Limbral
Menu
ES

Museums

National Gallery of Ireland

Dublin · museum data: onlinecollection.nationalgallery.ie/ (Fichas públicas del museo (sin licencia abierta declarada para los textos); se guardan sólo para revisar la procedencia) · reviewed on 2026-11-20

How to read this page

The automated analysis read the provenance National Gallery of Ireland publishes for each painting and flagged 26 with some lead: a Nazi-era looting dealer or agency, a dispossessed owner, a confiscation, a gap between 1933 and 1945, a looting inventory number or a match with a wanted work in our database.

A lead does not mean the work was looted. We read the strong and medium ones by hand, one by one, and sorted them into four groups. Each work says why, with the provenance sentence that matters and its sources. Weak leads (almost always just a gap in the chain) are listed at the end, not yet reviewed.

The provenance a museum publishes is a claim to be checked, not a source in itself. Some museums have left out persecuted Jewish owners or put names in the chain that did not belong there: Laurel Zuckerman, heir of Paul and Alice Leffmann, documented it with the case of Picasso's «The Actor» at the Met («Detecting Deception in the Art Trade», Springer, 2025; the family's claim). So we separate two things: a «false alarm» is ruled out by a record independent of the museum (Lost Art, the ERR, the Collecting Point, or a match that turned out to be another work), while «cleared only by the museum's own account» means the only basis is what the museum itself says, not checked against original documents.

Open cases · 0

The museum's provenance omits or contradicts another public record: a Lost Art search request, an ERR card, a published claim.

Pending documents · 9

There is a persecuted owner or a looting dealer in the Nazi years and what is published is not enough to know what happened. Each says which document is missing.

  1. Gustave Caillebotte, Banks of a Canal, near Naples, c.1872

    Inventory NGI.2008.90 · 39.7 × 59.7 cm · Purchased, 2008 · Museum record

    Pending documents. It was auctioned at Drouot on 30 October 1940, with Paris already occupied, with Vollard provenance. We do not know who sold it (Vollard's heirs, Martin Fabiani or Erich Chlomovitch, whose holdings came under suspicion). There is no Caillebotte in the ERR database. The sale catalogue naming the seller is missing.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Ambroise Vollard: Ambroise Vollard, Paris; Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 30 October 1940, lot 67; Palais Galliéra, Paris, 18 June 196…
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Ambroise Vollard, Paris; Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 30 October 1940, lot 67; Palais Galliéra, Paris, 18 June 1962, lot 65; Palais Galliéra, Paris, 4 December 1971, lot 69; Christie's, New York, 12 November 1985, lot 41; Private Collection, San Diego; purchased at Christie's, New York, 7 May 2008, Impressionist and Modern, Day Sale, lot 317.

  2. Jean Louis Ernest Meissonier, A Guard, 1840

    Inventory NGI.4259 · 28 × 19 cm · Presented, Sir Alfred Chester Beatty, 1950 · Museum record

    Pending documents. From Baron Gustave de Rothschild (died 1911) it passed to Chester Beatty, who gave it in 1950; we do not know when or from whom Beatty bought it. The ERR database has no matching Meissonier painting from the Rothschilds. The date of Beatty's purchase is missing.

    Ficha del museo; The Irish Times: Chester Beatty's French connection

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Édouard de Rothschild: Baron Gustave de Rothschild; Sir Alfred Chester Beatty.
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Baron Gustave de Rothschild; Sir Alfred Chester Beatty.

  3. Maurice de Vlaminck, Flowers, c.1935

    Inventory NGI.1877 · 41 × 33 cm · Purchased, 1968 · Museum record

    Pending documents. It matches in artist, title and size a Vlaminck 'Fleurs' from Jacob Goldschmidt's collection, which he sold in exile to Justin Thannhauser in February 1940 for $90 and which Lost Art is searching for. But the Lost Art entry has no image or description, its size is uncertain and 41×33 is a standard canvas format. The Dublin work was already in Ireland in 1944 (Friends of the National Collection exhibition). Probably not the same work; an image or label tying it to Goldschmidt's inventory no. 172 is missing.

