956 to NGA. [1] Information provided by Martha Hepworth of the Getty Provenance Index from the stock records of Agnew's; the relationship of Agnew and Ansdell to the firm of Agnew's is unclear; they purchased paintings from Agnew's in the early 1920s (letter of 25 February 1992, NGA curatorial files). [2] Notation of a letter from Geoffrey Agnew of 10 August 1956, on an artist card in NGA curatorial files, records that Sturges bought the painting from Agnew's, but gives no indication of when.

  23. Francisco Goya, Señora Sabasa Garcia, c. 1806/1811

    Inventario 1937.1.88 · 71 × 58 cm · Andrew W. Mellon Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. James Simon, mecenas judío de Berlín, la tuvo hacia 1908; para 1923 era de Sklarz y en 1930 de Mellon. Antes de 1933. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Dr. James Simon [1851-1932], Berlin, by 1908;[4] Count Paalen, Berlin; Heinrich Sklarz, Berlin, by 1923» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Señora Sabasa Garcia» (1937.1.88)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: James Simon: …after her death, sold by her husband Dr. Sota to Don José Joaquin Herrero, Madrid;[3] Dr. James Simon [1851-1932], Berlin, by 1908;[4] Count Paalen, Berlin; Heinrich Sklarz, Berlin, by 1923;[…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The sitter [b. 1790] until her death;[1] by inheritance to her goddaughter, Mariana García Soler, Madrid;[2] after her death, sold by her husband Dr. Sota to Don José Joaquin Herrero, Madrid;[3] Dr. James Simon [1851-1932], Berlin, by 1908;[4] Count Paalen, Berlin; Heinrich Sklarz, Berlin, by 1923;[5] (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris);[6] purchased 21 February 1930 by Andrew W. Mellon, Pittsburgh and Washington; deeded 28 December 1934 to The A.W. Mellon Educational and Charitable Trust, Pittsburgh; gift 1937 to NGA. [1] J. Valverde Madrid, "El Retrato de doña Sabasa García por Goya," _Goya_ no. 177 (1983): 109. [2] Elizabeth du Gué Trapier, _Goya and His Sitters_, New York, 1964: 55, no. 59; Valverde Madrid 1983, 108-109. The provenance card (in NGA curatorial files) for Herrero calls him Don José Juan (rather than Joaquin) Herrero. [3] Detlev Freiherrn von Hadeln, "Die Porträtausstellung des Kaiser Friedrich Museens Verein," _Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte_ 44 (1908-1909): 203, repro. 197. For more information about Simon, see Wilhelm Bode's introduction to _Collection Dr. James Simon de Berlin: Catalogue des tableaux, miniatures, bronzes, sculptures, ivoires, cires, bijoux, objets de vitrine, tapis, tapisseries, étoffes, et meubles_, Frederik Muller et Cie, Amsterdam, 25-26 October 1927). [4] August L. Mayer, _Francisco de Goya_, Munich, 1923: 206, no. 499. [5] _Duveen Pictures in Public Collections of America_, New York, 1941: 235. [6] David Finley notebook, in NGA Gallery Archives, copy in NGA curatorial files.

  24. Frans Hals, Portrait of a Woman Aged Sixty, 1633

    Inventario 1937.1.67 · 102.5 × 86.9 cm · Andrew W. Mellon Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. James Simon la tuvo hacia 1906; Duveen la compró en 1919. Antes del nazismo. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «James Simon [1851-1932], Berlin, by 1906; (Abraham Preyer, The Hague);[2] purchased 12 June 1919 by (Duveen Brothers» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Portrait of a Woman Aged Sixty» (1937.1.67)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: James Simon: …la Rupelle [née de Tascher, d. 1911], Paris; sold by 1905 to (Charles Sedelmeyer, Paris); James Simon [1851-1932], Berlin, by 1906; (Abraham Preyer, The Hague);[2] purchased 12 June 1919 by (…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Jurriaans;[1] (his sale, Van de Schley, Roos, and De Vries, Amsterdam, 28 August 1817, no. 20); Cornelius Sebille Roos [1754-1820], Amsterdam. Charlotte-Camille, Comtesse Boucher de la Rupelle [née de Tascher, d. 1911], Paris; sold by 1905 to (Charles Sedelmeyer, Paris); James Simon [1851-1932], Berlin, by 1906; (Abraham Preyer, The Hague);[2] purchased 12 June 1919 by (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris);[3] held jointly with (Thos. Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London), June to November 1919);[4] (Duveen Brothers, Inc.); sold June 1920 to Andrew W. Mellon, Pittsburgh and Washington, D.C.; deeded 28 December 1934 to The A.W. Mellon Educational and Charitable Trust, Pittsburgh; gift 1937 to NGA. [1] The name is also inscribed on copies of the 1817 sale catalogue as “Jurjans.” See the description of Sale Catalogue N-298 in The Getty Provenance Index© Databases, J. Paul Getty Trust, Los Angeles. [2] From The Hague on 4 May 1919, Preyer cabled fellow dealers Scott and Fowles in New York that he had purchased the painting; see Duveen Brothers Records, accession number 960015, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: reel 229, box 374, folder 7. [3] Duveen Brothers Records, accession number 960015, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: reel 103, box 248, folder 22. Oddly, the Duveen prospectus, in NGA curatorial files, says the painting was acquired by Duveen in 1927, which is clearly an error. [4] The painting was Agnew’s stock number J1821. This information comes from the Agnew stock books, and is recorded in the Public Collections portion of the Getty Provenance Index© Databases, J. Paul Getty Trust, Los Angeles.

  25. Giovanni Battista Tiepolo, Scene from Ancient History, c. 1750

    Inventario 1939.1.365 · 140.3 × 109.3 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Fue del banquero vienés Stefan von Auspitz, que perdió su colección en la crisis financiera austríaca de 1931, antes del nazismo; pasó por Van Beuningen y Bachstitz y la Fundación Kress la compró en 1937. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Stefan von Auspitz, Vienna, by 1931;[6] Possibly Daniel George van Beuningen [1877-1955]; (K.W. Bachstitz, The Hague);[7] purchased 1937 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Scene from Ancient History» (1939.1.365)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Kurt Walter Bachstitz: …n 1932 was necessitated by the Austrian financial crisis of 1931. [7] _Bulletin of the Bachstitz Gallery_ 1935: 22. When the von Auspitz collection was liquidated in 1932 some or all of…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann & Co. (André Seligmann): …, according to a letter inquiring about the painting dated 18 April 1933 from the firm of Jacques Seligmann, New York (Seligmann papers, Archives of American Art, Box 11, copy NGA curatorial files)…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Édouard de Rothschild: …for the paintings included in the sale, may have been acting as agent for Baron Adolph de Rothschild, who is said in a prospectus from the Bachstitz Gallery (in NGA curatorial files; see als…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Seligmann: …, according to a letter inquiring about the painting dated 18 April 1933 from the firm of Jacques Seligmann, New York (Seligmann papers, Archives of American Art, Box 11, copy NGA curatorial files)…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Almorò Barbaro [b. 1681], Venice; by descent to Marc Antonio Barbaro [d. 1860]; his sister, Elissa Bassi; sold to (Vicenzo Favenza), by 1866; sold to an unidentified Frenchman, probably a dealer;[1] (Palazzo Barbaro sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 9 February 1874, no. 3); Isaac, comte de Camondo [1851-1911], Paris;[2] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 13 February 1893, no. 27); (Eugène Féral);[3] Baron Adolph Carl de Rothschild [1823-1900], Château de Pregny, near Geneva.[4] Dr. Joseph Kranz, Vienna, by 1902.[5] Stefan von Auspitz, Vienna, by 1931;[6] Possibly Daniel George van Beuningen [1877-1955]; (K.W. Bachstitz, The Hague);[7] purchased 1937 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[8] gift 1939 to NGA. [1] Information about the sale of furnishings and works of art from the Palazzo Barbaro in the 1860s is contained in a letter of 9 February 1924 from Frank Lattimer to B. Burroughs of the Metropolitan Museum (archival envelope, _Apotheosis of Francesco Barbaro_, Metropolitan Museum, New York). Lattimer was the cousin of Ralph Curtis, then owner of the palace, and found this information in files assembled at the palazzo by Mrs. Curtis. [2] According to marginal notations in the sale catalogue housed in the Frick Art Reference Library, New York. [3] According to marginal notations in the Knoedler Fiche copy of the sale catalogue; Cammondo is not named anywhere on the catalogue, but Lugt, vol. 4, No. 51324, lists this as Cammondo's sale. Féral, named as a painter and authority for the paintings included in the sale, may have been acting as agent for Baron Adolph de Rothschild, who is said in a prospectus from the Bachstitz Gallery (in NGA curatorial files; see also note 4) to have purchased the painting at the Cammondo sale. [4] The prospectus from the Bachstitz Gallery, in NGA curatorial files, states that the painting was presented by Baron Adolphe (_sic_) von Rothschild of Paris to his daughter on the occasion of her marriage to a Baron von Springer of Vienna, and was subsequently purchased from Baron von Springer's estate by Dr. Kranz. However, Baron Adolphe, though married, died childless. The Getty Provenance Index suggested instead (letter of 15 March 1993 from Martha Hepworth to Eric Garberson, NGA curatorial files) that the painting passed to Adolphe's niece, Valentine Noémi de Rothschild (1886-1969), who in 1911 married Baron Sigismund von Springer (1875-1928), but the painting was already in the collection of Dr. Kranz by 1902. [5] Catalogued by Heinrich Modern, _Giovanni Battista Tiepolo. Eine Studie_, Vienna, 1902: 52 in the Kranz collection. [6] Borenius, _Italian Paintings of the Auspitz Collection_, 12, 67, nos. 49-50. This publication cannot be located, but is cited in Tancred Borenius, "The Stefan von Auspitz Collection", _Burlington Magazine_ 61 (1932): 283-288. Borenius 1932: 287, noted that the dissolution of the Auspitz collection in 1932 was necessitated by the Austrian financial crisis of 1931. [7] _Bulletin of the Bachstitz Gallery_ 1935: 22. When the von Auspitz collection was liquidated in 1932 some or all of it was sold through Bachstitz, while some was acquired by collector Daniel George von Beuningen, and consigned for sale to Bachstitz. The Tiepolo was with Bachstitz by c. 1932, according to a letter inquiring about the painting dated 18 April 1933 from the firm of Jacques Seligmann, New York (Seligmann papers, Archives of American Art, Box 11, copy NGA curatorial files). [8] See also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/1922.

  26. Gustave Courbet, A Young Woman Reading, c. 1866/1868

    Inventario 1963.10.114 · 60 × 72.9 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Max Silberberg, de Breslau, asesinado en el Holocausto, la vendió en su subasta de París del 9 de junio de 1932, antes de que los nazis llegaran al poder; la compró Chester Dale. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau, Germany [now Wroclaw, Poland];[6] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 9 June 1932, no. 18); Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «A Young Woman Reading» (1963.10.114)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Silberberg: …(Etienne Bignou, Paris), in 1924; sold to (Paul Rosenberg, Paris);[5] sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau, Germany [now Wroclaw, Poland];[6] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, P…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: ….J. van Wisselingh & Co., Amsterdam), in 1924. (Etienne Bignou, Paris), in 1924; sold to (Paul Rosenberg, Paris);[5] sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau, Germany [now Wroclaw,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    The artist to (Durand-Ruel et Cie., Paris) in 1872.[1] (sale, comte de R..., Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 27 January 1875, no. 14, as _Femme lisant_, 650 francs). Ad. Reitlinger, Paris, by 1882.[2] Alexandre Bernheim-Jeune [d. 1915], Paris.[3] Alexandre Berthier, 4th prince de Wagram [1883-1918], Paris. (Jos Hessel, Paris), in 1923.[4] (E.J. van Wisselingh & Co., Amsterdam), in 1924. (Etienne Bignou, Paris), in 1924; sold to (Paul Rosenberg, Paris);[5] sold before 1931 to Max Silberberg [d. 1944], Breslau, Germany [now Wroclaw, Poland];[6] (his sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, 9 June 1932, no. 18); Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York; bequest 1963 to NGA. [1] According to a letter from Robert Fernier to David Rust dated 31 July 1972, in NGA curatorial files. According to the Bignou photo albums at the Documentation center of the Musée d'Orsay, Paris, the picture passed through the Barbazanges gallery, but that has not been confirmed by any other source. [2] Lent by Reitlinger to _Exposition des Oeuvres de Gustave Courbet_, Ecole national superieure des beaux-arts, Paris, 1882, no. 30. [3] According to Chester Dale papers in NGA curatorial files. [4] According to Chester Dale papers in NGA curatorial files. In Robert Fernier, _La vie et l'oeuvre de Gustave Courbet, catalogue raisonné_, Lausanne and Paris, 1977: I:172, no. 287, Hessel is not listed in the provenance except as an expert in the 1932 Silberberg sale. [5] In a letter to Chester Dale dated 5 August 1932, in NGA curatorial files, Paul Rosenberg says the painting went through several hands from the Reitlinger collection, and that Rosenberg bought the painting from Bignou and sold it to Silberberg. Chester Dale papers in NGA curatorial files give Rosenberg and Bignou as joint owners, after van Wisselingh, in 1926. [6] Published in Karl Scheffler, "Die Sammlung Max Silberberg," _Kunst und Kunstler_, October 1931, repro. p. 7.

