Limbral
Menu
ES

Museums

Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

New York · museum data: github.com/MuseumofModernArt/collection (CC0 (datos abiertos del MoMA en GitHub; sin procedencia)) · reviewed on 2026-11-16

How to read this page

Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) does not publish its collection's provenance in a form that can be read in full, or blocks automated reading. So gaps in the chain of owners cannot be searched. What we did: cross the museum's list of works (from Wikidata, where available) with our database by artist, title and size, and search Lost Art and the ERR database (works looted by the Nazi agency in France) for those that these records place in this museum today. We checked each match by hand.

A work not appearing here does not mean its provenance is clean: it means it is not in those records.

The provenance a museum publishes is a claim to be checked, not a source in itself. Some museums have left out persecuted Jewish owners or put names in the chain that did not belong there: Laurel Zuckerman, heir of Paul and Alice Leffmann, documented it with the case of Picasso's «The Actor» at the Met («Detecting Deception in the Art Trade», Springer, 2025; the family's claim). So we separate two things: a «false alarm» is ruled out by a record independent of the museum (Lost Art, the ERR, the Collecting Point, or a match that turned out to be another work), while «cleared only by the museum's own account» means the only basis is what the museum itself says, not checked against original documents.

Open cases · 3

The museum's provenance omits or contradicts another public record: a Lost Art search request, an ERR card, a published claim.

  1. George Grosz, Republican Automatons (Republikanische Automaten), 1920

    Inventory 120.1946 · 55.2 × 42.5 cm · Advisory Committee Fund · Museum record

    Open case. It is one of three Grosz works claimed by the artist's heirs: they say his dealer, Alfred Flechtheim, held them on consignment when he fled Germany in 1933, and that they left without his permission. They asked MoMA in 2003 and sued in 2009; the federal court dismissed the suit as time-barred in 2010, the Court of Appeals affirmed and the Supreme Court declined the case in 2011. The merits were never tried: the museum keeps the works with no agreement with the heirs.

    MoMA: George Grosz, «Republican Automatons (Republikanische Automaten)» (120.1946); Grosz v. Museum of Modern Art, 2.º Circuito, 2010 (Universidad de Zúrich); ArThemis (Universidad de Ginebra), «Three Grosz Paintings»

  2. George Grosz, The Poet Max Herrmann-Neisse, 1927

    Inventory 49.1952 · 59.4 × 74 cm · Purchase · Museum record

    Open case. It is one of three Grosz works claimed by the artist's heirs: they say his dealer, Alfred Flechtheim, held them on consignment when he fled Germany in 1933, and that they left without his permission. They asked MoMA in 2003 and sued in 2009; the federal court dismissed the suit as time-barred in 2010, the Court of Appeals affirmed and the Supreme Court declined the case in 2011. The merits were never tried: the museum keeps the works with no agreement with the heirs.

    MoMA: George Grosz, «The Poet Max Herrmann-Neisse» (49.1952); Grosz v. Museum of Modern Art, 2.º Circuito, 2010 (Universidad de Zúrich); ArThemis (Universidad de Ginebra), «Three Grosz Paintings»

  3. George Grosz, Self-Portrait with a Model, 1928

    Inventory 548.1954 · 115.6 × 75.6 cm · Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Leo Lionni · Museum record

    Open case. It is one of three Grosz works claimed by the artist's heirs: they say his dealer, Alfred Flechtheim, held them on consignment when he fled Germany in 1933, and that they left without his permission. They asked MoMA in 2003 and sued in 2009; the federal court dismissed the suit as time-barred in 2010, the Court of Appeals affirmed and the Supreme Court declined the case in 2011. The merits were never tried: the museum keeps the works with no agreement with the heirs.

    MoMA: George Grosz, «Self-Portrait with a Model» (548.1954); Grosz v. Museum of Modern Art, 2.º Circuito, 2010 (Universidad de Zúrich); ArThemis (Universidad de Ginebra), «Three Grosz Paintings»

Pending documents · 1

There is a persecuted owner or a looting dealer in the Nazi years and what is published is not enough to know what happened. Each says which document is missing.