    Ficha del museo; Lost Art 622561

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Matches a work in our database: Fleurs / Blumen (missing) — mismo artista; medidas idénticas (41.0×33.0 vs 41.0×33.0 cm); título en común (flores) · score 66
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Galerie Montmartre, 33 Boulevard de Clichy, Paris; Fr. Jack Hanlon; Dawson Gallery, 4 Dawson Street, Dublin.

  4. Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes, El Sueño, c.1800

    Inventory NGI.1928 · 46.5 × 76 cm · Purchased, 1969 (Shaw Fund) · Museum record

    Pending documents. In 1924 it belonged to Mathilde Kocherthaler of Berlin, of the Kocherthaler business family of Madrid and Berlin; then to her heirs, then to Heinemann in New York. We do not know when or how the heirs sold it: a 2025 auction catalogue places them in Spain, keeping the collection until 1955, which makes a forced sale in Germany less likely but does not rule it out. It is not in Lost Art. The date of the sale to Heinemann is missing.

    «en 1924, ya pertenecía a la colección berlinesa de Mathilde Kocherthaler» — provenance published by the museum

    Ficha del museo; Fundación Goya en Aragón; Archivo Español de Arte: «María Luisa Caturla y el palacete Kocherthaler»; BBW Auktionen, Basilea, catálogo del 2 de abril de 2025

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1924 a 1969
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Exhibited by the Marqués de Cassa Jiménez in Madrid, 1900; the Marquesa de Casa Jiménez c.1924; Mathilde Kocherthler, Berlin; inheritors of Mathilde Kocherthler; Mr. Heineman, New York; Agnew and Son, London; Purchased, 1969 (Shaw Fund)

  5. Jacques-Louis David, The Funeral of Patroclus, 1778

    Inventory NGI.4060 · 94 × 218 cm · Purchased, 1973 (Shaw Fund) · Museum record

    Pending documents. The record jumps from the Serra collection in Naples (before 1840) to the Heim Gallery in London, which sold it to the museum in 1973. No Jewish owner is in sight, but there are no data for 1933–45 either.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1840 a 1973
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Sold by the artist to Abraham Fontanel, Paris, 12 March 1782; Acton Collection, Naples; Serra, Duca del Cardinale, Naples (prior to 1840); Heim Gallery, London; purchased, Heim Gallery, London, 1973

  6. Juan Fernández de Navarrete, Abraham and the Three Angels, 1576

    Inventory NGI.1721 · 287 × 238 cm · Purchased, 1962 (Shaw Fund) · Museum record

    Pending documents. Napoleonic war booty from the Escorial; owned by Marshal Soult's heirs 'until at least 1930', then a private French collection and Galerie Heim, which sold it in 1962. No Jewish owner is in sight, but who had it in France between 1930 and 1962 is missing.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1962
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Commissioned in 1575 by Philip II of Spain for the Recibimiento or Guest-Room of the monastery of the Escorial, where it remained in situ until taken as war booty by the French in 1809; given by Joseph Bonaparte to Marshal-General Soult, Duke of Dalmatia, 1809-1810; Galerie Lebrun, Paris, 19-22 May 1852, Soult sale, lot 3; re-sold Paris, second Soult sale, 1867; purchased by a member of the Soult family; by descent until at least 1930; Private Collection, France; Galerie Heim, Paris; purchased Galerie Heim, Paris, 1962

  7. Juan Gris, Pierrot, 1921

    Inventory NGI.4521 · 115 × 73 cm · Bequeathed, Máire MacNeill Sweeney, 1987 · Museum record