  27. Hans Memling, Madonna and Child with Angels, after 1479

    Inventario 1937.1.41 · 57.6 × 46.4 cm · Andrew W. Mellon Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Hugo Perls y Fritz Mannheimer (perseguidos más tarde) aparecen en 1927, cuando la obra pasó por ellos a Duveen y a Andrew Mellon ese mismo año. Todo antes de 1933. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold early 1927 to (Hugo Perls, Berlin);[2] sold via the Mannheimer collection, Amsterdam, to (Duveen Brothers» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Madonna and Child with Angels» (1937.1.41)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Fritz Mannheimer: …alt [1901-1947], Gotisches Haus; sold early 1927 to (Hugo Perls, Berlin);[2] sold via the Mannheimer collection, Amsterdam, to (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris);[3] purchased Novembe…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Hugo Perls: …o his son, Joachim Ernst, Duke of Anhalt [1901-1947], Gotisches Haus; sold early 1927 to (Hugo Perls, Berlin);[2] sold via the Mannheimer collection, Amsterdam, to (Duveen Brothers, Inc., Lo…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Probably Leopold III Friedrich Franz, Duke of Anhalt-Dessau [1740-1817], Gotisches Haus, Wörlitz, near Dessau;[1] probably by inheritance to his grandson, Leopold IV Friedrich, Duke of Anhalt [1794-1871], Gotisches Haus; by inheritance to his son, Friedrich I, Duke of Anhalt [1831-1904], Gotisches Haus; by inheritance to his son, Friedrich II, Duke of Anhalt [1856-1918], Gotisches Haus; by inheritance to his son, Eduard Georg Wilhelm, Duke of Anhalt [1861-1918], Gotisches Haus; by inheritance to his son, Joachim Ernst, Duke of Anhalt [1901-1947], Gotisches Haus; sold early 1927 to (Hugo Perls, Berlin);[2] sold via the Mannheimer collection, Amsterdam, to (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris);[3] purchased November 1927 by Andrew W. Mellon, Pittsburgh and Washington, D.C.; deeded 5 June 1931 to The A.W. Mellon Educational and Charitable Trust, Pittsburgh; gift 1937 to NGA. [1] This prince built the Gotisches Haus and its English park and was an active collector, adding early German and Netherlandish paintings to the family holdings; see C. Rost, "Der alte Nassau-Oranische Bilderschatz und sein späterer Verbleib," _Jahrbücher für Kunstwissenschaft_ 6 (1873), 52-93, esp. 78-79, listing early catalogues of the collection. The descriptions in the early catalogues of the Anhalt-Dessau collection are not sufficiently specific to identify the _Madonna and Child with Angels_. [2] According to a note on a photograph in the Friedländer archive, Rijksbureau voor Kunsthistorische Documentatie, (RKD), The Hague; and a letter of 23 October 1961 from Hugo Perls to the NGA (in NGA curatorial files). [3] Duveen Brothers Records, accession number 960015, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: reel 120, box 265, folder 18; and transcriptions from the Duveen Brothers Records (copies and transcriptions in NGA curatorial files).

  28. Hendrick Avercamp, A Scene on the Ice, c. 1625

    Inventario 1967.3.1 · 39.2 × 77 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. La firma Katz de Dieren (judía) la vendió hacia 1933–34 a J.M.B. Beuker, cuya viuda la vendió al museo en 1967. Venta en Holanda antes de la invasión. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «(Firma D. Katz, Dieren), by 1933; J.M.B. Beuker, Heelsum, by 1934» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «A Scene on the Ice» (1967.3.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Kunsthandel Katz (Nathan y Benjamin Katz): Said to have been at the Imperial Hermitage Gallery, Saint Petersburg.[1] (Firma D. Katz, Dieren), by 1933; J.M.B. Beuker, Heelsum, by 1934;[2] by inheritance to his widow, Mrs.…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Said to have been at the Imperial Hermitage Gallery, Saint Petersburg.[1] (Firma D. Katz, Dieren), by 1933; J.M.B. Beuker, Heelsum, by 1934;[2] by inheritance to his widow, Mrs. J.C. Beuker [née De Kruyff van Dorssen]; sold 5 April 1967 through (A. Martin de Wild, The Hague) to NGA. [1] In the catalogues for the 1934 and 1938 exhibitions in which it was included, the painting was described as having been previously in the collection of the Hermitage. However, the picture is not listed in any of that museum's collection catalogues. [2] Labels from the 1933 and 1934 exhibitions both say that Katz was the “exhibitor,” but they give two different names as the “owner” (removed from the back of the painting, now in NGA curatorial files). The owner’s name on the 1933 label is difficult to decipher, but appears to be two initials followed by “te H.” The owner’s name on the 1934 label clearly reads “J.M.B. Beuker Heelsum.”

  29. Honoré Daumier, with additions by later hands, Feast of the Gods, c. 1849/1850, with later additions by other hands

    Inventario 1943.11.2 · 29 × 39 cm · Rosenwald Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Oskar Skaller, coleccionista judío de Berlín, la tuvo en 1926; para 1930 estaba en Pensilvania. Antes de 1933. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Oskar Skaller, Berlin, by 1926.[2] François Monod, Paris. Lessing J. Rosenwald [1891-1979], Jenkintown, Pennsylvania, by 1930» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Feast of the Gods» (1943.11.2)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Oskar Skaller: O. Ackermann, Paris, by 1908 until at least 1912.[1] Julius Meier-Graefe, Berlin. Oskar Skaller, Berlin, by 1926.[2] François Monod, Paris. Lessing J. Rosenwald [1891-1979], Jenkintown,…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    O. Ackermann, Paris, by 1908 until at least 1912.[1] Julius Meier-Graefe, Berlin. Oskar Skaller, Berlin, by 1926.[2] François Monod, Paris. Lessing J. Rosenwald [1891-1979], Jenkintown, Pennsylvania, by 1930;[3] gift 1943 to NGA. [1] The painting was owned by Ackermann according to Klossowski's 1908 _Honoré Daumier_, and lent by Ackermann to the 1912 exhibition in Saint Petersburg. [2] Skaller lent the painting to a 1926 exhibition at the Galerie Matthiesen in Berlin. [3] Rosenwald lent the painting to a 1930 exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art.

  30. Jan Brueghel the Elder, Wooded Landscape with Travelers, 1610

    Inventario 2020.26.1 · 37 × 58 cm · The Lee and Juliet Folger Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. La compró la National Gallery en 2020 con un estudio de procedencia hecho con dos proyectos del Zentralinstitut de Múnich (Stern y Böhler). Pasó por la galería de Max Stern en Düsseldorf en 1936, mientras lo obligaban a cerrar, y por Richard Friede, judío, que la tenía antes de septiembre de 1938 y la llevó a Nueva York en 1941; su familia la vendió hacia 1992. El museo lo cuenta con documentos. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold 11 January 1936 to (Galerie Stern, Düsseldorf); Max Stern [1904-1987], Düsseldorf;[6] sold before September 1938 to Richard Friede [1883-1944], Bocholt, Germany,[7] and from 1941, New York» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Wooded Landscape with Travelers» (2020.26.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Marchante del saqueo: Theodor Fischer: …eum, Los Angeles) for three paintings by Strigel. The three Strigels came from the dealer Theodor Fischer in Lucerne, with Böhler acting as the intermediary for the exchange, taking the paintings…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Julius Böhler: …emäldesammlungen), Munich, by 1838;[4] given, with another painting, 10 December 1935 to (Julius Böhler, Munich), in exchange for three Bernhard Strigel paintings;[5] sold 11 January 1936 to (G…
    • Marchante del saqueo: Ernst Buchner: …nich to show Pinakothek officials (according to a letter of 30 April 1935 from Fischer to Ernst Buchner, director of the Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen; original in the Bayerische Hauptstaa…
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: arianización: …gallery in 1934. After losing his professional accreditation in 1935, Stern attempted to “Aryanize” the gallery, but the plan was not successful, and the gallery’s remaining stock was liq…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Max Stern: …rtschaftsarchiv (Bavarian Economic Archive), both in Munich, are in NGA curatorial files. Max Stern inherited his father Julius’s successful gallery in 1934. After losing his professional a…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Doucet: …online, from the library of the Institut National d’Histoire de l’Art [INHA], collections Jacques Doucet [Archives, Manuscripts, and Autographs], Paris: https://bibliotheque-numerique.inha.fr/vi…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Johann Wilhelm, Elector Palatine [1658–1716], Düsseldorf;[1] by inheritance to his brother, Karl III Philipp, Elector Palatine [1661–1742], Düsseldorf, and from 1730, Mannheim;[2] by inheritance to his nephew, Karl Theodor, Elector Palatine, and from 1777, Elector of Bavaria [1724–1799], Mannheim, and from 1777, Munich; by inheritance to his successor, Maximilian IV Joseph, Elector Palatine and Elector of Bavaria, and from 1806, King of Bavaria, as Maximilian I Joseph [1756-1825], Munich; by descent in the Bavarian Royal Collection, Munich, from 1822,[3] and subsequently the Königliche Pinakothek (Royal Pinakothek, later Alte Pinakothek, Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen), Munich, by 1838;[4] given, with another painting, 10 December 1935 to (Julius Böhler, Munich), in exchange for three Bernhard Strigel paintings;[5] sold 11 January 1936 to (Galerie Stern, Düsseldorf); Max Stern [1904-1987], Düsseldorf;[6] sold before September 1938 to Richard Friede [1883-1944], Bocholt, Germany,[7] and from 1941, New York;[8] by descent to his daughter, Ursula Friede Bamberger [1922-2019]; Ursula and Gerald Bamberger, Silver Spring, Maryland; sold c. 1992 to (Otto Naumann Ltd., New York) in partnership with (Roman Herzig/Galerie Sanct Lucas, Vienna); sold c. 1992 to (Bernheimer Fine Old Masters, Munich);[9] sold 1995 to Marietta Vok [d. 2019], near Villach, Austria; gift January 2018 to private collection, Italy;[10] consigned March 2020 to (David Koetser Gallery, Zurich); purchased November 2020 by NGA. [1] The painting was displayed in one of the two painting galleries in the palace; see _Detail Des Peintures du Cabinet Electoral de Dusseldorff_, possibly c. 1720: no. 7 (available online, from the Herzog August Bibliothek, Wolfenbüttel: http://diglib.hab.de/drucke/uc-kapsel-1-12s/start.html; accessed October 2020). Clarification of the provenance reconstructed here has been made possible due to the cooperation between two current research projects at the Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte in Munich, both funded by the Deutsches Zentrum Kulturgutverluste in Magdeburg: the Stern Cooperation Project and the Boehler Project; with particular thanks to Drs. Willi Korte, Christian Fuhrmeister, and Stephan Klingen for their research and kind assistance. See their full report in NGA curatorial files. [2] Johann Philipp von der Schlichten (Attributed to), _Cabinets des Peintures de Son Altesse Sérénissime électorale au Château de Manheim [_sic_] l’an 1731_ [Gemäldekabinette des Kurfürsten Karl III. Philipp von der Pfalz im Residenschloss Mannheim], 4 sheets of ink drawings with wash, 520 x 370 mm, illustrating the hanging arrangement of the paintings, 1731: 4th sheet, wall diagram on left side of sheet, lower left, no. 7, identified as by “F[ruelen]. Brugel” [there is a second no. 7 in this diagram, identified as by Vinckenbaum] (available online, from the library of the Institut National d’Histoire de l’Art [INHA], collections Jacques Doucet [Archives, Manuscripts, and Autographs], Paris: https://bibliotheque-numerique.inha.fr/viewer/22021/?offset=#page=6&viewer=picture&o=bookmark&n=0&q=; NUM MS 409). Reference to the Schlicten manuscript is in Reinhold Baumstark, et al., _Kurfürst Johann Wilhelms Bilder_, 3 vols., exh. cat. Alte Pinakothek, Munich, 2009: 1:no. 252. [3] Königl. Baier. Central-Gemälde-Sammlung (Bavarian Royal Central Painting Collection), no. 396 – the source is the 1822 Dillis inventory in the Archive of the Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen. Reference to the Dillis inventory is in Reinhold Baumstark, et al., _Kurfürst Johann Wilhelms Bilder_, 3 vols., exh. cat. Alte Pinakothek, Munich, 2009: 2:no. 185. [4] The Königliche Pinakothek, built to house the Bavarian royal painting collection, opened in 1836. See the reference for the painting in Georg von Dillis, _Verzeichniss der Gemälde in der königlichen Pinakothek zu München_, Munich, 1838: 205, no. 198, where it is mistakenly described as being on copper. The painting was subsequently listed in Alte Pinakothek catalogues: Rudolf Marggraff, _Die ältere königliche Pinakothek zu München_, Munich, 1872: 166, no. 790, mistakenly described as being on copper; _Katalog der Gemälde-Sammlung der Kgl. Älteren Pinakothek in München mit einer historischen Einleitung von Dr. Franz von Reber_, Munich, 1888: 142, no. 693; _Katalog der Gemälde-Sammlung der Kgl. Älteren Pinakothek in München mit einer historischen Einleitung von Dr. Franz von Reber_, Munich, 1908:150, no. 693. [5] In a complicated exchange, the Alte Pinakothek traded the Brueghel and a painting by Franz van Mieris (today in the J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles) for three paintings by Strigel. The three Strigels came from the dealer Theodor Fischer in Lucerne, with Böhler acting as the intermediary for the exchange, taking the paintings to Munich to show Pinakothek officials (according to a letter of 30 April 1935 from Fischer to Ernst Buchner, director of the Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen; original in the Bayerische Hauptstaatsarchiv, Staatsgemaeldesammlungen, vorl. Nr.Reg.AZ-231-1-0017, copy in NGA curatorial files). The process of working out details of the transaction took place between June and October 1935, with the deaccessioning and trade of the Brueghel and Van Mieris paintings approved by the Bavarian State Ministry for Education and Culture on 23 October 1935, and the final exchange of paintings occurring in December (see the e-mail of 29 September 2020 from Mirjam Neumeister, Head of Flemish Baroque Painting, Alte Pinakothek, Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Munich, to Marjorie E. [Betsy] Wieseman, NGA Curator of Northern European Paintings, as well as the extensive correspondence provided in the Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte’s report [see note 1], all in NGA curatorial files). The Van Mieris went to Fischer in Lucerne and was shared among three owners (Fischer, the Kunsthandel AG, and Nathan Katz), while Böhler kept the Brueghel as commission, according to records in the Julius Böhler archive, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, Munich (copies in NGA curatorial files). [6] Copies of records from the Böhler and Stern galleries, including the invoice, and of correspondence relating to the sale, from the Böhler Archiv, Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte, and Bayerische Wirtschaftsarchiv (Bavarian Economic Archive), both in Munich, are in NGA curatorial files. Max Stern inherited his father Julius’s successful gallery in 1934. After losing his professional accreditation in 1935, Stern attempted to “Aryanize” the gallery, but the plan was not successful, and the gallery’s remaining stock was liquidated at the auction house Lempertz in Cologne on 13 November 1937. However, Stern continued to operate during the time his case was under appeal (1935–1937). The Brueghel landscape was not included in the Lempertz auction and was likely sold before it took place. [7] Assets declaration of Richard Friede, 8 September 1938, in Landesarchiv NRW, Westfalen Department, L001a, Oberfinanzdirektion (Regional Finance Office) Münster, Devisenstelle (Foreign Currency Office), no. 2185; copy in NGA curatorial files. [8] Sailing from Glasgow, Richard and Grete Friede and their daughter Ursula arrived at St. John, New Brunswick, Canada, on 24 January 1941, their final destination declared as New York (National Archives and Record Administration, Washington, D.C., Manifests of Passengers Arriving in the Saint Albans, Vermont, District through Canadian Pacific and Atlantic Ports, 1/11/1895-11/30/1954, M164, roll no. 612, images 36-37). See also Josef Niebur, _Buch der Erinnerung: Juden in Bocholt_, Bocholt, Germany, 2013: 102. [9] Confirmation of the two transactions in c. 1992 was provided by Konrad Bernheimer, in his e-mail of 5 October 2020 to Henriette Rahusen of the NGA’s Department of Northern European Paintings, in NGA curatorial files. [10] The date of Marietta Vok’s acquisition of the painting, her place of residence, and the date of her gift of the painting were provided by David Koester, in his e-mail of 5 October 2020 to Henriette Rahusen, in NGA curatorial files.