  1. Henry Moore, Mother and Child, 1938

    Inventory 21.1953 · 77.2 × 35.2 cm · Acquired through the Lillie P. Bliss Bequest (by exchange) · Museum record

    Pending documents. Lost Art seeks a Henry Moore «Mutter und Kind» left in Katowice in 1939 by a British vice-consul (Thwaites) who had to flee the German advance; it gives no measurements or material. MoMA's is a 1938 elmwood carving the museum acquired in 1953. Moore made many «mother and child» works; we have not read MoMA's provenance (its website blocks automated reading), so we can neither rule it out nor confirm it.

    MoMA: Henry Moore, «Mother and Child» (21.1953); Lost Art: «Mutter und Kind» (Henry Moore)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Matches a work in our database: Mutter und Kind (missing) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; mismo título · score 45

Settled by the museum · 3

The work had a looting or forced-sale past, and the museum researched it and tells it: restitution, settlement with the heirs or purchase from them.

  1. Pablo Picasso, Boy Leading a Horse, Paris, 1905-06

    Inventory 575.1964 · 220.3 × 131.1 cm · The William S. Paley Collection · Museum record

    Settled by the museum. It belonged to Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy, a Berlin banker of Jewish family; Thannhauser sold it to William S. Paley in 1936 and Paley gave it to MoMA in 1964. The heir Julius Schoeps sued MoMA and the Guggenheim; on 2 February 2009 they announced a confidential settlement and the painting stayed at the museum.

    MoMA: Pablo Picasso, «Boy Leading a Horse» (575.1964); CultureGrrl (ArtsJournal), 02-2009

  2. Egon Schiele, Girl Putting on Shoe, 1910

    Added by hand: it did not come from the automated scan of the collection

    No published inventory number · Main source

    Settled by the museum. It belonged to Fritz Grünbaum, the Viennese cabaret performer who died in Dachau in 1941. The Manhattan District Attorney took it from MoMA and in September 2023 returned it to his heirs, along with five other Schiele drawings; it no longer belongs to the museum.

    MoMA: Egon Schiele, «Girl Putting on Shoe» (s-n-schiele-girl-shoe); Fiscalía de Manhattan, comunicado del 20-09-2023; Hyperallergic, 2023

  3. Egon Schiele, Standing Woman (Prostitute), 1912

    Added by hand: it did not come from the automated scan of the collection

    No published inventory number · Main source

    Settled by the museum. It belonged to Fritz Grünbaum, the Viennese cabaret performer who died in Dachau in 1941. The Manhattan District Attorney took it from MoMA and in September 2023 returned it to his heirs, along with five other Schiele drawings; it no longer belongs to the museum.

    MoMA: Egon Schiele, «Standing Woman (Prostitute)» (s-n-schiele-prostitute); Fiscalía de Manhattan, comunicado del 20-09-2023; Hyperallergic, 2023

False alarms · 8

The lead does not hold, and something independent of the museum shows it: the automatic match is another work (another subject, other measurements) or an independent record (Lost Art, the ERR, the Munich Collecting Point) settles it.

  1. Egon Schiele, Nude with Violet Stockings and Black Hair (Akt mit violetten Strümpfen und schwarzem Haar), 1912

    Inventory 22.1957 · 32.1 × 47.3 cm · Mr. and Mrs. Donald B. Straus Fund · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with «Liegender weiblicher Akt…» and «Liegende mit roten Strümpfen», two Schiele drawings of other subjects (the stockings are red, not violet). It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Egon Schiele, «Nude with Violet Stockings and Black Hair (Akt mit violetten Strümpfen und schwarzem Haar)» (22.1957)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level alta)
  2. Gustav Klimt, Reclining Woman (Liegender Halbakt nach rechts), 1912-13

    Inventory 828.1969 · 37.1 × 56.2 cm · Gift of Mrs. Gertrud A. Mellon · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with «Liegender Halbakt mit Baby», a Klimt drawing with a baby that MoMA's lacks, though the size is the same (Klimt always used the same sheet size). It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Gustav Klimt, «Reclining Woman (Liegender Halbakt nach rechts)» (828.1969)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level alta)
    • Matches a work in our database: Liegender Halbakt mit Baby (missing) — mismo artista; medidas idénticas (37.1×56.2 vs 37.1×56.2 cm); título en común (halbakt, liegender) · score 88
  3. Gustav Klimt, Reclining Woman (Liegender Halbakt), c. 1917