    Pending documents. Kahnweiler, Galerie Simon and G. F. Reber (1925); then back to Galerie Simon and on to collectors in Lausanne and Geneva before John Sweeney (1946). It was shown in Zurich in 1933 and Basel in 1945, so it seems to have spent the war in Switzerland. No ERR card. When it went back to Galerie Simon is missing.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1925 a 1946
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Daniel-Henry Kahnweiler; Galerie Simon, Paris, 1923; Dr G.F. Reber, Lausanne, 1925; Galerie Simon, Paris; Jean-Claude Anex, Lausanne; Galerie D. Bénador, Geneva; John L. Sweeney, 1946; Collection Mr. and Mrs. John Sweeney, Corofin, County Clare, 1967-1986; Máire MacNeill Sweeney; bequeathed, Máire MacNeill Sweeney, 1987

  8. Paul Signac, The Terrace, Saint-Tropez, 1898

    Inventory NGI.4361 · 72.5 × 91.5 cm · Purchased, 1982 (Shaw Fund) · Museum record

    Pending documents. Bernheim-Jeune had it in 1930; then the Parent, J. Planque and R. Gérard collections (perhaps the dealer Raphaël Gérard, who traded in Paris during the occupation) and Knoedler. No ERR card matches. The dates of each owner are missing.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1982
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Galerie Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, 1930; Parent collection, Paris; J. Planque, Paris; R. Gérard, Paris; M. Knoedler & Co., Inc., New York; Purchased, Christie's, New York, 19 May 1982, lot 24.

  9. Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Young Woman in white reading, 1873

    Inventory NGI.2007.74 · 35 × 27 cm · Purchased, 2007 · Museum record

    Pending documents. It passed through Bernheim-Jeune and Wildenstein, two Jewish Paris galleries the ERR looted in 1940–41, and Wildenstein showed it in New York in 1948. No ERR card matches. When it went from Bernheim-Jeune to Wildenstein is missing.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1914 a 1950
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Roux de Billencourt, France; Hotel Drouot, Paris, 25 November 1898, lot 56; purchased by Durand-Ruel, Paris; purchased by M. Furstenberg, Paris, 25 Aril 1914; Galerie Bernheim-Jeune, Paris; Wildenstein & Co., Paris and New York; purchased by Sam Salz, New York, 1950; Private Collection, New York; François Daulte, Paris; purchased for Private Collection, 8 June 1989; purchased at Sotheby's, New York, 8 November 2007, Impressionist & Modern Art Sale, lot 210

Settled by the museum · 0

The work had a looting or forced-sale past, and the museum researched it and tells it: restitution, settlement with the heirs or purchase from them.

False alarms · 1

The lead does not hold, and something independent of the museum shows it: the automatic match is another work (another subject, other measurements) or an independent record (Lost Art, the ERR, the Munich Collecting Point) settles it.

  1. Paul Cézanne, La Vie des Champs, c.1876-1877

    Inventory NGI.2023.1 · 27.5 × 35.2 cm · Purchased, 2022, with special support from the Government of Ireland and a generous contribution from a private donor. · Museum record

    False alarm. The Cézanne catalogue raisonné (FWN 641) gives the same chain as the museum: Bibesco sold it at Drouot in 1931, and from 1931 to 1949 it was with the Pierre Matisse Gallery in New York. The 'gap' is not a gap and there is no dispossessed Jewish owner.

    Ficha del museo; Catálogo razonado de Cézanne, FWN 641

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Ambroise Vollard: Ambroise Vollard, Paris; Prince Antoine Bibesco, Paris; sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 27 June 1931 (lot 75);…
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1931 a 1949
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Ambroise Vollard, Paris; Prince Antoine Bibesco, Paris; sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 27 June 1931 (lot 75); with Pierre Matisse Gallery, New York; sale, Parke-Bernet, New York, 6 January 1949 (lot 48); Galerie de l’Élysee; with Alex Maguy, Paris; with Acquavella Galleries, New York, from whom purchased by Mrs Elinor Dorrance Ingersoll; by descent to Dorrance H. Hamilton, until 2018; Purchased, 2022, with special support from the Government of Ireland and a generous contribution from a private donor.