  31. Jan van Huysum, Flowers in an Urn, c. 1720/1722

    Inventario 1977.7.1 · 79.9 × 60 cm · Adolph Caspar Miller Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Goudstikker la tuvo en 1919–1920; en 1924 la compró lord Claud Hamilton. Mucho antes del saqueo de 1940. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «(Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), by 1919 until at least 1920.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Flowers in an Urn» (1977.7.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Goudstikker: (Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), by 1919 until at least 1920. Vas Diag, before 1924; (Leggatt Brothers, Londo…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1924 a 1975
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), by 1919 until at least 1920. Vas Diag, before 1924; (Leggatt Brothers, London); acquired 21 July 1924 by Lord Claud Hamilton;[1] by inheritance to his widow, Lady Claud Hamilton; (sale, Christie, Manson & Woods, London, 28 November 1975, no. 23); (Alexander Gallery, London); purchased 18 February 1977 by NGA. [1] The provenance from Vas Diag to Lord Hamilton is given in a letter from Charles Leggatt to Arthur Wheelock, 31 December 1982, in NGA curatorial files. Records of the Leggatt Brothers that might have provided more information about Diag and the purchase from him were destroyed in World War II. “Lord Claud Hamilton” could be one of several people; one possibility is that he was Lord Claud Nigel Hamilton (1889–1975), whose widow (she died 1984) was born Violet Ruby Ashton, and was earlier Mrs. Keith W. Newall.

  32. Jean Siméon Chardin, Still Life with Game, probably 1750s

    Inventario 1952.5.36 · 49.6 × 59.4 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Era de David David-Weill, cuya colección saqueó el ERR en 1941. Pero esta tela la compró Wildenstein en 1937 con parte de la colección y ya se exhibía en Nueva York ese año. La National Gallery lo explica. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «purchased February/March 1937 with the David-Weill collection by (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Still Life with Game» (1952.5.36)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Organismo nazi del saqueo: Central Collecting Point: …Nazis in July 1941. Much of the collection was recovered and processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point after the war by the Allies. [4] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kre…
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: confiscación: …on, which had been safeguarded in Sourches by French museum administration officials, was confiscated by the Nazis in July 1941. Much of the collection was recovered and processed through t…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Pierre David-Weill: Possibly (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London);[1] David David-Weill [1871-1952], Neuilly-sur-Seine, France, by 1925;[2] purchased February/March 1937 with th…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Wildenstein & Co.: Possibly (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London);[1] David David-Weill [1871-1952], Neuilly-sur-Seine,…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: David David-Weill: Possibly (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London);[1] David David-Weill [1871-1952], Neuilly-sur-Seine, France, by 1925;[2] purchased February/March 1937 with th…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: David David-weill: Possibly (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London);[1] David David-Weill [1871-1952], Neuilly-sur-Seine, France, by 1925;[2] purchased February/March 1937 with th…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London);[1] David David-Weill [1871-1952], Neuilly-sur-Seine, France, by 1925;[2] purchased February/March 1937 with the David-Weill collection by (Wildenstein & Co., Paris, New York, and London);[3] sold 1946 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[4] gift 1952 to NGA. [1] Eisler 1977: 314 indicates that David-Weill acquired the painting from Wildenstein, whose Paris office no longer has records to confirm this transaction (see letter from Ay-Whang Hsia to David Rust, 8 August 1978, in NGA curatorial files). [2] The painting appears in the background of a portrait of David-Weill painted by Edouard Vuillard in 1925, and was catalogued in the David-Weill collection by Georges Henriot in 1926. [3] "Sale of the David-Weill Collection." _Art News_ 35 (27 February 1937): 12 and "David-Weill Pictures Come to New York." _Art Digest_ 12 (1 November 1937): 13. David-Weill, head of Lazard Frère Bank and Chairman of the Conseil des Musées de France, had an extraordinary collection of art which was dispersed in several ways during the World War II era. Some of the collection was consigned to Wildenstein's in London, who in turn sent some of the paintings, including this Chardin, to their New York branch where they were exhibited in 1937. Despite complications of nationality during the war, David-Weill managed to ship a large part of the collection via Lisbon to New York. Unfortunately another portion of the collection, which had been safeguarded in Sourches by French museum administration officials, was confiscated by the Nazis in July 1941. Much of the collection was recovered and processed through the Munich Central Collecting Point after the war by the Allies. [4] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/2017.

  33. Jean-Baptiste Joseph Pater, Fête Champêtre, c. 1730

    Inventario 1946.7.19 · 74.5 × 92.5 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Fue de Hannah Mathilde von Rothschild (m. 1924), de Frankfurt; Wildenstein la compró en 1930 y Kress en 1946. Venta anterior a 1933. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Baronin Hannah Matilde von Rothschild [1832-1924, wife of Baron Wilhelm Carl von Rothschild], Grünberg and Frankfurt am Main; purchased 1930 by (Wildenstein» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Fête Champêtre» (1946.7.19)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Édouard de Rothschild: …Co. kindly provided the year that the company acquired the painting from the Baronin von Rothschild. [2] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/76…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1946
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Baronin Hannah Matilde von Rothschild [1832-1924, wife of Baron Wilhelm Carl von Rothschild], Grünberg and Frankfurt am Main; purchased 1930 by (Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London);[1] sold 1946 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[2] gift 1946 to NGA. [1] During the preparation of the NGA systematic catalogue of its French paintings of the 15th through the 18th century, Joseph Baillio of Wildenstein & Co. kindly provided the year that the company acquired the painting from the Baronin von Rothschild. [2] See The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/768.

  34. Johannes Cornelisz Verspronck, Andries Stilte as a Standard Bearer, 1640

    Inventario 1998.13.1 · 104 × 78.5 cm · Patrons' Permanent Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Goudstikker la tuvo antes de 1917; la familia Pannwitz la conservó hasta 1988. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «(Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), before 1917. Dr. Walter von Pannwitz [1856-1920], Berlin, by 1917» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Andries Stilte as a Standard Bearer» (1998.13.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Goudstikker: (Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), before 1917. Dr. Walter von Pannwitz [1856-1920], Berlin, by 1917;[1] by inh…
    • Hueco entre 1933 y 1945: La procedencia salta de 1923 a 1959
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), before 1917. Dr. Walter von Pannwitz [1856-1920], Berlin, by 1917;[1] by inheritance to his wife, Catalina von Pannwitz [1876-1959, née Roth], Heemstede; by descent in the Pannwitz family; (Otto Nauman, Ltd., New York); purchased 1988 by Mr. and Mrs. Michal Hornstein, Montreal; (sale, Sotheby's, New York, 30 January 1998, no. 69); purchased through (Bob P. Haboldt & Co., New York) by NGA. [1] The Pannwitz family lent the painting to the Mauritshuis, The Hague, from 1917 to 1923. Walter von Pannwitz was a Munich lawyer who, with his second wife Catalina Roth, relocated to Berlin in 1910. He acquired an extensive collection of paintings and applied arts in the first two decades of the twentieth century.