    Inventory 597.1964 · 56.5 × 37.5 cm · Gift of Dr. Christopher Tietze · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with «Liegender Halbakt mit Baby», another Klimt drawing, with a baby. It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Gustav Klimt, «Reclining Woman (Liegender Halbakt)» (597.1964)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level alta)
    • Matches a work in our database: Liegender Halbakt mit Baby (missing) — mismo artista; medidas casi idénticas (37.1×56.2 vs 56.5×37.5 cm); título en común (halbakt, liegender) · score 80
  4. Gustav Klimt, Standing Woman (Stehende Schwangere mit reich ornamentiertem Gewand nach rechts), c. 1905

    Inventory 2.1966 · 55.2 × 35.3 cm · Gift of Mrs. Anneli Arms · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with a Klimt «Sitzende alte Frau» and «Stehendes Liebespaar», other subjects (Klimt always used the same sheet size). It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Gustav Klimt, «Standing Woman (Stehende Schwangere mit reich ornamentiertem Gewand nach rechts)» (2.1966)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level alta)
  5. Ernst Ludwig Kirchner, Street, Berlin, 1913

    Inventory 274.1939 · 120.6 × 91.1 cm · Purchase · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with «Rote Häuser / Die roten Dächer», another Kirchner of similar format; MoMA's is «Straße, Berlin», bought by the museum in 1939 in New York. It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Ernst Ludwig Kirchner, «Street, Berlin» (274.1939)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Matches a work in our database: Rote Häuser / Die roten Dächer (missing) — mismo artista; medidas parecidas (120.0×90.0 vs 120.6×91.1 cm); título en común (berlin, berliner≈berlin) · score 62
  6. Henri Matisse, Standing Nude, Collioure 1906 (cast 1950)

    Inventory 855.2011 · 47.6 × 12.1 cm · Gift of the Estate of Mimi and Bernie West · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with a Matisse «Standing Nude» without measurements; MoMA's is a bronze cast in 1950, from an edition. It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Henri Matisse, «Standing Nude» (855.2011)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Matches a work in our database: Standing Nude (doubtful provenance) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; mismo título · score 45
  7. Käthe Kollwitz, Woman and Children Going to Their Death (Frau mit Kindern in den Tod gehend), 1924

    Inventory 116.2024 · 58 × 45.2 cm · Gift of the Kallir Family in Honor of Hildegard Bachert · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is with «Der Tod greift nach zwei Kindern», another Kollwitz drawing with another subject. It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Käthe Kollwitz, «Woman and Children Going to Their Death (Frau mit Kindern in den Tod gehend)» (116.2024)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Matches a work in our database: Der Tod greift nach zwei Kindern (settlement with heirs) — mismo artista; medidas parecidas (44.0×59.0 vs 58.0×45.2 cm); título en común (kindern, tod) · score 62
  8. Odilon Redon, Vase of Flowers, c. 1912-14

    Inventory 553.1954 · 73 × 53.7 cm · William S. Paley Collection · Museum record

    False alarm. The Lost Art match is a «Blumen in einer Vase» doubtfully attributed to Redon, an oil on canvas that disappeared in Budapest in 1945 (Bertalan Neményi collection). MoMA's is a pastel on paper from William S. Paley's collection. It is not the same work.

    MoMA: Odilon Redon, «Vase of Flowers» (553.1954)

    What the automated analysis flagged (level media)
    • Matches a work in our database: Blumen in einer Vase (missing) — mismo artista; sin medidas: la puntuación depende del título y de la procedencia; mismo título · score 45

Cleared only by the museum's own account · 0

The lead came from the museum's provenance text, and so does what rules it out: a purchase before 1933, a sale out of Nazi reach, a name said to belong to someone else. We did not check it against original documents. It is not a clearance: it is what the museum asserts. If you have documents that contradict it, write to us.

Weak leads, not yet read by hand · 0

These are the other 0 of the 15 works with leads. Almost all have only a gap between 1933 and 1945 with the work in Europe before the jump. We list them so anyone can check them.