Cleared only by the museum's own account · 16

The lead came from the museum's provenance text, and so does what rules it out: a purchase before 1933, a sale out of Nazi reach, a name said to belong to someone else. We did not check it against original documents. It is not a clearance: it is what the museum asserts. If you have documents that contradict it, write to us.

  1. Emil Nolde, Women in the Garden, 1915

    Inventory NGI.4490 · 73 × 88 cm · Purchased, 1984 (Shaw Fund) · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. It was confiscated in 1937–38 as 'degenerate art', but not from a Jewish owner: it had been in a German public museum, the Städtische Galerie / Städel in Frankfurt, since 1926. Confiscations from German museums fall outside limbral's scope, which covers what was taken from Jews.

    «Stadelsches Kunstinstitut/Stadtische Galerie, 1926; confiscated … as 'Entartete Kunst'» — provenance published by the museum

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Confiscation or forced sale: confiscación: Luders, Hamburg; Kowarzik collection; Stadelsches Kunstinstitut/Stadtische Galerie, 1926; confiscated by the German government as 'Entartete Kunst', 1937/38; sold, 1938; Private Collection,…
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Luders, Hamburg; Kowarzik collection; Stadelsches Kunstinstitut/Stadtische Galerie, 1926; confiscated by the German government as 'Entartete Kunst', 1937/38; sold, 1938; Private Collection, Munich; Roman Norbert Ketterer, Campione d'Italia near Lugano, 1967; Private Collection, Brazil; purchased, Sotheby's, London, 26 June 1984, Impressionist and Modern Paintings and Sculpture sale, part 1, lot 36

  2. Eugène Delacroix, Demosthenes on the Seashore, 1859

    Inventory NGI.964 · 49 × 60 cm · Purchased, 1934 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. The museum bought it in 1934 from Georges Bernheim et Cie. in Paris, a commercial sale six years before the occupation of France. Georges Bernheim was looted in 1940, but this work was already in Dublin.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Georges Bernheim: …sale, lot 13; Henry Rigaud; Hotel Drouot, Paris, 3 April 1933, sale estate Rigaud, lot 4; Georges Bernheim et Cie., Paris; purchased, Georges Bernheim et Cie, Paris, 1934
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Francis Petit by 1860; le chevalier A. de Knieff; Charlin; Hotel Drouot, Paris, 29 April 1872, Charlin sale, lot 7; Bryce; Hotel Drouot, Paris, 16 March 1877, Bryce sale, lot 13; Henry Rigaud; Hotel Drouot, Paris, 3 April 1933, sale estate Rigaud, lot 4; Georges Bernheim et Cie., Paris; purchased, Georges Bernheim et Cie, Paris, 1934

  3. Jean-Honoré Fragonard, Venus and Cupid (Day), c.1755

    Inventory NGI.4313 · 114 × 133 cm · Purchased, 1978 (Shaw Fund) · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. It passed through Léon Helft, a Jewish Paris dealer looted in 1940, but years earlier: Emil Bührle's complete purchase list records this Fragonard ('Vénus', C.150) bought from Rosengart in Lucerne on 17 December 1937 and traded to Wildenstein in 1954. The sale was in Switzerland and before the occupation of France. The museum names Wildenstein, not Rosengart, as Bührle's seller; that C.150 is this work fits its exhibitions (Zurich 1943, Bern 1954).

    «Fragonard, Vénus / C.150, R'gart LU (17.12.1937) CHF 200'000» — provenance published by the museum

    Ficha del museo; Lista de compras de E. G. Bührle (Fundación Bührle)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Confiscation or forced sale: incautación: Sold by F.H. Drouais to Mme. du Barry, June 1770; seized at Louveciennes in 1794; presented by Napoleon I to Baronne Denot; Collection Leon Helft;…
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Sold by F.H. Drouais to Mme. du Barry, June 1770; seized at Louveciennes in 1794; presented by Napoleon I to Baronne Denot; Collection Leon Helft; Wildenstein, New York; Collection Emile Buhrle, Zurich; Wildenstein, New York; purchased, Wildenstein, New York, 1978

  4. Jean-Léon Gérôme, On Duty, 1870s

    Inventory NGI.4234 · 81 × 65 cm · Presented, Sir Alfred Chester Beatty, 1950 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Henri de Rothschild sold it at a Drouot auction in Paris in March 1933, seven years before the occupation of France; it then passed to Chester Beatty, who gave it to the museum in 1950. It is not a persecution-related loss.