  35. Lippo Memmi, Saint John the Baptist, probably c. 1325

    Inventario 1939.1.291 · 88.7 × 42.2 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Pasó por Jacques Goudstikker, pero él lo vendió en febrero de 1937, a través de Paul Cassirer, a Duveen; la invasión alemana de Holanda fue en 1940. Venta normal de un marchante, antes del saqueo. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «(Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), by 1934;[5] purchased February 1937 through (Paul Cassierer & Co., Amsterdam) by (Duveen Brothers» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Saint John the Baptist» (1939.1.291)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jacques Goudstikker: …at Frederik Muller & Co., Amsterdam, 13 April 1932, no. 3, as by Taddeo di Bartolo).[4] (Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), by 1934;[5] purchased February 1937 through (Paul Cassierer & Co., Amsterda…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Probably church of San Francesco, San Gimignano, until 1553;[1] church of San Giovanni Battista, San Gimignano, until 1782/1787;[2] church of San Francesco, Colle Val d’Elsa, between 1787 and mid-nineteenth century.[3] Graf von Oriola, Schloss Budesheim, Oberhessen; (his sale, Mensing & Fils at Frederik Muller & Co., Amsterdam, 13 April 1932, no. 3, as by Taddeo di Bartolo).[4] (Jacques Goudstikker, Amsterdam), by 1934;[5] purchased February 1937 through (Paul Cassierer & Co., Amsterdam) by (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London, New York, and Paris);[6] sold June 1938 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[7] gift 1939 to NGA. [1] In 1865 Francesco Brogi saw two of the original companion panels to the NGA’s painting in the church of the Franciscans of Colle Val d’Elsa (not published until 1897: Francesco Brogi, _Inventario generale degli oggetti d’arte della provincia di Siena_, Siena, 1897: 158). However, it has been convincingly suggested (Alessandro Bagnoli, "La Chiesa di San Francesco a Colle di Val d'Elsa, intenti per un restauro globale," in _Restauri e Recuperi in terra di Siena. XI Settimana dei Beni Culturali_, Sienna, December 1995: n.p.; Alessandro Bagnoli, _La Maestà di Simone Martini_, Milan, 1999: 151 n. 184; Marianne Lonjon, “Précisions sur la provenance du retable dit 'de Colle val d’Elsa' de Lippo Memmi,” _Revue des Musée de France_ 56, no. 2 [2006]: 31-40) that they were transferred there only in the late eighteenth century from the church of the same order in San Gimignano; it may be presumed that they had originally adorned its high altar. Situated outside the city walls, the church of San Francesco in San Gimignano was demolished in 1553, when, by order of Cosimo I de’ Medici, a new system of fortifications was erected around the city. [2] After the 1553 demolition of their church of San Francesco, the Franciscans moved inside the city of San Gimignano, settling in the convent annexed to the church of San Giovanni Battista. In 1782 Duke Leopold suppressed this convent, forcing the friars to make another move. [3] The community of friars moved to the convent of San Francesco in Colle Val d’Elsa in 1787, likely bringing with them all the church furnishings from San Gimignano. As mentioned above (note 1), two companion panels, Memmi’s _Saint Francis_ and _Saint Louis of Toulouse_ (both now in the Pinacoteca Nazionale in Siena), were recorded by Francesco Brogi in 1865 as hanging in the sacristy of the Franciscan church of Colle. The other panels of the dismembered altarpiece were no longer there at this time. [4] The auction catalog offered for sale a “Collection Comte Oriola, formée en Italie de 1860-1896 env.,” without further explanation. Lot 1 of the sale was a detached fresco by Perugino representing the Pietà, which apparently remained unsold (now in the collection of the Cassa di Risparmio in Florence). Walter and Elisabeth Paatz (_Die Kirchen von Florenz. Ein kunstgeschichtliches Handbuch_, 6 vols., Frankfurt am Main, 1940-1953: 4 [1952]: 649-650, n. 35) cite the fresco as belonging to the heirs of Graf Oriola in Büdesheim, Oberhessen, the location of the collection. The year 1883 is stated as the date of Graf Oriola’s acquisition. An Italian stone relief representing the _Profile Portrait of a Man_, lot 46 of the 1932 sale in Amsterdam, which similarly found its way into the Kress Foundation’s collection in 1938 and subsequently into the Philbrook Art Center in Tulsa, is also stated to have belonged to the Oriola Collection in Büdensheim; see Ulrich Middeldorf, _Sculptures from the Samuel H. Kress Collection. European Sculptures_, London, 1976: 67. It is possible that the “Comte Oriola” named in the sale catalogue referred to Eduard Ernst Lobo da Silveira (1809-1862) and his sons, Waldemar (1854-1910) and Joachim (1858-1907) Lobo da Silveira, all of whom were known as Graf von Oriola. They were the son and grandsons, respectively, of a Portuguese minister, Joaquim José Lobo da Silveira (1772-1846), who was given a title in the Prussian nobility by Friedrich Wilhelm III, king of Prussia (1770-1840) and who resettled his family in Prussia. Waldemar had Schloss Büdesheim constructed in 1885 near an older castle of the same name, and Joachim was a naval attaché in the German embassy in Italy. [5] Goudstikker lent the painting to an exhibition in Amsterdam in 1934. On the life and career of the Dutch dealer see Charlotte Wiefhoff, “De Kunsthandelaar Jacques Goudstikker 1897 - 1940,” _Nederlands Kunsthistotisch Jaarboek_ 32 (1982): 249-278. [6] Duveen Brothers Records, accession number 960015, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: reel 119, box 264, folder 8; reel 121, box 266, folder 18 (copies in NGA curatorial files). [7] The bill of sale for eight paintings, including this one, is dated 21 June 1938; payments were to extend through November 1939. The attributions on the bill, in this case to Simone Martini, were those of Bernard Berenson. Duveen Brothers Records, accession number 960015, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: reel 329, box 474, folder 5 (copies in NGA curatorial files). See also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/1858.

  36. Lyonel Feininger, Street of Barns, 1914

    Inventario 2001.129.1 · 121.9 × 99.1 cm · Collection of Arnold and Joan Saltzman · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Confiscada al Museo Folkwang de Essen como «arte degenerado» en 1937 (inventario de confiscación 16083, citado por el museo). Es una confiscación a un museo público, no a un dueño perseguido; Alemania nunca anuló esa ley. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «removed by the Nazi government as "degenerate art" in 1937» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Street of Barns» (2001.129.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: expolio: …s Point, New York; gift (partial and promised) 2001 to NGA; gift completed 2020. [1] Beschlagnahmeinventar "Entartete Kunst" no. 16083, "Degenerate Art" Research Center, Freie Universität…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Acquired by the Museum Folkwang, Essen, from which it was removed by the Nazi government as "degenerate art" in 1937.[1] (Robert Norbert Ketterer, Lugano, Switzerland). (Sale no. 147, Kornfeld & Klipstein, Bern, June 1973, no. 221). Arnold A. [1916-2014] and Joan R. [1919-2019] Saltzman, Sands Point, New York; gift (partial and promised) 2001 to NGA; gift completed 2020. [1] Beschlagnahmeinventar "Entartete Kunst" no. 16083, "Degenerate Art" Research Center, Freie Universität Berlin. http://emuseum.campus.fu-berlin.de/eMuseumPlus?service=ExternalInterface&moduleFunction=search

  37. Pablo Picasso, The Tragedy, 1903

    Inventario 1963.10.196 · 105.3 × 69 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Flechtheim «posiblemente» antes de 1913 y Paul Schüler hasta hacia 1929; Chester Dale la compró en 1930. Antes de 1933. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Paul Schüler [1876-1942] Bochum, Germany, by 1927 until c. 1929.[3] (Paul P. Rosenberg et Cie., Paris); sold 15 May 1930 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Tragedy» (1963.10.196)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alfred Flechtheim: Possibly Alfred Flechtheim [1878-1937], Düsseldorf.[1] Professor Kreis, Düsseldorf, in 1913.[2] Paul Schüler [1876-1…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …seldorf, in 1913.[2] Paul Schüler [1876-1942] Bochum, Germany, by 1927 until c. 1929.[3] (Paul P. Rosenberg et Cie., Paris); sold 15 May 1930 to Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York; bequest 1963 to…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Schüler: …ly Alfred Flechtheim [1878-1937], Düsseldorf.[1] Professor Kreis, Düsseldorf, in 1913.[2] Paul Schüler [1876-1942] Bochum, Germany, by 1927 until c. 1929.[3] (Paul P. Rosenberg et Cie., Paris)…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly Alfred Flechtheim [1878-1937], Düsseldorf.[1] Professor Kreis, Düsseldorf, in 1913.[2] Paul Schüler [1876-1942] Bochum, Germany, by 1927 until c. 1929.[3] (Paul P. Rosenberg et Cie., Paris); sold 15 May 1930 to Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York; bequest 1963 to NGA. [1] Dale records give "Flechtheim, Dusseldorf" as part of provenance, but this was not included in the 1965 NGA catalogue of the Dale Collection. The Flechtheim gallery operated by Alfred Flechtheim [1878-1937] first opened in Düsseldorf and later in Berlin. [2] The painting was lent by Professor Kreis to a 1913 exhibition in Munich. [3] The invoice from Paul Rosenberg to Chester Dale incorrectly names the prior owner as Mr. Schubert, Bochum. Information regarding Paul Schüler's ownership was kindly provided by Stefan Koldehoff (copies in NGA curatorial files). The incorrect name on the Rosenberg invoice suggests that he did not acquire the painting directly from Schüler.

  38. Paul Cezanne, Boy in a Red Waistcoat, 1888-1890

    Inventario 1995.47.5 · 89.5 × 72.4 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, in Honor of the 50th Anniversary of the National Gallery of Art · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Fue del banquero Jakob Goldschmidt, que huyó de Alemania. Lo conservó: se vendió en la subasta de su sucesión en Sotheby's en 1958. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «sold 1929 to Jakob Goldschmidt [d. 1955], Berlin and New York; his estate; (Goldschmidt sale, Sotheby's, London, 15 October 1958, no. 6)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Boy in a Red Waistcoat» (1995.47.5)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Jakob Goldschmidt: …at least 1925;[1] (Paul Rosenberg, Paris, and Wildenstein Galleries, Paris); sold 1929 to Jakob Goldschmidt [d. 1955], Berlin and New York; his estate; (Goldschmidt sale, Sotheby's, London, 15 Octo…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …is); sold 1896 to Egisto Fabbri [1866-1933], Paris and Florence, until at least 1925;[1] (Paul Rosenberg, Paris, and Wildenstein Galleries, Paris); sold 1929 to Jakob Goldschmidt [d. 1955], Berl…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ambroise Vollard: (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris); sold 1896 to Egisto Fabbri [1866-1933], Paris and Florence, until at…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris); sold 1896 to Egisto Fabbri [1866-1933], Paris and Florence, until at least 1925;[1] (Paul Rosenberg, Paris, and Wildenstein Galleries, Paris); sold 1929 to Jakob Goldschmidt [d. 1955], Berlin and New York; his estate; (Goldschmidt sale, Sotheby's, London, 15 October 1958, no. 6); purchased by (Carstairs Gallery, New York) for Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon, Upperville, Virginia; gift 1995 to NGA. [1]According to John Rewald, _The Paintings of Paul Cézanne: a Catalogue Raisonné_, New York, 1996, no. 659, Fabbri sold the picture back to Vollard in 1904 and repurchased it at a later date. Fabbri lent it to the 1925 exhibition in Paris.

  39. Paul Cezanne, House of Père Lacroix, 1873

    Inventario 1963.10.102 · 61.3 × 50.6 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Alphonse Kann la tuvo antes de Pellerin (m. 1929); Durand-Ruel de Nueva York la vendió en 1937. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Saint Germain-en-Laye. Auguste Pellerin [1852-1929], Paris.[1] (Durand-Ruel, New York); sold 27 November 1937 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «House of Père Lacroix» (1963.10.102)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Alphonse Kann: (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris). Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Saint Germain-en-Laye. Auguste Pellerin [1852-1929], Paris.[1] (Durand-Ruel,…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Bernheim-Jeune: (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris). Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Saint Germain-en-Laye. Auguste Pellerin [1852-1929],…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Ambroise Vollard: (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris). Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Saint Germain-en…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). (Bernheim-Jeune, Paris). Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Saint Germain-en-Laye. Auguste Pellerin [1852-1929], Paris.[1] (Durand-Ruel, New York); sold 27 November 1937 to Chester Dale [1882-1962], New York;[2] bequest 1963 to NGA. [1]This painting was not included in the 1926 Pellerin sale held in Paris. At his death in 1929 Pellerin's collection was inherited by his son and daughter, Jean-Victor Pellerin and Mme Réne Lecomte. [2]According to Chester Dale papers in NGA curatorial files.