    «Sale of Monsieur X [Henri de Rothschild], Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 18 March 1933» — provenance published by the museum

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Édouard de Rothschild: Sale of Monsieur X [Henri de Rothschild], Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 18 March 1933, no.30, as ‘En Faction’; Sir Alfred Chester Beatty;…
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Henri de Rothschild: Sale of Monsieur X [Henri de Rothschild], Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 18 March 1933, no.30, as ‘En Faction’; Sir Alfred Chester Beatty;…
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Sale of Monsieur X [Henri de Rothschild], Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 18 March 1933, no.30, as ‘En Faction’; Sir Alfred Chester Beatty; Presented, Sir Alfred Chester Beatty,1950.

  5. Sebastiano del Piombo, Portrait of Cardinal Antonio Ciocchi del Monte (1461-1533), c.1512 -1515

    Inventory NGI.783 · 88 × 69 cm · Bequeathed, Sir Hugh Lane, 1918 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. The confiscation is Cardinal Fesch's in 1806, in Napoleonic times. The work came to the museum in 1918 as Sir Hugh Lane's bequest.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Confiscation or forced sale: confiscación: …(?) Bignole Collection sale at the Galleria di Palazzo Rosso; Farnese Collection by 1693; confiscated by Cardinal Fesch in 1806; auction, between 1841 and 1845, Cardinal Fesch sale; purchas…
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Discovered in 1845; (?) Venice, Niccolo Renieri sale, 1666; Giovanni Maria Durazzo, Genoa, 1670; (?) Bignole Collection sale at the Galleria di Palazzo Rosso; Farnese Collection by 1693; confiscated by Cardinal Fesch in 1806; auction, between 1841 and 1845, Cardinal Fesch sale; purchased by Leopoldo Fabbri (or Del Nero collection); Angus collection, Montreal by 1857; Sir Hugh Lane; bequeathed, Sir Hugh Lane, 1918

  6. Unknown Artist, Salzburg, Christ on the Cross with the Virgin Mary and John, c.1430

    Inventory NGI.979 · Purchased, 1936 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. The museum bought it from Galerie Sanct Lucas in Vienna on 5 February 1936, two years before the annexation of Austria. The doubts about that gallery concern works that passed through it from 1938 on.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Galerie Sanct Lucas: Purchased, Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, 5 February 1936
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Purchased, Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, 5 February 1936

  7. Unknown Artist, Styria, Austria, The Separation of the Apostles, 1494

    Inventory NGI.978 · 67.2 × 134.5 cm · Purchased, 1936 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. It belonged to Admont Abbey until 1935; the museum bought it from Galerie Sanct Lucas in Vienna on 5 February 1936, before the annexation of Austria. There is no Jewish owner in the chain.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Owner dispossessed under Nazism: Galerie Sanct Lucas: …Schloss Rothelstein from 1865 until at least 1916); Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna; purchased, Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, 5 February 1936
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Stift Admont, Admont, Austria, 1865-1935 (housed in neighbouring Schloss Rothelstein from 1865 until at least 1916); Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna; purchased, Galerie St. Lucas, Vienna, 5 February 1936

  8. Gabriel Metsu, Man Writing a Letter, 1664-1666

    Inventory NGI.4536 · 52.5 × 40.2 cm · Presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection) · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Beit Collection: Alfred Beit owned it from the late 19th century and it stayed in the family, in London and Ireland, until Sir Alfred Beit gave it to the museum in 1987. The 1933–45 'gap' is only that the record does not repeat the date.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1898 a 1987
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Amsterdam, 28 March 1720, Hendrick Sorgh sale, lot 29 (fl. 560 with its pendant); Amsterdam, 16 March 1724, G. Bruyn sale (fl. 785 with its pendant); Johannes Coop; Gerrit Braamcamp, Amsterdam, c.1744-1750; Amsterdam, 31 July 1771, G. Braamcamp sale,no. 125 (fl. 5205 with its pendant), bt. Jan Hope; Jan Hope; Lord Francis Pelham Clinton Hope, Deepdene, thence by descent; the collection purchased en bloc by A. Wertheimer and P. & D. Colnaghi, 1898; Sir Alfred Beit, London and Blessington; presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection)

  9. Gabriel Metsu, Woman Reading a Letter, 1664-1666

    Inventory NGI.4537 · 52.5 × 40.2 cm · Presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection) · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Pendant of the previous one (Beit Collection): in the same family, in London and Ireland, from the late 19th century until the 1987 gift.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1898 a 1987
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Amsterdam, 28 March 1720, Hendrick Sorgh sale, lot 29 (fl. 560 with its pendant); Amsterdam, 16 March 1724, G. Bruyn sale (fl. 785 with its pendant); Johannes Coop; Gerrit Braamcamp, Amsterdam, c.1744-1750; Amsterdam, 31 July 1771, G. Braamcamp sale,no. 125 (f. 5205 with its pendant), bt. Jan Hope; Jan Hope; Lord Francis Pelham Clinton Hope, Deepdene, thence by descent; the collection purchased en bloc by A. Wertheimer and P. & D. Colnaghi, 1898; Sir Alfred Beit, London and Blessington; presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection)

  10. Guercino, Jacob Blessing the Sons of Joseph, c.1620

    Inventory NGI.4648 · 170 × 211.5 cm · Presented by Sir Denis Mahon to the British Fund for the National Gallery of Ireland, 2008 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. The clue is Hermann Voss, who later ran Hitler's Linz museum project, but here he appears in 1932, before the Nazi period, and Denis Mahon bought it from a Paris dealer in 1934. There is no Jewish owner in the chain.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Looting-era dealer: Hermann Voss: …dispersed; collection of Lord Northwick, by 1843; auction, 1859, 2nd Lord Northwick sale; Hermann Voss, Paris, 1932; acquired from a Paris dealer in 1934 by Denis Mahon; placed on long-term lo…
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Commissioned by Cardinal Jacopo Serra, Papal Legate of Ferrara, in 1620; after his death it passed to his successor, Cardinal Giulio Sacchetti; given by Sacchetti in 1646 to Don Juan Alfonso Enriquez de Cabrera, 9th Almirante de Castilla and former Viceroy of Naples, Spanish envoy to Pope Innocent X; recorded in the inventory of his collections in Madrid in 1647 when inherited by his son; following his death in 1691, donated to the Church of San Pascal Bailon, Madrid; removed from the church c. 1803 by Manuel Godoy Alvarez, Principe de la Paz and first minister of Spain; following Godoy's fall from power in March 1808 his collection was dispersed; collection of Lord Northwick, by 1843; auction, 1859, 2nd Lord Northwick sale; Hermann Voss, Paris, 1932; acquired from a Paris dealer in 1934 by Denis Mahon; placed on long-term loan to the National Gallery of Ireland by Sir Denis Mahon, 1997; presented by Sir Denis Mahon trough the British Fund for the National Gallery of Ireland, 2008