  40. Paul Sérusier, Farmhouse at Le Pouldu, 1890

    Inventario 2000.95.1 · 72 × 60 cm · Gift of Alexander Mellon Laughlin and Judith Walker Laughlin · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. El Museo de Ulm lo tuvo en una lista de «arte degenerado» en 1933 y lo usó en una muestra para burlarse de su director judío, Julius Baum; pero se salvó de la confiscación de 1937, siguió en el museo y el propio museo lo vendió en 1955. La National Gallery lo documenta con ayuda de la investigadora del museo. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «in 1937 the painting somehow escaped the fate of over 200 works of art that were seized from the Ulm Museum and either auctioned off or destroyed.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Farmhouse at Le Pouldu» (2000.95.1)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Confiscación o venta forzada: incautación: …oad, and in 1937 the painting somehow escaped the fate of over 200 works of art that were seized from the Ulm Museum and either auctioned off or destroyed. It remained in storage at the…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    (Druet, Paris).[1] Hugo Troendle [1882-1955], Munich;[2] purchased 1925 by the Ulm Museum, Germany; (sale, Stuttgarter Kunstkabinett Roman Norbert Ketterer, Stuttgart, 29 November – 1 December 1955);[3] (Hermann & Günther Abels, Cologne).[4] sold January 1956 to Josef [1911-1975] and Hadassah [1912-1997] Rosensaft, Montreux, Switzerland, and New York.[5] Frank Lloyd, New York. (Marlborough-Gerson Gallery Inc., New York);[6] Mr. and Mrs. [1927-2020] Alexander M. Laughlin, New York; gift (partial and promised) 2000 to NGA; gift completed 2024. [1] This name and that of “Professor Baum” are on a label on the back of the painting. However, Alexandra Chava Seymann, provenance researcher at the Ulm Museum, has kindly explained to the Gallery that Baum was never an owner of the painting; he was Prof. Dr. Julius Baum (1882-1959), director of the Ulm Museum from 1924 to 1933. She also suggested that "Druet, Paris" is likely the gallery owned by Eugène Druet (1867-1916); his name does not appear in the Ulm Museum's file on the painting. See her e-mails of 11 and 18 December 2017, in NGA curatorial files. [2] This information, the additional details in note 3 about the painting’s ownership by the Ulm Museum, and copies that are now in NGA curatorial files of many relevant documents were kindly provided by Alexandra Chava Seymann (see note 1). Troendle was a German painter and writer about art, and it is possible he bought the painting from the Thannhauser Gallery in Munich, although there seems to be no records of this in the Thannhauser papers at ZADIK (Zentralarchiv für deutsche und internationale Kunstmarktforschung, Cologne). The painting was originally a loan to the Ulm Museum in 1925, as number L117, with the title _Bretonisches Bauernhaus_. [3] With the rise of the National Socialist party in Germany in the 1930s, the painting was considered “Degenerate Art,” and, because he was Jewish, the Ulm Museum’s director, Julius Baum (see note 1) was forced out of his position. The painting was included in a 1933 list of works to be deaccessioned from the museum, and in the same year it was part of an exhibition at the museum, _10 Jahre Ulmer Kunstpolitik_, meant to mock and defame Baum and his support of modern art and artists. The museum’s new acting manager made unsuccessful attempts to exchange the painting or sell it abroad, and in 1937 the painting somehow escaped the fate of over 200 works of art that were seized from the Ulm Museum and either auctioned off or destroyed. It remained in storage at the museum, and by 1950 the painting was again on display; a local newspaper article featured it: “Artwork of the Month,” _Schwäbische Donauzeitung_ (15 June 1950). However, in the early 1950s, with much of the museum’s modern art gone, the decision was made to focus on regional art, and to deaccession and sell works to raise funds for new acquisitions. A group of works from the Ulm Museum, including this painting, were sent to auction in late 1955; there is no record of the purchaser. See also: Brigitte Reinhardt, ed., _Kunst und Kultur in Ulm 1933-1945_, exh. cat., Ulmer Museum, Ulm, 1993: 60, no. 50. [4] The Abels’s purchase of the painting at the1955 Stuttgart sale is documented in the Hermann und Günther Abels gallery papers (A-32) at ZADIK, Cologne. Copy of the inventory page kindly provided by ZADIK in e-mail of 26 February 2025 (NGA curatorial records). [5] Sale date according to the gallery’s inventory sheet for the painting (see footnote 4). Rosensaft and his wife Hadassah Binkow were both Holocaust survivors who lived in Switzerland temporarily before moving to New York in the late 1950s. The painting was given as still with Rosensaft in the Sérusier catalogue raisonné (Marcel Guicheteau, _Paul Sérusier_, Paris, 1976: no. 23); however, it was not among those works sold by his estate on 17 March 1976 at Sotheby's, New York. [6] Documents from the donors to the Gallery, in NGA curatorial files, appear to indicate the painting was purchased from this New York gallery, but they do not include a date.

  41. Vincent van Gogh, La Mousmé, 1888

    Inventario 1963.10.151 · 73.3 × 60.3 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Resuelto por el museo. Alphonse Kann la tuvo en 1917; para 1928 era de Stang, en Oslo; Chester Dale la compró en 1929. Veredicto basado en la procedencia publicada por el museo.

    «Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris, by 1917.[4] J.B. Stang, Oslo;[5] sold 3 January 1928» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «La Mousmé» (1963.10.151)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Paul Rosenberg: …Hulpe, Belgium;[2] traded 1909 to (Bernheim-Jeune & Cie, Paris).[3] (Jos Hessel, Paris). (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris). Georges Bernheim, Paris. Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris, by 1917.[4] J…
    • Dueño despojado por el nazismo: Germain Seligmann: …e d'Arles." [5] The Stang collection was visited in January 1929 by Cesar de Hauke and Germain Seligmann, per the Seligmann papers, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington:…
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Mme Johanna van Gogh-Bonger, the artist's sister-in-law, Amsterdam;[1] sold May 1909 to (J.H. de Bois [C.M. van Gogh, Mme van Gogh-Bonger's uncle by marriage], The Hague); sold 1909 to Carl Sternheim [1878-1942], Munich and later La Hulpe, Belgium;[2] traded 1909 to (Bernheim-Jeune & Cie, Paris).[3] (Jos Hessel, Paris). (Paul Rosenberg and Co., Paris). Georges Bernheim, Paris. Alphonse Kann [1870-1948], Paris, by 1917.[4] J.B. Stang, Oslo;[5] sold 3 January 1928 through (Dr. Alfred Gold [1874-1958], Berlin) to (Alex Reid and Lefèvre, Ltd., Glasgow and London) on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); sold 21 May 1929 through (Galerie Étienne Bignou, Paris) to Chester Dale [1883-1962], New York;[6] bequest 1963 to NGA. [1] The painting is no. 169 in the Andries Bonger list of 1890, described as "Jeune fille à la fleur, toile de 25" ("Catalogue des oeuvres de Vincent van Gogh," manuscript b 3055 V/1962, Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam; copy in NGA curatorial files). [2] The painting sold for 3000 guilders, per Jan Frederik Heijbroek and E.L. Wouthuysen, _Kunst, kennis en commercie: de kunsthandelaar J.H. de Bois (1878-1946)_, Amsterdam, 1993:195, and Christ Stolwijk and Han Veenenbos, _The account book of Theo van Gogh and Jo van Gogh-Bonger_, Amsterdam and Leiden, 2002: 52 (17/12), 127 (92/10), 149, 172. See also Walter Feilchenfeldt, _Vincent van Gogh and Paul Cassirer, Berlin: The Reception of van Gogh in Germany from 1901-1914_, Zwolle, 1988: 94. A label from the "Kunsthandel C.M. van Gogh, Keizersgracht 953, Amsterdam" is on the back of the painting. [3] Thea Sternheim, _Tagebücher 1905-1927. Die Jahre mit Carl Sternhaim_, Mainz, 1995: 25, mentions Carl trading the portrait to Bernheim-Jeune in exchange for a landscape. Bernheim-Jeune & Cie no. 16771 is per a label on the back of the painting. Hessel, Rosenberg and Georges Bernheim are per Chester Dale papers, in NGA curatorial files. [4] The painting was lent by Kann to the 1917 exhibition _Französische Kunst des XIX. u. XX. Jahrhunderts_, Zürchner Kunsthaus, no.108, as _Fillette d'Arles_. There is also a partial label on the back of the painting that reads "Alph. Kann. van Gogh, Fillette d'Arles." [5] The Stang collection was visited in January 1929 by Cesar de Hauke and Germain Seligmann, per the Seligmann papers, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington: Box 208. The collection was described, and this painting reproduced, by Paul Jamot in "L'Art français en Norvège," _La Renaissance_ (February 1929). This painting, however, was already sold by Dr. Alfred Gold to Reid & Lefèvre by that time. See Reid & Lefèvre, Paintings Sold, sheet no. 161, #312/28 B1343, which records the date of purchase from Gold as 3 January 1928 (Lefèvre archives, Hyman Kreitman Research Centre, Tate Britain, London, TGA 2002/11, Box 283). Gold was selling pictures from the Stang collection over a number of years; see the Seligmann papers, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington: Box 394. Copies of all the archival documents are in NGA curatorial files. [6] The invoice dated 5 April 1929 from Bignou to Reid & Lefèvre for the re-framing of the painting suggests it was in Paris by that time (Lefèvre archives, Hyman Kreitman Research Centre, Tate Britain, London, TGA 2002/11, Box 180). On 29 May 1929, Bignou writes that he has shipped the picture to London (Lefèvre archives, Hyman Kreitman Research Centre, Tate Britain, London, TGA 2002/11, Box 218). Copies of the 1929 invoice and letter are in NGA curatorial files.

Falsas alarmas · 6

La pista no se sostiene, y lo muestra algo que no depende del museo: la coincidencia automática es con otra obra (otro tema, otras medidas) o un registro independiente (Lost Art, el ERR, el Collecting Point de Múnich) aclara el caso.

  1. Canaletto, Entrance to the Grand Canal from the Molo, Venice, 1742/1744

    Inventario 1945.15.4 · 114.5 × 153.5 cm · Gift of Mrs. Barbara Hutton · Ficha en el museo

    Falsa alarma. La regla la unió a una obra buscada de nuestra base sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. La regla la unió a una «Canale Grande» buscada sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. La procedencia es inglesa (Castle Howard) hasta 1938 y Barbara Hutton. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold 1938 by the Trustees of Geoffrey Howard to Barbara Hutton» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Entrance to the Grand Canal from the Molo, Venice» (1945.15.4)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Canale Grande con Chiesa della Salute ( Venice ) (procedencia dudosa) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; título en común (canale≈canal, grande≈grand, venice) · puntaje 45
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Probably Henry Howard, 4th earl of Carlisle [1694-1758], or Frederick, 5th earl of Carlisle [1748-1825], Castle Howard, Yorkshire;[1] by descent to Hon. Geoffrey William Howard [1877-1935], Castle Howard, Yorkshire; sold 1938 by the Trustees of Geoffrey Howard to Barbara Hutton, the countess Hangwitz Reventlow [1912-1979], Winfield House, London;[2] gift 1945 to NGA. [1] The date of acquisition of the group of paintings by Canaletto at Castle Howard is uncertain. Although the greatest part of the picture collection appears to have been brought together by Frederick, 5th earl of Carlisle (1748-1825), who traveled in Italy in 1768, it is almost certain that the Canalettos were acquired by his father, the 4th earl. Some of these were certainly at Castle Howard by 1745, where they were seen by Lady Oxford in an account of her journey in that year through northern England into Scotland: "April 27, Saturday. Set out from York for Castle Howard, the seat of the Earl of Carlisle . . . in the drawing-room . . . are several views of Venice by Canaletti lately put up there" (Finberg, Hilda F., "Canaletto in England," _The Walpole Society_ 9 (1920-1921): 25). The probate inventory taken in 1758 (Castle Howard Archives F4/1) includes several references to "views of Venice," including eighteen in the "Blue Coffoy Drawing Room." Moreover, the 5th earl does not record any Canalettos in his list of works of art bought by himself, but does include "between 30 & 40 views of Venice small" and "10 views of Venice Canaletti" in his list of "the best pictures at Castle Howard not purchased by me" (Castle Howard Archives J14/30/2; information from Eeyan Hartley, Keeper of Archives, letter of 7 December 1993). The standard eighteenth- and nineteenth-century descriptions of the Castle Howard paintings collection specify few individual pictures by Canaletto: Neale 1818-1823, 5: n.p., Castle Howard, Yorkshire: "Eighteen fine views.-Canaletti"; Waagen, Gustav Friedrich, _Treasures of Art in Great Britain_, 3 vols., London, 1854: 3: 323-324, no. 69: "'A large view of Venice [_The Bacino di San Marco_ (Museum of Fine Arts, Boston)]. In every respect one of the best works of the master, whose extraordinary merit can only be appreciated in England.' Nos. 71 88, 'Pictures by Canaletto, some of them very excellent.'" Henry Howard, 4th earl of Carlisle, made his second visit to Italy in 1738-1739 and was said by Lady Mary Wortley Montagu to have been in Venice in November 1738 (Halsband, Robert, ed., _The Complete Letters of Lady Mary Wortley Montagu_, 3 vols., Oxford, 1965-1967: 1: 127, 148-149). The family tradition is that the paintings were acquired from Canaletto himself by the 4th earl of Carlisle (undated letter in NGA curatorial files from the 12th and present earl of Carlisle, Naworth Castle, Brampton, Cumbria). According to Browning (Browning, H. Ellen, "The Canaletto Collection at Castle Howard", _Art Journal_ 68 (1905): 340) there were, in 1905, four large and nine smaller views by Canaletto in the "Canaletto Room" at Castle Howard, as well as eleven smaller works by Marieschi. Three more "hanging in the music-room and one in Lady Carlisle's drawing-room" were evidently large pictures by Canaletto. A curious note on the early provenance of the National Gallery's paintings is provided by the inscription ("Bought of Lord Carlisle/ 1825 Gower") on the reverse of the lining canvas of 1945.15.4, suggesting that the painting was sold by the 5th earl in 1825. (George Granville, baron Gower [1758-1833], became 2d marquess of Stafford in 1803 and 1st duke of Sutherland in 1833. He was one of the syndicate of three, together with his uncle the duke of Bridgewater and the 5th earl of Carlisle, involved with the importation of the Italian pictures from the Orléans collection in France in 1797-1798). The 5th earl died in 1825, so it may be that his son, George, 6th earl of Carlisle (1773-1848) sold the painting after his father's death to assist with the usual financial problems connected with probate. As Eeyan Hartley points out (letter of 7 December 1993 in NGA curatorial files), "This leaves the puzzle as to when the painting was returned to the Castle Howard collection." Constable, W. G., _Canaletto: Giovanni Antonio Canal, 1697-1768_, 2nd ed. revised by J. G. Links, 2 vols., Oxford, 1989: 2:nos. 40, 50, 85 [b], 154, 131, 171, 236, 334, discusses eight of the Castle Howard paintings as by Canaletto or his studio. Links, J. G., _Canaletto_, Oxford, 1982: 83-84, noting the uneven quality of the Castle Howard Canalettos, most of which were sold in the late 1930s or destroyed by fire in 1940, suggested that the 4th earl of Carlisle may have employed an agent other than Joseph Smith for his acquisition of paintings by the artist. "Such an agent may well have had his own sources for view paintings, but he or Lord Carlisle must have gone to Canaletto for three pictures of the collection": the Washington paintings, signed with the artist's initials, an unheard-of-practice before the 1740s, and the Boston view of the Bacino di San Marco from the Dogana, one of the artist's masterpieces. [2] Information from the archival house lists of the collections, Castle Howard. For a resumé of the paintings formerly at Castle Howard, see Constable and Links 1989, 2: 203, and note 1. _The Bacino di San Marco_ (Museum of Fine Arts, Boston) was acquired in 1939 from Castle Howard through the intermediation of Captain J. Spink, London, who may also have been involved with the sale of the other paintings (information from the Museum of Fine Arts curatorial files).