  11. Jan Steen, The Marriage Feast at Cana, 1665-1670

    Inventory NGI.4534 · 63.5 × 82.5 cm · Presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection) · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Beit Collection: Alfred Beit bought it between 1895 and 1900; it passed by inheritance to Otto Beit (1906) and Sir Alfred Beit (1930), who gave it to the museum in 1987.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1987
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Amsterdam, 7 April 1806, A. van Hoek sale, lot 17; Amsterdam, 19 July 1809, Bicker and Wijckersloot sale, lot 51; Spaan; Phillips, London, 2 June 1814, Alexis Delahante sale, lot 37; Woodburn; London, 1815, sale; Paris, 1829, Amedee Constantin sale; Nieuwenhuys, London; Christie’s, London, 10 May 1833, Nieuwenhuys sale, lot 117; Northon; Christie's, London, 24 May 1838, Lord Northwick sale, lot 100; Clowes; Christie's, London, 5 May 1848, Casimir Perier (Paris) sale, lot 14; Woodin; collection John Walter, Bearwood; Alfred Beit between 1895 and 1900; by descent to Otto Beit, 1906; by descent to Sir Alfred Beit, 1930; presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection)

  12. Johannes Vermeer, Woman Writing a Letter, with her Maid, c.1670

    Inventory NGI.4535 · 71.1 × 60.5 cm · Presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987 (Beit Collection) · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Beit Collection: Alfred Beit's from c. 1895, then Otto Beit's (1906–1930) and Sir Alfred Beit's (1930–1986). It was stolen from Russborough in 1986 and recovered in 1993; nothing to do with Nazi looting.

    «1930-1986, when the painting was stolen, the painting was recovered in 1993» — provenance published by the museum

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1952
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Catharina Bolnes, widow of Vermeer, Delft, 1676; Hendrick van Buyten, Delft, 1676-1701; Josua van Belle, Rotterdam, before 1710; Ida Catharina van der Meyden, widow of van Belle, Rotterdam, 1710-1729; Rotterdam, 6 September 1730, van Belle sale, lot 92; Franco van Bleyswijk, Delft, 1734; by descent to Catharina van der Burch, married to Hendrick van Slingelandt, The Hague, 1761-1775; possibly Barthout van Slingelandt, Dordrecht, 1771-1798; Viktor von Miller zu Aichholz, Vienna, before 1881; Charles Sedelmeyer, Paris, 6 April 1881; E. Secrétan, Paris, 1881-1889; Paris, 1 June 1889, Secretan sale, lot 140; to Boussod, Valadon & Cie.; Marinoni Collection, Paris; F. Kleinberger, Paris; Alfred Beit, London, c.1895-1906; Sir Otto Beit Bt, London, 1906-1930; Sir Alfred Beit, 2nd Bt, London and (from 1952) Blessington, Russborough, near Dublin (1930-1986, when the painting was stolen, the painting was recovered in 1993); presented, Sir Alfred and Lady Beit, 1987

  13. Master of the Annunciation to the Shepherds, Christ Disputing with the Doctors, 1640s

    Inventory NGI.4700 · 98.8 × 131.7 cm · Heritage Gift, IIB Bank, 2001 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Viscount Powerscourt's from 1836 and in the family until the 1998 Sotheby's sale. It stayed in Ireland throughout.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1836 a 1998
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Jean-Baptiste-Joseph Wicar (1762-1834); acquired after his death by Viscount Powerscour in 1836; by descent; Sotheby's, London, 17 December 1998, lot 58; Rob Smeets, Milan; Heritage Gift, IIB Bank, 2001

  14. Peter Paul Rubens, Head of a Bearded Man, 1622-1624

    Inventory NGI.2016.21 · 50.8 × 41.3 cm · Heritage Gift, Denis & Catherine O'Brien, 2016 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. Sir Otto Beit bought it from Agnew's in London in July 1930 and it stayed in the family, with Sir Alfred Beit, until it came to the museum in 2016.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1930 a 1994
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Count Serguiew, Belgrade and Moscow; Dr. A.C. von Frey, Paris; with Agnew’s, London, from whom acquired in July 1930 by Sir Otto Beit, 1st Bt. (1865-1930); by descent to Sir Alfred Beit, 2nd Bt. (1903-1994), Russborough, Co. Wicklow, Ireland; Heritage Gift, Denis & Catherine O'Brien, 2016