  2. Eugène Boudin, Beach at Trouville, 1864/1865

    Inventario 1970.17.12 · 27 × 49.1 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Falsa alarma. La regla la unió a una obra buscada de nuestra base sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. Unida por título («Plage de Trouville», tema que Boudin pintó decenas de veces) sin medidas. La procedencia es inglesa: venta Rothermere en Londres, 1941. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(his sale, Christie's, London, 19 December 1941, no. 34); purchased by (Arthur Tooth and Sons, London and Paris) for Capt. Edward H. Molyneux» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Beach at Trouville» (1970.17.12)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Plage de Trouville (desaparecida) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; mismo título · puntaje 45
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Dieterle, Paris. Paul Gerson, New York. Harold Sidney Harmsworth, 1st Viscount Rothermere [d.1940]; (his sale, Christie's, London, 19 December 1941, no. 34); purchased by (Arthur Tooth and Sons, London and Paris) for Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952;[1] sold 15 August 1955 to Ailsa Mellon Bruce [1901-1969], New York; bequest 1970 to NGA. [1] According to annotated copy of the sales catalogue in NGA curatorial files. This is almost certainly the picture recorded as Boudin, "At Deauville" in Arthur Tooth records, volume XXI, London Branch Stock Inventory, p. 85 (Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles, accession no. 860679), which was sold with another Rothermere picture to Molyneux on the day of the Christie's sale.

  3. Francesco Guardi, Grand Canal with the Rialto Bridge, Venice, probably c. 1780

    Inventario 1942.9.27 · 68.5 × 91.5 cm · Widener Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Falsa alarma. La regla la unió a una obra buscada de nuestra base sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. Unida por título genérico de Venecia sin medidas; en Filadelfia desde 1894. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «John G. Johnson, Philadelphia; purchased 1894 by Peter A. B. Widener» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Grand Canal with the Rialto Bridge, Venice» (1942.9.27)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: View on Venice, Canale Grande (procedencia dudosa) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; título en común (canale≈canal, grande≈grand, venice) · puntaje 45
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Possibly John Ingram [1767-1841], Matsala [or Marsala] House, England;[1] probably passed to his son Hughes Ingram [b. c. 1800]; probably passed to his nephew Ingram Fuller Godfrey [1827-1916].[2] John G. Johnson, Philadelphia; purchased 1894 by Peter A. B. Widener, Lynnewood Hall, Elkins Park, Pennsylvania;[3] inheritance from Estate of Peter A. B. Widener by gift through power of appointment of Joseph E. Widener, Elkins Park, Pennsylvania; gift 1942 to NGA. [1] _Catalogue of Paintings Forming the Private Collection of P.A.B. Widener, Ashbourne, near Philadelphia. Part II. Early English and Ancient Paintings_, Paris, 1885-1900: 202, gives the provenance as "Ingram (Marsala House) Collection." A typewritten copy of the same catalogue, dated 1908 on the binding (NGA library, Rare Book Collection), changes "Marsala" to "Matsala." Subsequent Widener catalogues (1916, 1923, and 1931) give the provenance as Matsala House. The probable pendant (see text of the NGA systematic catalogue entry) is listed in the _Catalogue of a Collection of Pictures Belonging to John G. Johnson_, Philadelphia, 1892: 86, no. 257, as coming from "Ingram of Marsala House." Ingram has not been identified conclusively, but would appear to be John Ingram, who is known to have collected Guardi views in Venice around 1800. On John Ingram see Francis Haskell, "Francesco Guardi as _Vedutista_ and Some of His Patrons", _Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes_ 23 (1960): 271-272. In a letter of 17 September 1968 (NGA curatorial files), Haskell wrote that he was baffled by the reference to Matsala House. John Ingram is known to have resided at Staindrop Hall, County Durham; in Venice; and later in Rome. [2] The later history of John Ingram's collection is traced by James Byam Shaw, "Some Guardi Drawings Rediscovered", _Master Drawings_ 15 (1977): 3-5. Parts of Ingram's collection were dispersed at the end of the nineteenth century in public sales that did not include paintings. Johnson may have acquired the Washington and Philadelphia paintings directly or indirectly from Ingram's heirs at about this time, but this cannot be documented. [3] According to a typewritten card in the Lynnewood Hall Inventories, NGA curatorial files. The painting does not appear in the 1892 Johnson catalogue cited in note 1.

  4. Francesco Guardi, Santa Maria della Salute, c. 1770

    Inventario 2015.19.29 · 32.39 × 52.71 cm · Corcoran Collection (William A. Clark Collection, 1926) · Ficha en el museo

    Falsa alarma. La regla la unió a una obra buscada de nuestra base sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. Unida por título genérico sin medidas; en Estados Unidos desde 1911. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «purchased October 1922 by William A. Clark [1839-1925], New York» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Santa Maria della Salute» (2015.19.29)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Ansicht auf Santa Maria de Salute in Venedig (desaparecida) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; título en común (salute, santa, virgen) · puntaje 45
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Private Collection, Paris. (Théodore Bonjean, Paris);[1] purchased 20 May 1911 by (M. Knoedler & Co., New York); Knoedler sold half-share to (P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.);[2] purchased October 1922 by William A. Clark [1839-1925], New York;[3] bequest 1926 to the Corcoran Gallery of Art, Washington; acquired 2015 by the National Gallery of Art. [1] Early provenance according to Knoedler. See M. Knoedler & Co. Records, accession number 2012.M.54, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: Painting Stockbook 5, 8800-12652, 1899 April-1911 December, page 243, the painting is stock number 12569. [2] The first mention of joint-ownership with Colnaghi is dated 30 April 1912. See M. Knoedler & Co. Records, accession number 2012.M.54, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: Painting Stockbook 6, 12653-15139, 1911 December-1920 July, page 21. [3] See See M. Knoedler & Co. Records, accession number 2012.M.54, Research Library, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles: Painting Stockbook 7, 15140-17039, 1921 January-1927 December, page 2.

  5. Lorenzo Monaco, Madonna and Child, 1413

    Inventario 1943.4.13 · 113.5 × 52.8 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Falsa alarma. La regla la unió a una obra buscada de nuestra base sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. Unida por título genérico («Madonna with child») sin medidas. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Count Alessandro Contini Bonacossi, Florence), by 1938;[2] sold September 1939 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Madonna and Child» (1943.4.13)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: madonna with child (procedencia dudosa) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; mismo título · puntaje 45
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Masson collection, Amiens, by 1904.[1] (Édouard Larcade, Paris), by 1927. (Count Alessandro Contini Bonacossi, Florence), by 1938;[2] sold September 1939 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, New York;[3] gift 1943 to NGA. [1] Osvald Sirén, _Don Lorenzo Monaco_, Strasbourg, 1905: 88-89. [2] Raimond van Marle (_The Development of the Italian Schools of Painting_, 19 vols., The Hague, 1923-1938: 9[1927]: 162) notes that at that time the painting was no longer in the Masson collection. A manuscript annotation on a photo of the painting in the archives of the Biblioteca Berenson at I Tatti, Florence, dated 30 November 1927, states it then belonged to E. Larcade, Paris. Expertises by Giuseppe Fiocco and Wilhelm Suida written in English (apparently for Contini Bonacossi in expectation of the sale to Samuel H. Kress; copies in NGA curatorial files) are dated May 1938. George Pudelko (“The stylistic development of Lorenzo Monaco,” _The Burlington Magazine_ 73 [1938]: 237-248 and 74 [1939]: 76-81) describes the painting as belonging to Alessandro Contini Bonacossi. [3] The painting was included on a bill of sale between the Kress Foundation and Contini Bonacossi dated 1 September 1939, where it is described as “formerly in the Musee Masson, Amiens and in the Larcade Collection, Saint Germain” (copy in NGA curatorial files). See also The Kress Collection Digital Archive, https://kress.nga.gov/Detail/objects/1334.

  6. Rembrandt Workshop, Joseph Accused by Potiphar's Wife, 1655

    Inventario 1937.1.79 · 105.7 × 97.8 cm · Andrew W. Mellon Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Falsa alarma. La regla la unió a una obra buscada de nuestra base sólo por artista y título, sin medidas. Unida por título sin medidas; es la venta del Hermitage a Mellon en 1931. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold January 1931, as a painting by Rembrandt, through (Matthiesen Gallery, Berlin, P. & D. Colnaghi & Co., London, and M. Knoedler & Co., New York) to Andrew W. Mellon» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Joseph Accused by Potiphar's Wife» (1937.1.79)

    Qué marcó el análisis automático (nivel media)
    • Coincide con una obra de nuestra base: Joseph and Potifar´s wife (procedencia dudosa) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; título en común (joseph, potifara≈potiphar, wife) · puntaje 45
    Procedencia completa publicada por el museo

    Gerard Hoet, Jr. [d.1760], The Hague; (his sale, by Arnoldus Franken, The Hague, 25-26 August 1760, no. 44).[1] Johann Ernst Gotzkowsky [1710-1775], Berlin; acquired in 1763 by Catherine II, empress of Russia [1729-1796], Saint Petersburg; Imperial Hermitage Gallery, Saint Petersburg; sold January 1931, as a painting by Rembrandt, through (Matthiesen Gallery, Berlin, P. & D. Colnaghi & Co., London, and M. Knoedler & Co., New York) to Andrew W. Mellon, Pittsburgh and Washington; deeded 1 May 1937 to The A.W. Mellon Educational and Charitable Trust, Pittsburgh;[2] gift 1937 to NGA. [1] Gerard Hoet, _Catalogus of Naamlyst van Schilderijen..._, 2 vols., The Hague, 1752, supplement by Pieter Terwesten, 1770, reprint ed. Soest, 1976, 3: 225, no. 44. The painting, which was described as a "kapitaal en uitmuntend stuk," sold for 100 florins. [2] The Mellon purchase date and the date deeded to the Mellon Trust are according to Mellon collection records in NGA curatorial files and David Finley's notebook (donated to the National Gallery of Art in 1977, now in the Gallery Archives). In 2012 The Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles, acquired the M. Knoedler & Co. records (accession number 2012.M.54), and in 2013 processed portions of the archive were first made publicly available. An entry from a January 1931 Knoedler sales book confirms the sale to Mellon (on-line illustration of the sales book page, in Karen Meyer-Roux, "Treasures from the Vault: Knoedler, Mellon, and an Unlikely Sale," _The Getty Iris_ [http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/author/kmeyerroux/], 30 July 2013).

Sin pistas sólo según el museo · 193

La pista salió del texto de procedencia del museo, y lo que la descarta también: una compra antes de 1933, una venta fuera del alcance nazi, un nombre que sería de otra persona. No lo cotejamos con documentos originales. No es un descarte: es lo que afirma el museo. Si tenés documentos que lo contradigan, escribinos.

Son muchas: para que la página cargue rápido, acá va el veredicto de cada una con su cita y sus fuentes; la procedencia completa está en la ficha del museo.

  1. Adriaen Isenbrant, The Adoration of the Shepherds, probably 1520/1540

    Inventario 1978.46.1 · 74.6 × 57 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Fund · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. La galería Paul Cassirer, ya trasladada a Ámsterdam por sus dueños emigrados, la tenía en 1936 y Rudolf Heinemann en Nueva York desde 1937. Cassirer aparece como marchante en el exilio que vende, no como dueño despojado. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Paul Cassirer, Amsterdam, by June 1936). (Rudolf Heinemann, New York, by 1937-January 1975)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Adoration of the Shepherds» (1978.46.1)

  2. Ambrogio de Predis, Bianca Maria Sforza, probably 1493

    Inventario 1942.9.53 · 51 × 32.5 cm · Widener Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. La regla saltó por una palabra de confiscación o incautación que se refiere a otra época, no al nazismo. La palabra «confiscación» está en una nota y no se refiere al nazismo; la obra está en Estados Unidos desde 1904 (Widener) y llegó al museo en 1942. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo.