  15. Salvator Rosa, Landscape with the Baptism of Christ in the River Jordan, 1650s

    Inventory NGI.96 · 147 × 221 cm · Purchased, 1856 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. The museum bought it in Rome in 1856. The 'gap' is only that the provenance ends with that purchase.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1856 a 1953
    Full provenance published by the museum

    Purchased, Mr R. MacPherson, Rome, 1856 National Gallery of Ireland / Accessibility / Login Copyright © document.getElementById('currentYear').appendChild( document.createTextNode( new Date().getFullYear() ) ); National Gallery of Ireland This website uses cookies We use optional cookies to enhance your user experience and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our analytics partners who may combine it with other information that you’ve provided to them or that they’ve collected from your use of their services. Details About Cookies Cookies are small text files that can be used by websites to make a user's experience more efficient. The law states that we can store cookies on your device if they are strictly necessary for the operation of this site. For all other types of cookies we need your permission. This site uses different types of cookies. Some cookies are placed by third party services that appear on our pages. You can at any time change or withdraw your consent from the Cookie Declaration on our website. Learn more about who we are, how you can contact us and how we process personal data in our Privacy Policy. Please state your consent ID and date when you contact us regarding your consent. Necessary Cookies Necessary cookies help make a website usable by enabling basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website. The website cannot function properly without these cookies. Name Provider Purpose Expiry Type JSESSIONID eMuseum User Session Session HTTP Statistics Cookies Statistic cookies help website owners to understand how visitors interact with websites by collecting and reporting information anonymously. Name Provider Purpose Expiry Type _ga Google Tag Manager Registers a unique ID that is used to generate statistical data on how the visitor uses the website. 2 years JavaScript _gid Google Tag Manager Registers a unique ID that is used to generate statistical data on how the visitor uses the website. 1 day JavaScript Allow only necessary Allow all var a2a_config = a2a_config || {}; a2a_config.onclick = 1; var require = {"shim":{"t5/core/typeahead":["jquery"]},"baseUrl":"/modules"}; require(["t5/core/pageinit"], function(pi) { pi(["/assets/meta/emuseumcore/5a2c5e4b/js/emuseum.js","/assets/skin/290a0c85/js/custom.js"], ["emuseum/IsoGrid:init",["t5/core/autocomplete",{"id":"quicksearchsuggest","url":"/objects/details.layout.quicksearchform.quicksearchsuggest:autocomplete?sid=nJ5c54Ub2WbAqdux&t:ac=11775","minChars":1,"limit":5}],"t5/core/forms","emuseum/QuickSearch","t5/core/zone",["emuseum/MediaZoom:init",3000,1953,"/internal/media/zoomdispatcher/13505",256],["emuseum/MediaDownload","daMediaZone","/objects/details.detail.detailactions.mediadownload:update-da-media-zone/MEDIAID?sid=nJ5c54Ub2WbAqdux&t:ac=11775"]]); });

  16. Vincent van Gogh, Rooftops in Paris, 1886

    Inventory NGI.2007.2 · 45.6 × 38.5 cm · Purchased, 2007 · Museum record

    Cleared only by the museum's own account. According to the museum, a private collection bought it in 1926 and it stayed in the family until the 2007 Sotheby's sale. It did not change hands between 1933 and 1945.

    Ficha del museo

    What the automated analysis flagged (level baja)
    • Gap between 1933 and 1945: La procedencia salta de 1926 a 2007
    Full provenance published by the museum

    L. C. Enthoven, Voorburg; Fred. Muller & Cie., Amsterdam, 18th May 1920, lot 234; purchased by Kunsthandlung W. Scherjon, Utrecht; Galerie d'Art Huinck, Utrecht; purchased, Private Collection, 1926 and by descent; purchased, Sotheby's, London, 6 February 2007, Impressionist and Modern Art Day Sale, lot 322

Weak leads, not yet read by hand · 0

These are the other 0 of the 26 works with leads. Almost all have only a gap between 1933 and 1945 with the work in Europe before the jump. We list them so anyone can check them.