    «acquired 1904 on joint account by (Durlacher Brothers, New York) and (P & D Colnaghi's, London and New York)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Bianca Maria Sforza» (1942.9.53)

  3. Amedeo Modigliani, Monsieur Deleu, 1916

    Inventario 1963.10.76 · 81.1 × 46.7 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Marcel Bernheim la vendió en 1927 y Chester Dale la compró en 1928. El «hueco» 1928–1962 es sólo el tiempo que Dale la tuvo en Nueva York hasta su legado. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Marcel Bernheim et Cie, Paris); purchased 1927 by (Etienne Bignou, Paris); sold 18 April 1928 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Monsieur Deleu» (1963.10.76)

  4. Andrea Mantegna, Portrait of a Man, c. 1470

    Inventario 1952.2.5 · 24.2 × 19.1 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Las firmas Seligmann (Jacques Seligmann & Co., Arnold Seligmann) eran marchantes de familia judía de París y Nueva York; el stock parisino de André Seligmann fue confiscado en 1940. Importan sólo si la obra estaba en París en la ocupación. Seligmann la compró en 1929 y la vendió a Kress en 1950. La regla marca a Seligmann por el saqueo de su stock en París; el texto no dice que la obra estuviera en París en 1940 (la firma operaba desde Nueva York), y no lo verificamos en otros registros. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold 1929 by his widow to (Jacques Seligmann & Co., Inc., Paris and New York);[2] sold May 1950 to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Portrait of a Man» (1952.2.5)

  5. André Derain, Still Life, 1913

    Inventario 1963.10.131 · 73.4 × 92.4 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. El secuestro es el de la Primera Guerra Mundial: Francia confiscó el stock del alemán Kahnweiler y lo remató en 1921. Chester Dale la compró en 1929. Nada que ver con el nazismo. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sequestered by French government during World War I and sold by the government at (Kahnweiler sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 17-18 November 1921)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Still Life» (1963.10.131)

  6. André Derain, The Old Bridge, 1910

    Inventario 1963.10.130 · 81 × 100.3 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Kahnweiler aparece sólo como primer marchante; en 1928 Chester Dale la compró en la venta Laroche. Todo antes de 1933. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Jean Laroche [1866-1935], Villa Sauge Pourprée, Deauville, by 1924; (his sale, Paris, 8 December 1928, no. 43); purchased by (Etienne Bignou, Paris) for Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Old Bridge» (1963.10.130)

  7. André Derain, View of the Thames, 1906

    Inventario 1985.64.12 · 73.3 × 92.2 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Vollard la compró en 1906; después Van der Velde (m. 1922) y una colección privada de París en 1955. Hay un hueco largo, pero no pasa por ningún dueño perseguido conocido; el veredicto se apoya sólo en el texto del museo. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Purchased 1906 by (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris).[1] Pieter van der Velde [1848-1922], Le Havre. Private collection, Paris, in 1955.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «View of the Thames» (1985.64.12)

  8. Antoine Watteau, The Italian Comedians, probably 1720

    Inventario 1946.7.9 · 63.8 × 76.2 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Wildenstein & Co. era una galería de familia judía cuyo stock en París saquearon los nazis; su nombre sólo importa si la obra estaba en París en 1940 o venía de un dueño perseguido. Wildenstein la recompró y la vendió a Kress, en Nueva York, en 1942. Antes fue de Thyssen y de lord Moyne. No hay dueño perseguido; el texto no aclara en qué sucursal estaba, pero en 1942 la venta es en Estados Unidos. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London), by December 1936; purchased 23 November 1942 by the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Italian Comedians» (1946.7.9)

  9. Antonio Joli, Procession in the Courtyard of the Ducal Palace, Venice, 1742 or after

    Inventario 1945.15.1 · 160.7 × 221.6 cm · Gift of Mrs. Barbara Hutton · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Las firmas Seligmann (Jacques Seligmann & Co., Arnold Seligmann) eran marchantes de familia judía de París y Nueva York; el stock parisino de André Seligmann fue confiscado en 1940. Importan sólo si la obra estaba en París en la ocupación. Arnold Seligmann la tenía en Londres a comienzos de los años 30 y se la vendió a Barbara Hutton. Londres, fuera del alcance nazi. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Arnold Seligmann, London), early 1930s; sold to Barbara Hutton; gift 1945 to NGA.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Procession in the Courtyard of the Ducal Palace, Venice» (1945.15.1)

  10. Antonio Joli, Procession of Gondolas in the Bacino di San Marco, Venice, 1742 or after

    Inventario 1945.15.2 · 160.7 × 221.6 cm · Gift of Mrs. Barbara Hutton · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Las firmas Seligmann (Jacques Seligmann & Co., Arnold Seligmann) eran marchantes de familia judía de París y Nueva York; el stock parisino de André Seligmann fue confiscado en 1940. Importan sólo si la obra estaba en París en la ocupación. Igual que su par (1945.15.1): Arnold Seligmann en Londres a comienzos de los 30, vendida a Barbara Hutton. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Arnold Seligmann, London), early 1930s; sold to Barbara Hutton; gift 1945 to NGA.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Procession of Gondolas in the Bacino di San Marco, Venice» (1945.15.2)

  11. Auguste Renoir, A Girl with a Watering Can, 1876

    Inventario 1963.10.206 · 100 × 73 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Marcel Kapferer era socio en una cuenta conjunta de marchantes que la vendió a Chester Dale en 1931. Antes del nazismo. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold September 1931 through (Galerie Étienne Bignou, Paris) to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «A Girl with a Watering Can» (1963.10.206)

  12. Auguste Renoir, Bather Arranging Her Hair, 1893

    Inventario 1963.10.204 · 92.4 × 74 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Vollard y Kapferer figuran como marchantes; Chester Dale la compró en 1929. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «on joint account with (M. Knoedler & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (Marcel Kapferer); sold May 1929 through (Galerie Étienne Bignou, Paris) to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Bather Arranging Her Hair» (1963.10.204)

  13. Auguste Renoir, Child with Blond Hair, 1895/1900

    Inventario 1970.17.69 · 9.5 × 8.4 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Salta de Vollard a Edward Molyneux (para 1952) sin el tramo intermedio. Es parte de un grupo de Renoir de Vollard que Molyneux vendió en 1955 a Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Hay hueco, pero Vollard y sus herederos no fueron perseguidos; el veredicto se apoya en el texto del museo. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Child with Blond Hair» (1970.17.69)

  14. Auguste Renoir, Child with Brown Hair, 1887/1888

    Inventario 1970.17.70 · 11.7 × 10.1 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo que 1970.17.69: de Vollard a Molyneux (para 1952), vendida en 1955 a Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Child with Brown Hair» (1970.17.70)

  15. Auguste Renoir, Claude Monet, 1872

    Inventario 1985.64.35 · 65 × 50 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Paul Rosenberg la tuvo después de 1912; Decourcelle la vendió en 1926 y Arthur Sachs la compró en 1928. Rosenberg es anterior a 1933. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Paul Rosenberg, Paris). Pierre Decourcelle [1856-1926], Paris; (his sale, Paris, 16 June 1926, no. 63)» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Claude Monet» (1985.64.35)

  16. Auguste Renoir, Diana, 1867

    Inventario 1963.10.205 · 199.5 × 129.5 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Kapferer fue socio en la cuenta que la vendió a Bignou en 1929; Chester Dale la compró en enero de 1933. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold 25 November 1929 to (Etienne Bignou, Paris and New York);[2] sold 16 January 1933 to Chester [1882-1962] and Maud [1875-1953] Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Diana» (1963.10.205)

  17. Auguste Renoir, Landscape at Vétheuil, c. 1890

    Inventario 1970.17.72 · 11.5 × 16.5 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo de Renoir de Vollard que pasó a Molyneux (para 1952) y a Ailsa Mellon Bruce en 1955. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Landscape at Vétheuil» (1970.17.72)

  18. Auguste Renoir, Mademoiselle Sicot, 1865

    Inventario 1963.10.209 · 116 × 89.5 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Georges Bernheim la compró en la venta de 1929 y la vendió enseguida; Chester Dale la tenía desde 1930. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Georges Bernheim, Paris; sold to (Demotte Galleries); sold 1930 in conjunction with (Marie Sterner Galleries, New York) to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Mademoiselle Sicot» (1963.10.209)

  19. Auguste Renoir, Nude with Figure in Background, c. 1882

    Inventario 1970.17.74 · 12.8 × 8.3 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo Vollard → Molyneux (para 1952) → Ailsa Mellon Bruce (1955). Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Nude with Figure in Background» (1970.17.74)

  20. Auguste Renoir, Peaches on a Plate, 1902/1905

    Inventario 1970.17.79 · 22.2 × 35.6 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. De Vollard salta a Sam Salz en Nueva York (1958). Hueco largo, pero sin dueño perseguido conocido; veredicto basado en el texto del museo. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Acquired from the artist before 1919 by (Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris).[1] (Sam Salz Inc., New York); sold 6 November 1958» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Peaches on a Plate» (1970.17.79)

  21. Auguste Renoir, Small Study for a Nude, 1882

    Inventario 1970.17.73 · 13.3 × 10.3 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo Vollard → Molyneux → Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Small Study for a Nude» (1970.17.73)

  22. Auguste Renoir, The Young Soldier, c. 1880

    Inventario 2014.18.46 · 54.93 × 33.02 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Jos Hessel, marchante de París, la tenía en 1932; en 1935 estaba en la galería Carstairs de Nueva York. No pasa por un dueño perseguido entre 1933 y 1945. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Jos Hessel, Paris), by 1932.[2] (Carroll Carstairs Gallery, New York), 1935.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Young Soldier» (2014.18.46)

  23. Auguste Renoir, Woman Standing by a Tree, 1866

    Inventario 1970.17.67 · 25.2 × 15.9 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo Vollard → Molyneux → Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Woman Standing by a Tree» (1970.17.67)

  24. Auguste Renoir, Woman by a Fence, 1866

    Inventario 1970.17.66 · 25 × 16.1 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo Vollard → Molyneux → Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Woman by a Fence» (1970.17.66)

  25. Auguste Renoir, Woman in a Park, 1866

    Inventario 1970.17.68 · 26.1 × 16.1 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo Vollard → Molyneux → Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Woman in a Park» (1970.17.68)

  26. Auguste Renoir, Young Girl Reading, c. 1888

    Inventario 1970.17.71 · 14.8 × 10.7 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Ambroise Vollard fue el gran marchante de los impresionistas; no fue perseguido por el nazismo (murió en un accidente en 1939), así que su nombre no indica saqueo. Mismo grupo Vollard → Molyneux → Ailsa Mellon Bruce. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Ambroise Vollard [1866-1939], Paris). Capt. Edward H. Molyneux [1891-1974], Paris, by 1952» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Young Girl Reading» (1970.17.71)

  27. Auguste Renoir, Young Woman Braiding Her Hair, 1876

    Inventario 1970.17.63 · 55.5 × 46 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Bernheim-Jeune la pasó en 1934 a Durand-Ruel de Nueva York y Andrew Mellon la compró en 1937. Salió de Francia antes de la guerra por venta normal. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Private collection of Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, by 1913;[2] in partnership 1934 to (Durand-Ruel, New York); sold 1937 to (Carroll Carstairs Gallery, New York); sold 1937 to Andrew Mellon» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Young Woman Braiding Her Hair» (1970.17.63)

  28. Bartolomeo Veneto, Portrait of a Gentleman, c. 1520

    Inventario 1939.1.257 · 76.8 × 58.4 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. René Gimpel, marchante judío que murió deportado en 1945, la tuvo con Wildenstein hacia 1911 y la vendió en 1919. Mucho antes del nazismo. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Probably owned jointly by (Wildenstein & Co., London, New York and Paris) and (René Gimpel, Paris), from c. 1911; sold 1919 to Henry Goldman» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Portrait of a Gentleman» (1939.1.257)

  29. Berthe Morisot, The Mother and Sister of the Artist, 1869/1870

    Inventario 1963.10.186 · 101 × 81.8 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Paul Rosenberg se la vendió a Chester Dale en 1930; el «hueco» hasta 1962 es la propiedad de Dale. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Paul Rosenberg, Paris); sold 15 May 1930 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Mother and Sister of the Artist» (1963.10.186)

  30. Camille Pissarro, Boulevard des Italiens, Morning, Sunlight, 1897

    Inventario 1963.10.198 · 73.2 × 92.1 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Rosenberg la vendió a Wildenstein en 1929 y ese año la compró Chester Dale. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., London and New York); by whom sold February 1929 to (Wildenstein & Co., London and New York); sold 1929 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Boulevard des Italiens, Morning, Sunlight» (1963.10.198)

  31. Camille Pissarro, Charing Cross Bridge, London, 1890

    Inventario 1985.64.32 · 60 × 90 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Rosenberg aparece sin fecha entre 1930 y 1939; para 1939 la tenía Bignou y después Reid & Lefèvre y el escocés Cargill. No hay indicio de que estuviera en poder de Rosenberg en 1940; no lo verificamos en el ERR más allá de nuestra base. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Paul Rosenberg and Co., London, New York and Paris). (Galerie Étienne Bignou, Paris and New York), by 1939.» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Charing Cross Bridge, London» (1985.64.32)

  32. Camille Pissarro, Peasant Woman, 1880

    Inventario 1963.10.199 · 73 × 60.4 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Rosenberg se la vendió a Chester Dale en 1928. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold to (Paul Rosenberg and Co., London, New York and Paris); by whom sold 17 April 1928 to Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Peasant Woman» (1963.10.199)

  33. Camille Pissarro, The Artist's Garden at Eragny, 1898

    Inventario 1970.17.54 · 73.4 × 92.1 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Rosenberg aparece antes de 1939; para 1939 era de Louise Gillou y siguió en su familia hasta 1964. Rosenberg no la tenía en 1940. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Paul Rosenberg et Cie., Paris). Mme Louise Gillou, Paris, by 1939; her daughter, Mme. René Fenwick, Paris» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Artist's Garden at Eragny» (1970.17.54)

  34. Charles Amédée Philippe Van Loo, Soap Bubbles, 1764

    Inventario 1945.10.2 · 88.6 × 88.5 cm · Gift of Mrs. Robert W. Schuette · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Wildenstein & Co. era una galería de familia judía cuyo stock en París saquearon los nazis; su nombre sólo importa si la obra estaba en París en 1940 o venía de un dueño perseguido. Wildenstein la vendió en 1929 a los Schuette de Nueva York. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London); sold 1929 to Robert W. [d. 1935] and Florence Steuber Gaines Harkness [d. 1945] Schuette» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Soap Bubbles» (1945.10.2)

  35. Charles Amédée Philippe Van Loo, The Camera Obscura, 1764

    Inventario 1945.10.1 · 88.6 × 88.5 cm · Gift of Mrs. Robert W. Schuette · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Wildenstein & Co. era una galería de familia judía cuyo stock en París saquearon los nazis; su nombre sólo importa si la obra estaba en París en 1940 o venía de un dueño perseguido. Igual que su par: Wildenstein la vendió en 1929 a los Schuette. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Wildenstein & Co., Inc., Paris, New York, and London); sold 1929 to Robert W. [d. 1935] and Florence Steuber Gaines Harkness [d. 1945] Schuette» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «The Camera Obscura» (1945.10.1)

  36. Charles Georges Dufresne, Still Life, 1927/1928

    Inventario 1963.10.141 · 81.6 × 100.3 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Los Bernheim (Bernheim-Jeune, Georges, Marcel, Emile, Gaston) y los Kapferer eran coleccionistas y marchantes judíos de París; importan sólo si tenían la obra durante la ocupación. Henry Kapferer la vendió en Drouot en 1930 y la compró Chester Dale. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Henry Kapferer, Paris; (sold, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 14 June 1930); purchased by Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Still Life» (1963.10.141)

  37. Cima da Conegliano, Madonna and Child with Saint Jerome and Saint John the Baptist, c. 1492/1495

    Inventario 1937.1.33 · 102 × 144 cm · Andrew W. Mellon Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Las firmas Seligmann (Jacques Seligmann & Co., Arnold Seligmann) eran marchantes de familia judía de París y Nueva York; el stock parisino de André Seligmann fue confiscado en 1940. Importan sólo si la obra estaba en París en la ocupación. Seligmann la vendió en 1919 a lord D'Abernon. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(Jacques Seligmann & Co., Inc., Paris and New York); sold December 1919 to Sir Edgar Vincent» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Madonna and Child with Saint Jerome and Saint John the Baptist» (1937.1.33)

  38. Circle of Jacopo Tintoretto (Probably Lambert Sustris), Christ at the Sea of Galilee, c. 1570s

    Inventario 1952.5.27 · 117.1 × 169.2 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Las firmas Seligmann (Jacques Seligmann & Co., Arnold Seligmann) eran marchantes de familia judía de París y Nueva York; el stock parisino de André Seligmann fue confiscado en 1940. Importan sólo si la obra estaba en París en la ocupación. Arthur Sachs la vendió en Nueva York en 1943 a través de Seligmann; Seligmann fue intermediario en Estados Unidos. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «sold March 1943 through (Jacques Seligmann & Co., New York) and (Moses & Singer, New York) to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Christ at the Sea of Galilee» (1952.5.27)

  39. Circle of Jacques-Louis David, Portrait of a Young Woman in White, c. 1798

    Inventario 1963.10.118 · 125.5 × 95 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. La regla confundió un apellido («Mr. Levy» en una nota). La obra estuvo en Nueva York desde 1914 (Havemeyer) y Dale la compró en 1930. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «(her estate sale, American Art Association, New York, 10 April 1930, no. 79); Chester Dale» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Portrait of a Young Woman in White» (1963.10.118)

  40. Claude Monet, Woman with a Parasol - Madame Monet and Her Son, 1875

    Inventario 1983.1.29 · 100 × 81 cm · Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon · Ficha en el museo

    Sin pistas sólo según el museo. Paul Rosenberg era un marchante judío de París cuyo stock saquearon los nazis en 1940–41; su nombre sólo importa si la obra seguía en su poder en Francia en 1940. Rosenberg figura como «posiblemente» antes de 1924; desde 1924 fue de Georges Menier hasta su venta en 1965. Veredicto basado en el texto del museo; el cruce automático de limbral con Lost Art, el ERR y las bases de Linz y Göring no encontró una obra que coincida.

    «Possibly (Paul Rosenberg and Co., London, New York, and Paris).[1] Georges Menier, Paris, by 1924» — procedencia publicada por el museo

    National Gallery of Art: «Woman with a Parasol - Madame Monet and Her Son» (1983.1.29)

Ver las 193

Pistas débiles, sin leer a mano todavía · 446

Son las otras 446 de las 711 obras con pistas. Casi todas tienen sólo un hueco entre 1933 y 1945 con la obra en Europa antes del salto. Las dejamos a la vista para que cualquiera pueda revisarlas.

Son muchas: para que la página cargue rápido, acá va el veredicto de cada una con su cita y sus fuentes; la procedencia completa está en la ficha del museo.

  1. Adam Pynacker, Wooded Landscape with Travelers, late 1640s

    Inventario 1979.27.1 · 57 × 48 cm · Gift of Ruth B. Benedict and Bertha B. Leubsdorf in memory of Sophie and Carl Boschwitz · Ficha en el museo

  2. Adolphe Monticelli, Return from the Hunt, 1860/1861

    Inventario 2015.19.32 · 52.07 × 102.87 cm · Corcoran Collection (William A. Clark Collection, 1926) · Ficha en el museo

  3. Adolphe Monticelli, Still Life, 1880s

    Inventario 2015.19.33 · 41.91 × 62.87 cm · Corcoran Collection (William A. Clark Collection, 1926) · Ficha en el museo

  4. Adriaen Brouwer, Youth Making a Face, c. 1632/1635

    Inventario 1994.46.1 · 13.7 × 10.5 cm · New Century Fund · Ficha en el museo

  5. Adriaen van Ostade, Tavern Scene, early 1660s

    Inventario 1977.21.1 · 23.8 × 20.4 cm · Gift of John Russell Mason · Ficha en el museo

  6. Aelbert Cuyp, A Pier Overlooking Dordrecht, early 1640s

    Inventario 2012.73.1 · 44.5 × 75.9 cm · Gift of George M. and Linda H. Kaufman · Ficha en el museo

  7. Agnolo Bronzino, Eleonora di Toledo, c. 1560

    Inventario 1961.9.7 · 86.4 × 65.1 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

  8. Alan Shields, Quackey Stud Duck or Sparrows Won't Eat Onion Bread (Halitosis), 1972

    Inventario 2015.19.182 · 210.82 × 419.1 cm · Corcoran Collection (Gift of Marvin and Florence Gerstin, 1983) · Ficha en el museo

  9. Albert Marquet, The Pont Neuf, 1906

    Inventario 1963.10.164 · 50.2 × 61.3 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  10. Albrecht Dürer, Portrait of a Clergyman (Johann Dorsch?), 1516

    Inventario 1952.2.17 · 41.7 × 32.7 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

  11. Alexandre-François Desportes, Still Life with Dressed Game, Meat, and Fruit, 1734

    Inventario 2012.11.1 · 121 × 95 cm · Chester Dale Fund · Ficha en el museo

  12. Alexej von Jawlensky, Portrait of a Woman, c. 1911

    Inventario 2020.112.6 · 64.5 × 53.7 cm · Collection of Arnold and Joan Saltzman · Ficha en el museo

  13. Alfred Sisley, Boulevard Héloïse, Argenteuil, 1872

    Inventario 1970.17.82 · 39.5 × 59.6 cm · Ailsa Mellon Bruce Collection · Ficha en el museo

  14. Alfred Sisley, The Banks of the Oise, 1877/1878

    Inventario 1963.10.214 · 54.3 × 64.7 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  15. Alfred Sisley, The Road in the Woods, 1879

    Inventario 1963.10.215 · 46.3 × 55.8 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  16. Alfred Stevens, Young Woman in White Holding a Bouquet, c. 1865/1875

    Inventario 1963.10.65 · 28.8 × 21.5 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  17. Ambrosius Bosschaert, Bouquet of Flowers in a Glass Vase, 1621

    Inventario 1996.35.1 · 31.6 × 21.6 cm · Patrons' Permanent Fund and New Century Fund · Ficha en el museo

  18. Amedeo Modigliani, Café Singer, 1917

    Inventario 1963.10.44 · 92.4 × 60.3 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  19. Amedeo Modigliani, Chaim Soutine, 1918

    Inventario 1963.10.47 · 91.7 × 59.7 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  20. Amedeo Modigliani, Girl in a Green Blouse, 1917

    Inventario 1963.10.45 · 81.3 × 46 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  21. Amedeo Modigliani, Léon Bakst, 1917

    Inventario 1963.10.173 · 55.3 × 33 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  22. Amedeo Modigliani, Madame Amédée (Woman with Cigarette), 1918

    Inventario 1963.10.172 · 100.3 × 64.8 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  23. Amedeo Modigliani, Madame Kisling, c. 1917

    Inventario 1963.10.175 · 46.2 × 33.2 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  24. Amedeo Modigliani, Nude on a Divan, 1918

    Inventario 1963.10.77 · 60.2 × 91.7 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  25. Amedeo Modigliani, Roma Woman with Baby, 1919

    Inventario 1963.10.174 · 115.9 × 73 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  26. Amedeo Modigliani, Woman with Red Hair, 1917

    Inventario 1963.10.176 · 92.1 × 60.7 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  27. Andrea del Sarto, Charity, before 1530

    Inventario 1957.14.5 · 119.5 × 92.5 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

  28. André Derain, Flowers in a Vase, 1932

    Inventario 1963.10.128 · 75 × 94 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  29. André Derain, Harlequin, 1919

    Inventario 1963.10.129 · 74 × 61 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  30. André Derain, Head of a Woman, 1926

    Inventario 1963.10.20 · 36.2 × 33 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  31. André Derain, Woman in an Armchair, 1920/1925

    Inventario 1963.10.72 · 92.4 × 73.7 cm · Chester Dale Collection · Ficha en el museo

  32. Angelica Kauffmann, Possibly Franciska Krasinska, Duchess of Courland, c. 1790

    Inventario 1954.5.1 · 62.9 × 49.5 cm · Gift of Miss Alice Preston · Ficha en el museo

  33. Anne Vallayer-Coster, Still Life with Flowers in an Alabaster Vase and Fruit, 1783

    Inventario 2023.40.1 · 108.5 × 89.5 cm · Chester Dale Fund · Ficha en el museo

  34. Anne-Louis Girodet de Roussy-Trioson, Coriolanus Taking Leave of his Family, 1786

    Inventario 2019.169.1 · 144.78 × 176.53 cm · New Century Fund, Gift of Edwin L. Cox – Ed Cox Foundation, and Chester Dale Fund · Ficha en el museo

  35. Annibale Carracci, River Landscape, c. 1590

    Inventario 1952.5.58 · 88.3 × 148.1 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

  36. Anthonie van Borssom, River Scene with Windmill and Boats, Evening, probably 1655-1660

    Inventario 2012.99.1 · 18.42 × 26.67 cm · Gift of Robert H. and Clarice Smith · Ficha en el museo

  37. Anton Raphael Mengs, The Adoration of the Shepherds, c. 1764/1765

    Inventario 2014.136.114 · 264.16 × 152.4 cm · Corcoran Collection (Gift of William Wilson Corcoran, 1869) · Ficha en el museo

  38. Antwerp 16th Century, Lady of the De Pape Family, 16th century

    Inventario 2014.136.24 · 90.17 × 72.39 cm · Corcoran Collection (William A. Clark Collection, 1926) · Ficha en el museo

  39. Antwerp 16th Century, Portrait of an Almoner of Antwerp, 1542

    Inventario 1956.3.2 · 84.8 × 63.2 cm · Gift of Lewis Einstein · Ficha en el museo

  40. Antwerp 16th Century (Possibly Matthys Cock), The Martyrdom of Saint Catherine, c. 1540

    Inventario 1952.2.18 · 62.2 × 118.2 cm · Samuel H. Kress Collection · Ficha en el museo

Ver las 446